Title: Revitalization Opportunities of Missouri Brownfields: Approaches to Attracting and Leveraging Funds
1- Revitalization Opportunities of Missouri
Brownfields Approaches to Attracting and
Leveraging Funds - Charlie Bartsch
- www.nemw.org/brownfields.htm
2Following the money.What this presentation will
cover
- Existing financing gaps, and why public-sector
support is needed - Commonly leveraged federal programs
- Low-cost/no-cost tools that can enhance
brownfield transactions - Examples
3The Brownfields Red Zone
- What Impact Does Contamination Have on Financing?
- Conceptualizing and Planning the Project
- Economic Analysis for Marketing the Project
- Dealing with Stigma
- for Site Assessment
- Additional Underwriting/Site Development/R.O.R.
Costs - for Preparing a Cleanup Plan and Taking It
Through - VCP/State/Local Regulatory Agencies
- for Cleanup
Regular Real Estate Construction/Development
Costs When Site is Shovel Ready
4Brownfield Support Can Take Many Forms, Have
Various Goals
- Reduce lenders risk
- loan guarantees companion loans
- Reduce borrowers costs
- interest-rate reductions or subsidies due
diligence assistance - Improve the borrowers financial situation
- re-payment grace periods tax abatements
training and technical assistance help - Provide comfort to lenders or investors
- loan guarantees performance data
- Provide resources directly
- grants forgivable/performance loans
5Where Can You Get the Green for Brownfields?
Federal Financial Assistance Programs
- Grants (continued)
- DOT (various system construction and
rehabilitation programs) - DOTs transportation and community system
preservation (TCSP) pilot grants - Army Corps of Engineers (cost-shared
services) - Equity capital
- SBAs Small Business Investment Companies
- Tax incentives and tax-exempt financing
- Targeted expensing of cleanup costs (through
12/31/05) - Historic rehabilitation tax credits
- Low-income housing tax credits
- Industrial development bonds
- Tax-advantaged zones
- HUD/USDA Empowerment Zones (various
incentives) - HUD/USDA Enterprise Communities (various
incentives)
- Loans
- EDAs Title IX (capital for local revolving loan
funds) - HUD funds for locally determined CDBG loans and
floats - EPA capitalized brownfield revolving loan funds
- SBAs microloans
- SBAs Section 504 development company debentures
- EPA capitalized clean water revolving loan funds
(priorities set/ programs run by each state) - HUDs Section 108 loan guarantees
- SBAs Section 7(a) and Low-Doc programs
- Grants
- HUDs Brownfield Economic Development Initiative
(BEDI) - HUDs Community Development Block Grants (for
projects locally determined) - EPA assessment grants
- EDA Title I (public works) and Title IX (economic
adjustment)
6Where Can You Get the Green for Brownfields?
Federal Programs Most Commonly Used
- Loans
- EDAs Title IX (capital for local revolving loan
funds) - HUD funds for locally determined CDBG loans and
floats - EPA capitalized revolving loan funds
- Grants
- HUDs Brownfield Economic Development Initiative
(BEDI) - HUDs Community Development Block Grants (for
projects locally determined) - EPA assessment and cleanup grants
- EDA Title I (public works) and Title IX (economic
adjustment)
- Grants (continued)
- DOT (various system construction and
rehabilitation programs) - DOTs transportation and community system
preservation (TCSP) grants - Army Corps of Engineers (cost-shared
services) - Tax incentives and tax-exempt financing
- Targeted expensing of cleanup costs (through
12/31/05) - Historic rehabilitation tax credits
- Low-income housing tax credits
7Federal Financing Programs EPA
-
- SITE ASSESSMENT GRANTS
-
- Funds pre-cleanup environmental activities for
example, site assessment, inventories, planning,
design, and outreach -
- SITE CLEANUP GRANTS
-
- Funds cleanups by cities, development agencies,
non-profits, and similar entities at sites that
they own -
- BROWNFIELD CLEANUP REVOLVING LOAN FUND GRANTS
-
- Provides capital to establish RLFs to make low/no
interest loans for cleanup recipients may use up
to 40 of capitalization award for cleanup
sub-grants -
8Firebarn St. Anthony Falls, MN
- Vacant former car dealership and auto
services/body work facilities - Prospective new user demanded clean site
- Hennepin County Health Dept. made a 240,000
BCRLF loan for soil and groundwater cleanup - Leverage -- 30 million mixed-use complex built
on clean site -- 78 housing units, 45,000 square
feet of commercial/retail/ office space
9Consumers Energy Headquarters Jackson County, MI
- In 1999, Jackson proposed a downtown brownfield
site composed of 36 abandoned and underused
parcels on 15 acres for Consumer Energys new
corporate headquarters an EPA assessment grant
helped the city to prioritize target sites for
this project . - Other financing sources include an 8.6-million
Single Business Tax credit from the state to
Consumers Energy and a 1-million Brownfields
Cleanup Revolving Loan Fund grant and a 150,000
Brownfields Supplemental Assistance grant from
U.S. EPA. - Leverage -- Consumers Energys relocation to
downtown retains 600 Jackson jobs while bringing
750 new jobs into the downtown area.
