MilitaryCivilian Transportation Safety Workshop

1
Military/Civilian Transportation Safety Workshop
Don Borkoski TRAFFIC SAFETY SPECIALIST
2
National/USN/USMC Motorcycle Data
USN-USMC/10,000
National/100,000
USN/USMC/10
National/1,000
3
DoD Motorcycle Service Comparisons
DoD Motorcycle Class A Rates
Personnel Under Age 30
Increased Training has had an impact on the
Fatality Rate!
4
FY06 Total Cost and Deaths Navy and Marine Corps
Cost
Fatalities
PMV 144 (60)
PMV
AVIATION
Recreation
Shore/Ground/
515M
26
34M
Aviation
Afloat
21
19M
PMV
27M
Shore/Ground/
Recreation
49
13M
Afloat 1
Total Cost 607M
Total Fatalities 241
FY 2006
5
National/USN/USMC Motorcycle Data
Values are percentage of Fatalities
6
DON Way Ahead

• Change OPNAVINST 5100.12G and MCO 5100.19E to
  require
• Service-Wide Solution
• Training continuum
• Sports Bike Training
• PPE Standards
• NSC, CMC-SD and Fleet Representatives Research to
  Determine Best Solution for Service-wide
  Motorcycle Training
• Outsourcing
• Trainer Bikes
• Course curriculum
• Course Material
• Mentorship Programs
• Emphasize Command Personal Accountability

7
Knowing what happened is vital

• DoN instituted an investigation process for all
  Fatal crashes.
• Non-fatal crash victims are being investigated
  for line of duty status
• Autopsies are being reviewed for all major
  Mishaps
• WESS has been expanded to collect almost 1000
  data points from a crash
• Preliminary Loss Reports are distributed within a
  week of a crash

8
Fatal Factors in Motorcycle Deaths
FY-07 NSC
9
NAVY/MARINE DUI by age
70
21
7
3
FY-06 NSC
10
Mishap Causal Factors
Culture
Judgment Error
Latent Conditions Human Factors
Reasons Swiss Cheese Model
11
5
4
3
Steps
Rules
Levels
12
5 STEPS OF ORM

• IDENTIFY
• HAZARDS

2. Assess Hazards
13
4 RULES of ORM

• Accept risks when benefits outweigh costs.
• 2. Accept no unnecessary risk.
• 3. Anticipate and manage risk by planning.
• 4. Make risk decisions at the right level.

14
3 LEVELS of ORM

• TIME CRITICAL (Reaction)
• Decision under duress. Little time for a
  decision.
• on the run, snap decision adjusting to
  identified hazard
• DELIBERATE (Action)
• Everyday decision making. decisions to avoid
  anticipated problems, planning ahead to reduce
  probability of risk
• IN DEPTH (Anticipate)
• Long term planning. Agreed upon decisions based
  on recurring situations. Usually written or
  enforce policy.

15
Decision Making Styles
Criticality, People, Tools

• Decisions will be impacted by
• Available time
• Criticality of the decision
• Number of people involved
• Available tools sources of information
• Decision making bias

Analytical
Deliberate
Time Critical
Time

16

• MSF provides the curriculum for DOD training
  including
• Basic Rider Course (BRC)
• Experienced Rider Course (ERC)
• Group Riding Suit
• New ventures include
• ERC II sport bike specific training focused on
  Stopping, Cornering and Risk Management
• SERC (Skill Enhancement Rider Course)- Advanced
  skills and Traction Demonstrations

