Title: SWIFT regional conference in Turkey
1Welcomeback
2Securities and treasury Daring to transform
3Todays plenary session
- Host OTC derivativesFabian Vandenreydt, Head
of FX and Derivatives Market, SWIFT - Market infrastructure Our foundation for
growthArthur Cousins, Member of the SWIFT Board,
Director, Standard Bank of South Africa and CLS
Board Member - Improving cross-border clearing and settlements
arrangements in the European UnionPatrick Georg,
Director ICSD Cash Securities Settlement,
Clearstream - Transformation in actionJohn Falk, Manager,
Securities Market Infrastructures, SWIFT
4 Market infrastructureOur foundation for growth
- Arthur Cousins
- Member of the SWIFT Board Director,Standard Bank
of South Africa, and CLS Board Member
5Agenda
- Introduction
- Reform in The Securities Markets
- Issues in the Derivatives Markets
- Road to CLS
- Conclusion
6Objectives
- Cover Issues which apply to all markets
- Exchange views and learn from each other
- Chance to see what role SWIFT can play with
regard to issues discussed
7Reform in the securities markets
- Up until late 1990s
- We had Paper Share Certificates
- No Settlement through an RTGS
- No Contractual Settlement
- T5 meant a cup of tea for five people
- We were at the bottom end of GSCS benchmark rating
8Action taken
- Created Central Securities Depository
- Changed legislation to allowfor
demateriali-sation of Share Certificates - Acquired settlement software
- Agreed to use ISO 15022 Standards and SWIFT
network for messaging - Agreed to settle in Central Bank Funds via RTGs
which had recently been introduced
9Situation now
- We now have T5 Contractual Settlement
- We have DVP in Central Bank Funds
- We now have no paper certificates
- We now enjoy some of the highest settlement
ratings in the world - We even comply with the Giovaninni requirements
10Issues in the derivatives markets
- Back offices impacted by daily creation of new
products - Low profit margins means little money for
investments in Operations - Few standards for exchanging information
- Regulators concerned about operational risks
11Action required
- Agreement by Standards development entities to
collaborate - SWIFT should take a leadership role in Standards
development and connectivity - Market infrastructures/organisations, e.g. ISDA,
DTCC, SWAPSCLEAR, SWIFT, FPML and others to
create an agenda for back office reform (G30 type
approach)
12Road to CLS
- South African Authorities share concern about FX
settlement risk - Supported all efforts to have Rand included in
CLS - Changed legislation finality of payment
- Changed RTGs to include SWIFT Y copy to support
stable Rand - Fiscal and monetary policies implemented to
support stable Rand
13Conclusion
- South Africa now has a world class financial
infrastructure - Investors have the same level of certainty in
South Africa that they enjoy in developed
countries - Urgent work needed in the area of derivatives
14Istanbul 6-8 March 2006
SWIFT regional conference in Istanbul
15OTC derivativesAddressing post-trade issues
- Fabian Vandenreydt
- Head of FX and Derivatives Markets
16Market trends
17Market trends
18Market trends
19OTC derivatives and Hedge Funds high industry
attention
- Corrigan report issued July 2005 by CRMPG II
- The primary focus of the Policy Group was
directed at credit risk, market risk and
liquidity risk
20Main themes and key lessons for treasurers
- Among the report's 47 recommendations are two
strong themes - Need to better monitor the role of hedge funds in
the markets - Urgent challenge of tackling the problems
associated with credit derivative products and
other complex instruments - Key lessons for treasurers
- Ask more critical questions about the credit-risk
management practices of their counterparties - More proactively explain their credit-risk
management approach to banks and other
counterparties. This will determine access, and
the terms of access, to credit including
collateral arrangements
21the Policy Groups Recommendations and Guiding
Principles center on seven closely related themes
- Corporate Governance
- Risk Management and Monitoring
- Financial Infrastructure and Operational
Integrity - Understanding and Managing Complex Financial
Instruments - Reputational Risk Areas of Special Focus
- Transparency
- Hedge Funds
22Financial Infrastructure and Operational
IntegritySection IV of the Report contains 13
Recommendations and Guiding Principles
- 12 Immediate need to address the backlog of
unsigned confirmations in some segments of the
OTC market - 15 Industry-wide need to accelerate the
development of straight-through processing of OTC
transactions - 21 Need to develop a simultaneous net
settlement system for credit default swaps - 22 Urgent need for market participants to stop
assigning or accepting assignment of trades
without the consent of all three parties to the
trade
Source Counterparty Risk Management Policy Group
II
23Derivatives and Hedge Funds eco-system
Investor
the servicing side triangle
Transfer agents
Fund Admin.
