Title: A Review of Relationship Development Intervention for Autism Treatment Lisa Berkstresser Erin Chambe
1A Review of Relationship Development
Intervention for Autism TreatmentLisa
Berkstresser Erin Chambers Sandra R. GomesDawn
HornerCaldwell College Graduate Programs in
Applied Behavior Analysis
2What is Relationship Development
Intervention(RDI)?
- Developed and trademarked by husband and wife
team Steven Gutstein, Ph. D and Rachelle K.
Sheely, Ph.D. - Both are clinical psychologists
3Backgroundon Dr. Steven Gutstein
- Prior to 1987, Dr. Gutstein was a nationally
renowned developer of innovative clinical
programs for children with high-risk conditions. - 1983 received grant from Hogg Foundation for
Mental Health. - Earned his Ph.D in Clinical Psychology from Case
Western Reserve University. - Served as Assistant Professor of Psychiatry and
Pediatrics at Baylor College of Medicine and the
University of Texas Medical School. -
4Background on Dr. Steven Gutstein
- During this period, Dr. Gutstein also served as
the director of Pediatric Psychology for Texas
Childrens Hospital. - Currently Director of The Connections Center in
Houston, TX. - Formed Foundation for Autism Research and
Remediation (FARR) in 2004
5Publications of Dr. Gutstein
- Gutstein, S. (2003). Can my Baby Learn to Dance
Exploring the Friendships of Asperger Teens. In
Lianne Holliday Willey (Ed.). Asperger Syndrome
in Adolescence. Jessica Kingsley Publications
London. - Gutstein, S. Sheely, R. (2002). Relationship
Development Intervention Activities for Children,
Adolescents and Adults. Jessica Kingsley
Publications London.
6Publications of Gutstein
- Gutstein, S. Sheely, R. (2002). Relationship
Development Intervention Activities for Young
Children. Jessica Kingsley Publications London. - Gutstein, S.E. (2001). Autism/ Asperger's
Solving the Relationship Puzzle. Future Horizons
Press Arlington, Texas. - Gutstein, S. E. (2007). The Relationship
Development Intervention (RDI) Program and
Education. Connections Center Publishing Houston.
7What Does RDI Claim to do?
- RDI is a treatment program proposed for autistic
spectrum disorders. - Claims to of found the missing link in autism.
- Focus of RDI is to teach parents and others how
to motivate and enable those with autism to
experience dynamic social relationships. - Social and emotional developmental activities
8How do children with autism differ from children
without autism?
- Lack five core areas of thinking about.
- Referencing
- Co-regulation
- Experience-sharing Communication
- Flexible Thinking
- Episodic Memory
- Type of thinking which tells us how child will do
in dynamic, changing environments. - We refer to this areas as Dynamic Intelligence.
9Dynamic Intelligence
- Dr. Gutstein found that even the most capable
individuals on the autism spectrum lacked certain
environments that are dynamic and changing. - Many different abilities are essential for
success in dynamic systems. - Foundations of dynamic intelligence underlie
success in life.
10Dynamic Intelligence
- Experience Sharing
- Sharing different perspectives, integrating
multiple information channels and determining
good enough levels of comprehension. - Dynamic Analysis
- Determine relative meaning and value to
information. Ongoing evaluation of change. - Flexible and Creative Problem-Solving
- Ability to obtain meaning base upon the larger
context. Solving problems that have no right-and
wrong solutions.
11Dynamic Intelligence
- Episodic Memory and Self-awareness (Foresight and
Hindsight) - Ability to reflect on past experiences and
anticipate potential future scenarios in a
productive manner. - Resilience
- Coping with a messy unpredictable world where
setbacks and errors are unavoidable.
12So what does this mean?
- Creating a good quality of life for those on the
spectrum. - Without the foundations of Dynamic Intelligence,
an individual on the spectrum will always be
deprived. - Deprived of the happiness of being connected to
another with a smile or intimate glance from
across the room the thrill of playing on a team
or self-confidence of living independently. - RDI states dont loose hope for the future.
13The Goal of RDI
- RDI states that children with autism are lacking
Dynamic Intelligence. - RDI aims to teach this in a systematic and
practical way. - Goal of COMPETENCE
- Parent-based treatment method.
