Title: Nancy K. Young, Ph.D., Director
1Methamphetamine Use and the Impact on Child
Welfare
Nancy K. Young, Ph.D., Director National Center
on Substance Abuse and Child Welfare Jay
Wurscher, Director Oregon Child Welfare Addiction
Services Presented at CWLA Methamphetamine
Teleconference September 22, 2005
2Overview, Treatment and Risks to Children
3Overview, Treatment and Risks to Children
- 1. NCSACW
- 2. Scope of the Problem
- 3. Patterns of Use
- 4. Effects of Meth Addiction
- 5. Risks to Children
- 6. Treatment for Meth
4- A Program of the
- Substance Abuse and Mental Health
- Services Administration
- Center for Substance Abuse Treatment
- and the
- Administration on Children, Youth and Families
- Childrens Bureau
- Office on Child Abuse and Neglect
5NCSACW Mission
- To improve outcomes for families by promoting
effective practice, and organizational and system
changes at the local, state, and national levels - Developing and implementing a comprehensive
program of information gathering and
dissemination - Providing technical assistance
6NCSACW Consortium
- American Public Human Services Association
(APHSA) - Child Welfare League of America (CWLA)
- National Association of State Alcohol and Drug
Abuse Directors (NASADAD) - National Council of Juvenile and Family Court
Judges (NCJFCJ) - National Indian Child Welfare Association (NICWA)
7Recent NCSACW Products
- Understanding Substance Abuse and Facilitating
Recovery A Guide for Child Welfare Workers - (A short monograph for front-line workers)
- On-Line Training Now Available
- Understanding Child Welfare and the Dependency
Court A Guide for Substance Abuse Treatment
Professionals - Understanding Substance Use Disorders, Treatment
and Family Recovery A Guide for Child Welfare
Professionals
8Scope of the Problem
9Scope of the Problem
- Meth use has increased
- Use has spread from the West
- Accounts for a small percentage of the total
number of people affected by drug and alcohol
problems - The impact of meth use on child welfare varies
widely among States and among Counties
10Meth/Amphetamine Treatment Admission Rate Per
100,000 Population Aged 12 or Older - 1993-2003
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
11Eastward Spread of Methamphetamine
Admissions per 100,000 population
12Eastward Spread of Methamphetamine
Admissions per 100,000 population
13Treatment Admissions by Primary Substance - 2003
- Alcohol 42
- Heroin/Other Opiates 18
- Marijuana 15
- Cocaine 14
-
- Meth/Amphetamine and 7
- Other Stimulants
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
14Impact of Increasing Methamphetamine Use
- Methamphetamine is affecting communities that
have not experienced prior stimulant drug
problems - Child welfare agencies are dealing with more
cases involving methamphetamine
15Smoked Cocaine/Crack and Meth/Amphetamine
Treatment Admissions by Race/Ethnicity
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
16Meth/Amphetamine Cocaine Treatment Admissions
According to Census Division 2003
RATE per 100,000
Rate per 100,000
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
17Gender Differences
- 47 of admissions are women
- Since women are often caretakers of children,
more children are likely affected.
Source Vaughn, C. (2003)
18Treatment Admissions Meth/Amphetamine as Primary
Substance by Gender
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
19Meth/Amphetamine Admissions By Gender - 2003
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
20Female Treatment Admissions States with Highest
of Meth/Amphetamine as Primary Substance
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
21Trends in Primary Substance UseTreatment
Admissions for Pregnant Females by Primary
Substance 1995-2003
Percent of Womens Admissions for
Meth/Amphetamine and Marijuana Nearly Doubled
over 8 Years
Source Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS)
22Foster Care Population and Persons Who First Used
Crack or Methamphetamine in Prior Year
23Effects of Methamphetamine Addiction
24Short-Term Effects of Methamphetamine
- PHYSICAL
- Heart rate
- Respiration
- Blood pressure
- Pupil size
- Sensory acuity
- Energy
- Appetite
- Sleep
- Reaction time
- PSYCHOLOGICAL
- Confidence
- Alertness
- Mood
- Sex drive
- Energy
- Talkativeness
- Boredom
- Loneliness
- Timidity
Source Judith Cohen, Ph.D., Presentation to
NASADAD, June 2005
25Methamphetamine Chronic Physical Effects
- Tremors
- Weakness
- Headaches
- Sweating
- Coughing
- Dry Mouth
- Oily skin/complextion
- Burned lips/sore nose
- Dental
- Weight Loss/Anorexia
26MethamphetamineChronic Psychological Effects
- - Confusion -
Irritability - - Concentration - Paranoia
- - Hallucinations - Panic
reactions - - Fatigue -
Depression - - Memory loss - Anger
- - Insomnia - Psychosis
Source Richard Rawson, Ph.D., Presentation to
SAMHSA, August 2005
27Cognitive Effects
- Decreased ability to
- Recognize and recall words and pictures
- Make inferences
- Manipulate information
- Ignore irrelevant information
- Learn from experience
- Users and people in early recovery may find it
difficult to - Pay attention
- Comprehend spoken and written information
- Remember information
Source Simon (1999)
28Cognitive Effects
- Abilities that improve after 12 weeks abstinence
- Manipulate information
- Ignore irrelevant information
- Abilities that do note improve after 12 weeks
abstinence - Recognize and recall words
- Recognize and recall pictures (declines less than
word recognition and recall)
Source Obert et al. (2002)
29Cognitive Effects
- Rate of recovery is associated with severity of
abuse and days of abstinence. - Study documented significant recovery with Meth
abusers who were able to stay drug free for at
least 9 months. - After 4 years of abstinence, no deficits in
- Memory
- Learning
- Attention
- Executive function
- Motor function
Sources Lundahl et al. (2004) Volkow et al.
