Investment Thesis, Industry Competitive Advantage, - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1 / 11
About This Presentation
Title:

Investment Thesis, Industry Competitive Advantage,

Description:

SYM's should be valued as a soon to be liquidated REIT rather than as a retailer. ... Investors in WPC managed REIT's experience a 10% haircut. ... – PowerPoint PPT presentation

Number of Views:746
Avg rating:3.0/5.0
Slides: 12
Provided by: JHU90
Category:

less

Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Investment Thesis, Industry Competitive Advantage,


1
Investment Thesis, Industry Competitive
Advantage, Investment Risks Sections Seminar
  • October 13, 2009

2
TSTY Key Issue 1
  • Investment Thesis
  • Three valuation methods indicate TSTY is
    significantly overvalued.
  • Investment Risk
  • TSTY could be acquired at a premium price by a
    larger more efficient manufacturer, a private
    equity firm, or a hedge fund for strategic
    reasons.
  • However, the lack of brand equity makes TSTY an
    unattractive acquisition target.

3
TSTY Key Issue 2
  • Investment Thesis
  • TSTY has limited long-term growth potential.
  • Poor market outlook for non-nutritious bakery
    goods among increasingly health-conscious
    consumers.
  • TSTY cannot generate sufficient cash to finance
    its Strategic Growth Initiative.
  • Investment Risk
  • TSTY might experience a highly successful
    marketing campaign.
  • TSTY might develop new products which appeal to
    new trends in consumer tastes.
  • TSTY could uncover new ways to enhance
    productivity
  • However, achieving these benefits and
    implementing these changes may take several years.

4
TSTY Key Issue 3
  • Investment Thesis
  • TSTY is in a cash-poor financial condition
  • Gross profit margins far below peers.
  • TSTY operates in a very competitive and mature
    industry forecasted to experience low growth
    during the next 5 years.
  • Positive cash flows from operations are being
    offset by negative cash flows from investing and
    financing..
  • Investment Risk
  • The stock market is inefficient and some
    investors find TSTYs low relative valuation
    attractive.
  • However, the catalysts required to drive the
    price of the stock higher over the next 12 months
    will not be present.

5
TSTY Key Issues 4 5
  • Investment Thesis 4
  • The rising health consciousness of consumers is a
    major challenge facing TSTY and its industry.
  • Random sample of over 3000 consumers in TSTYs
    core distribution area found that 76.5 of them
    classified the companys products as junk.
  • A face-to-face interview with a long-time
    independent sales distributor confirmed TSTYs
    brand equity problems and demand challenges
  • Investment Thesis 4
  • The occupiers of the top four positions in the
    company own only a minimum number of shares and
    thus the interests of top management may conflict
    with those of TSTYs shareholders.

6
SYM Key Issue 1
  • Investment Thesis
  • SYMs should be valued as a soon to be liquidated
    REIT rather than as a retailer.
  • Stock performance has been more correlated with a
    real estate index than with its closest retail
    competitors.
  • Investment Risk
  • Family control makes liquidation catalyst
    indeterminable.
  • However, if liquidation is deferred there is a
    low downside risk of 3.71 annually over the next
    5 years.
  • Real estate market could correct.
  • However, the fundamental value of the real estate
    provides a downside floor.
  • Control shareholders could take the company
    private
  • However, this is unlikely because of the
    appreciation that has occurred in the price of
    SYMs shares and the large amount of debt that
    would have to be assumed.

7
SYM Key Issue 2 3
  • Investment Thesis 2
  • The sale of the Dallas store suggests
    liquidation.
  • The store was profitable.
  • SYMs was made an enticing offer which was
    confirmed by the CFO
  • Investment Thesis 3
  • There is hedge fund interest in SYMs
  • Dimensional Advisors recently purchased 8.34 of
    outstanding shares.

8
WPC
  • Investment Thesis 1
  • Buy recommendation supported by valuation
    approaches.
  • Investment Thesis 2
  • WPC has stable sources of income
  • Investment Thesis 3
  • WPC has maintained their conservative borrowing
    standards.
  • Investment Thesis 4
  • WPC managements impeccable track record will
    help the company navigate the challenging credit
    markets that currently exist.

9
WPC
  • Investment Risk 1
  • WPCs investment team not so independent.
  • However, WPC has achieved high returns with this
    structure.
  • Investment Risk 2
  • Investors in WPC managed REITs experience a 10
    haircut.
  • However, WPC REITs have been successfully sold
    in the past.
  • Investment Risk 3
  • Performance fees now based on operating cash
    flows rather than assets under management.
  • However, long-term leases usually experience
    highly stable cash flows.
  • Investment Risk 4
  • WPC may have trouble raising capital for its
    CPA17 REIT and maintaining historic returns.
  • Default risk is substantial risk to WPCs
    revenues and asset values.
  • However, analysis revealed an average risk of BBB
    on directly owned leased properties and an
    average risk of BB in the REITs managed by WPC.

10
PVH
  • Investment Thesis 1
  • PVH is cheap
  • Investment Thesis 2
  • International licensing will continue to be the
    driver for the company
  • Investment Thesis 3
  • PVHs retail and wholesale businesses will not
    hurt them that much in the current business
    downturn
  • Investment Thesis 4
  • PVH has a strong balance sheet and cash position

11
PVH
  • Investment Risk 1
  • Major retailers/licensees bankruptcy and/or
    consolidation
  • However, consolidation will improve the
    efficiency of the industry and not reduce in the
    long run the number of retail doors and PVH can
    find replacement licensee partners
  • Investment Risk 2
  • Extended recession PVH will be negatively
    impacted
  • Investment Risk 3
  • International licensing revenue grows slower than
    expected
  • However, business interests of licensees are
    aligned with PVH which will mitigate this risk
  • Investment Risk 4
  • Currency translation loss
  • However, PVHs diversified portfolio of licensees
    will mitigate this risk.
  • Investment Risk 5
  • Larger wholesale discounts and returns than
    expected
  • However, dont worry because tested in scenario
    analysis.
Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
About PowerShow.com