147 Core Principles of RDI
- Current RDI program is based on a framework of
seven core principles. - 1. Prioritize remediation but maintain balance
with treating co-occurring conditions and using
short-term compensations. - Aid parents in clearly understanding what autism
is vs. co-occurring conditions.
157 Core Principles of RDI
- 2. Set appropriate objectives
- Stop thinking about programs and start thinking
about specific objectives and goals for the
child. - Help parents evaluate if they are making progress
in treating autism. - The RDI Program Curriculum
- 24 Stages and 400 activities
167 Core Principles of RDI
- 3. Develop a customized treatment plan reflecting
the child and familys unique needs. - No two children are alike and no two families are
alike, so no two treatment plans can be alike. - Assessing strengths and obstacles as part of a
customized treatment plan is critical for
success.
177 Core Principles of RDI
- 4. Teach parents to conduct Guided Participation.
- Parents are the ones who are the primary
reference points for helping their children
interpret and gain meaning from the world. -
- 5. Modify family communication to promote
thoughtfulness and experience-sharing. - Do not confuse speech with communication.
- Guide families to create an experience-sharing
communication environment with their child on the
spectrum, whether or not their child is verbal or
non-verbal.
187 Core Principles of RDI
- 6. Develop episodic memories of competence in
dynamic systems. - Type of memories which combine events with
personal feelings and meaning, and which connect
past and future. - Research???
197 Core Principles of RDI
- 7. Modify lifestyle for family heath and
opportunities for a master-apprentice
relationship. - Need to create an RDI Lifestyle.
- Getting out of crisis, prioritizing, simplifying
life, creating a workable reality and using
everyday activities for doing the RDI program.
20How to get started!
- Phone consultation
- 2 Day Introductory Workshop
- 4 Day Parent Seminar
- Relationship Development Assessment
21The Relationship Curriculum
- Composed of six levels and 24 stages
- -Each of the six levels represents a dramatic
developmental shift in the central focus of
relationships. - Each level has four stages
- Level I Novice
- -Students are referred to as Novices
- Level II Apprentice
- -The student has earner the rank of Apprentice
- Level III Challenger
- -Students referred to as Challengers
- Level IV Voyager
- -Students referred to as Voyagers
- Level V Explorer
- -Students referred to as Explorers
- Level VI Partner
- -Students referred to as Partners
22Level I Novice
- Summary
- To develop a core relationship between the parent
and the child. - Participants
- The Coach and Novice are the sole participants in
Level I. - Settings
- Bare rooms.
- Language
- Used to enhance facial referencing and not
distract from or compete with it. - Coaching Points
- Remain firmly in charge of the structure of all
activities. - Watch out for a tendency for the Novice to try
and control the interaction. - It is critical for activities to be exciting and
produce happiness. They should never be done when
the parent or novice is tired or in a bad mood.
23Stage 1 Attend
- 1- My words are important
- 2- I lost my voice
- 3- Unexpected sounds and actions
- 4- Chant
- 5-Unexpected Labels
- 6- Two Coach Approach
- 7-The tunnel
- 8- Climbing and Jumping
- 9- Affection Sharing
- 10- Now You See Me, Now You Dont
24Stage 2 Reference
- 20- Sneaky partner
- 21- Sneaky Pete
- 22- Disappearing Coach
- 23- Save Me
- 24- Non-Verbal Towers
- 25- Follow my Eyes to the Prize
- 26- Trading Places
- 27- Mother May I
- 28- You Lose
- 29- Silent Card Game
- 30- Stay Tuned to this Station
25Stage 3 Regulate
- 31- Assistant
- 32- Bill Ding
- 33- Matching
- 34- Guiding
- 35- Transition
- 36- Incomplete Completion
- 37- Expression
26Stage 4 Coordinate
- 38- Beanbag Mountain
- 39- Breaking the Chain
- 40- Vegetable Delivery
- 41- Store
- 42- Stop and Go
- 43- Start and Stop
- 44- Role Actions
- 45- Parallel Pretend Play
- 46- Cars and Ramps
- 47- Crashing Cars
- 48- Two Ball Roll
27Level II Apprentice
- Summary
- Children are ready to become co-regulators.
