GMV

1
GM-VV PDG meeting at07 Spring SIW Norfolk
RoadmapStephane CHAIGNEAURene JACQUART Ad
Van LIER Simone YOUNGBLOODTony MASYS
2
Outline

• Overall view
• Status of the other initiatives
• Coordination proposal
• GM-VV architecture of actions
• Expected contributions
• Conclusion

3
Overall Architecture of issues

• Organisational Issues
• Archiving data, information and knowledge (SISO
  reflector)
• Maintaining the VVA Roadmap (SSG ?)
• Council of chairs SISO, NATO and others
  (national representatives)?
• Establish a dialogue with sponsoring organization
  (NATO, national representatives)
• Technical issues
• General aspects
• Acceptance and validation
• Risk management
• Cost management
• Tools and guidance

4
Overall Architecture of issues

• Organisational Issues
• Archiving data, information and knowledge (SISO
  reflector)
• Maintaining the VVA Roadmap (SSG ?)
• Council of chairs SISO, NATO and others
  (national representatives)?
• Establish a dialogue with sponsoring organization
  (NATO, national representatives)
• Technical issues
• General aspects
• Acceptance and validation
• Risk management
• Cost management
• Tools and guidance

• Identify objectives and VVA problem statement,
  which problem to solve
• Define common concept and terminology
• Define a common taxonomy of the VV products
• Define a high level common process and methodology

5
Overall Architecture of issues

• Organisational Issues
• Archiving data, information and knowledge (SISO
  reflector)
• Maintaining the VVA Roadmap (SSG ?)
• Council of chairs SISO, NATO and others
  (national representatives)?
• Establish a dialogue with sponsoring organization
  (NATO, national representatives)
• Technical issues
• General aspects
• Acceptance and validation
• Risk management
• Cost management
• Tools and guidance

• Referent
• Acceptance and Validation criteria specification
• Levels of VV
• Managing/optimising VV efforts/costs, in
  relation with risk. VV tailoring.
• VV in composed-based Simulation models

6
Overall Architecture of issues

• Organisational Issues
• Archiving data, information and knowledge (SISO
  reflector)
• Maintaining the VVA Roadmap (SSG ?)
• Council of chairs SISO, NATO and others
  (national representatives)?
• Establish a dialogue with sponsoring organization
  (NATO, national representatives)
• Technical issues
• General aspects
• Acceptance and validation
• Risk management
• Cost management
• Tools and guidance

• Define Model and taxonomy of risks
• Define Levels of risks
• Supporting risk based Acceptance
• Risks driven VVA management

7
Overall Architecture of issues

• Organisational Issues
• Archiving data, information and knowledge (SISO
  reflector)
• Maintaining the VVA Roadmap (SSG ?)
• Council of chairs SISO, NATO and others
  (national representatives)?
• Establish a dialogue with sponsoring organization
  (NATO, national representatives)
• Technical issues
• General aspects
• Acceptance and validation
• Risk management
• Cost management
• Tools and guidance

• VV product managing cost
• Taxonomy of MS and VV product managing cost,

8
Overall Architecture of issues

• Organisational issues
• Archiving data, information and knowledge (SISO
  reflector)
• Maintaining the VVA Roadmap (SSG ?)
• Council of chairs SISO, NATO and others
  (national representatives)?
• Establish a dialogue with sponsoring organization
  (NATO, national representatives)
• Technical issues
• General aspects
• Acceptance and validation
• Risk management
• Cost management
• Tools and guidance

• Requirements for a repository model
• VVA tools
• VVA planning and implementation

9
Overall VVA efforts
Dialogue with sponsors
Maintain roadmap
Council of chairs
Archiving data
Generic Process and Methodology
Objectives VVA statements
Concept Terminology
Specification of of VV products
Taxonomy of of VV products
Referent
Component-based models
Acceptance Validation criteria
Tailoring Managing/optimising V efforts/costs
VV levels
Risks Model Taxonomy
Risks Levels
Assessment and risk driven
VV product managing cost
Taxonomy lt-gt managing cost
VV tools
Requirements for Repository
VV planning implementation
10
Overall VVA standardisation products
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Referent frame
Risks identification and propagation
Guidance for techniques and tools
Requirements for MS documentation
Composition and interoperability
Requirements for a VV repository
11
Outline

