Title: Mike Finney
1CUFC EPA2010 Update
- Mike Finney
- Vocational Sales Manager, Utilities and Cranes
- May, 2009
2Agenda
- Why SCR?
- EPA10 SCR Equipment
- Component Packaging
- Vehicle Performance/Operation
- Cummins Experience SCR vs Extreme EGR
- Diesel Exhaust Fluid Myths
- DEF Infrastructure
- Summary
- M2e Hybrid
- Natural Gas Vehicles
3Overview
Common Terms
- SCR Selective Catalytic Reduction
- A vehicle emissions control technology to reduce
diesel engine emissions for passenger cars, light
heavy duty trucks. Reduces NOx using a reducing
agent by converting NOx into nitrogen, water and
tiny amounts of carbon dioxide.
- DEF Diesel Exhaust Fluid
- A solution of 32.5 automotive-grade urea and
67.5 purified water used in the SCR process
also referred to as AUS32
32.5 Urea
100 DEF Diesel Exhaust Fluid
67.5 Water
4Overview
Common Terms
- DOC Diesel Oxidation Catalyst
- Part of the 2007 Aftertreament system that
converts soot into ash
- DPF Diesel Particulate Filter
- Part of the 2007 Aftertreatment system that traps
ash
- ATD AfterTreatment Device
- Combination of DOC and DPF used to meet 2007 EPA
emissions standards
- SCR Catalyst
- EPA 2010 hardware used to convert NOx into
Nitrogen and Water
5Overview
How SCR Works
Intake Throttle Valve
NOx PM
Doser
P
T
T
T
NOx
Diesel Oxidation Catalyst (DOC)
Diesel Particulate Filter(DPF)
N2
H2O
6SCR Benefits
- SCR is better economics with 3 - 5 better
diesel fuel economy than equivalent HD 2007
engines, and 5 9 better than a high EGR
approach for medium duty engines, SCR is the
first emissions change to provide a cost benefit
to the customer. - SCR is cleaner SCR is the only technology that
is able to meet NOx levels of 0.2g/bhp-hr at the
tailpipe. Customers can be proud to support
environment improvements. - SCR is convenient Fewer active regenerations
will improve operational flexibility. DEF supply
will not be an issue and will become second
nature to driver when operating their vehicles. - SCR is proven With over 600,000 SCR vehicles in
operation in Europe and over 10 Million SCR test
miles run in the United States customers can be
confident in SCR.
7Daimler Vehicles
Daimler Trucks Trucks for the World!
Truck market (Med/Hvy) 2.1 Million units 2008
Principal Daimler Trucks production sites in the
world
Market share
Manufacturer
Vehicles
Components
8Most Engine and Truck OEMs Are Gearing Up For SCR
In 2010
Overview
9SCR Equipment
- New major components for 2010
- Understep or Vertical system contains both ATD
SCR catalyst - OR
- 2 Box separates ATD SCR catalyst (est. 10
vehicles) - DEF plastic storage tank (6, 13, 23 gallon sizes)
ISB/C Switchback
DD13 1-Box
10SCR Equipment - Myth vs Facts
Myth - what the competitor says SCR will look like
11MD 1-Box Understep ATS
- Pros
- Clear BOC solution
- Lightest weight
- Cons
- LH fuel tank only
122nd 1 box system (current DC 016-1BT)
MD 1-Box Understep ATS W/HZ Outlet
13MD 2-Box Vertical ATS (2V2)
Left-hand and Right-hand configurations required
for markets, e.g. Snow Plows
Cummins configuration in M2-106 shown
14MD 2-Box Vertical ATS (2V2)
Left-hand and Right-hand configurations required
for markets, e.g. Snow Plows
DD13 configuration in M2-112 shown
15MD 2-Box Horizontal (2HH)
- Pros
- Clear BOC solution
- Familiar design
- Support dual fuel tanks
- Cons
- PTO restrictions
- W/B restrictions
16DEF Storage and Injection System
MD 13 23 Gallon DEF Tank Mtg
19mm fillerneck (smaller than diesel nozzle)
DEF Dosing Pump
MD CBOC 6 Gallon DEF Tank
17SCR Equipment
- Compared to EPA07 weight increase for EPA 2010
will be approximately 217lbs 500lbs - Lower weight for medium duty with 6 gallon DEF
(217 lbs) - ISB with SCR expected to be 325 lbs lighter than
Maxxforce DT w/high EGR - Higher for on-highway w/23 gallon DEF (up to 500
lbs) - Includes the weight of DEF
- SCR hardware is designed to last the life of the
vehicle - Current maintenance intervals will not change