- Participants
- Introduction of peer partners into activities.
- Settings
- Careful restriction of settings which contain
activities. - Language
- Used to teach enactment, to communicate need for
regulatory actions. - Coaching Points
- Allow the child to gradually introduce more
variation into joint activities. - Continue to carefully monitor your use of
language. - Carefully monitor your pacing during activities.
Always sacrifice speed for coordination.
28Stage 5 Variation
- 55- Degrees of Change
- 56- Car Crash Variations
- 57- Number Crash
- 58- Ball Rolling Variations
- 59- Drum Changes
- 60- Walking Changes
- 61- Too Close or Too Far
- 62- Degrees of Happy
- 63- The sound of Excitement
- 64- Getting Better
29Stage 6 Transformation
- 65- Activity Transformations
- 66- Function Transformations
- 67- Rule Changes
- 68- Opposite World
- 69- Unexpected Jokes
- 70- Morphing Emotions
- 71- Role Reversals
- 72- Transforming Rhythms
30Stage 7 Synchronization
- 73- Are You Ready
- 74- Talk to Yourself
- 75- Synchronized Rhythms
- 76- Tricky Partner
- 77- Synchronized Roles
- 78- Synchronized Humor
- 79- Conversation Frameworks
- 80- Anticipation
31Stage 8 Duets
- 81- Reviews for Duets
- 84- Mixed up Puzzles
- 85- Are we Connected?
- 86- Partner Pretend Play
- 87- Partner Role-Plays
- 88- Curious Conversations
32Level III Challenger
- Summary
- Children learn how to add variation while
maintaining coordination with a peer partner. - Participants
- Peers partners take more responsibility.
- Settings
- Physical movement and actions settings.
- Language
- Language is used as a major interaction enhancer.
- Coaching Points
- Celebrate each challengers co-creations.
- Record co-creations in journals and photographs.
- Parents are still in charge of the pace and
progression of activities.
33Stage 9 Collaboration
- 89- Ball and Net
- 90- Lifting and Carrying
- 91- Its dark!
- 92- Buddy Baseball
- 93- Parking Garage
- 94- The Beltway
- 95- Self Instruction
- 96- Replays
- 97- Musical Variations
- 98- Buddy Walkers
- 99- Relay Race
- 100- Shark and Fishermen
- 101- The Monster Again
- 102- Map Reader and Scout
34Stage 10 Co-Creation
- 103- Created Rhythms
- 104- Art Car
- 105- Created Songs
- 106- Our Song
- 107- Created Phrases
- 108- Created Games
- 109- Created Role Plays
- 110- Joke Factory
- 111- Created Structures
- 112- Created Sculptures
35Stage 11 Improvisation
- 113- Improvised Activities
- 114- Improvised Structures
- 115- Improvised Rules
- 116- Improvised Rhythms
- 117- Improvised Music
- 118- Improvised Songs
- 119- Improvised Movement
- 120- Improvised Role-Plays
- 121- Improvised Jokes
36Stage 12 Running Mates
- 122- Emotions
- 123- Talk Without Words
- 124- Can You Hear Me Now?
- 125- Pass it on
- 126- Wordless Drawings
- 127- Connected Conversations
- 128- Learning How to Lose
- 129- It Takes Two
- 130- Joining in
- 131- Discovery Boxes
- 132- What do you See
37Level IV Voyager
- Summary
- Beginning of a permanent, dramatic change.
- Participants
- Peers begin choosing peers over adults.
- Settings
- Not distracted so easily.
- Language
- Becomes more creative.
- Regulation and Repair
- Attempting to understand.
- Coaching Points
- Be careful to distinguish pointing.
- Faces are main reference.
- Self talk and narration are critical skills.
38Stage 13 Perspective
- Goals
- Introduction to the world of relative versus the
absolute. - Activity summary
- Begin with activities geared towards sharing
personal experience. - Ending with introduction to concepts of strategy
and the use of perspective.
39Stage 13 PerspectiveActivities
- 71 Returning from a journey
- 72 Play-by-Play
- 73 Video Narration
- 74 Video Documentary
- 75 Comparing
- 76 Watching
- 77 Shared Journey
- 78 Strategies
- 79 Different Versions
40Stage 14 ImaginationActivities
- 80 You Think Its Funny But I Dont
- 81 Enhancing or Changing
- 82 Silly Captions
- 83 Silly Soundtracks
- 84 Imaginative Role-Plays
- 85 What Could This Be?
