Title: Header Slide
1(No Transcript)
2FDA Advisory Panel MeetingMay 29, 2003
- Cardima, Inc.
- Linear Ablation REVELATION Tx Microcatheter RF
Ablation System
3Panel Presentation
- Corporate Profile Marianne Baldwin
- Treatment Options for Atrial Fibrillation
Neal Kay, M.D. - Pre-clinical Studies Hugh Calkins, M.D.
- Protocol Development Hugh Calkins, M.D.
- Clinical Study Results Abe Kocheril, M.D.
- Conclusions Neal Kay, M.D.
4Indications for Use
- Cardima, Inc., REVELATION Tx Microcatheter
Ablation System is indicated for the treatment of
atrial fibrillation in patients with drug
refractory paroxysmal atrial fibrillation by
mapping, pacing, and ablating with a set of
continuous linear lesions in the right atrium.
5Cardima Background
- Since 1993 Cardima has been developing,
manufacturing and marketing catheter-based
systems for the Electrophysiological field,
exclusively. - The catheters include the PATHFINDER family of
mapping devices, the VENAPORT, VUEPORT and
NAVIPORT guiding catheters and the REVELATION
family of mapping and ablation systems.
6- Currently the company is marketing its diagnostic
and guiding catheters in the USA, Canada, EU (CE
Mark) and Japan. - The REVELATION mapping and ablation family of
devices is marketed in Canada and EU (CE Mark).
Cardima Background
7Cardima Commercially Available Products (US)
- Diagnostic Microcatheters
- PATHFINDER (1997)
- PATHFINDER mini (1998)
- REVELATION (1998)
- TRACER (1999)
- Guide Catheters
- VENAPORT (1995)
- NAVIPORT (1998)
- VUEPORT (1998)
- Surgical Ablation System (2002)
8PATHFINDER Mapping Catheter
9REVELATION Series
10Guide Catheter
8Fr deflectable lumen catheter
11Technology Comparison
12Lesion Shape Comparison
Conventional Endocardial Hot Tip Catheter
Cardima Linear Coil Electrode
13Linear Lesion Formation
Coil Ablation Electrode
Thermocouple
14Treatment Options for Atrial Fibrillation
- G. Neal Kay, M.D.
- Professor of Medicine
- Director of Electrophysiology
- University of Alabama at Birmingham
- Birmingham, AL
15US and AF Age Distribution
U.S. populationx 1000
Population with AFx 1000
Population withatrial fibrillation
30,000 20,000 10,000 0
500 400 300 200 100 0
U.S. population
lt5
5-9
10-14
15-19
20-24
25-29
30-34
35-39
40-44
45-49
50-54
55-59
60-64
65-69
70-74
75-79
80-84
85-89
90-94
gt95
Age, yr
Feinberg WM. Arch Intern Med 1995155469-473.
16Classification of Atrial FibrillationACC/AHA/ESC
Guidelines
J Am Coll Cardiol. 2001381231-1265. Fuster V,
Rydén LE, Asinger RW, et al. ACC/AHA/ESC
guidelines for the management of patients with
atrial fibrillation a report of the American
College of Cardiology/American Heart Association
Task Force on Practice Guidelines and the
European Society of Cardiology Committee for
Practice Guidelines and Policy Conferences
(Committee to Develop Guidelines for the
Management of Patients With Atrial Fibrillation.)
J Am Coll Cardiol. 2001381231-1265.
17d,l-Sotalol vs Placebo for AF/AFlTime to
Symptomatic Recurrence of AF/AFl
P values are vs placebo.Benditt Am J Cardiol
199984270-277.
18Canadian Trial of Atrial Fibrillation (CTAF)
Excluded recurrence in first 21 days. Roy,
et al NEJM 2000342913-920.
19Antiarrhythmic Drugs
CHF
Coronary Artery Disease
HTN
LVFW gt 1.4 cm
Sotalol
Amiodarone Dofetilide
Yes
No
Amiodarone Dofetilide
Amiodarone
Type 1C
Amiodarone Dofetilide Sotalol
Non-Pharmacologic Options
20Right Sided Approach to AF
- These results demonstrate that there is a place
for right sided treatment of AF - Cardima has demonstrated this approach in a
clinical study
21Pre-clinical Studies
- Hugh Calkins, M.D.