17
MSFs Risk Mitigation Routine
SEE

• Search

18
On July 29, an E-3 attached to USS Fort McHenry
was killed when he lost control of his vehicle,
struck another vehicle and then hit a utility
pole in Norfolk. On July 27, a master gunnery
sergeant from HQBN / 4th MCD was fatally injured
when an oncoming vehicle crossed into his lane
and collided head-on with his motorcycle near
Twenty Nine Palms, Calif.  PMV Stats     PMV
Narratives90  Navy and Marine Corps PMV Deaths
FY07 to date
Diving  
Explosives  
Aeromedical  
Approach  
Safetyline eNewsletter  
Approach Vault  
Magazines  
Citations  
Checklists  
About Training Center  
Alsafe Messages  
Commander  
Biographies  
Diving  
Explosives  
Aeromedical  
Approach  
Safetyline eNewsletter  
Approach Vault  
Magazines  
Citations  
Checklists  
About Training Center  
Alsafe Messages  
Commander  
Biographies  
Traffic Death Update
Submarine  
Marine Corps  
Aviation Data  
Ground Warrior  
Diving Safety Lines  
Art Gallery  
Newsletters  
Civilian Community   
Downloads  
Course Catalog  
Awards  
Deputy Commander  
Mission  
Submarine  
Marine Corps  
Aviation Data  
Ground Warrior  
Diving Safety Lines  
Art Gallery  
Newsletters  
Civilian Community   
Downloads  
Course Catalog  
Awards  
Mission  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Surface Warfare  
Motor Vehicle  
Culture Workshops  
Mech  
Flash  
Clip Art  
Galleries  
Ergonomics  
Instructions  
PDC Information  
2007 Naval Safety Planner  
NSC Strategic Plan 07-08  
Surface Warfare  
Motor Vehicle  
Culture Workshops  
Mech  
Flash  
Clip Art  
Galleries  
Ergonomics  
Instructions  
PDC Information  
2007 Naval Safety Planner  
Hign Risk Training  
Investigations  
Sea  Shore  
Ships' Safety Bulletin  
Mech Vault  
Safety Posters  
Fire Protection   
Links  
Quota Request  
Mishap Reduction  
Directory  
Hign Risk Training  
Investigations  
Sea  Shore  
Ships' Safety Bulletin  
Mech Vault  
Safety Posters  
Fire Protection   
Links  
Quota Request  
Mishap Reduction  
Directory  
Recreation  
Maintenance  
Traffic 5100  
Photo Gallery  
Afloat OSH  
Presentations  
Quota Cancellation  
ORM  
Contact Us  
Recreation  
Maintenance  
Traffic 5100  
Photo Gallery  
Afloat OSH  
Presentations  
Quota Cancellation  
ORM  
Contact Us  
Tactical  
Operations  
Aviation 3750  
Videos  
Ground OSH  
Public Affairs  
Safety Tips  
Tactical  
Operations  
Aviation 3750  
Videos  
Ground OSH  
Public Affairs  
Safety Tips  
 
Parachuting  
School of Aviation Safety  
Shore OSH  
Newsroom/Press Kit  
Seasonal Resources  
 
Parachuting  
Shore OSH  
Newsroom/Press Kit  
Surveys  
What's New on Our Site  
Surveys  
Statistics  
Statistics  
Studies  
Studies  
WESS - On-line Reporting  
WESS - On-line Reporting  
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Naval Safety Center Web Site
 
 
http//www.safetycenter.navy.mil
 
 
 
 

• 1 million hits per month
• Worldwide access
• Single source for Navy Safety materials
• 2nd most viewed Navy Web site
• Hundreds of Links

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
19
Community Involvement

• Scheduled conferences with local Motor vehicle
  safety organizations, Law enforcement, Safety
  managers
• Click-it or Ticket
• Arrive Alive
• Drive for Life
• Mid-Atlantic Partnership Campaign
• NHTSA Drive safe holiday campaigns
• MADD-Mother Against Drunk Driving
• Critical Days of Summer

20
Future PMV Initiatives

• Driver History Profile Initiative
• Motorcycle Skill-Enhanced Rider Course
• Driver training continuum
• Trainer Motorcycles
• Navy-wide Mentorship program
• Revitalized Personal Risk Management
• DBAT Driver Behavior Assessment Tool
• TRiPS Traffic Related Personnel Safety

21
NAVY/MARINE MOTOR VEHICLE FATALITIES
144
NUMBER OF FATALITIES
101
75
66
73
58
53 PMV4 15 PMV2 7 PED
40 PMV4 23 PMV2 3 PED
42 PMV4 25 PMV2 6 PED
32 PMV4 21 PMV2 5 PED
91 PMV4 44 PMV2 9 PED
61 PMV4 36 PMV2 4 PED
As of 17 Aug 07 NSC
22
Questions?
?
Thank You Keep the Rubber Down !
23
The End..