10Federal Financing Programs HUD
- COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANTS (entitlement
and state/small cities) - Activities locally determined
- Can include coping with contamination as part of
financing for site preparation or infrastructure
development - Can be lent to private companies under some
circumstances
11How Can CDBG Funds Be Used For Brownfield
Projects?
- Eligible activities include
- planning for redevelopment or revitalization of
brownfields sites - site acquisition
- environmental site assessment
- site clearance/preparation, including demolition
- removal or remediation of contamination from
sites or structures - rehabilitation of buildings
- construction of real estate improvements
12Visiting Nurses Assisted Living -- Somerville, MA
- Former mattress factory, vacant 2 years.
- Contaminants included barium, lead and petroleum
- The project's redeveloper, the non-profit
Visiting Nurses Association, remediated the site
and demolished the existing structures - VNA constructed an assisted-living facility and
health center, containing 97 units for
low-to-moderate income seniors. - Leverage -- 100,000 in CDBG was used as a
cost-containment reserve.
13Chevy Place Rochester NY
- Former downtown auto dealership and service
garage UST and other contamination - CDBG used for site assessment, partial cleanup
(including tank removal) - Leverage -- 77 new residential units, coffee
house, and restaurant
14Shaws Supermarket Bangor, ME
- Bangor acquired and cleared the 6-acre Bangor
Gas Works site 25 years ago, doing a partial
cleanup - Site cleanup was completed when the Boulos
Company proposed building a 60,000 sq. ft. Shaws
Supermarket - Bangor used 350,000 in state/small cities CDBG
and 975,000 in TIF financing for final cleanup - Leverage -- Boulos invested 7 million in the
building and associated site improvements, and
Shaws spent 1.8 million on equipment and
furnishings for the supermarket.
15Federal Financing Programs HUD
- SECTION 108 LOAN GUARANTEES
-
- Finances site clearance, property acquisition,
infrastructure, or rehabilitation (including
cleanup) activities too big for single-year block
grant funding - Block grant recipients may borrow up to 5 times
their entitlement, for up to 20 years - Requires pledge of future CDBG funds as
collateral - Small cities must work through state CDBG agency
16Federal Financing Programs HUD
- BROWNFIELD ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INITIATIVE (BEDI)
-
- Established to provide additional financial
assistance for brownfield development projects
supported by Section 108 - Must be used in tandem with Section 108 guarantee
- Competitive grant application process
- Non-entitlement small cities not eligible on
their own
17Old Montgomery Ward Distribution Center Fort
Worth, TX
- Historic, 800,000-square-foot building on a
45-acre site - Damaged in March, 2000 tornado
- Proposed reuse mixed light industrial/commercial
/office - Leverage -- mix of financing tools including
- 13 million Section 108 loan
- 2 million BEDI grant
- Historic rehab tax credits
- State tax abatements and fee waivers
- DOT (CMAQ) used for related road sidewalk
infrastructure
18Federal Financing Programs EDA
- ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ADMINISTRATION
- Two major programs
- (1) public works grants finance industrial
development site and infrastructure preparation,
and - (2) economic dislocation program capitalizes RLFs
for distressed areas - EDA also supports rural planning
- 2/3 of all resources traditionally go to small
towns and rural areas
19Bates Mill Lewiston, ME
- Textile mill, shut down in 1993, redeveloped in
stages as small business incubator - EDA funding supported site cleanup and
infrastructure upgrading activities, part of 41
million financing package - Leverage
- 19 tenants occupying 284,000 sq. ft
- Less than 100 employees in 1993 today, 1,000
- Mill generated 160,000 in taxes in 1993 today,
543,000 per year even with tax incentives in
place
20Cimarron Center Sand Springs, OK
- Former zinc smelter, abandoned rail spur in small
OK community - Challenge was structuring a cleanup plan that
made the site was economically competitive for
big-box retail with nearby greenfield - Financing included EDA planning resources, local
TIF - Leverage Cimarron Center, with Wal-Mart
Supercenter as anchor, has created 350 new jobs,
added 3.5 million in annual city sales tax
revenues..