- Professor of Medicine
- Director of Electrophysiology
- The Johns Hopkins Medical Center
- Baltimore, MD
22Pre-Clinical Studies
- Biocompatible
- Compliant with applicable ISO 10993 requirements
- Reliable
- Compliant with mechanical and electrical
performance requirements of Massi guidelines
23Animal Studies
- Studies submitted in support of PMA
- David Keane, M.D. / Massachusetts General
Hospital - Performance of REVELATION Tx in Right Atrium of
a Goat (n7) - Mauricio Arruda, M.D. / University of Oklahoma
- Performance of REVELATION Tx in the right atrium
of a Canine (n6) - RF Lesion Formation of REVELATION Tx in Canine
Thigh Muscle (n2) - RF Ablation Using the NavAblator in the Right
Atrium (n6) - Additional independent studies performed..
24Right Atrial Multipolar Catheter Ablation
of Atrial Fibrillation in a Pace-Induced Goat
Model Keane D, Guerrero L, Ettelson L, McGovern
B, Ruskin JJACC 199732A.
- 8 goats
- AF (gt 5 min) inducible at baseline
- 4 linear lesions with Cardima microcatheters
- AF no longer inducible in 8 of 8 goats
- Transmural linear lesions were achieved
25Can Microcatheters Produce Linear Lesions without
Sacrificing Transmurality in the Canine Atrium?
Asirvatham S, Mayo Foundation Circulation 1999
100(18)1-374
- 14 dogs
- Linear right and left atrial lesions with Cardima
microcatheters - 30 linear lesions with 8 pole 3.7 Fr
microcatheters - 36 linear lesions with 10 pole 4mm ablation
catheter
Ablation Strategy Cardima vs Stnd multipolar abl
catheter Width 4.21 vs 5.4
1.6 Depth 1.4 0.6 versus 1.3 0.7 Volume 29
15 versus 42 62 Lesion formation 98 vs
95 Transmural lesion 89 vs 85
26NavAblator Canine Study University of
Oklahoma Mauricio Arruda
- 6 dogs
- NavAblator catheter for isthmus ablation
- Lesion length 20 30 mm
- Lesion depth 1.0 to 3.5 mm
- Complete linear isthmus lesion in 5 of 6 dogs
27Prospective Comparison of Lesions Created Using a
Multipolar Microcatheter Ablation System with
Those Created Using a Pullback Approach with
Standard RF Ablation In the Canine Atrium
Jumrussirikil P, Atiga W, Lardo A, Berger R,
Halperin H, Hutchins G, Calkins HPACE 2000
23203-213.
- 10 dogs
- 4 with standard pullback approach
- 6 with Cardima microcatheters
- 4 linear lesions intercaval, septal, flutter,
anterior lines - One month to animal sacrifice
- Compared lesion size and shape and complications
28Linear Atrial Ablation Using the Drag and Burn
Technique
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
29Linear Atrial Ablation Using the Cardima
Multielectrode Ablation Catheter
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
30Comparison of Lesion Width
Width of Lesion(mm)
?
4.9
2.6
? p lt 0.05
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
31Comparison of Lesion Length
p 0.NS
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
32Comparison of Lesion Depth
Depth of Lesion(mm)
2.4
2.1
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
33 Comparison of Lesions Linearity
?
25 in 25 lesions (100)
6 in 16 lesions (37)
Multipolar Microcatheter
Pullback Approach
? p lt 0.05
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
34 Comparison of Lesion Continuity
Continuous 18/25 (72)
Continuous 6/16(37)
?
Multipolar Microcatheter
Pullback Approach
? p lt 0.05
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
35 Comparison of Lesion Anchoring to an
Anatomic Structure
Anchor 23/25 (92)
Anchor 10/16 (62)
?
Multipolar Microcatheter
Pullback Approach
? p lt 0.05
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
36Conclusions
- 1) Atrial lesions created using MICRO
- are narrower, more continuous, more
linear, and more likely to be anchored to an
anatomic structure than those created with STND. - 2) These differences in lesions characteristics
may facilitate cure of atrial fibrillation with a
catheter based MAZE procedure.
Jumrussirikil et al PACE 2000 23203-213.
37Rationale for a Right Atrial Procedure
- Very likely lower risk than left atrial ablation
- May be more widely applicable
- With lower risks, physicians are likely to offer
a right atrial ablation procedure to highly
symptomatic patients
38Protocol Development and Study Design
- Hugh Calkins, M.D.
- Professor of Medicine
- Director of Electrophysiology
- The Johns Hopkins Medical Center
- Baltimore, MD
39Indications for Use
- The Cardima Inc., REVELATION Tx Microcatheter
Ablation System is indicated for the treatment of
atrial fibrillation in patients with drug
refractory paroxysmal atrial fibrillation by
mapping, pacing, and ablating with a set of
continuous linear lesions in the right atrium.