41Stage 15 Group FoundationsActivities
- 86 Integrating Ideas
- 87 Group Structures
- 88 Group Games
- 89 - Joining in 2
- 90 Our World
- 91 Group Journeys
42Stage 16 Emotional RegulationActivities
- 92 Stress 1
- 93 Agreements and Conflicts
- 94 Faces and Voices
- 95 Expanding the Feelings Vocabulary
- 96 Representing Emotions
- 97 Rejection
- 98 Inviting a Friend
43Level V Explorer
- Summary
- Friendship progressed to level of pre-adolescent.
- Participants
- Geared for larger groups.
- Settings
- Largely irrelevant.
- Language
- Is now critical.
- Regulation/Repair
- Expected to be skilled.
- Coaching Points
- Learn to be a good listener.
44Stage 17 Ideas
- Objective facts and subjective beliefs Goals and
Objectives - Learn to understand their interests, preferences,
and emotional reactions. - Activity Summary
- Begins with activities making sure it is
understood that they have and can express their
own ideas and ends with the difference between.
45Stage 17 IdeasActivities
- 99 Idea poems
- 100 Integrating Ideas
- 101 Sill Questions
- 102 Shared Stories
- 103 I know Some Things You Dont
- 104 You are Master, I am Novice
- 105 Good Enough Solutions
- 106 Appreciating Alternatives
- 107 Interest
- 108 - Preferences
- 109 Opinions
- 110 Emotional Reactions
- 111 - It Cant e Wrong. Its Mine!
46Stage 18 Whats Inside?Activities
- 112 Should You Believe?
- 113 - Pretend Feelings
- 114 I am Only Joking
- 115 Absurd Facts
- 116 - Imagine the Future
- 117 - Could Something Go Wrong?
- 118 - Accidental Deliberate?
- 119 - Teasing
- 120 - Who am I Now?
- 121 - Empathy?
47Stage 19 ConversationsActivities
- 122 Conversation Functions
- 123 Conversation Enhancement
- 124 - Conversational Tennis
- 125 Conversation Rhythms
- 126 Understanding and
misunderstanding - 127 Boring
- 128 In Demand
48Stage 20 AllyActivities
- 129 Stress 2
- 130 Mistakes 2
- 131 Friends have Fights
- 132 How to Kill a Friendship
- 133 - Friend Maps
- 134 Ally Contract
49Level VI Partner
- Summary
- Marks the emergence of a real interest in family.
- Participants
- Any number.
- Settings
- No specific setting required.
- Language
- Is critical.
- Repair
- Includes the concept of damage to a relationship.
- Coaching Points
- Maintain Coach relationship.
50Stage 21 Shared Selves
- Goals and Objectives
- Share intimate information, and feel safe to make
self-disclosures. - Activity Summary
- Begins with concept of Personal Identity and ends
with ways in which others view them.
51Stage 21 Shared SelvesActivities
- 135 Layers of Me
- 136 Loneliness
- 137 Beliefs
- 138 Strong and Weak
- 139 How do you see me?
- 140 Private Me
- 141 Me Executive Summary
52Stage 22 Family RootsActivities
- 142 Family Maps 1
- 143 Family Maps 2
- 144 Family Maps 3
- 145 Family Appreciations
- 146 Family Stories
- 147 Family Emotions Bank
53Stage 23 Group ConnectionsActivities
- 148 Group Diagrams
- 149 Group Roles
- 150 Group Influence
- 151 Group Problem Solving
54Stage 24 Intimate RelationsActivities
- 152 Different Kinds of Friendship
- 153 Trust
- 154 Friendship Maintenance
- 155 - Advanced Friend Maps
- 156 - Friends Forever
55Appendix A The Relationship Development
Questionnaire
56Appendix B Progress Tracking Form
57Video Clip
- http//www.youtube.com/watch?vRF_XOp01UEYfeature
related - http//www.youtube.com/watch?vp9rR7-9sPdgfeature
related - http//www.youtube.com/watch?vIG9uo-AZzv4feature
related
58RDI Certification Process
- Includes completion of three, 4-day intensive
training seminars - Supervision via videotape and demonstration of
proficiency in the Relationship Development
Assessment (RDA) - Submission of video footage with two families
- a supervision family.