(2001)
30Risks to Children When Parents Use Meth
31Six Different Situations for Children
- Parent uses or abuses methamphetamine
- Parent is dependent on methamphetamine
- Mother uses meth while pregnant
- Parent cooks small quantities of meth
- Parent involved in trafficking
- Parent involved in super lab
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
32Six Different Situations for Children
- Each situation poses different risks and requires
different responses - Child welfare workers need to know the different
responses required - The greatest number of children are exposed
through a parent who uses or is dependent on the
drug - Relatively few parents cook the drug
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
33Parent Uses or Abuses Meth
- Risks to safety and well-being of children
- Parental behavior under the influence poor
judgment, confusion, irritability, paranoia,
violence - Inadequate supervision
- Inconsistent parenting
- Chaotic home life
- Exposure to second-hand smoke
- Accidental ingestion of drug
- Possibility of abuse
- HIV exposure from needle use by parent
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
34Parent Is Dependent on Meth
- Risks to safety and well-being of children
- All the risks of parents who use or abuse, but
the child may be exposed more often and for
longer periods - Chronic neglect is more likely
- Household may lack food, water, utilities
- Chaotic home life
- Children may lack medical care, dental care,
immunizations - Greater risk of abuse
- Greater risk of sexual abuse if parent has
multiple partners
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
35Mother Uses Meth While Pregnant
- Risk to child depends on frequency and intensity
of use, and the stage of pregnancy - Risks include birth defects, growth retardation,
premature birth, low birth weight, brain lesions - Problems at birth may include difficulty sucking
and swallowing, hypersensitivity to touch,
excessive muscle tension (hypertonia) - Long term risks may include developmental
disorders, cognitive deficits, learning
disabilities, poor social adjustment, language
deficits
Sources Anglin et al. (2000) Oro Dixon,
(1987) Rawson Anglin (1999) Dixon Bejar
(1989) Smith et al. (2003) Shah (2002)
36Mother Uses Meth While Pregnant
- Observed effects may be due to other substances,
or combination of substances, used by the mother - For example, if the mother also smokes, growth
retardation may be significant - Observed effects may be complicated by other
conditions, such as the health, environmental, or
nutritional status of the mother
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
37Mother Uses While Pregnant
- Scope of the problem
- An estimated 10 to 11 of all newborns are
prenatally exposed to drugs or alcohol this
amounts to 400,000 to 480,000 newborns per year - Only about 5 of prenatally exposed newborns are
placed in out-of-home care the rest go home
without assessment and services
Sources Vega SAMHSA, OAS, National Survey of
Alcohol and Drug Use During Pregnancy, 2002 and
2003
38Mother Uses While Pregnant
Home environment is the critical factor in the
childs outcome Consequences can be mediated
Shah, R. (2005, June). From NASADAD presentation
39Parent Cooks Small Quantities of Meth
- All the risks of parents who use or are dependent
on meth, with added risks of manufacturing the
drug -
- Chemical exposure
- Toxic fumes
- Risk of fire and explosion
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
40Environmental Methamphetamine Exposure and Risks
- Toxic effects of manufacturing
- Children more at risk
- Higher metabolic rates
- Developing bone and nervous systems
- Thinner skin than adults which absorbs chemicals
faster - Children tend to put things in their mouth and
use touch to explore
Source Mason (2004)
41Parent Involved in Trafficking
- Presence of weapons
- Possibility of violence
- Possibility of physical or sexual abuse by
persons visiting the household
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
42Parent Involved in Super Lab
- Lower likelihood of children on the site
Source Nancy Young, Ph.D., Testimony before the
U.S. House of Representatives Government Reform
Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy,
and Human Resources, July 26, 2005
43Number of Children in Meth Labs
4 years 2,881 all children 1,200,000
Source El Paso Intelligence Center
44Medical Interventions for Children
- Field medical assessment
