Title: Breast Surgery Past, Present
1 Breast Surgery Past, Present Future
- Texas Tumor Registrars Association
- September 29, 2005
- Walton Taylor, MD
- Co-Director Presbyterian Allen Breast Center
- Co-Director Dallas Breast Center at Forest Park
2Basic Cancer Management
- Local Therapy
- Regional Therapy
- Systemic Therapy
3Past Interactions
Imager
Surgery
Medical Oncology
Radiation
4Past Surgical Breast Care
- Imaging Xeromammograms/Thermography
- Surgery - Mastectomy
- Adjuvant Therapy not much
- Breast surgery was relegated to general surgeons
who did not like doing it!
5Current Interactions
Imager
Surgery
Medical Oncology
Radiation
6Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging
- Biopsy
- Coordination of BC Treatment
- Operative Care
- Lesion Targeting for lumpectomy
- Whole Breast Surgery
- Axillary Surgery
- Post-operative
- Radiation Therapy
- Chemotherapy and Hormonal Therapy
7Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging plain films/ultrasound
8Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging plain films or digital
- 13MHz ultrasound
9Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging plain films or digital
- 13MHz ultrasound MRI
10Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging plain films or digital
- Ultrasound
- MRI
- PET
- PET Mammography
11Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
- Office Care
- Biopsy - 14g core
12Stereotactic Biopsy
Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
13Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- Office Care
- Ultrasound Biopsy 8 or 11g Core Devices
- Larger cores, fewer indeterminant dxs
- EnCor
- Vacora
- Cassi
- Neothermia
- ATEC
- Mammotome
14Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- Office Care
- Ultrasound (or Stereotactic) Biopsy
- 8 or 11g Core
- Ultrasound Visible Clip Placement
15Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- US visible marker
- absorbable echogenic material plus wire marker
- placed at Stereotactic or Ultrasound Biopsy
- visible several weeks
- Allows OR ultrasound localization if needed
16(No Transcript)
17MRI Guided Biopsy
Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
18Coordination of Breast Cancer Care
- Either make the diagnosis or at least discuss the
entire care plan with patient - Surgery
- /- NeoAdjuvant Chemo or Hormonal therapy
- /- Adjuvant Chemo or Hormonal therapy
- /- Radiation Therapy
- Emotional support of patient and their
family/friends
19Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging
- Biopsy
- Coordination of BC Treatment
- Operative Care
- Lesion Targeting for lumpectomy
- Whole Breast Surgery
- Axillary Surgery
- Post-operative
- Radiation Therapy
- Chemotherapy and Hormonal Therapy
20- Breast Surgery - Lumpectomy
- Needle Localization
- Non-Palpable to Palpable Localization
- Anchor Guide
- Cryoassisted Lumpectomy
- Palpable Mass Lumpectomy
-
21Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
Breast Surgery Lumpectomy
22Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
Lesion Targeting
- Preoperative Needle Localization (PNL)
- Tried and true, reliable
- Time-consuming
- Cumbersome Scheduling
- first case 10 AM
- limited time slots
- Little help with margin control
- Does not make lesion palpable or retractable
23Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
Breast Surgery Needle Localization
24Lesion Targeting US guidance for US visible
lesions
Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- Before prep
- Note depth
- Proximity to skin
- Proximity to fascia
- Mark location
- /- place wire
25US guidance for US visible lesions
- place wire (routine or selective)
- Small lesion or large breast
26US guidance for US visible lesions
- Intraoperative US
- Examine specimen
27US guidance for US visible lesions
- Intraoperative US
- Margin control
- Tissue Conservation
28Make a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach a
handle)
- RF assisted wire anchor
- Cryo Assisted Lumpectomy (CAL)
29Make a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach a
handle)
- RF assisted wire anchor
- RF wire loop at tip
30Make a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach a
handle)
- RF assisted wire anchor (cont.)
- Radially-oriented prongs
- deploy at opposite angles
- outward from lesion center
31Make a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach a
handle)
- RF assisted wire anchor (cont.)
- Deployed device tip and prongs palpable
Preliminary data Improved margin control with
tissue conservation
32Making a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach
a handle)
- Positive Margins
- PNL (37) 30
- AG (30) 10
33Making a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach
a handle)
- cryoprobe assisted lumpectomy
- Cryotherapy technology
- Cryoprobe placed through lesion with US
Image courtesy of Sanarus
34Make a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach a
handle)
- cryoprobe assisted lumpectomy (cont.)
35Make a nonpalpable lesion palpable(and attach a
handle)
- cryoprobe assisted lumpectomy (cont.)