40Protocol Development Chronology
- Initial Study Design Collaboration with MGH,
FDA, CARDIMA - Phase Ia Mapping Study (PATHFINDER AF)
- Phase IIa Mapping and Ablation (REVELATION Tx)
- Circulatory Systems Recommendations for Clinical
Trial Design - Advisory Panel for AF Studies
- Phase IIb Mapping and Ablation (REVELATION Tx)
- Circulatory Systems Recommendations for Clinical
Trial Design - Advisory Panel for AF Studies
- 2000 Phase III Mapping and Ablation
- (REVELATION Tx and NAVABLATOR)
41FDA Advisory Panel Recommendations
3 episodes per month
42FDA Advisory Panel Recommendations (contd)
43Study Objectives
- Reduction in symptomatic AF episodes
- Safety
- Improvement in quality of life
44 Inclusion Criteria
- Three or more symptomatic AF episodes per 30 days
(documented by cardiac event monitor) - Refractory to two or more (AADs) or to
amiodarone alone - Absence of significant structural heart disease,
LA size lt 5 cm - Absence of echocardiographic evidence of
intra-atrial thrombus, PFO, and/or ASD on TEE
45Exclusion Criteria
- Acute ablation failure within 2 months
- MI within 6 weeks
- CVA or TIA within 6 months
- Pregnancy
- Coagulopathy or bleeding diathesis
46Study Schema
47Patient Follow-up
48Study Endpoints
- Primary clinical endpoints
- Frequency of spontaneous symptomatic AF episodes
- Incidence of adverse effects
- Secondary clinical endpoint
- Quality of life based on the SF-36 and the AFSS
49Success Criteria
- Acute Procedural Success
- Reduction in amplitude, fragmentation or widening
of local electrograms - Appearance of split potentials
- Increase in pacing threshold
50Success Criteria, contd
- Primary Endpoint
- ?50 reduction in AF episodes for patients with
? 5 AF episodes per month - ?75 reduction in AF episodes for patients with
? 3-4 AF episodes per month - Clinical Success
- Reduction in AF episodes as specified above
- While maintained on the same anti-arrhythmic
drug regimen or a reduced dosage
51Sample Size
- N80 evaluable subjects at 6 months follow up
- Based on estimated patient success rate
- Statistical considerations with a clinically
acceptable margin of error (SE0.056) - This sample size was specified in the FDA
approved protocol
52Summary
- Multiple animal studies have demonstrated safe
creation of thin , transmural, linear ablation
lesions - Clinical study was designed in collaboration with
the FDA - Clinical study incorporates a large number of
measures of safety and efficacy - As the first AF clinical trial this study is
charting new waters
53Patient Population and Study Results
- Abraham G. Kocheril, M.D.
- Head of Cardiac Electrophysiology,
- Carle Heart Center.
- Associate Professor of Medicine,
- University of Illinois COM at U-C,
- Urbana, IL
5420 Clinical Sites
55Patient Accountability
Ablated n120
Withdrew lt6 months, n8
?6 Months Post Ablation n87
lt6 Months Post Ablation n18
Withdrew gt6 months n7
56Effectiveness Cohorts
57Patients Withdrawn Prior to Six Months (n8)
one patient included in effectiveness analysis
58Demographic and Baseline Characteristics
59Prior Cardiac Interventions
60Breakdown of Ablations(for 87 subjects with 6 mo
FU)
61Baseline Arrhythmia Symptoms
62Baseline Symptomatic AFEpisodes Per Month
Mean, SD 10.1 8.9
63SF-36 Mean Scores at Baseline Study Group vs. US
Population
Adjusted for the age and gender distribution of
the study group
64Study Results
65Lesion Locations
66Procedure Times
67Acute Procedural Success
- Surrogate for clinical effectiveness
- Initial plans to record specific measurements of
acute procedural success became unwieldy - Investigator assessment of acute procedural
success at the time of the procedure - 110/118 (93)
68Six Month Results
- Primary Endpoint
- ?50 reduction for pts with ? 5 sAF episodes per
month - ?75 reduction for pts with 3-4 sAF episodes
per month - Results
- 69/81 (85) met this endpoint
69Per-Subject AF Episode Reduction (n81)
70No symptomatic AF episodes at 6 months 44/81
(54)
AF Episode Reduction
71Mean Episode Frequency Reduction (n81)
72Reduction in Common Arrhythmia Symptoms(Pre- vs.