- DEF filter will need replacement at approximately
200,000 to 300,000 miles
18Vehicle Performance/Operation
Gauges/Lights
100
0
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
Full
Empty
DEF in tank
19Vehicle Performance/Operation
Gauges/Lights
- 0 to 2.5 DEF tank level
- - Under no circumstances will the engine be
shutdown due to running the vehicle out of DEF or
putting the improper fluid in the DEF tank - After prolonged driver warnings and clear
evidence of safe vehicle situation, vehicle speed
may be limited to 5 mph. - after refueling diesel tank
- vehicle stationary for more than 1 hour
- after restart
100
0
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
Full
Empty
DEF in tank
20Vehicle Performance/Operation
- SCR system will detect when an improper fluid has
been put in the Diesel Exhaust Fluid tank
- When improper or contaminated DEF is detected,
the following inducement will be employed - 25 engine derate
- 55 mph speed limit imposed
- After 1,000 miles or 20 hours of operation
without remedy a more significant action will be
initiated in which the vehicle speed will be
limited to 5 mph provided one of the following
conditions are met - after refueling diesel tank
- vehicle stationary for more than 1 hour
- after restart
Malfunction Indicator Lamp
- Under no circumstances will the engine be
shutdown due to running the vehicle out of DEF or
putting the improper fluid in the DEF tank
21Vehicle Performance/Operation
Engine Optimized for Fuel Efficiency
3 - 5 better diesel fuel economy than comparable
HD 2007 engine 5 - 9 better diesel fuel economy
than extreme EGR approach on MD 2010 engine
225 Reasons Cummins chose SCR vs High EGR for EPA10
Cummins Experience High EGR vs SCR
- Reliability
- Cummins found high-EGR engines produce
condensation in the engine which severely impacts
life to overhaul (20 to 25 reduction) - Fuel economy
- Cummins SCR solutions found to be 5-9 more fuel
efficient than high-EGR - Performance
- High-EGR would have resulted in 50-100hp loss for
same displacement engine - Throttle Response
- Better throttle response in 2010 with SCR
- Operating Range
- Wider sweet spot for driveability and enhanced
fuel economy
23Costs for meeting emissions change
Cummins Experience High EGR vs SCR
- Clearly there are costs associated with meeting
tightening regulations - Cummins found that there would have been costs
with either high-EGR or SCR solutions. - High-EGR complex changes to EGR system, air
handling system, vehicle cooling systems. Twin
turbos, additional coolers, new hoods and cooling
systems, new injection system and electronics - SCR addition of SCR catalyst, tanks, lines
- SCR is the solution that provides long term
payback - MD 5-9 fuel economy differential between SCR and
high-EGR - SCR has no degredation in durability/reliability
- SCR has no change to maintenance intervals
- SCR extends duration between DPF Regen cycles
24Cummins Experience High EGR vs SCR
- Heat rejection significantly lower heat
rejection for SCR - No hood or cooling package redesign needed
- This drives cost for high-EGR solution
- Power ratings no change in power for same
displacement engine - High-EGR would have either had to reduce hp by
50-100 hp depending on the platform or increase
displacement - This drives cost and adds weight for high-EGR
solution - Weight impact minimal
- SCR approximately 217 lbs on midrange (including
6 gallons DEF) - High-EGR weight of EGR cooler, additional
turbo, etc on engine - Fuel Economy significantly better fuel economy
- Starting at a fuel advantage already with 2007
product - SCR significantly more fuel efficient than
high-EGR for MD products (laws of physics) - Any compensation to reduce (although not
eliminate) condensation/reliability issues only
further impacts fuel economy in a negative way. - This provides payback for SCR solutions which
high-EGR would not have
25DEF Fact or Fiction?
