Title: Challenges for HIV Health Care Practitioners regarding Domestic Violence in the Border Communities
1Challenges for HIV Health Care Practitioners
regarding Domestic Violence in the Border
Communities
- Gishela Alfaro, MA, LPCI
- Ellen J. Elliston, PhD, LSCW
- Victim Intervention Program / Rape Crisis
- Parkland Health Hospital System
2(No Transcript)
3Introduction to VIP/ Rape Crisis
- Outpatient clinic under Parkland Health
Hospital System serving residents of Dallas
County - 24 hour response for domestic violence and sexual
assault victims within the hospital - Follow up case management and counseling related
to the abuse - Forensic interviews and expert testimony for
- Domestic violence
- Sexual assault
- Child sexual abuse
- People who have experienced persecution in their
homes countries and are seeking asylum in the
U.S. - Victims of trafficking
4Relevance of Violence to HIV/AIDS
- Underestimated risks
- Presence of domestic violence and/or sexual
assault are risk factors for exposure to HIV - Women who are HIV or have AIDS are at increased
risk for abuse/ violence from their partners or
past partners - Since domestic violence and sexual assault are
both issues that arent openly discussed, we do
not know the actual number of women who
experience either or both
5Domestic violence is an under recognized
barrier regular medical care for HIV/AIDS
- Domestic violence is a barrier to health care due
to - The abusers interference in
- Keeping medical appointments
- Obtaining or taking medication
- The victims emotional condition related to
HIV/AIDS and/or being in an abusive relationship - Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
- Depression
- Shame/ Guilt
- Fear
- Suicidal ideation
6Defining Domestic Violence in relation to HIV /
AIDS
- Domestic violence can be defined as a pattern of
behavior in any relationship that is used to gain
or maintain power and control over an intimate
partner. - Abuse is physical, sexual, emotional, economic or
psychological actions or threats of actions that
influence another person. - This includes any behaviors that frighten,
intimidate, terrorize, manipulate, hurt,
humiliate, blame, injure or wound someone. - Domestic violence can happen to anyone of any
race, age, sexual orientation, religion or
gender. It can happen to couples who are married,
living together or who are dating. - Domestic violence affects people of all
socioeconomic backgrounds and education levels. - National Domestic Violence www. ndvh.org
7Power and Control in Domestic Violence
- Intimidation
- Emotional Abuse
- Isolation
- Minimizing, Denying Blaming
8Power and Control in Domestic Violence
- Using Children
- Male Privilege
- Economic Abuse
- Coercion Threats
9Increased Vulnerability
- A large percentage of women in the U.S. are more
vulnerable to exposure to HIV because of - Abusive/ violent partners or ex-partner
- Childhood sexual abuse
- Sexual assaults from strangers/acquaintances
- Teen date rape and date rape drugs
- Alcohol drug use are associated
with partner abuse HIV - Increase in females being trafficked and forced
to be sex slaves or prostitutes in the U.S.
10Emotional Vulnerability
- When women are abused or sexually assaulted, they
are emotionally vulnerable. HIV/AIDS increases
the emotional vulnerability. - They are trapped, both in their relationships,
by past experiences, and/or with the disease - Heightened risk for depression, anxiety, or PTSD
- Suicidal ideation may increase
- They feel helpless to make changes
- Being identified as HIV increases
- their fear of losing their children
- It is hard to follow a medical regimen
- when you feel hopeless.
11Border Environmental Factors Affecting Both
HIV/AIDS and Domestic Violence
- Poverty
- High risk neighborhoods
- Drugs / alcohol use
- Lack of medical options
- Societal attitudes about women
- Power and control /Gender roles
- Lack of information and information provided to
women
12What Can Service Providers Do?
- Screen
- Support
- Intervene
- Empower through referral
13Screen for Domestic Violence When and Who
- Recommended methods of screening
- Include open ended questions
- Be non-judgmental
- Focus on patients safety
- Sample screening questions
- Do you feel safe?
- Is there anything that goes on at
home that makes you feel
afraid? - Has your partner ever tried to keep
you from taking your
medication or from seeking medical help? - Provide support through counseling,
referrals to domestic violence
agencies
14Screen Things to look for
- Minimization of abuse/violence
- Lack of family or social support
- Lack of knowledge about how
to support herself and children
- Inability to function well in the
American culture
- Being homeless or living with others
- Self blame, guilt, depression,
PTSD or other debilitating
conditions requiring
professional intervention - Intentions to hurt self or others
15Support Avoid Harmful Assumptions
- There are no typical characteristics or profiles
of abusers or victims. Rather than determining
whether someone fits a type, determine whether
warning signs of abuse exist. Care about the
person. - AVOID
- Violating confidentiality
- Minimizing the abuse
- Blaming the victim
- Not respecting her autonomy
- Ignoring her need for safety
- Normalizing victimization
- You may encounter
- Silence as a response from victim
- Resistance as a response from victim
16Intervene Steps Techniques
- Assessing the lethality
- Tips for treatment consistency
- Guarding documentation
- Confidentiality in follow up
- Low profile referral information shoe cards,
nail files with numbers for shelters - Internet safety
17Why we must respond
- Identifying and intervening in domestic abuse
and violence is a critical step in the
treatment and prevention of HIV/AIDS - Comprehensive integrated health care response is
the way to break though this under recognized
barrier to effective HIV/AIDS treatment.
18Empower through referrals Working together
- Referrals for Domestic Violence Agencies
- www.ncadv.org The National Coalition Against
Domestic Violences website contains current
information for survivors and those dealing with
violence. - www.endabuse.org The Family Violence Prevention
Fund website provides materials which can be
ordered, including No Excuse for Abuse
materials and health care provider brochures. - www.nrcdv.org The National Resource Center on
Domestic Violences website features various
publications and resources for organizations and
individuals working to end domestic violence. - www.ncvc.org The National Center for Victims of
Crime information site includes materials on
domestic violence, stalking and sexual assault.
19Working Together
- Victim Intervention Center/
- Rape Crisis
- Parkland Health Hospital System
- 4811 Harry Hines
- Dallas, TX
- 214-590-2926
- www.parklandhospital.com
20Conclusion of Presentation