Title: Lecture II: Political Parties and Political Struggle in the Turmoil of 1917
1Lecture IIPolitical Parties and Political
Struggle in the Turmoil of 1917
- In the framework of the course Crucial Issues of
Russian Political History from the early XXth
century up the present time - Sergey Verigin, Ass. Prof.
- Petrozavodsk State University
2Contents list
- The February Democratic Revolution. The nature of
diarchy - Three political crises in Russia
- The defeat of Kornilov. The process of the
Soviets "bolshevisation" (the process when
Bolsheviks began to play decisive role in the
Soviets). - Victory of armed revolt in Petrograd
3I. The February Democratic Revolution.February
revolution and political parties
- In February 1917 tsar monarchy, after having
existed for more than 300 years, was ruined in
several days. Many historians tried to explain
this phenomenon. Western historiography states,
that the revolution was spontaneous. Soviet
historians persisted that the Bolshevik Party
played an organising role in this revolution. But
the analysis of the facts shows that Bolsheviks
were not able to inspire people for the
revolution in February. - By the beginning of the February Revolution all
democratic parties were in difficult situation.
They didn't carry out any active propaganda
their best leaders were either abroad or in
exile. - Only 2 thousand Bolsheviks worked in Petrograd.
The whole number of them was 24 - 25 thousand
people. They were not guided from one centre.
"Zagranichnaya League" (the part, which worked
abroad) headed by Lenin and Zinovyev worked in
Switzerland. In fact, it fulfilled the functions
of the Central Committee of the RSDRP. The
Russian Bureau of the Central Committee under
the leadership of Shlyapnikov was at the head.
Shlyapnikov had been closely connected with Lenin
till February 1917. - During the World War I there was no unity in the
Menshevik's movement. It's Left wing consisted of
mensheviks - internationalists, who worked abroad
(Y.Martov, P.Acsel'rod), the Organising Committee
and Menshevik's fraction of the IV State Duma
(under the leadership of N.Chxeidze) worked in
Petrograd. - Most of socialist - revolutionary leaders of all
orientations (for example, Defending, Centristic,
International movements) were either abroad
(V.Chernov, B.Savinkov, N.Avkcentiev) or in
Siberian exile (A.Gots, E.Breshko-Breshkovskay
4I.Vladimirov. Generals arrested in February days
of 1917
5February strikes
- Second half of February 1917 - main events took
place in Petrograd. - There were serious problems with the delivery of
bread at that time. This caused a new wave of
strikes, which started on the 23 th of February.
On that day working people also celebrated the
International Women's Day (the 8 th of March -
according to a new style). - Some 128 thousand women took part in the
demonstration. Their slogans were "No war!",
"Give us Bread!", "Bring back our husbands". The
authorities did not pay any attention to this
event. - 24 25 of February - there were conflicts between
strikers and police. The character of peaceful
demonstrations ("Give us Bread") changed and
become a revolutionary one ("Down with the
tsarist autocracy"). On the 26th and 27th of
February strikes spread out, and the Capital
Garrison Units joined working people. - The revolt grew into the change of political
regime.
6State Duma and Provisional Government
- February 27 - the Soviet of Working Deputies
was organised by revolting people. The menshevik
Chxeidze was its first chairman. - The same day members of the state Duma organised
the interim Committee, which formed the
Provisional Government headed by the prince
L?vov. - March 1 - the Petrogradsky Soviet issued the
Order ? 1, according to which the troops of the
Petrograd Garrison were placed under the command
of Soviet and couldnt be called from the capital
without its permission. - The Provisional Government was led first by
Prince Georgy Lvov and then by Aleksandr
Kerensky. It succeeded in organizing the
elections, but failed to end Russia's involvement
in World War I, thereby weakening its popularity
among Russia's war-weary people. It was also
reluctant to make decisive policy decisions,
because it was supposed to be provisional. This
weakness led to challenges from right in the form
of the Kornilov Affair, and from the left, which
brought it to an end in the October Revolution.
When the constituent assembly was disbanded, and
the Mensheviks walked out of the Soviet meeting
in the Smolny Institute, power was left to the
Bolsheviks alone.
