Title: Activities regarding UBL at ECOM in Japan
1Activities regarding UBL at ECOM in Japan
May 10, 2004 Yukinori Saito Vice Chair of OASIS
UBL JPLSC Fuji Electric Information Service Co.,
Ltd. saito-yukinori_at_fujielectric.co.jp
2Activities done in fiscal 2003 at ECOM.
Standard business documents conversion method
research ad-hoc TF
- Research of development methods of Standard
Business Documents. - Development methods of standard business
documents. - Recommendable standard business documents between
industries. - Recommendable methods and software products to
convert standard business documents. - The method of XML-izing and some consideration
points. - 2. Case study of business documents conversion
system and consideration. - 3. Mapping trial between UBL and Japanese major
industrys business documents. Consideration of
UBL gotten by this trial.
3Objective of the TF
- Background
- Many industries develop many standard business
documents and are operating them as real business
now. - In case some companies have their proprietary
business documents, they have to convert the
business documents to do business in the
industry. - In case to do business with any other industry,
many companies under the industry have to convert
the business documents to the other business
documents to keep interoperability. This is a
very big issue with which many industries and
companies are faced. - ebXML standard is being developed as an
international standard to do e-business. As
standards to develop standard business documents,
Core Component specification, XML Schema design
rules, standardized CC (Core Components) and BIE
(Business Information Entities), and maybe ebXML
authorized standard business documents are now
being developed. - Even though ebXML would develop these standards
described above, many industries have needs to
convert business documents between the industry's
business documents and ebXML authorized standard
business documents. - 2. Objective
- The objective of the TF is to propose
recommendable conversion methods of standard
business documents for industries in Japan.
4Where UBL Can Fit Into Existing XML B2B
Objective of the TF is to study how to convert
business documents between industries which is
recommended application of UBL by UBL TC.
Reference UBL Realizing eBusiness XML (Mark
Crawford, XML Europe 2003)
5The Reason for us to focus on UBL
- The reason for us to focus on UBL
- OASIS (the major standard body on XML) is
promoting UBL. - UN/CEFACT recognizes and supports UBL.
UN/CEFACT will support only one document-centric
approach to XML content and its desire is that
UBL will be the foundation for that approach.
(August 21, 2003) - UBL is fully based on ebXML CC Technical
Specification. UBL is committed to, and fully
conformant with, the ebXML CCTS. (XML Conference
2002) - Observation of UBL for us
- UBL is the first major candidate of the next
generation international XML standard business
document. - UBL is the standard business document that is
used on the second approach to develop business
document, which is described on the following
page 8.
6UBL Position among International standards for e
Business
BCF and ebXML BCF and Web services
BOV Business Process Definition BCF UMM BCF UMM BCF UMM
BOV Business Process Specification Description BPSS BCSS BPEL4WS
BOV Party/ Product Code Management
BOV Business Document (Standard Message) (UBL)
BOV Data Element Definition CC
FSV Technical Partner Agreement Services Description CPPA WSDL
FSV Registry and Repository RR UDDI
FSV Messaging (Routing, Reliable Messaging) ebMS WS-Reliable Messaging
FSV Packaging ebMS SOAP,MIME SOAP DIME,MIME
FSV Security CPPA, MS XMLDSIG WS-Security XMLDSIG,?
FSV Communication Protocol HTTP,SMTP FTP, etc. HTTP,SMTP FTP, etc.
Red Characters means XML based Standard.
indicates that specifications of other standard
are applied. ( ) means future plan.
7Typical B2B Standards in Industries
OAGIS EDIINT RosettaNet ECALGA(JEITA)
BOV Trading Partner Agreement (Business level TPA) Trading Partner Agreement (Business level TPA) RN TPA ECALGA TPA
BOV Business Process Definition Business Process Definition Integration Scenario PIP ECALGA CBC,BC
BOV Business Process Specification Description Business Process Specification Description ebXML BPSS (ebXML BPSS) (BPEL4WS) ebXML BPSS
BOV Party/ Product Code Management Party/ Product Code Management DUNS, GTIN UNSPSC CII Enterprise Code, ECALS
BOV Business Document (Standard Message) Business Document (Standard Message) BOD PIP ECALGA BD
BOV Data Element Definition Data Element Definition BOD (ebXML CC) PIP RNBD,RNTD ECALGA BD ECALS
FSV Technical Partner Agreement Services Description Technical Partner Agreement Services Description (ebXML CPPA) RN TPA (ebXML CPPA) ebXML CPPA
FSV Registry and Repository Registry and Repository UDDI
FSV Messaging (Routing, Reliable Messaging) Messaging (Routing, Reliable Messaging) RNIF ebMS EDIINT RNIF, (ebMS,Web Services) ebMS
FSV Packaging Packaging RNIF ebMS MIME RNIF MIME ebMS
FSV Security Security ebMS EDIINT S/MIME S/MIME ebMS
FSV Communication Protocol Communication Protocol HTTP HTTP SMTP HTTP SMTP HTTPS
Red Characters means XML based Standard.
indicates that specifications of other standard
are applied. ( ) means future plan.