Transfer agents
Transfer agents
Investment Managers
Prime Brokers
Hedge Fund Managers
Custodians
Local custodians
Local custodians
Executing broker
Local custodians
Executing broker
Executing broker
24Derivatives and Hedge Funds servicingBurning
issues
Position and Control
- Trade lifecycle management
- IRS/CDS trade capture
- IRS/CDS confirmations
- Identify OTC trade
- Assignments
- Lending pools
- Buy-side connectivity to MIs
- Standardized access to MIs
- Contract management
- Repository of contracts
- Collateral negotiation
Corporate Actions
Core Transaction Processing
Funding and FX
Reconciliation
Investment
Decision
Order
Trade Reconciliation
Placement
Reference Data
Product and Financial Control
Portfolio valuation
Trade
Settlement
Execution
Post Trade Processing
Stock Lending and Borrowing
Risk/Collateral Management
25Derivatives and Hedge Funds servicingBurning
issues
- Trade settlement
- Projected cash flow reporting and reconciliation
- Payment SSI
- Valuation and risk management
- Portfolio/position reporting and reconciliation
- Fund NAV messaging aggregation
- Valuation reporting reconciliation
- Collateral management reporting and
reconciliation - Corporate actions
Position and Control
Corporate Actions
Core Transaction Processing
Funding and FX
Reconciliation
Investment
Decision
Order
Trade Reconciliation
Placement
Reference Data
Product and Financial Control
Portfolio valuation
Trade
Settlement
Execution
Post Trade Processing
Stock Lending and Borrowing
Risk/Collateral Management
26 Strategic focus 2006-2007
Three main focus areas
? Derivatives post-trade processing ? Hedge Funds
servicing ? Cross-Asset reporting and Collateral
Management
- Leverage SWIFTNet Accord matching functionality
for other instruments and services - Leverage Collateral Management and portfolio
valuation messages and SWIFTNet Funds solution - Extend offering to buy-side players (Affirmation
model) - Align our efforts with the ISDA roadmap (eg,
FpML, Collateral Mgmt) - Build a common agenda for OTC derivatives
post-trade processing with other market
infrastructures
27Product focus 2006
28Product focus 2006
29Product focus 2006
30SWIFTNet Affirmations
4 Affirming Party agrees or disagrees 5 -
(Dis-)agreement is stored on Central HUB 6 - Bank
views (dis-)agreement -OR- hub sends
response in MT 398 envelope
1 - Bank and user enter into a deal 2 - Bank
sends confirmation to central hub 3 - User views
confirmations in graphical environment
31Istanbul 6-8 March 2006
SWIFT regional conference in Istanbul
32 Improving cross-border clearing and settlements
arrangements in the European Union
- Patrick Georg
- Director ICSD Cash Securities Settlement,
Clearstream
33Istanbul 6-8 March 2006
SWIFT regional conference in Istanbul
34 Transformationin action
- John Falk
- John Falk, Manager, Securities Market
Infrastructures, SWIFT
35Why do markets need to reform?
- The Lisbon Agenda
- By 2010, European Union to become the most
competitive and dynamic knowledge economy in the
world - Assisted by creation of a single, integrated
financial market - Investor protection
- Business enhancement
- Financial Services Action Plan
- Directives moving into national law
- Best practice initiatives
36Recommendations, Barriers or Regulations
- A
- Single Protocol
- for
- Clearing and Settlement
37Recommendations, Barriers or Regulations
- 2001 CPSS-IOSCO, Recommendation 16
- Securities Settlement Systems should use or
accommodate relevant international communication
procedures standards - 2003 Giovannini, Barrier 1
- Define EU wide protocol to eliminate national
differences in IT interfaces used by Clearing
Settlement providers - 2003 G30, Recommendation 2
- Harmonise message standards communication
protocols - 2004 ESCB-CESR, Standard 16 (draft)
- Entities providing securities clearing and
settlement services, and participants in their
systems should use or accommodate relevant
international communication procedures and
messaging and reference data standards
G30 Recommendation 2 All market participants
should adopt ISO15022 as the global standard for
straight-through securities messaging across the
entire securities life cycle XML should become
the language to describe standardised
messages Market participants should support
and use communication networks that adopt open,
standardised, IP-based protocols for securities