• Overall view
• Status of the other initiatives
• Coordination proposal
• GM-VV architecture of actions
• Expected contributions
• Conclusion

12
Identification of initiatives
Europa MoU
ISO
15288
REVVA
EIA IS
SISO
GM-VV
731
SCM
VPMM
IEEE
NATO
1220
VVA Overlay
NMSG 19
1516
1278
NMSG 54
National initiatives
US (DMSO)
Canada (SECO)
GBR
GER
VPMM
ITESC
Website
ITOP 7.2
RPG
Templates
13
What has already been done

• SISO and NATO outcomes
• VVA overlay to the FEDEP submitted to IEEE
• REVVA outcomes
• Reference and Users manuals (2004 )
• ITOP outcomes
• ITOP official release n1-1-002 (2004)
• DMSO outcomes
• RPG, Templates
• Website
• VPMM (03S_SIW_127)

14
What tasks are currently being processed

• SISO and NATO
• Processing second round of comments resolution
  of comments completed, PDG drafting group working
  on a new draft
• Creation of a new GM VV PDG and a new NMSG 54
• REVVA
• Working on several themes
• Case studies
• Reference Manual VVA Methodology, VV products
  support, VV process support, Interface of VVA
  to system engineering
• Taxonomy, Cost-benefit models and tailoring
  techniques
• ITOP
• Steady state
• DOD/MSCO ?

15
Global coverage VVA standardisation products
REVVA
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Generic Process
Referent frame
Assessment of VV raw data

Intended purpose

Generate acceptance criteria
Human behavior
Federation
Risks identification and propagation

Users manual
RPG
RPG
Plan VV tasks
Target of Acceptance
Risks
Guidance for techniques and tools
Definitions
Generate VV report
Physics based
Cost benefits
Requirements for MS documentation
Generate Acceptance report
CAE Structure
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Roles
Doing VV
Organisation
Composition and interoperability
Achievement
Human in the loop
Process
Target of VV
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Users manual
Users manual

Acceptance and VV report
Engineering
Requirements for a VV repository

Tailoring Techniques
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Tailoring

Analysis
Glossary
Taxonomy - Relationship between MS and VV
products


Users manual
RPG
RPG

Process Improvement
Levels
16
Global coverage VVA standardisation products
ITOP
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Generic Process
Referent frame
Assessment of VV raw data
Intended purpose
Generate acceptance criteria
Human behavior
Federation
Risks identification and propagation
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Plan VV tasks
Target of Acceptance
Risks
Guidance for techniques and tools
Definitions
Generate VV report
Physics based
Cost benefits
Requirements for MS documentation
Generate Acceptance report
CAE Structure
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Roles
Doing VV
Organisation
Composition and interoperability
Achievement
Human in the loop
Process
Target of VV
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Users manual
Users manual
Acceptance and VV report
Engineering
Requirements for a VV repository
Tailoring Techniques
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Tailoring
Analysis
Glossary
Taxonomy - Relationship between MS and VV
products
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Process Improvement
Levels
17
Global coverage VVA standardisation products
VPMM
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Generic Process
Referent frame
Assessment of VV raw data
Intended purpose
Generate acceptance criteria
Human behavior
Federation
Risks identification and propagation
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Plan VV tasks
Target of Acceptance
Risks
Guidance for techniques and tools
Definitions
Generate VV report
Physics based
Cost benefits
Requirements for MS documentation
Generate Acceptance report
CAE Structure
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Roles
Doing VV
Organisation
Composition and interoperability
Achievement
Human in the loop
Process
Target of VV
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Users manual
Users manual
Acceptance and VV report
Engineering
Requirements for a VV repository
Tailoring Techniques
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Tailoring
Analysis
Glossary
Taxonomy - Relationship between MS and VV
products
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Process Improvement
Levels
18
Global coverage VVA standardisation products
VVA Overlay
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Generic Process
Referent frame
Assessment of VV raw data
Intended purpose
Generate acceptance criteria
Human behavior
Federation
Risks identification and propagation
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Plan VV tasks
Target of Acceptance
Risks
Guidance for techniques and tools
Definitions
Generate VV report
Physics based
Cost benefits
Requirements for MS documentation
Generate Acceptance report
CAE Structure
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Roles
Doing VV
Organisation
Composition and interoperability
Achievement
Human in the loop
Process
Target of VV
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Users manual
Users manual
Acceptance and VV report
Engineering
Requirements for a VV repository
Tailoring Techniques
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Tailoring
Analysis
Glossary
Taxonomy - Relationship between MS and VV
products
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Process Improvement
Levels
19
Outline