- Real-time US monitors iceball formation
Images Courtesy of Lorraine Tafra, MD
- Edges of iceball advance past periphery of
lesion
- Iceball maintained as surgeon dissects around
now- palpable mass
36Cryo Assisted Lumpectomy Study
- Prospective, randomized 330 patients
- Cancers seen on sono and lt1.7 cm
- Randomized 2/3 CAL 1/3 NWL
- Endpoints
- Operative time
- Volume of tissue removed
- Pathologic margins
- Cosmesis
37Palpable Mass Lumpectomy
Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
38Palpable Mass Lumpectomy
Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
39Palpable Mass Lumpectomy
Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
40Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging
- Biopsy
- Coordination of BC Treatment
- Operative Care
- Lesion Targeting/Lumpectomy
- Whole Breast Surgery
- Axillary Surgery
- Post-operative
- Radiation Therapy
- Chemotherapy and Hormonal Therapy
41 Mastectomy
Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
- Elliptical Incisions
- Avoid the Dog Ears - oncoplastic
- Reconstruction Options
- TRAM Flap
- Latissimus Flap
- Implant/Expander
42 Whole Breast Surgery
Breast Surgery Current State of the Art
- Skin Sparing Mastectomy with reconstruction
- ?Nipple Sparing Mastectomy controversial
- Oncoplastic Techniques
- Lumpectomy with reduction
- Local tissue advancement flaps
- Contralateral reduction/mastopexy to match
ipsilateral reconstruction
43Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging
- Biopsy
- Coordination of BC Treatment
- Operative Care
- Lesion Targeting/Lumpectomy
- Whole Breast Surgery
- Axillary Surgery
- Post-operative
- Radiation Therapy
- Chemotherapy and Hormonal Therapy
44Axillary Surgery
- Past (? Present) Complete Axillary Lymph Node
Dissection - Morbid lymphedema, ROM, neuro deficits
- Less accurate
- Techniques varied
45Axillary Surgery
- Present Standard of Care Sentinel Lymph Node
Biopsy
46Axillary Surgery
- Present Standard of Care Sentinel Lymph Node
Biopsy
47Axillary SLN Surgery
- NSABP B-32 Randomized study of SLN vs. SLN
CALND in SLN negative patients (5600 pts) - Identification rate 97
- False negative 9.7
- 60 only one positive lymph node
- SLN significantly less morbid than CALND
48Axillary SLN Surgery
- ACOSOG Z10 Immunohistochemical analysis of
negative SLNs and bone marrow (5400 pts) - Low morbidity with SLN
- 12 IHC () unknown clinical significance
49Axillary SLN Surgery
ACOSOG Z11 Randomized Trial of Observation vs.
CALND for SLN Positive Pts
50Axillary Surgery
- Present State of the Art Sentinel Lymph Node
Biopsy - or PET
51Axillary Surgery
- Present State of the Art Sentinel Lymph Node
Biopsy - or PET Ultrasound Monitoring
52Breast Surgery Current Standard of Care
State of the Art
- Office Care
- Diagnostic Imaging
- Biopsy
- Coordination of BC Treatment
- Operative Care
- Lesion Targeting
- Breast Surgery
- Axillary Surgery
- Post-operative
- Radiation Therapy
- Chemotherapy and Hormonal Therapy
53Radiation Oncology
- Present Standard of Care
- Whole Breast Radiation with tumor bed boost
- possible treatment of regional basins
54Radiation Oncology
55Multi-catheter Brachytherapy
Kuske template
56Mammosite Balloon Catheter
- MammoSite device (Proxima Therapeutics)
- Inflatable Balloon Placed In Lumpectomy Cavity
- Remote Afterloading
- 3400 cGy (340 cGy X 10) in 5 days
- FDA approval May 2002
Proxima Therapeutics
573D Conformal External Beam RadiotherapyPhase
I/II PBI Trial- William Beaumont Hospital -
Lt ASIO
Rt PSIO
Rt AISO
Lt AISO
58(No Transcript)
59Systemic Therapy
- Past Hormonal Tamoxifen
- Chemotherapy CMF, AC, T, others
- Present Hormonal AIs
- Chemotherapy Her/EGFR blockers chemo
60The Future
61Future Shock
- Breast Specialization by 2009 - 75 of breast
cancer care will be delivered by 250 centers - Breast Imager
- Breast Surgeon
- Breast Medical Oncologist
- Breast Radiation Oncologist
62Future Interactions ?