Fiction
- DEF is corrosive, hazardous, and unsafe to handle
Fact
- Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS)
- Hazards Identification Urea Solution is not
Flammable - First Aid MeasuresWash area thoroughly with
soap and water - Fire Fighting MeasuresUrea solution is not
flammable - Transportation InformationUrea solution is not
listed by any US or Canadian transportation
authority as a hazardous material
26DEF Fact or Fiction?
Fiction
- Urea becomes toxic at 118F
Fact
Urea does not become toxic at any
temperature at 122F, DEF will still meet ISO
specifications of less than 0.2 ammonia for at
least 35 days. At that rate with would take more
than 2 years to reach the ammonia level of
household ammonia which is still not classified
as toxic James Spooner VP GM Colonial
Chemical Company
27DEF Fact vs. Fiction
Fiction
- DEF is useless in the cold because it freezes at
12F
EPA Requires DEF flow within 70 minutes Detroit
Diesel testing has proven DEF flow within EPA
requirements
Fact
Engine coolant is used to thaw DEF in tank.
System will function until DEF begins to flow
DEF will start to freeze at 12F
28DEF Fact vs. Fiction
- At 86F DEF will only last 1 month
Fiction
Fact
At 86F DEF has a shelf life of 1 YEAR!
95F avg. July temp
Source Terra Industries
29DEF Fact vs. Fiction
Fiction
- DEF will cost between 17 and 34 per gallon
Fact
DEF pricing is dependant on packaging size
Worst CasePass Car Dealership Gallon
Most Frequent ScenarioFleet Terminal 275 Gallon
IBC
15.50 per Gallon
2.61 per Gallon
719.60/275 2.61/gallon
7.752 15.50/gallon
302010 Fact vs. Fiction
Even Europe is moving away from SCR technology
Fiction
Fact
- Euro 6 (2013) limits are almost certainly going
to require EGR and SCR to share the burden of NOx
control - - Roadtransport.com
- It is generally accepted that a Euro 6 (2013)
engine will combine both SCR and EGR technology.
- Automotive World
312010 Fact vs. Fiction
Fiction
SCR is not a long term solution
Fact
- SCR reduces fuel consumption which is directly
tied to CO2 emissions
- Transport Topics
EGR 2007
EGR 2010
32How Can I Determine how Much DEF I will Use?
Diesel Exhaust Fluid Myths
Example Delivery Annual miles for average truck
15,000 miles MPG for average truck 8
mpg 15,000 miles / 8 mpg 1,875 gallons diesel
fuel per year DEF usage _at_ 2 of fuel consumption
37.5 gallons of DEF / year 37.5 gallons / 6
gallon tank (average size) 7 DEF fill-ups /
year Diesel cost 5,625 DEF cost 97.50 per
year Diesel cost savings due to fuel economy
improvement 300
SoDEF fill-up approx. every 6 to 8 weeks
Example Only
33How Can I Determine how Much DEF I will Use?
Diesel Exhaust Fluid Myths
Example Utility Truck with PTO operation Fuel
consumption at high idle 1.2 gallons/hour Assume
PTO operation 6 hours per day, 240 days per year
1,440 gallons per year 5,000 miles / 7 mpg
714 gallons diesel fuel per year DEF usage _at_ 2
of fuel consumption 43 gallons of DEF / year 43
gallons / 6 gallon tank (average size) 8 DEF
fill-ups / year Diesel cost 6,462 DEF cost
112 Diesel cost savings due to fuel economy
increase 349
SoDEF fill-up approx. every 6 weeks
Example Only
34Diesel Exhaust Fluid - Calculator
35Myth 5 DEF will be difficult to find.