21Federal Financing Programs DOT
- DOT highway and transit construction programs
- Can support brownfields by
- (1) upgrading existing facilities
- (2) offering transportation amenities that
improve access to and marketability of sites - (3) funding facilities and structures that serve
as part of the remedial solution
22Riverfront redevelopment -- Moline, IL
- largely abandoned riverfront
- converted to residential and marina/mixed use
complex and commercial space - Leverage -- 3.2 million in state and federal
funding included DOT funds for roads and
enhancements
23Marsh Island Carry Old Town, ME
- Transformation of an under-used contaminated
warehouse site to a revitalized waterfront park
and commercial property - Funding included a 400,000 Enhancement Grant
from Maine DOT for the park and walkways - Leverage funding sources include
- 400,000 CDBG for infrastructure
- 24,500 from the National Trails Recreation Act
for trails, walkways, and river stabilization - 8,000 from ME Forest Service for tree planting.
24USDA Rural Development Programs With Possible
Brownfield Links
- Community facility loans and grants can support
development activities that include industrial
park sites or access ways - Business and industry loans are available to
public or private organizations to improve the
economic and environmental climate in rural
communities.
25USDA Rural Development Programs With Possible
Brownfield Links
- Intermediary Re-Lending Program intermediaries
such as local governments are loaned money to
re-lend to companies, in order to finance
business facilities - Rural development grants given to provide
operating capital and finance emerging private
business and industry, including conversion,
enlargement, or modernization of buildings,
plant, and equipment.
26East Coast Steel Greenfield, NH
- 2.54 acre site in Greenfield, NH (pop. 1,519)
abandoned by East Coast Steel - Cleanup completed in late 2003
- In 2004, the town redeveloped the site as a
community septic system and open space park - USDA Community Facilities Loan was a critical
part of the 2.1 million in project funding,
along with G.O. bond proceeds
27Federal Financing Programs Tax Incentives
- BROWNFIELD EXPENSING TAX INCENTIVE
-
- Deduction pegged to cleanup costs, which allows
new owners to recover cleanup costs in the year
incurred only incentive targeted to private site
owners. - Expired 12/31/03 Congress re-renewed to
12/31/05, retroactive to the first of this year -
28Inryco and Babcock Wilcox Milwaukee, WI
29Federal Financing Programs Tax Incentives
- REHABILITATION TAX CREDITS
- Taken the year renovated building is put into
service - 20 credit for work done on historic structures,
with rehab work certified by state - 10 credit for work on non-historic structures
build before 1936 no certification required
30Sherman Perk -- Milwaukee, WI
- Abandoned gas station, closed since 1989
- Issues of financing/addressing cost of petroleum
contamination 9 years tax delinquency - Financing included state forgiveness of back
taxes linked to VCP participation, rehabilitation
tax credits - Leverage reuse of historically significant
building as successful neighborhood retail anchor
After
31Federal Financing Programs Tax Incentives
- LOW-INCOME HOUSING TAX CREDITS
-
- Can encourage capital investment in affordable
housing projects on brownfield sites - States get a population-based allocation for
distribution to communities and non-profits
32Circle F Senior Housing Project Trenton, NJ
- Former industrial building converted to 70 units
of senior housing - Developed by non-profit housing organization,
partnering with bank - LIHTCs a key piece of financing package
33Low-Cost/No-Cost Tools That Enhance the Climate
for Brownfield Transactions
- Institutional controls
- California Speedway
- Home Depot, Honolulu
- Innovative remedial technologies
- Williamsport retail
- Cost saving technical assistance/project support
- Victor Building, Camden
- Environmental insurance
- Office building, Cambridge
- Creative revenue generators/offsets
- Golf course, Wyandotte
- Riverfront revitalization, Stamford
- Mills of Carthage, Cincinnati
34California Speedway Fontana, CA
- Institutional controls
- Speedway on a portion of 23-acre former Kaiser
Steel Mill site (from 1942 to 1983) - Raceway and interior facilities used as an
environmental cap, saving hundreds of thousands
in cleanup costs - The California Speedway opened in June 1997
- In 2004, Speedway generated 12.5 million in
economic activity, 2.5 million in new tax
revenues and 1200 new jobs.