Imager/Surgeon
Medical Oncology
Radiation
63High Risk Assessment
- Gail Risk Assessment
- Claus Model Assessment
- Genetic Profiling
- Brca testing
- Oncovue
64Future Breast Cancer Treatment
- Diagnostic Biopsy tumor/genetic markers
- Treatment
- MRI to map complete extent of tumor
- Neo-ablation therapy to maximally shrink tumor
- Percutaneous ablation ultrasound, stereo, or
MRI guided - MRI to assess complete destruction
- Sentinel node irrelevant
- Radiation therapy focused or whole breast based
on initial MRI pattern of tumor
65Future Breast Cancer Treatment
- Diagnostic Biopsy tumor/genetic markers
- Oncotech
- Precision Therapeutics
- Gene Arrays
- Oncotype DX
- Tumor typing
66Oncotype DX Technology Final Gene Set
PROLIFERATION Ki-67 STK15 Survivin Cyclin B1 MYBL2
ESTROGEN ER PGR Bcl2 SCUBE2
HER2 GRB7 HER2
GSTM1
REFERENCE Beta-actin GAPDH RPLPO GUS TFRC
CD68
INVASION Stromolysin 3 Cathepsin L2
BAG1
67Oncotype DX Need for Better Markers of
Recurrence
68Future Breast Cancer Treatment
- Diagnostic Biopsy tumor/genetic markers
- Treatment
- MRI to map complete extent of tumor
- Neo-ablation therapy (chemo/biologic/hormonal)
to maximally shrink tumor - Percutaneous ablation ultrasound, stereo, or
MRI guided - MRI to assess complete destruction
- Sentinel node irrelevant
- Radiation therapy focused or whole breast based
on initial MRI pattern of tumor
69Ablative Techniques
- Technology developed for hepatic tumors now
applied to treatment of other tumors including
breast - Core biopsy pre-ablation for definitive
histologic diagnosis and thorough analysis of the
cancer - ER/PR, Her-2/neu, EGFR, Oncotype DX, etc.
- Current protocols for breast malignancy are
ablation followed by resection (future MRI
examination for completeness of ablation plus
peri-tumoral core biopsies)
70Ablative Techniques
- Current ablative techniques under investigation
include radiofrequency, cryoablation, focused
ultrasound, microwave and laser - Image-guided (ultrasound, stereotactic or MR)
which allows localization of tumor in
three-dimensions for percutaneous ablation
71Ablative Techniques
- Ablation of breast lesions can be performed in
the radiology suite, office setting or in
ambulatory operating room - Will offer patients an alternative to surgical
excision for treatment of benign and malignant
disease
72Radiofrequency (RF) Ablation
- Destruction of solid tumors through heat
- Generated by high frequency alternating current
- Probe itself is not the source of heat, but a
frictional heat from ions within tissue changing
direction with alternating current
73RF Breast Cancer Ablation
- Insulated 15 g probe placed by ultrasound or
stereotactic guidance - Electrode prongs emerge in star-like array
- Allows larger diameter of tissue destruction
- Size adjustable
- Temperature sensing feedback to assess target
temperature
74(No Transcript)
75(No Transcript)
76(No Transcript)
77(No Transcript)
78(No Transcript)
79(No Transcript)
80(No Transcript)
81RF Breast Cancer Ablation
- 5-7 minute to reach target temperature 950C
- 15 minutes at target
- 1 minute cool down
82(No Transcript)
83(No Transcript)
84Edge of ablation zone
85RF Breast Cancer Ablation
- Pathological Analysis
- Standard HE
- NADH tumor viability stain
- Viable cells stain - blue (cytoplasmic granules
with NADH oxidation reaction) - Non-viable cells stain- grey-washed out
86RF Breast Cancer Ablation Studies
Jeffrey et al, Arch Surg, 1999Izzo et
al, Cancer, 2001Elliot et al, Amer Surg, 2002
87RF Ablation and Pre/Post Imaging
- Burak et al, 10 pts with RF ablation and
subsequent resection - Pre and post ablation MRI
- 9/10 no enhancement on post ablation MRI
- Corresponded with residual diseases upon
resection - Burak et al, Cancer, 98, 2003
88Cryoablative Technique
- Longstanding successful treatment of metastatic
hepatic tumors - Similar technology now being applied as primary
treatment for variety of tumors including
fibroadenomas - Investigational studies are underway for breast