8Two approaches to develop business documents.
- All Industries and companies recognize that next
generation EDI standard business documents are
XML based. - The next issue is how to develop or introduce
XML-based standard business documents, and what
are they. - Newly design and develop standard business
document including BIEs based on ebXML
methodologies. - This approach requires much resources (e.g. Man
power, money, time). - The big industries are maybe able to do this
approach. e.g. Japan Electronics Information
Technology Industries Association (JEITA). - To introduce or reuse some major XML-based
business documents. - This approach requires less resources.
- This approach may be recommendable one for medium
or small industries or companies. - The next issue for this approach is conversion
method of business documents.
9Research of development methods of standard
business documents
- Questions
- Development method of standard business document.
Which one is desirable among followings? - Newly design and develop standard business
document based on ebXML methodology. - Reuse the previous or current standard business
documents of XML syntax. - Use the previous or current standard business
documents (not XML) as it is. - (2) Standard business documents between
industries. - How to chose the interoperable business
documents? - What are the recommendable international standard
business documents? - (3) Recommendable methods and software products
to convert business documents. - (4) The method of XML-izing and some
consideration points. - Reply companies
- Propylon, Ireland - Inforteria, Japan
- CECID, Hong Kong - NTT, Japan
- DagangNet, Malaysia - IT vendor (Anonymous)
10Answers to the development method of standard
business document.
- Propylon, Ireland
- Newly design and development standard business
document based on ebXML methodology is difficult
because achieving industry wide consensus for a
single XML format based on the ebXML methodology
can take a very long time. - Reuse the current XML based standard business
document seems to be the most sensible. - CECID, Hong Kong
- We recommends the use of XML to replace the
proprietary format. - When there is a suitable XML application standard
(e.g. XBRL) for a specific business area, we will
use that standard. - When there is no suitable XML application
standard, we have to design our own. We recommend
the use of CCTS /UBL methodology to model the
data elements and design the XML Schema.
11Answers to the recommendable standard business
document.
- Propylon, Ireland
- We would suggest that for basic documents (like
invoices) between industries, the best route
would be take a UBL document, because it is much
more specific than other meta-models. - UBL is based on actual business documents
including good examples and overviews. - CECID, Hong Kong
- We will consider to use the standard with more
dominant, popular, and horizontal application
first. Then we will consider to use an
industry-specific standard, if the horizontal
standard is not applicable. - UBL V1.0 was released on Nov. 26, 2003, therefore
we think UBL became mature, we will choose UBL. - Infoteria, Japan
- At first, we should evaluate UBL specifications.
If applicable, we had better select UBL and use
UBL as an original specification.
12Answers to the recommendable method and software
products to convert standard business document.
- Propylon, Ireland
- We would obviously recommend PropelX, our
implementation of the Xpipe transformation
methodology. PropelX currently offers the
simplest most powerful and most flexible XML
translation capabilities. - XML style sheet are not easily understood or
modified. - CECID, Hong Kong
- For simple translation, we use XSLT. But usually
XSLT is not powerful enough to do the conversion
from one standard to another, which is usually
very difficult. - We write customized programs to do the
conversion. - NTT, Japan
- Using some commercial translators is
recommendable to convert business document.
13The method of XML-izing for BIEs.
- Trends or current situation in Japanese
industries. - The naming methods of XML Tag name in Japan.
- Using Japanese language as it is. e.g. Paint
industry, ApparelArk (Chemical) - Using BIEs item number (Alphanumeric character).
e.g. ECALGA (JEITA) - Use English name. e.g. RosettaNet, Aerospace
industry - (2) Many industries are intending to design
English XML Tag names.
- Consideration
- English XML Tag name is desirable by
consideration of implementation. - Japanese Tag name requires large burden for
implementers. Because some tools for editing XML
data cannot be used for Japanese Tag names. - The English Tag names is much better to convert
to international business document (e.g. UBL). - XML naming rules led by international standard
body are based on English. - (2) The Japanese people are not good at English
(reading/ writing and conversation). But they can
understand the English words. - (3) Of cause, the values between start tag and
end tag should be both Alphanumeric characters
and Japanese characters.
14Case study of conversion system between standard
business documents.