7The state emblem of the Provisional Government
8Abdication of Nicolas II
- The attempts to suppress the uprising in the
capital with the help of military units, recalled
from the front were not successful. - March 2, 1917 - in Pskov, Nicolas II signed the
Abdication Act in favour of his brother Michail
Romanov. - M.Romanov didn't take the throne and gave the
Constituent Assembly the right to make a decision
concerning the future state system. The
Provisional Government had to call this Assembly. - The change of the political regime was caused by
a spontaneous burst of people's discontent. The
majority of people believed in a future
deliverance from the war. They believed in
democracy and social justice, but it was an
illusion. The country was in a very difficult
situation.
9Nicolas II.1868-1918
- Nicolas II was the eldest son of emperor
Alexander III. He received home education, and
though he had the best teachers Empire could
offer him, he came to the throne in November 1894
without any political ideas of his own. - Nicolas II married Princess Alix of
Hesse-Darmstadt, a German princess and a
granddaughter of Brittish Queen Victoria. She
took the name Alexandra when converted to Russian
Orthodox Church. She gave birth to four daughters
and a son, Alexis, who had hemophilia. - Nicolas II signed the October Manifesto of 1905
in which he gave Russia main constitutional
freedoms including parliament (State Duma). - Nicolas II was very negative towards two first
Dumas which seemed too radical to him. They were
closed and in June 1907 he limited the electorial
law which allowed the 3rd and 4th Dumas to become
more liberal and bourgeois. - In 1914 Russia was dragged into the World War I.
Crisis which followed the war led to the February
Revolution. In March Nicolas II had no
alternative but to abdicate from the throne. - after the February revolution Nicolas II and his
family were imprisoned and in April 1918 taken to
Ekaterinburg. As the anti-Bolshviks detachments
were approaching the city, local Bolsheviks
killed the royal family in July of 1918, almost
certainly under the order of Vladimir Lenin.
10Nicolas II after abdication in March of 1917.
11Historical conceptions of revolutions in history
- In modern historical literature there are
different approaches to the analysis of the
October period events. According to Lenin's
saying revolution is "a locomotive of history",
a creation of people. - Many Soviet historians considered the October
revolution to be a border line between the
periods of New and Modern Histories. - Many historians abroad consider the World War I,
but not the October revolution to be the
beginning of Modern History (for example,
Japanese historian Vada). - French historian Gorge Lephevr had a concept of
the Great French Revolution as a complex of
separate revolutions. According to Vada,
Lephevr's concept fits completely the revolution
of 1917, that is, this revolution is a complex of
4 independent revolutions - 1. The Bourgeois and People's Revolution
- 2. The Workers and Soldiers Revolution
- 3. The Peasants Revolution
- 4. The Revolution of nationalists.
- The February Revolution won due to the
combination of the first two revolutions, and the
October revolution was a combination of the 2nd,
3rd and 4th revolutions - After February the revolution of workers and
peasants took place. October revolution was a
victory of Bolsheviks, workers and soldiers over
the bourgeoisie. Russian peasants and peoples,
living in national districts also contributed to
the victory.
12Diarchy of power (two powers)
- As it was mentioned before, the diarchy (that is
the power of Soviets and the Provisional
Government after February revolution) was the
result of the February revolution. The Petrograd
Soviet, formed in the revolution, had an
opportunity to concentrate all the power in its
hands, but failed to do that. Soviet leaders
(mensheviks and socialist-revolutionaries)
thought that a bourgeois revolution had taken
place in Russia and they handed the power over to
the bourgeois Provisional Government. - The majority of Bolsheviks had the same opinion,
by the beginning of April 1917 2 factions
(Bolsheviks and Mensheviks) had to merge into
one, but Lenin prevented this event.
13Lenin and the February revolution
- On April 3, 1917 - Lenin returned from the
emigration to Petrograd and on April 4 he
announced a new programme. His ideas were not to
stop at the bourgeois stage of the revolution,
but to go over to a socialist one. - The disputes about Lenin's return to Russia
across Germany being in war with Russia are still
in progress. The versions about the German
pecuniary aid to Bolsheviks were widely spread, - as well as the information that Lenin was an
agent of the German General Staff. We don't share
these extreme points of view. But it is necessary
to stress the fact that for Germany it was
favourable to let Lenin pass through to Russia,
because he spoke in support of tsarist defeat in
the war and of Russia withdrawal from it.