Six Months Post-RFA)
73Secondary Endpoint
- Improvement in Quality of Life Scores
- Atrial Fibrillation Severity Score (AFSS)
- SF-36
74AFSS(Pre- vs. Six Months Post-RFA)
75SF-36 Mean Scores Baseline vs. 6 Months
76Major Complications
- An adverse event that occurs within 7 days
following investigational procedure and - Is life-threatening
- Results in permanent impairment or damage to a
body structure - Requires significant intervention to prevent
permanent impairment - Requires hospitalization or an extended hospital
stay - Results in moderate transient impairment or
damage to a body structure - Requires intervention such as medication or
cardioversion to prevent permanent impairment or
damage to a body structure
FDA definition of acute major complications for
catheter ablation studies
77Major Complications 4 /123 (3.3)
- Pericardial effusion requiring pericardial window
one week post ablation - Sinus node injury requiring pacemaker
implantation - Stroke 4 days post ablation
- AV Fistula
Not major complication 1 pacemaker within 7d,
but with documented preexisting sinus node
dysfunction. Patients with pacemakers addressed
later.
78Adverse Events during Follow-up31/120 patients
(27)
79Other Adverse Events
80Adverse Events during Follow-upSummary
- No reports of
- Mortality
- Cardiac Perforation
- AV Fistula or arterial injury
- Thromboembolism
- 73 reported no adverse events
81Summary Results
82Issues for Clarification
- Catheters/Lesion Sets
- Pacemakers
- Clinical Success Antiarrhythmic Drugs
- TTM Compliance
83Lesion Sets
84Catheters/Lesion Sets
- REVELATION Tx used for all non-isthmus linear
lesions - REVELATION Tx linear catheter could ablate some
but not all flutter isthmus. - Thus, investigators used clinically available 4
mm tip ablation catheters to create the flutter
line - NavAblator catheter developed for Phase III
- Some investigators preferred use of their
standard 4 mm catheters
85Catheters/Lesion Sets
- Phase III FDA required that a conventional 4mm
tip ablation catheter be specified. - Cardima manufactured the NAVABLATOR to be
specified as part of the system, solely for the
creation of the flutter line at the isthmus
when the anatomy was not compatible with the
REVELATION Tx linear electrode array.
86Pacemakers
- Per protocol Subjects electing to receive
implantable ppms prior to 6 mo f/u will be
considered failures. - Intent subjects should not require adjunctive
pacemaker therapy to address AF - Not all pts receiving ppms fall into this
category - Patients with pacemakers not excluded from study
87Pacemakers
88Pacemakers
- 3 Pacemakers shortly after procedure
- All 3 had known preexisting sinus node
dysfunction - Pt.1 HR 49 when in SR no AVN ablation
- Pt.2 sinus pauses, 34 episodes to 1 at 6 mo no
AVN ablation - Pt.3 sinus brady, 3 sec pauses, 6 to 1 no AVN
ablation - Not major complications
89Percentage Of Patients Who Achieved Six Month
Success Including Failures"
90Clinical Success Antiarrhythmic Drugs
- Primary endpoint was reduction in AF frequency
independent of AAD use (69/81, 85) - Study population was drug refractory (avg. 3) and
had concomitant medical conditions - Clinical Success defined per protocol
Reduction in sAF episodes while maintained on
the same anti-arrhythmic drug regimen or a
reduced dosage - As determined by clinical site, 19 of the 69
successful patients had an increase in AADs - Thus, the clinical success rate is 50/81 (62)
- Given current information on the efficacy of
AADs, it is difficult to determine a true
increase in an AAD regimen
91Clinical Success Antiarrhythmic Drugs
92Changes in AADs from BL to 6 Months (n87)
6 Months
Baseline
19 (17, 1, 1)
12
(10, 1, 1)
21
Amiodarone
5
(7, 0)
4
(3, 2)
Membrane Active Drug
7
47 (37, 10)
39
(31, 8)
52
(3, 0)
6
(4, 0)
Rate Control Drug
3
21 (19, 2)
(6, 0)
14
11
(9, 2)
(Success/Failure) 1 patient with unknown sAF
at 6 months
93Changes AADs from BL to 6 Months for 23
Increases
6 Months
Baseline
4
4
6
Amiodarone
Membrane Active Drug
2
12
15
15
1
Rate Control Drug
3
2
4
1
2/23 had indeterminate baseline episode
frequencies. 21/23 patients were considered
successes.