- Research of conversion systems and needs to
conversions between several standard business
documents. There are much needs to conversions of
standard business documents in real business. - Categories of conversion systems and example
systems. - To convert the data in in-house backend system
manually. - Electronics industrys purchasing iron and steel
by way of Trading company. - Electronics industrys purchasing chemical goods
by way of Trading comp. - (2) Plural orders are received by different
business documents, and they are converted to
single business document. 7 cases including
followings. - JEMIMA (Japan Electric Measuring Instruments
Manufacturers Association). - Sales system in Electronics devices supplier.
- Next generation EDI system at Chemical industry.
- Purchasing system of PC software at Microsoft
Japan. - EDI at distribution industry.
- (3) To convert one single business document to
plural business documents. - Purchasing system of Sony corporation.
- (4) To convert business documents using ASP
service. - ASP service of Port logistics industry.
15Needs at JEMIMA
Situation and issues Orders are received from
Communication, Automotive, Petro-chemical, and
Electronics devices industries. And their
business documents are different each
other. Solution Plural orders business
documents will be converted to a single major
business document (e.g. ECALGA (JEITA), UBL) at
the sales receiving EDI function. It is desirable
that the conversion software would be developed
and provided by some standard bodies . e.g.
government, ECOM, JEITA.
Automotive
Iron and Steel
Petro-chemical
Industries
Communication
Business Documents
Proprietary
Iron and Steel
JPCA
EIAJ
Sales received
BP Conversion ?ECALGA,UBL
EDI function
JEMIMA indutry
Sales System
Purchasing System
Purchase
EIAJ
Electronics Devices Industry
16Sales system in Electronics devices supplier.
- Situation and issues
- Electronics devices supplier receives orders by
several different business documents and they are
troublesome to handle. - Electronics devices supplier receives EDIFACT by
overseas electronics vendors.
Domestic Electronics Vendors
B
A
C
Order (EIAJ)
Order (Proprietary)
Order (RosettaNet)
Electronics Devices Supplier
Overseas Electronics Vendors
Backend System
BP Conversion
O
Order (UN/EDIFACT)
EIAJ
Subsidiary Companies
X
Y
17Planning next generation EDI system of
Petro-Chemical Industry
- Next generation EDI system
- Trading company or major chemistry vendor is
planning to conversion system. - Chem-eStandard business document will be
converted to JPCA-BP at the major chemistry
vendors front-end system. The sales system will
be managed by using single JPCA-BP business
document.
Electronics Devices Supplier
Second Trading Company
Order (EIAJ)
Order (Chem-eStandard)
Trading Company
A
B
JPCA-BP
Chem-eStandard
BP Conversion Chem-eStandard?JPCA-BP
Major Chemistry Vendor
JPCA-BP Business Document
Backend System
18Mapping trials between UBL and major industrys
business documents in Japan.
- Objective
- To research whether UBL is interoperable with
major business documents in Japan or not. - To research whether UBL is operable in Japanese
industries. - To study and evaluate UBL.
- Targeted standard business documents
- (1) ECALGA Order
- ECALGA (Electronic Commerce ALliance for Global
business Activity) is a next generation EDI
standard developed by JEITA (Japan Electronics
and Information Technology Association). - ECALGA is the succeeding standard of EIAJ, which
is very popular in Japan. - ECALGA is based on ebXML BP, CPPA, and MS.
- (2) JEDICOS-XML Order
- - JEDICOS-XML is a recently developed XML based
standard business documents for the distribution
industry developed by Distribution Systems
Research Institute.
19Mapping methods (1/2)
- Targeted business document
- - We selected a business document Order at
first. - Understanding UBL Order
- We used the spread sheet of UBL Order V1.0.
- We made a single UBL Order spread sheet by
integrating both UBL Order 1.0-beta.xls and UBL
Reusable 1.0-beta.xls. The number of ABIE, BBIE,
and ASBIE of the single UBL Order spread sheet is
384. - We made Japanese business terms for all BIEs of
UBL Order. These Japanese business terms are not
merely translation of names of UBL BIEs, but the
Japanese business terms are made by using current
business terms which are used in many business
documents in Japan. - Understanding the structure of the business
document Order. - We made a single UBL Order class diagram in one
document (MS Word). - Also, we made a single Order class diagram for
ECALGA Order and JEDICOS XML Order.
20Mapping methods (2/2)
- Mapping BIEs between UBL and ECALGA, JEDICOS
XML - We made mapping spread sheets.
- Example of mapping chart between UBL and ECALGA.
ECALGA Order
UBL Order
Mapping Data with UBL
Header
Name (UBL) Name (Japanese)
BuyersID ????
SellersID ????
CopyIndicator ?/???
GUID ?????No.
No. ECALGA Order ??
00007 ????
Not mapped
Not mapped
00001 ?????No.
No. ECALGA Order ??
00001 ?????No.
Body
No. ECALGA Order ??