14Vladimir Lenin (Ulyanov) (1870-1924)
- Lenin's desire to destroy autocracy in Russia
began when his brother Alexander was executed for
anti-tsarist strikes. Lenin's revolutionary life
dates to the late1880s. He was one of the
founders of the "Union of struggle for
deliverance of the Russian people" in 1895. - In 1897 Lenin was sentenced to a 3-year exile in
Siberia. In 1900 he left Russia. In 1903 after
the split of the RSDWP he headed the Bolshevik
faction. In 1905-7, during the first Russia
revolution, was in Russia, in 1907 he had to flee
to Europe again. - In April 1917 Lenin came to Petersburg and in his
"April Theses" stated that socialist revolution
had to be the target of the Bolshivik Party.
After the July crisis of 1917 was in hiding,
because Kerensky, the head of the Provisional
Government, accused him of anti-government
activities. In October 1917 Lenin headed the
revolt which gave a power to the Bolsheviks.
After the revolt he headed the Soviet government
and the Soviet of Defence. - Lenin supervised the first 5 years of Bolsheviks'
policy (war communism, NEP, peace with Germany,
etc) till he got seriously ill in December of
1922. Since that time Lenin did not participate
in political life.
15Vladimir Lenin (Ulyanov) (1870-1924)
16II. Three political crisis in RussiaApril crisis
- The Provisional Government declared that it
supported democratic principles The Government
abolished the system of estates and national
restrictions. But a final decision of those
questions was put off till a calling of the
Constituent Assembly. - On April 18 - Milyukov sent a note to the Allied
governments, promising to continue the war to a
victorious conclusion. This pronouncement, in
sharp contrast with the earlier declaration "to
the people of the whole world" issued by the
Petrograd Soviet on March 14. Contrary to the
proposal of General Lavr Georgiyevich Kornilov to
quell the demonstrations by force, the Petrograd
Soviet, which assumed sole command of the
garrison of the capital, ordered all troops to
remain in their barracks. As a result of the
political crisis, Milyukov and Guchkov resigned,
and the government was reorganized on May 5 to
include representatives of the socialist parties,
which received 6 of the 15 portfolios Kerensky
became minister of war.
17June crisis
- The crisis stimulated considerable growth in the
Bolshevik Party, but it still held only a
minority of the delegates to the first
all-Russian Congress of Soviets, which was held
in Petrograd on June 3. This congress was
dominated by the Mensheviks and Socialist
Revolutionaries. - The workers responded with economic and political
strikes and with demands that the government
institute measures to cope with the crisis. The
Congress of Soviets, which supported the
government, declared in favor of state monopolies
of bread and other necessary items. The
government, however, like its predecessor,
subordinated all problems to the prosecution of
the war. On June 16 Kerensky ordered an offensive
that ended in a complete defeat and the virtual
disorganization of the armyall of which added
credibility to Bolshevik propaganda. Discipline
broke down, and millions of soldiers streamed
home from the front to escape further fighting
and to take part in the division of the land.
18Trotsky's speech against the Provisional
Government
19July crisis
- During the ill-fated offensive, the opposition by
workers and soldiers in Petrograd to a renewal of
military hostilities forced the Congress of
Soviets to adopt a resolution calling for the
abolition of the Dumathat is, the political base
of the Provisional Governmentand setting
September 30 as the date for the convocation of a
constituent assembly. A demonstration of about
400,000 Petrograd workers, organized by the
Congress of Soviets during the offensive,
unexpectedly revealed that the Bolshevik
influence was very strong in the working class of
the capital the prevailing slogans in the
demonstrations were "Down with the Offensive" and
again "All Power to the Soviets." - On July 3, 4, and 5, there were a demonstrations
of 500,000 workers, soldiers of the city
garrison, and sailors of the nearby naval
fortress of Kronstadt. The demonstrators
denounced the government and converged on the
Tauride Palace, where the Congress of Soviets was
in session, to force it to assume sole power. - The executive committee of the Congress of
Soviets denounced the demonstration as a
counterrevolutionary Bolshevik insurrection and
summoned troops from the front to disperse the
demonstrators. The troops, arriving on July 5,
when the demonstration had run its course, placed
themselves at the disposition solely of the
Congress of Soviets, in effect recognizing it as
the supreme governing authority in the country. - On July 10 Kerensky succeeded Lvov as prime
minister, and on July 23 a second coalition
government, including the Socialist and Kadet
wings, was formed, with Kerensky and his
political friends holding the decisive posts.