94Clinical Success Antiarrhythmic DrugsPatients
with Increased AADs (n21)
- 19 had reduction in AF episodes (success)
- 10/19 show a 100 reduction in sAF episodes at 6
months with increases to an AAD regimen to
which they were previously refractory - The remaining 9/19 had gt 50 reduction in episodes
95Clinical Success Antiarrhythmic Drugs Patient
Success by AAD Use at Six Months
96Treatment Algorithm for AF
Sotalol or beta-blockers are the initial drugs
of choice for adrenergic AFIB. Consider
nonpharmacologic options to maintain sinus rhythm
if drug failure occurs. HF heart failure CAD
coronary artery disease LVH left ventricular
hypertrophy
97Patients with Decrease/No Change in AADs(n60)
- 36 patients had decrease in AADs at six months
- 6 patients were off AADs at 6 months
- 28 patients had no change in AADs
98Transtelephonic Event Monitoring
- Three redundant mechanisms for symptomatic
episode monitoring - TTM (to capture both spontaneous and scheduled
transmissions) - Arrhythmic events reports (CRFs)
- Clinical history at baseline, 1, 3, 6, and 12
months to document reports of AF frequency and
severity - EKG at baseline, 1, 3, and 6 months
- AFSS questionnaire
- Additional documentation of AF frequency and
severity
99Transtelephonic Event Monitoring
- Record and transmit each symptomatic episode
- Transmit at least weekly (with or without
symptoms) - Perform as above at baseline 1, 3 and 6 months
post ablation
100Transtelephonic Event Monitoring
- Patients were blinded to number of AF episodes
required for study eligibility - TTMs reviewed by independent cardiologist to
verify sufficient AF episodes for study
eligibility
101Transtelephonic Event Monitoring
- 22 subjects did not transmit recordings at six
months. - All had EKG/Office Visit at 6 month FU
- One subject not included
102Transtelephonic Event Monitoring
103Transtelephonic Event Monitoring
Patient Compliance with 6-Month Assessments of
Arrhythmic Events
104AFSS Mean Scores at Six Monthsby Six-Month
Transmission Compliance
105Issues for Clarification
- Although this study design, while consistent with
the recommendations of the FDA Advisory Panel,
has some inherent limitations compared to a
controlled, randomized study (CRT), Cardima
believes it is unlikely that the patient
improvements seen in these study results could be
attributable individually or collectively to the
effects of these limitations
106Study Summary
- Effectiveness
- Reduction in AF episodes at 6 mo 69/81
(85) - No AF at 6 months 44/81 (54)
- Clinical success 50/81 (62)
- Off all AADs 6/81 (7 )
- Reduction in AADs 36/81 (44)
- Quality of Life Significant improvements
- Safety
- Mortality 0/120 (0)
- Major Complications 4/120 (3)
107Closing Remarks
- G. Neal Kay, M.D.
- Professor of Medicine
- Director of Electrophysiology
- University of Alabama at Birmingham
- Birmingham, AL
108Conclusion
- The REVELATION Tx linear ablation system is safe
and effective in treatment of patients with
paroxysmal atrial fibrillation in the absence of
significant structural heart disease.
109Study Strengths
- Robust Study Design - Patients acted as their own
control - Study consistent with FDA Advisory Panel
recommendations - Use of TTM provided an objective measure of
therapy success - Use of subjective measures of therapy
effectiveness (i.e., QOL) captured important
patient parameters - Study demonstrated excellent safety profile
- Study demonstrated clinically meaningful
improvement in patient outcomes
110Summary of Study Results
- This is the first multicenter clinical trial of
catheter ablation for atrial fibrillation to be
completed - Right atrial linear ablation offers a level of
success for control of paroxysmal atrial
fibrillation - Most patients continued on AADs at the same or
lower dose - AF did not appear to worsen in most PAF pts, as
is the natural history of the disease - This level of success was accomplished with a
very low risk of serious complications
111The Atrial Fibrillation Challenge
- PV isolation is effective in about 2/3 of
patients with paroxysmal AF - The risks are significant and include
- PV stenosis - 1-8 and is related to experience
- Stroke 1-4
- Tamponade - 1-4
- Major bleeding - 2-3
- Limited to physicians competent to perform
transeptal catheterization - There have been no multicenter prospective trials
of PVI
112Risk Benefit
- The lower risks of this relatively simple
procedure are likely to allow it to be performed
by a wider range of physicians than a complex
left atrial ablation procedure - It is likely that a simple right atrial ablation
procedure will be offered to patients with highly
symptomatic paroxysmal atrial fibrillation before
more risky techniques
113Conclusions
- REVELATION Tx is a new RF catheter ablation
technology specifically designed to create linear
lesions in the right atrium - Provides an important treatment option for many
patients with drug refractory paroxysmal AF - Addresses currently unmet public health need for
safe and effective treatment of AF, a disease of
great clinical significance to the medical
community, both in terms of patient suffering and
high medical costs of treating AF and its
clinical sequelae - This technology has been demonstrated to
eliminate gt 50 of symptomatic AF episodes in
treated patients
114REVELATION Tx