Diesel Exhaust Fluid Myths
- DEF will be available for customers to purchase
- DTNA and Cummins are working with industry
partners to ensure DEF is readily available - DTNA and Cummins will be working to ensure
availability of DEF through our distributor and
dealer network - Many major truck stops will carry DEF through the
country
36Infrastructure Taking Shape Rapidly
DEF Infrastructure - Availability
- SCR Stakeholders group continues to move forward
with the distribution network to ensure a smooth
transition into 2010. - Pilot Travel Centers, TA Travel Centers of
America, and Petro Stopping Centers have already
commented to supplying DEF. - Other partners are expected to make announcements
in early 2009
37DEF Infrastructure - Bulk Systems
- Numerous bulk manufactures have announced above
ground products available for DEF - Gilbarco and Wayne Dresser are preparing to
deliver approved dispensing devices - WM approval is an open issue
- UL approval is an open issue
- A number of European system manufactures are
evaluating U.S partnerships in order to launch
local businesses
38DEF Infrastructure - Bulk Containers
- (275) gallon IBCs will support the early launch
of DEF as the primary home fill option - IBCs will be available from locator DEF
distributors OR at our Dealer / Distributor
network - One IBC will support 89,375 miles of truck
utilization - IBC enclosures will become available to house the
product in cold climates (Heated enclosures) - DDC is currently testing an prototype enclosure
produced by Bennacor.
39DEF Infrastructure Dealer/Distributors
- All Dealers and Distributors will handle DEF to
support the network - This program will be launched mid year to support
customer demo units and pre series volumes - Part number will be generated and a direct ship
program will be launched - The market will be competitive as DEF
distributors will also offer product direct
40DEF Infrastructure - Fluid Locator
- The U.S Department of Energy has developed a web
site which will show DEF availability - The internet software will show locations of DEF
availability - The site will go live with the automobile sites
in 1st quarter 2009 - Commercial diesel locations will follow in 2nd
quarter 2009 - All DTNA dealers and distributors will be added
to the site - All travel centers handling DEF will also be part
of the site
41DEF Infrastructure - Industry Website
FactsAboutSCR.com
- What you will find there
- Third Party information about SCR Technology
- Recent 2010 Emission Press Releases
- Diesel Exhaust Fluid developments
42SCR Summary
- SCR is better economics with 3 - 5 better
diesel fuel economy than equivalent HD 2007
engines, and 5 9 better than a high EGR
approach for medium duty engines, SCR is the
first emissions change to provide a cost benefit
to the customer. - SCR is cleaner SCR is the only technology that
is able to meet NOx levels of 0.2g/bhp-hr at the
tailpipe. Customers can be proud to support
environment improvements. - SCR is convenient Fewer active regenerations
will improve operational flexibility. DEF supply
will not be an issue and will become second
nature to driver when operating their vehicles. - SCR is proven With over 600,000 SCR vehicles in
operation in Europe and over 10 Million SCR test
miles run in the United States customers can be
confident in SCR.
43M2e Utility Hybrid (342-1R4)
- Key Specs (342-1R4, EH-8E306-UP)
- M2-106 straight truck
- GVW up to 40K
- Cummins ISB 200 to 300hp / 520 to 660 ft-lb
- Eaton Parallel Electric Hybrid Drive 60hp/310
lb-ft peak - 6 speed Ultrashift transmission
- Air Brakes
- Performance (dependent on stationary PTO usage)
- Fuel Economy Improved 40 - 60
- Idle Time Reduced 4 to 5 Hours per Day
- CO2 Output Reduced 13 to 17 Tons/Year
- Financial
- Federal Tax Credit
- Class 6 6K
- Class 7 12K
- Annual savings 4,500 to 6,000
Southwest Research Dyno Testing ePTO Cycle
44DTNA is committed to continued support of the NG
Market with the introduction of the
Freightliner M2-112 with Natural Gas
Sterling to Freightliner Transition
Sterling SB 113 Production discontinued March 2009
M2 112 2009 SOP
45