20Demonstration is fleeting from the troops loyal
to the Provisional Government. July 1917
21III. The defeat of Kornilov. The process of the
Soviets "bolshevisation" (the process when
Bolsheviks began to play decisive role in the
Soviets).Kornilovs revolt
- End of the summer 1917 - the insolvency of the
Provisional Government economic policy had become
obvious. The unemployment increased there was a
deficit of top priorities. The agrarian question
was not solved in the country, peasants struggled
against landowners. They captured land without
any permission. The Bolsheviks encouraged these
actions. - The crisis became deeper. At the end of August
1917 the right forces tried to undertake a coup
d'etat and to establish a military dictatorship
in the country. - The July demonstration produced a wave of
political reaction. Some land committees were
dissolved by the government the death penalty,
abolished during the first days of the
revolution, was restored in the fighting zones
although not enforced and the convocation of the
constituent assembly was postponed to the end of
November. Forceful methods were employed against
the Bolsheviks. Lenin was denounced as a paid
agent of German imperialism and went into hiding
in Finland Trotsky and others were arrested. - Nonetheless, the Sixth Congress of the Bolshevik
Party opened in Petrograd on July 26, despite the
absence of some of its leaders.
22Kornilovs revolt
- Because the Kerensky government took no effective
steps to overcome the economic situation,
Bolshevik influence again began to increase.
Convinced that Kerensky could not cope with the
situation, some Kadet elements and the general
staff, led by Kornilov, the newly appointed
commander in chief, decided to bring loyal troops
to Petrograd and establish a military
dictatorship. For a time Kerensky was a party to
the conspiracy, but when he learned that Kornilov
proposed to remove him from the government, he
appealed to the Petrograd Soviet for support. - While Kornilov's forces advanced on the capital,
the workers' and soldiers' militia prepared to
defend it. With the approval of the Congress of
Soviets, military organizations were established
throughout the city, and the boldness and
initiative of the Bolsheviks in these bodies made
them the leaders of the defense. The railroad
workers refused to transport Kornilov's force. As
the troops advanced on foot, they encountered the
soldiers and workers of the capital, who came out
of the city to meet them with appeals to
fraternize. Kornilov's army dissolved before it
reached the capital he himself was arrested.
These events left the workers of Petrograd
organized and armed. And now, for the first time,
the Bolsheviks secured a majority in the
Petrograd Soviet.
23Kornilov's defeat
- After Kornilov's defeat the Provisional
Government was virtually powerless. - Under growing Bolshevik pressure the All-Russian
Soviet Executive Committee decided on the
election of a new Congress of Soviets on October
20 later it was postponed to October 25. - A Bolshevik majority in the new congress was
assured by the rising tide of support for Lenin's
party among the soldiers and workers. On October
16 the Petrograd Soviet created the Military
Revolutionary Committee for the defense of the
capital against the counterrevolution on this
committee the Bolsheviks obtained a commanding
majority, and the Mensheviks and Socialist
Revolutionaries there upon refused to participate.
24Bolshevisation of Soviets
- The Soviets under Bolshevik control found a way
out. - March 2, 1917 - only 19 members (the whole
number of them was 400) of the Petrograd Soviet
voted for the Bolshevik's Resolution against the
assignation of power to the Provisional
Government, but on the 31st of August the
majority of this Soviet voted for the Bolshevik's
proposal..
25Provisional government's losing power
- September 1 - the Provisional Government
declared Russia republic. On the same day A.
Kerensky informed the Soviet Central Executive
Committee about formation of a Directory,
consisted of 5 people, as a provisional body for
the operative country management. On the 2nd of
September CEC (Central Executive Committee)
passed a resolution about a calling of a
Democratic Conference, which had to solve the
question of power. And at that moment CEC called
for the support of Kerensky's Government. But
this government couldn't improve the country
economy. The inflation increased, there were
serious problems with food and fuel deliveries.
All these events accelerated the loss of
Kerensky's Government authority. And Kornilov's
defeat demonstrated the power of the Left wing,
headed by Bolsheviks.
26Lavr Kornilov (1870-1918 )
27Aleksandr Kerensky(1881-1970)
28Democratic Conference
- September 14 - the Democratic Conference began
its work. L.Trotsky being elected as a chairman
of the Petrograd Soviet in September 1917 spoke
at this meeting and demanded to transfer all
power to the Soviets. - There was a lot of debates during the conference.
It didn't decide anything and passed the question
of power to the pre-parliament, a working body,
elected at the Democratic Conference. - September 25 - the Government crisis ended with
the organising of the 3d coalition government. - A.Kerensky was a Head and Commander in Chief.