cancer - Core biopsy or FNA pre-ablation for definitive
diagnosis
89Cryoablative Technique
- Image-guided via ultrasound which allows 3D
localization of tumor for percutaneous ablation - Local anesthetic to skin freezing acts as
anesthetic to deep tissue - Cryoablation of fibroadema can be performed in
the office setting or in ambulatory operating
room
90(No Transcript)
91Cryoablation of Fibroadenoma
- Argon gas creates sonographic freezeball
- Real-time monitoring encompass tumor
- Multiple freeze-thaw cycles with target temp
-160 / -196oC
92Cryoablation of Fibroadenomas
- Multi-institutional series (50 patients)
- Core biopsy dx/cryoablation w/o resection
- Tumor size
- range 0.7cm-4.2cm
- median 2.0 cm
- Tumor volume decrease
- 65 at 6 months
- 95 at 12 months
- Kaufman et al, Amer J Surg, 1842002
93(No Transcript)
94(No Transcript)
95(No Transcript)
96(No Transcript)
97Cryoablation of Fibroadenomas
- FDA approved treatment of fibroadenomas
- Currently being used in several institutions off
protocol for treatment without surgical removal
98Cryoablation for Breast Cancers
99Cryoablation Breast Cancer Studies Rand
et al, Cryobiology, 1985Staren et al, Arch Surg,
1997Stocks et al, Abstract, Amer Soc of Breast
Surgeons, 2002
100Cryoablation of Breast Cancers
- 27 breast T1 invasive breast cancers
- Mean tumor size 1.2cm (range 0.6-2.0cm)
- Ultrasound guided cryoablation
- Surgical resection by lumpectomy post ablation
- Average time to resection 14 days (range 6-30
days) - SLNB performed in 25/27 patients
- M. Sable, C. Kaufman, P. Whitworth, H. Change, L.
Stocks, R. Simmons, M. Schultz - Ann Surg Onc, 2004
101Cryoablation of Breast Cancers
- No procedural complications
- No patient required narcotics for analgesia
- M. Sable, C. Kaufman, P. Whitworth, H. Change, L.
Stocks, R. Simmons, M. Schultz - Ann Surg Onc, 2004
102Cryoablation of Breast Cancers
- 23/27 patients (85) showed no viable invasive
tumor - 4/27 showed DCIS surrounding the cryozone
- 2 cases adjacent to cryozone
- 2 cases multifocal disease away from cryozone
- M. Sable, C. Kaufman, P. Whitworth, H. Change, L.
Stocks, R. Simmons, M. Schultz - Ann Surg Onc, 2004
103Success of Cryoablation Dependent Upon Size and
Histology
- All patients 27 21(78)
- Tumors lt1.0cm 11
11(100) - Tumors gt1.0cm 16
10 (75) - Any size lobular/colloid 5
2 (40) - Any size IFDC with EIC 5
3(60) - Any size IFDC/medullary - EIC 17
15(88) - Tumors lt1.5cm/IFDC/med -EIC 10
10(100) - Tumors gt1.5cm/IFDC/med EIC 7
5 (71) - M. Sable, C. Kaufman, P. Whitworth, H. Change, L.
Stocks, R. Simmons, M. Schultz - Ann Surg Onc, 2004
104Laser Ablation of Breast Cancers
- Image-guided by stereotactic mammography or MR
- Laser generates heat to destroy cancer
- Can be applied to mammographic microcalcifications
or lesions seen only on MR
105Laser Ablation of Breast Cancers
- Lesion localized by standard stereotactic needle
- Parallel to needle temperature monitor probe
- Target temperature 80-100oC 15-20 minutes
- MR temperature maps to monitor remaining breast
- Photo courtesy of Dr. Kombiz Dowlatshahi
106(No Transcript)
107Laser Ablation of Breast CancersBloom et
al, Amer J Surg, 2001Photo courtesy of Dr.
Kombiz Dowlatshahi
- Gross path concentric rings
- Central cavity-laser tip
- Peripheral ring-fat necrosis
- Pseudo-viable zone between
- recognizable histological tumor
- Immunostaining shows non-viable tissue
108HE SectionPhoto courtesy of Dr. Kombiz
Dowlatshahi
109Cytokeratin SectionPhoto courtesy of Dr.
Kombiz Dowlatshahi
110Laser Ablation Breast Cancer Studies
Dowlatshahi, et al, Arch Surg,
2000Harms, et al, SPIE, 1999
111Ablative Techniques
- The challenge in the success of these techniques
is the ability to completely map the cancer
within the breast and then to assure complete
treatment of the cancer (MR, PEM, thermal
imaging, ultrasound, core biopsies).
112Conclusions
- High Risk Analysis
- Imaging
- Local Control
- Regional Control
- Systemic Control
- Long Term Follow-Up