C00108 ??BD??
00007 ????
18103 ???
C00109 ??BD??.??
00167 ??????
21Consideration of interoperability by mapping
trials
- UBL and ECALGA
- The number of BIEs of ECALGA Order is 101.
- The structure of ECALGA Order is one item per
one document. This is not match to UBL Order (the
structure of UBL Order is multiple items per one
document.). - The BIEs of ECALGA Order is generally match to
BIEs of UBL. Especially, necessary BIEs of ECALGA
are including in UBL Order. - UBL and JEDICOS-XML
- The number of BIEs of JEDICOS-XML Order is 112.
- The structure of JEDICOS-XML Order is multiple
items per one document. This is match to UBL
Order (the structure of UBL Order is multiple
items per one document.). - The abundant BIEs of UBL include BIEs of
JEDICOS-XML. Therefore, if the indutry select
commonly used BIEs from UBL, interoperability
between UBL and JEDICOS-XML will be possible.
22General Consideration of UBL gotten by mapping
trials.
- The necessary BIEs for sales in Japan are
provided by UBL business document. UBL business
documents are useable in Japanese industries. - The UBL BIEs are abundant. UBL BIEs include some
BIEs that are not used in the trading business in
Japan. Some BIEs of UBL are capable to be defined
by the trading partner agreement. The industry or
companies are able to adopt UBL by selecting
necessary BIEs from UBL standards. - Plural items are capable to be defined per one
document. - Separate delivery (e.g. deferent schedule) can be
defined. Also, delivery methods are able to be
defined by items. - Plural delivery place are capable to be defined
for general purpose and per items. - Both base price and total amount can be defined.
- UBL TC prepared the seven business documents that
are expected to be used high frequently. The
minimum trading business can be done in
industries with these business documents.
23Proposals regarding marketing to promote UBL
deployment in the world
- Publication of Introduction guide book of UBL.
For examples are follows. - Position of UBL
- e.g. UBL is supported by both OASIS and
UN/CEFACT. UBL is fully based on ebXML CCTS. UBL
is applicable for purchasing of not only MRO but
also direct materials - Introduction methods of UBL to industries
- e.g. (1) Industry organization develop
their business document by subsetting the UBL
schemas. (2) They will build new documents, using
the standard components from the UBL standard
abundant libraries. (3) They will use the UBL as
a common business document between industries. - Easy understanding description of UBL standard
business documents - e.g. Class diagrams of business documents
by single document. - Recommendable conversion methods and systems
between UBL and other standard business
documents. - Publication of deployment cases of UBL
- e.g. The e procurement system by Danish
government.
24Next steps at ECOM (1/2)
- Activities regarding EDI which were done at
ECOM in fiscal 2003 - (1) Survey of EC in SME domain
- ECOM has researched survey regarding Electronic
Commerce including EDI in SME domain. The scale
of investigation is 5,000 SME companies by the
questionnaire method. - SME companies are introducing EC systems
recently. - They are suffering from non-standardized
multiple business documents. - And they dont have sufficient EC promoting
resources (e.g. engineers and budget). - (2) Proposals for the recommendable next
generation EDI system not only for big
enterprises but also for SMEs. - To develop standard EDI client system including
messaging function and business document
processing function. - The messaging function had better to be based on
ebXML MS specification. - To develop common and interoperable Hub service
to exchange EDI data. - This system will adopt commonly useable business
document. The big candidate are UBL and ECALGA.
25Next steps at ECOM (2/2)
A consortium named Common XML/EDI practical
use promotion consortium will be established
since May, 2004, to develop next generation EDI
system ,based on ECOMs proposal, supported by
government.
- Planning activities regarding EDI at ECOM in
fiscal 2004 - (1) Detailed design of the proposal of next
generation EDI system - EDI messaging function.
- EDI business document processing function.
- EDI ASP service.
- (2) Research the recommendable business document
for SME. - To research currently used business documents by
major buyers in real business. - To estimate what is desirable business document
or some requirements. e.g. UBL, ECALGA,
JEDICOS-XML. - (3) Promotion of development of the standard
business document conversion system.
26Reference documents
- Individual documents
- Answers to questions about standard business
document and conversion method. (Overseas
companies, English) - UBL Order BIE spread sheet with Japanese business
terms. (MS Excel) - UBL Order class diagram. (MS Word, English)
- Mapping spread sheet between UBL and ECALGA.
- Mapping spread sheet between UBL and JEDICOS-XML.
- (2) Total report of activities at ECOM
- Standard business document conversion methods
research report. (83 pages, published by ECOM on
March 2004, Japanese language) - Current situation of Internet EDI and proposal to
promote EDI in Japan (123 pages, published by
ECOM on March 2004, Japanese language)