- a case presentation family.
- Process generally takes 12-18 months
59RDI Certification Process
- You will learn
- how to help families understand autism and RDI so
you can be an effective educator and prepare them
for the process. - how to coach parents, help them when they get
stuck, and become a good consultant. - how to administer the RDA effectively.
- how to develop highly effective customized
intervention plans.
60RDI Certification Process
- Certification fees are 9,240 USD
- It is claimed that most professionals recoup
their investment in the training very quickly.
61RDI Certification Process 2 Day Introductory
Workshop
- Goal is to be thoroughly introduced to the RDI
Program to ensure it is a good fit for you. - Workshop provides a good background about the
latest research from the fields of - autism
- the brain
- developmental psychology and learn how it relates
to the RDI Program.
62RDI Certification Process 2 Day Introductory
Workshop
- Workshop provides strategies for learning how
families can - Adapt their communication style to bring about
dramatic changes in relating. - Develop a new type of memory to create motivation
for genuine relationships. - Adapt everyday activities so they can use RDI
Program concepts as a regular part of their daily
life.
63RDI Certification Process Beginning Seminar
Information
- A theoretical and practical approach to the
implementation of the RDI Program - Prerequisites
- Read Solving the Relationship Puzzle
- Two-day Introductory RDI Program workshop or DVD,
"Going to the Heart of Autism" - Bachelor's degree and Professional experience in
related clinical interventions - Application for Certification
64RDI Certification Process Beginning Seminar
Information
- Prerequisites (cont)
- Parents of a child on the Autism Spectrum must
have a letter of recommendation from an RDI
Consultant. - Letter must include
- verification of having mastered all parent
objectives through stage 4 and currently working
on stage 5. - verification of having consistently met with RDI
Consultant every 2 weeks over the last 6 months. - verification of having consistently submitted
video clips to consultant of your work with your
child every 2 weeks over the last 6 months.
65RDI Certification Process Beginning Seminar
Information
- Four-day seminar develops the clinician's ability
to - Evaluate parent and child readiness
- Consult with parents to frame activities for
effective intervention - Consult with parents to incorporate RDI Program
into real-life activities - Consult with parents to use appropriate
scaffolding and spotlighting techniques - Consult with parents to implement regulation into
all aspects of their childs day before
introducing challenge
66RDI Certification Process Intermediate Seminar
Information
- Both theoretical and practical, this four-day
seminar focuses on - Pathogenesis of Autism Spectrum Disorders.
- The Process of Guided Participation.
- Functioning as an RDI Program Consultant.
- Using the RDA to evaluate the parent-child
relationship. - Developing hypotheses for treatment planning,
including system readiness, strengths and
obstacles.
67RDI Certification Process Supervision
Expectations
- Following the back-to-back Beginning and
Intermediate Seminars, Consultants-in-Training
are required to work with two families through
the RDIos (online communication system.) - These families must have a child formally
diagnosed with an Autism Spectrum Disorder. - This work will be submitted via our secure server
for review by a supervising Consultant. - If you do not believe you will have two dedicated
families, please wait to register for a future
Beginning/Intermediate.
68RDI Certification Process Supervision
Expectations
- Deadline for Tape 1 (NT RDA1) 5 weeks after
Intermediate Seminar. - Deadline for Subsequent Tapes Typically, two
weeks after previous tape is approved. - You must be able to comply with these deadlines
to register.
69RDI Certification Process Supervision
Expectations
- Consultants-in-Training must demonstrate
competency in the following areas - RDA1 administration with a typical child.
- Proficiency in addressing Education and Readiness
Commitment Stages with parents. - Full RDA administration, scoring, and
intervention planning with your supervision
families. - Proficiency in addressing subsequent parent
stages with your supervision families. - Supervision of 14 consecutive RDI Program
assignments which are typically submitted every
two weeks.