They also decided to call the 2nd All-Russian
Congress of Soviet on the 20 of October.
29Bolsheviks and the Congress of Soviets
- Such after the beginning of the Democratic
Conference Bolsheviks stood up for the quickest
calling of the Congress and proclaimed the slogan
"All Power to Soviets!" The meaning of this
slogan was understood differently. - Left wing Bolsheviks (such as Lenin, Trotsky)
believed that the Congress of Soviets had to
transfer the power to the Left Parties
Government, which would immediately make peace
and realise the programme of radical reforms. - Right wing Bolsheviks (L.Kamenev, G.Zinovyev)
considered the Congress to be a possibility to
form a Government on a homogeneous socialist
basis.
30IV. Victory of armed revolt in
PetrogradPreparations for revolt
- After the Democratic Conference the Left wing
Bolsheviks began an active preparation of a
military revolt. A large amount of the Red Army
Military forces and units appeared to be under
their control. On the 10th of October the CK
(Central Committee) of Bolshevik accepted an
offer of the Left wing to prepare a military
revolt.. The Military Revolutionary Committee
(MRC-VRK) was formed for this purpose. It was
planed to transfer the power to Petrograd Soviet
by the 25th of October- the date of opening of
the 2nd All-Russian Congress of Soviets. This
Congress would sanction such a transfer. This
tactics proved to be correct.
31Kerenskys counteractions
- But Kerensky's Government tried to suppress a
possible Left wing uprising. Loyal troops were
concentrated in the capital, but the number of
them was not enough. - October 24 - Kerensky came to pre-parliament
and demanded to put him confidence in struggle
against Bolsheviks. - Mensheviks and Socialist-revolutionaries
suggested starting negotiations with Bolsheviks.
Kerensky rejected these proposals and in the
morning of the 25th of October he left Petrograd
for Pskov. He moved to the North Front Head
-quarters to assemble loyal units.
32Troops of Provisional Government guarding a
telegraph station
33October revolt
- It is generally believed that the insurrection
was planned by the military organization of the
party to coincide with the opening of the second
Congress of Soviets. It was carried out during
the night of October 24 to 25 and the following
day by the Military Revolutionary Committee under
the direction of Trotsky. - Armed workers, soldiers, and sailors stormed the
Winter Palace, headquarters of the Provisional
Government. Although the seizure of power
involved tens of thousands of men and women, it
was virtually bloodless. - On the afternoon of October 25 Trotsky announced
the end of the Provisional Government. Several of
its ministers were arrested later that day
Kerensky escaped and subsequently went into
exile. - In the evening October 24 Bolsheviks started the
revolt. During the night and the next day the
headquarters, telegraph, telephone stations, post
offices, bridges and so on had been captured by
the workers. - In the morning of the 25th of October the VRK
(Military Revolutionary Committee) of Petrograd
Soviet declared that the Provisional Government
was overthrown.
34October revolt
- In the of October 25 - in Smolniy the 2nd
All-Russian Congress of Soviet began its work. - At 4 a.m. it was reported that Winter Palace was
captured, and the Provisional Government was
arrested. - 507 delegates out of 670 supported the power
transfer to the Soviets.
35New legislative acts. Soviet government
- The Congress passed two main documents the
'Decree on Peace" contained proposals to all the
belligerents to start the negotiation on just and
democratic peace. - The "Decree on Land" consisted of the mandate of
242 peasant-deputies, according to which all land
was transmitted to people's property, private
property was abolished, and every man could
cultivate land on the basis of equal land use. - The Congress guaranteed a calling of the
Constituent Assembly, the power in regions was
transferred to local Soviets. - A new membership of VCIK (All-Russian Central
Executive Committee) -101 people (62 Bolsheviks
and 29 Left socialist-revolutionaries among them)
was formed at the Congress. - The Soviet Government - that is the Soviet of
People's Commissary (only Bolsheviks were members
of it), was formed. Lenin became the head of the
Government, the first people's commissars were
Stalin, Trotsky, Rykov, in all - 13 people.