35Home Depot Honolulu, Hawaii
- Institutional controls
- First site through Hawaii VCP
- Anchor for new commercial redevelopment area
- Institutional controls venting, capping,
monitoring wells key to economic viability of
project
36Downtown retail, Williamsport, PA
- Innovative technologies
- former airplane engine factory, abandoned nearly
50 years, with groundwater contamination that
proved too costly to treat by conventional means - state and local governments worked with
developer to identify innovative cleanup
technology that would work within standards of
VCP - Result retail complex and parking facility
37Victor Building Camden, NJ
- Cost saving technical assistance and project
support - Abandoned former RCA Victor Building on Camdens
waterfront, with pervasive PCBs - Site intended for residential re-use challenge
was keeping 7 million cleanup manageable - NJDEP provided t.a. to developer, working with
him on remedial and monitoring applications, ICs,
entombment of residual PCBs strategies that
allowed cleanup and redevelopment to go forward
concurrently, all with considerable cost savings - Result 60 million private investment in 341
units, 1st market rate housing built in Camden in
40 years, landmark Nipper Tower saved
38Genzyme Building Cambridge, MA
- Environmental insurance
- Century-old former Cambridge Gas Light MGP
site, vacant 20 years, significant subsurface
contamination - State subsidized environmental insurance key to
leveraging private financing - Result -- contaminated brownfield site now home
to new mixed-use 1.3 million sq. ft.
transit-oriented development that is transforming
Cambridges Kendall Square neighborhood.
Signature 12-story Genzyme Building is seeking
LEED certification
39Chemical Site on Detroit River Wyandotte, MI
- Creative finance
- Defunct, 84 acre chemical manufacturing plant
along the Detroit River, converted into a public
recreation area and a 9-hole golf course - User fees have allowed the golf course to be
self-supporting and pay for maintenance of the
park. - The nine-hole, par 36 golf course cost
approximately 5.2 million in public
funds--supported primarily from Wyandotte's tax
increment finance district and the issuance of
tax increment bonds.
40Stamford, CT Riverfront Revitalization
- Creative finance
- Earmarking of tax revenue from brownfield
successes - Public investment in first site, rolling tax
revenues into subsequent sites
After
41Mills of Carthage Cincinnati, OH
- Creative finance
- Abandoned industrial property was transferred to
new owner for 1, in exchange for an agreement to
take - site through Ohio VCP, clean it up, and reuse it
- First new housing in Carthage neighborhood in 40
years
42Charlies Web Site
- www.nemw.org/brownfields.htm
- Federal Legislative Proposals to Promote
Brownfield Cleanup and Redevelopment - whats
happening in Congress - State of the States - profiles of state VCPs,
including new information on financing
incentives, economic benefits, eligible
contaminants, cleanup standards, and
institutional controls - Guide to Federal Brownfield Programs - detailed
information on programs throughout the federal
government that can promote and support
brownfield cleanup and redevelopment - Financing options for brownfield cleanup and
redevelopment - Contacts in state and federal brownfield programs
- Link to EPA brownfield home page
- Links to brownfield databases and organizations