Title: LNG Markets
1LNG Markets Price VolatilityJean-Pierre
MateilleGeneral Manager, Gas Power
TradingTotal Gas PowerLNG14 Conference,
Doha, March 22nd, 2004
2LNG Markets and Price Volatility
- Price determination in gas markets
- The portfolio approach
- Management of price risks
- Concluding remarks
3LNG Markets and Price Volatility
- Price determination in gas markets
- The portfolio approach
- Management of price risks
- Concluding remarks
4Price determination
- LNG markets are not isolated LNG prices depend
ultimately on regional gas markets - Long-term gas price drivers
- marginal cost of supplying markets
- pattern of demand growth generation, domestic,
GDP - government policies conservation, supply
security... - Short-term gas price drivers
- day-to-day uncertainty on local supply/demand
balance gas production transportation,
weather, power generation - availability of tools storage, flexibility,
fuel switching,... - positioning of each market participant
5 Price determination over time (US market)
- weather / temperature
- competing fuels / markets
- storage / interconnections
- industry confidence
6Price formation in UK gas market
- The National Transmission System (NTS) and the
National Balancing Point (NBP) - any licensed shipper can buy and sell gas in the
high pressure network (NTS) under the Network
Code - within the NTS, natural gas is exchanged at a
virtual trading hub (NBP) - capacity must be booked or purchased through
auctions to enter into and exit from the NBP - NBP price is the immediately negotiable value for
a given delivery period (day-, week-,
month-ahead) - Most UK gas is traded at fixed price at the NBP
7UK National Transmission System (NTS) and
National Balancing Point (NBP)
8Recent price developments in the UK
- Spot UK gas prices remain high and above 2001
highs - Gas Year 2004 is assessed at 24.6 p/th (12.5
/MWH 4.5 /MMBTU) - How do spot gas prices compare with long term
contract prices ?
9Price formation in Continental Europe
- Over 90 of continental demand is imported from
Russia, Algeria and Norway - long-term natural gas compete with LNG imports
- crude oil and oil products indexation interact
with spot gas - emergence of continental spot trading hubs
(Zeebrugge) - Dynamic linkage UK / Europe (Interconnector)
- Growing distortion between
- long-term horizon of supplies, and
- short-term horizon of demand most customers
make competitive supply tenders every year - Market players must constantly balance portfolio
10How do spot prices compare with LT contract
prices ?
- Continental European gas prices remain oil driven
- Spot prices are influenced by short term
supply/demand distortions (UK switch to import) - Contrary to recent history todays spot prices
(NBP or ZHUB) are above Long Term oil indexed
contract prices - LNG supply contracts must compete in this market
11LNG Markets and Price Volatility
- Price determination in gas markets
- The portfolio approach
- Management of price risks
- Concluding remarks
12The global market
- LNG is the only physical link between world gas
markets - LNG participates in the global equilibrium of gas
prices - direct influence is however difficult to
demonstrate - conversely flows of LNG are directly influenced
by variations in regional gas prices, leading to
arbitrage opportunities - Aspiring leading market players will need to
- balance the right mix of gas and LNG supplies
- secure access to logistics assets (regas
terminals, pipes, ships) - access end-user markets
- be active in most gas and LNG markets
- develop sophisticated risk management expertise
(hedging)
13Integrated Oil Companies as LNG buyers
- IOCs have been traditional players in upstream
markets and LNG liquefaction - IOCs are becoming purchasers of LNG
- leverage their gas reserves and allow for faster
launch of upstream project by securing outlets - IOCs are developing a strong marketing base, with
direct access to end-user markets - credit worthiness
- expertise in technical, commercial and financial
matters, as well as risk management (Oil, Gas,
Power, FOREX)
14Why developing a portfolio ?
- In todays complex environment, back-to-back
deals will become exceptional - Market players hold a set of purchase and sale
commitments that cannot fully match - Portfolio
- manage sum of purchase and sale commitments, and
adjust base load and swing supplies to demand - manage time horizon discrepancies
- aggregate risks using a unique rule book
- take advantage of correlations between price
formulas - minimize cost of commercial operations and
logistics
15How TOTAL portfolio aggregates flows risks in
Europe
- LNG is a long term business (15 yrs )
- Trading is perceived as a short term activity (1
day ) - Retail Marketing are medium term businesses (1
yr ) - Portfolio management conciliates these different
time horizons
16TOTAL European Gas Marketing Assets
Leading supplier to IC market
UK 6.7 BCM 20 IC
As of 2004, TOTAL end-user European demand
amounts to 17 BCM/y
NWE 1 BCM
Cross-border pipeline project
FRANCE 8 BCM 17 market share
SPAIN 1.3 BCM 6 market share
1/3 Equity in FOS 2 terminal
4th marketer in Spain
17The Gas LNG portfolio of TOTAL in the Atlantic
basin
The building blocks of a worldwide portfolio are
progressively put in place
18LNG Markets and Price Volatility
- Price determination in gas markets
- The portfolio approach
- Management of price risks
- Concluding remarks
19The best hedge ? The right formula !
- A right price formula initially
- LNG price formula must be representative of the
fair value of gas in the target market - versus alternative competing supplies (gas or
LNG) - A right price formula during contracts life
- long term take-or-pay and price reviews are
linked - price review mechanism is of utmost importance to
guarantee that the contract will remain balanced - LNG price formula must remain representative of
gas prices
20The representation of risks
- Mark-to-market
- flows risks are recorded when commitment is
taken - exposure can then be evaluated and categorized
against set of references, driven by market
standards - contracts are said to be marked to the market
- examples of such references Henry Hub in the US,
NBP in the UK, oil-indexed prices in Continental
Europe - At portfolio level, mark-to-market exposure of
all contracts, LNG as well as pipeline gas, can
be aggregated - identification of overall risk
- implementation of appropriate hedging strategy
21Risk management in LNG markets
- Risk management over long-term horizon
- the right formula
- price review mechanism
- Risk management over mid-term horizon
- adequation between expected import flow and
market - market risks are evaluated when the annual
delivery programme is known - buyer can decide to take hedging and corrective
action for exchange rates, oil vs. gas, crude vs.
products - Risk-management over short-term horizon
- day-to-day adjustment to schedules and actual
physical flows
22LNG competition (LNG vs. LT gas - FRANCE Zone
North)
23LNG Markets and Price Volatility
- Price determination in gas markets
- The portfolio approach
- Management of price risks
- Concluding remarks
24Concluding remarks
- LNG markets have achieved a maturity comparable
to gas markets in North West Europe and North
America - For IOCs acting as buyers, LNG purchases are now
an integral part of their global gas portfolio
supplying their marketing affiliates - Mastering the technicalities of markets is a key
part of the commercial expertise required to be a
successful player in LNG markets