• Overall view
• Status of the other initiatives
• Coordination proposal
• GM-VV architecture of actions
• Expected contributions
• Conclusion

20
GM VV Standard products scope
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Generic Process
Assessment of VV raw data
Intended purpose
Generate acceptance criteria
Risks identification and propagation
Plan VV tasks
Target of Acceptance
Risks
Guidance for techniques and tools
Generate VV report
Cost benefits
Generate Acceptance report
CAE Structure
Doing VV
Organisation
Achievement
Target of VV
Users manual
Acceptance and VV report
Requirements for a VV repository
Tailoring Techniques
Glossary
Taxonomy - Relationship between MS and VV
products
Process Improvement
Levels
21
Timeframe
Drafting group
04 07
01
07
03
09
11
GM-VV
Scope, Timeframe, expected Outcomes
SIW
Euro SIW
SIW
SIW
Euro SIW
SIW
SIW
Euro SIW
SIW
2007
2008
2009
22
Outline

• Overall view
• Status of the other initiatives
• Coordination proposal
• GM-VV architecture of actions
• Expected contributions
• Conclusion

23
GM VVExpected contribution from VVA forum
Generic Process and Methodology
Objectives VVA statements
Concept Terminology
Specification of of VV products
Taxonomy of of VV products
General technical aspect
Acceptance Validation criteria
Tailoring Managing/optimising V efforts/costs
VV levels
Acceptance and validity
Risks Model Taxonomy
Risks Levels
Risks
VV product managing cost
Taxonomy lt-gt managing cost
Costs
VV tools
Requirements for Repository
VV planning implementation
Tools and guidance
24
GM VV Expected contributions
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Generic Process
Assessment of VV raw data
Intended purpose
Generate acceptance criteria
Risks identification and propagation
Plan VV tasks
Target of Acceptance
Risks
Guidance for techniques and tools
Generate VV report
Cost benefits
Generate Acceptance report
CAE Structure
Doing VV
Organisation
Achievement
Target of VV
Users manual
Acceptance and VV report
Requirements for a VV repository
Tailoring Techniques
Glossary
Taxonomy - Relationship between MS and VV
products
Process Improvement
Levels
25
VVA efforts GM-VV not concerned
Dialogue with sponsors
Maintain roadmap
Council of chairs
Archiving data
Component-based models
Referent
Assessment and risk driven
Managing cost
26
GM-VV not concerned VVA standardisation products
TERMINOLOGY
REFERENCE GUIDE CONCEPTS

GENERIC USER GUIDE RPG
APPLICATION CONTEXT SPECIFIC
GUIDANCES
Referent frame
Human behavior
Federation
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Definitions
Physics based
Requirements for MS documentation
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Roles
Composition and interoperability
Human in the loop
Process
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Engineering
Users manual
RPG
RPG
Tailoring
Analysis
Users manual
RPG
RPG
27
Process view
Management process
Operational process
Enabling process Information system
28
Outline

• Overall view
• Status of the other initiatives
• Coordination proposal
• GM-VV architecture of actions
• Expected contributions
• Conclusion

29
Conclusion

• The GM-VV focus is to provide the MS community
  with a generic VVA methodology
• Which will have to be tailored for your specific
  MS domains/needs,
• However, by using a the repository approach
  provides easy access to re-use of existing
  related VVA activities (re-use tailoring and
  methods)
• Provides a mechanism to detect MS capability
  gaps/assets
• Creates a consistent and exchangeable
  communication format (terminology, methodology,
  methods, reports)
• GM-VV doesn't address all issues such as
• Specific RPGs for each MS domain (will emerge
  over time)
• Long term development ( to be covered by VV
  summit, VVA Forum, NATO)

30

• Thank you for your attention

31
Relationship and interface between VPMM and GM
VV
VPMM Levels
32
Relationship and interface between VVA Overlay
to the FEDEP and GM-VV
VVA overlay to the FEDEP
VVA process to the FEDEP
Roles
VV Products
Risks
33
Relationship and interface between the 2 SISO SG
Simulation Conceptual Model and GM-VV
34
Concepts, TerminologyTaxonomy of MS and VV
products