36Spread of the Bolsheviks power
- The period from October 1917 to March 1918 is
characterised by the establishment of the Soviet
Power all over the country. It was established
peacefully in 79 cities out of 97. - The organisation of the country government system
was the main task. - By the summer of 1918 VCIK (All-Russian Central
Executive Committee) and Soviet of Peoples
Commissaries had adopted about 700 decrees, which
became the basis of a future legislation. - Revolutionary Law-courts, elected by Soviets,
were set up. - In December 1917 the Russian Extraordinary
(Emergency) Commission (VChK) headed by
Dzerdjinsky, was formed. In fact it often
exceeded its authority. From the first days of
its existence the Soviet Government carried out
several reforms in the interests of working
people, such as 8 hours working day, the system
of women and teenagers labour protections,
education free of charge and medical care. They
proclaimed equality and sovereignty of nations, a
right for self-determination (even for State
separation).
37Constituent Assembly. Formation of RSFSR.
- January 5, 1918 - The Constituent Assembly
started its work. - Some 715 delegates, 412 -socialist-revolutionarie
s and only 183-bolsheviks among them' were
present at it. - On behalf of SNK and VCIK Ia.Sverdlov proposed to
adopt " The Declaration of Working and Oppressed
People Rights", in which accepted decrees were
reflected. He also suggested the Constituent
Assembly to recognise the Soviet Power. - But that didn't happen. After that Bolsheviks
and Left wing socialist-revolutionaries made
protest and left the conference hall. The other
delegates decided to continue the work, but on
the next day -on the 6th of January 1918 the
Constituent Assembly was broken up by force. - On the 10th of January 1918 the 3d All-Russian
Congress of Soviet was opened. It accepted "The
Declaration of Working and Oppressed People
Rights", declared Russia to be the Russian Soviet
Federal Socialist Republic (RSFSR).
38Soviet republic and World War I
- Having declared "The Decree on Peace", the Soviet
Republic demonstrated its variant of withdrawal
from the First World War. The essence of it is
that people had to solve this problem themselves. - Soviet proposals were rejected by Antanta
(England and France), but accepted by Germany. - On the 14th of November 1917 Separate
negotiations began in Brest-Litovsk and on the 3d
of March 1918 a peaceful treaty was signed. - Trying to hold up the power, the Soviet
Government headed by Lenin agreed to a
humiliating ultimatum of Germany the Ukraine,
Finland, Poland, Georgia, Baltic countries were
seized from the Soviet Russia. Nearly 75 of
metallurgical industry, 27 of plough land were
situated on this territory. They imposed a great
contribution on Russia. - Such a humiliating peace treaty intensified
disunity of the Russian society. It accelerated
the Civil War.
39Russias economy. Provision units
- The Bolsheviks coming to power was not a
stabilising factor in economy. The sabotage of
officers and businessmen strengthened. The Soviet
Government began a process of mass
nationalisation of factories, plants, banks, and
railways. This led to the industry
disorganisation. - There was a falling-of in relations with
peasants. The desire to provide cities with
food-staffs led to provisional dictatorship. - Provision units were organised in cities,
which were sent to villages to confiscate surplus
grain. The Poor People Committees were organised
in the villages. In fact they became powerful
bodies in the country. - Both Provision's Unites and Poor People
Committees abused power and arms. Their actions
caused military resistance of peasants in the
spring and summer of 1918.
40Rapture with left SRs
- Strict measures of Bolsheviks were the reasons of
counteractions not only of the enemies but of the
allies-left-wing socialist-revolutionaries as
well. Brest peace and the agrarian reform caused
the main disagreements - .At the 5th Congress of Soviets (July 1918) Left
wing socialist-revolutionaries tried to urge
delegates to reject a peaceful treaty and the
Poor People Committee's decree. They failed to do
this. And on the 6th of July military uprising
took place in Moscow and some other cities. - The revolt was suppressed but the consequences
were serious. One party system was finally
formed. The desertion of the Left wing
socialist-revolutionaries to the Bolshevik's
enemies completed the polarization of political
forces in the country. - The October Revolution didn't stabilize political
and economic situation in the country but put
Russia on the brink of the Civil War.
41Literature to the topic 2
- Charques R.D. The twilight of imperial Russia
the reign of Tsar Nicolas II (1894-1917). London
Phoenix House, 1958. 256 p. - Crankshaw E. The shadow of the Winter Palace the
drift to revolution, 1825-1917. London
Macmillan, 1976. 429 p. - Florinsky M.T. The end of the Russian Empire. New
York Collier Book, 1961, 254 p. - Floyd D. Russia in revolt, 1905 the first crack
in Tsarist power. London Macdonalds, 1969. 127
p. - Frankland N. Crown of tragedy Nicholas II.
London Kimber, 1960. 208 p.