70RDI Certification Process Supervision
Expectations
- Prerequisite
- Completion of Beginning and Intermediate Seminars
- Professionals must begin professional supervision
within six months of attending the Beginning
Seminar. Failure to do so results in "inactive"
status. If inactive status lasts for longer than
six months, the related professional supervision
payment will be lost.
71RDI Certification Process Advanced Seminar
Information
- Four-day seminar where Consultants-in-Training
demonstrate ability to analyze parental readiness
and parent-child process. - Consultants-in-Training are to demonstrate
ability to screen for potential co-occurring
disorders and to use referrals and professional
services in an appropriate manner. - Training is provided on breaking objectives down
into assignments. - Training is provided on using the various
feedback methods in the RDIos. - Training is provided on ethics of consultation.
- How to evaluate your own efficacy, obstacles,
problems, and progress as a consultant.
72RDI Certification Process Advanced Seminar
Information
- Prerequisites
- Completion of prior beginning and intermediate
seminars. - Approval of Tapes 1-4
- All seminars are facilitated by Dr. Steven
Gustein and/or Dr. Rachelle Sheely.
73RDI Certification Process
- Certified Consultants of the RDI Program are
listed on the RDI Connect Website. - Some are highlighted with One Star upon
successfully. completing the certification or
re-certification process. - Some are highlighted with a diamond signifying
consultants who have attained supervisory status
for at least one year and continue to maintain
it.
74 Solid Research?
Ps
- Questions asked of those
considering certification - Have (you) already been intuitively using RDI
principles and methods in your work? - Do you feel excited about being on the cutting
edge of a clinical intervention for autism which
is based on solid research?
75Pseudoscience
- Lets look at the natural process and slow it
down..what happens if we take the same process
and break it down, and then teach Parents what
theyre already capable of intuitively.
Dr. Steven Gutstein.
76Dr. Gutstein Interview with Rhonda Brunett
KPDQ 06/01/2006
I began to study the research and the clinical
practice and I found that they dont overlap.
I ran a school, its no longer an operation
and it was a great experience.
77Dr. Gutstein Interview with Georgene Rice KPDQ
03/21/2006
Retraining myself. Empowering families with
what God created them to do. Were attempting
to teach parents how to be able to think
flexibly.
78Gustein et al. 2007
- Evaluation of RDI program
- Purpose of the study
- - Study examines the effectiveness of a
cognitive developmental parent training model
(RDI) and is a follow-up to a preliminary
evaluation study. - Hypothesis
- Gustein hypothesized children would be highly
flexible and adaptive after RDI treatment. - Any gains made would not be related to IQ.
79Research supporting RDI
Gutsteins preliminary study is still in
press According to Dr. Wendy Stone, the
co-author of Does my child have autism? and
the co-developer of Screening tools for autism in
two year olds, There are currently no
scientific, controlled studies assessing the
effectiveness of the RDI model (Stone, 2006)
80Possible Confounds
- According to archives from the U.S. National
Library of Medicine, generability of current
findings is limited by the lack of control or
comparison group. - In his own press release, Dr. Gutstein admits
The small sample size needs to be taken into
account when considering the implications of the
research.
81Testimonials
- What we read up on autism therapy was not
helpful. Kenneth should be as happy and Natural
as possible. Hui Boon, Singapore
82Testimonials
- His ADOS score has gone from 20 in March
2005.to 8 in March 2006. He has mastered stage
1 and has had 3 assessments with our RDI
consultant this past year. Catherine
Shropshire, England
83References
- Gustein, E. S., Burgess, F. A., Montfort, K.
(2007) Evaluation of the relationship
intervention - program. Autism, 11, 397.
- Gutstein, S. Sheely, R. (2002). Relationship
Development Intervention Activities for -
- Children, Adolescents and Adults. Jessica
Kingsley Publications London. -
- Gutstein, S. Sheely, R. (2002).
Relationship Development Intervention Activities
for Young - Children. Kingsley Publications London.
- Retrieved June 6, 2008, from http//www.rdiconnect
.com. - Retrieved June 5, 2008 from http//autismsupportce
nter.org. - Retrieved June 5, 2008 from http//www.crossroads-
solutions.net/rdi.html. - Retrieved June 9, 2008 from http//www.portal.wpsp
ublish.com/portal.html.