transactions
Giovannini Barrier 1 National differences in
the information technology and interfaces used by
clearing and settlement providers should be
eliminated via an EU wide protocol SWIFT should
ensure the definition of this protocol through
the Securities Market Practice Group
38A Single Protocol for Clearing and Settlement
39Terminology Protocol scope
IMI Investment Manager B/D Broker Dealer VMU
Virtual Matching Utility ETCP Electronic Trade
Confirm provider GC Global Custodian SC
Sub-Custodian SA Settlement Agent
(Clearer) CCP Clearing House / Central
Counterparty (I)CSD (International) Central
Securities Depository
Institutional (buy) Side
Street (sell) Side
Trade Date
Order
IMI
B/D
B/D
Trade
Space 1 Pre-trade / Trade
Exchange
1
VMU / ETCP
Space 2 Post Trade / Pre-Settlement
Trade Date X
CCP
2
GC
SA
SC
SA
Space 3 Clearing Settlement
(I)CSD
3
Non Trade Related Activity
Space 4 - Custody Services
40Giovannini Protocol content
- Mandatory use of ISO15022/20022 for x-border
- Optional for domestic
Not applicable
- SWIFT to complete ISO15022/20022 gap analysis
fill gaps - Other initiatives adopt protocol, e.g. MiFID
- Available in TARGET opening hours
- Satisfy local business, regulatory performance
resilience needs - Message/file log, guaranteed delivery, delivery
once only once
- ISO15022/20022 compliant
- Internet Protocol (IP)
- Message, file transfer GUI
- Authentication/ Data integrity via PKI
- Non-repudiation
- Time stamping
41Protocol Content ExampleElement 1 Data
Standards
- EU Cash Securities Securities Clearing
Settlement Systems, CS Infrastructures and
Central CounterParties should implement relevant
ISO data standards in support of ISO15022/20022 - Such as but not limited to
- ISO 3166 - Country Codes
- ISO 4217 - Currency codes
- ISO 6166 - ISIN
- ISO 8601 - Date/time format
- ISO 9362 - BIC
- ISO 10383 - MIC
- ISO 10962 - CFI
- ISO 13616 - IBAN
- ISO 16732 - IBEI (Provisionally)
42Giovannini Implementation Support
- Infrastructures fully involved
- ICSDs Clearstream, Euroclear NCSD
(ECSDA) - Clearing Houses/CCPs Eurex (via Clearstream),
LCH.Clearnet - Central Banks European Central Bank
- Protocol to include statement of compliance
intent from - Infrastructures
- Top 30 EU active Financial Institutions
- Thought leaders from the Fund Management community
43SWIFT meeting the challengePresent and future
- Communication network
- SWIFTNet (IP based service)
- Market Practice Standards worldwide
- Securities Market Practice Group (SMPG)
- Data Standards
- ISO15022
- SWIFT ISO XML Standards
- UNIFI (ISO20022 - Standards convergence)
44Next Steps
- Industry review
- October 25th, 2005 January 27th, 2006
- Posted to 350 institutions
- 2 questions
- Will this protocol eliminate Barrier 1?
- Will my institution support its implementation?
- Final publication
- March 31st 2006
45The Holy Grail for the EU Securities MarketA
true end to end Standards solution?
IMI Investment Manager B/D Broker Dealer VMU
Virtual Matching Utility ETCP Electronic Trade
Confirm provider GC Global Custodian SC
Sub-Custodian SA Settlement Agent
(Clearer) CCP Clearing House / Central
Counterparty (I)CSD (International) Central
Securities Depository
Institutional (buy) Side
Street (sell) Side
MiFID ISO20022
Trade Date
Order
IMI
B/D
B/D
Trade
Space 1 Pre-trade / Trade
Exchange
1
VMU / ETCP
Space 2 Post Trade / Pre-Settlement
Giovannini ISO20022 (inc ISO15022)
Trade Date X
CCP
SEPA ISO20022 Target 2 ISO20022
2
GC
SA
SC
SA
Space 3 Clearing Settlement
(I)CSD
3
Non Trade Related Activity
Space 4 - Custody Services
46And if it doesnt happen
- The Commission is taking a close look at the
economic case for action. We will decide on
whether any European legislation, or other
intervention, is necessary on that basis and in
the light of developments in the market. The next
six months are crucial. As far as I am concerned,
the clock is ticking - Commissioner Charlie McCreevy,
- September 2005
47Istanbul 6-8 March 2006
SWIFT regional conference in Istanbul
48SWIFT regional conference in IstanbulWednesdays
agenda
- 0900-1030 Plenary session
- Securities and treasury Daring to transform
-
- 1100-1230 Panel session
- Transformation in action
- 1400-1530 Closing plenary
- Transforming the way you do business
1100-1230 Work session 5
49SWIFT regional conference in Istanbul