- Immediate care protocol
- Baseline assessment protocol
- Initial follow-up care protocol
- Long-term follow-up care protocol
Source Colorado DEC
45Treatment for Methamphetamine
46CSATs Methamphetamine Treatment Project
- Largest randomized clinical trial of treatment
for meth dependence - Compared the MATRIX manualized treatment model
developed at UCLA to treatment as usual - 8 study sites site in HI was all women
47Matrix Model
- Intensive outpatient setting
-
- Three to five visits per week of comprehensive
counseling for at least the first three months - Cognitive behavioral approach
- Contingency management
48Urinalysis Results
- Results of UA tests at discharge, 6 months
- and 12 months post admission
- Matrix Group TAU Group
- D/C 66 MA-free 65 MA-free
- 6 mo 69 MA-free 67 MA-free
- 12 mo 59 MA-free 55 MA-free
- Over 80 follow-up rate in both groups at all
points
Source Richard Rawson, Ph.D., Presentation to
SAMHSA, August 2005
49Similar Outcomes
- Treatment outcomes do not differ from other drugs
of abuse - Treatment outcomes have more to do with the
quantity and quality of treatment than type of
drug abused
50Treatment Outcomes for Women
- Of 10 MA-abusing women entering treatment
After treatment 1mo.
12mo. 24mo.
48mo.
Still MA-abstinent 6
4 3
3
3 still MA-abstinent 48 months after treatment
Source M.L. Brecht, Ph.D. (2004)
51Gender Differences and Implications for Treatment
- Co-occurring mental health problems
- Trauma
- Body image
52Behavior Symptom Inventory (BSI) Scores at
Baseline
Richard Rawson, Ph.D., Presentation to SAMHSA,
August 2005
53Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) Scores at
Baseline
Richard Rawson, Ph.D., Presentation to SAMHSA,
August 2005
54Self-Reported Reasons for Starting
Methamphetamine Use
Richard Rawson, Ph.D., Presentation to SAMHSA,
August 2005
55Gender Differences and Implications for Treatment
- Co-occurring mental health issues complicate
treatment and require longer duration for
treatment - Violence linked to meth use is related to trauma
and safety needs which must be addressed in
treatment - Body image and nutrition need to be addressed
56Gender Differences and Implications for
Treatment
- Threats of violence and reduced cognitive
capacity to manage activities of daily living
suggest that a period of residential treatment
will most often be indicated for women with
serious addiction to methamphetamine - When residential care is not available, IOT may
be indicated, with additional supports such as
transportation, meals, child care, referral to
safe houses or supervised housing
57What Predicts Longer Abstinence?
- Longer abstinence following treatment for women
with - Longer time in treatment (e.g. those with 4 or
more mo. of treatment have more than double the
rate of 24-48 mo. abstinence) - More sessions per month of individual counseling
(or sexual recovery groups) - Treatment, intervention and case planning need to
account for short-term effects, especially
cognitive deficits and verbal communication - Drug Court involvement
- Family involvement
M.L. Brecht, Ph.D., et al. (2005)
58Sacramento, California Model of Effective Child
Welfare and Substance Abuse Services
- Comprehensive trainingto understand substance
abuse and dependence and acquire skills to
intervene with parents - Early Intervention SpecialistsSocial workers
trained in motivational enhancement therapy are
stationed at the family court to intervene and
conduct preliminary assessments with ALL parents
with substance abuse allegations at the first
court hearing - Improvements in Cross-System Information
Systemsto ensure that communication across
systems and methods to monitor outcomes are in
place as well as management of the countys
treatment capacity
59Sacramento, California Model of Effective Child
Welfare and Substance Abuse Services
- Prioritization of Families in Child Protective
ServicesCounty-wide policy to ensure priority
access to substance abuse treatment services - Specialized Treatment and Recovery Services
(STARS)provides immediate access to substance
abuse assessment and engagement strategies
conducted by staff trained in motivational
enhancement therapy. STARS provides intensive
management of the recovery aspect of the child
welfare case plan and routine monitoring and
feedback to CPS and the court - Dependency Drug Courtprovides more frequent
court appearances for ALL parents with
allegations of substance use.
60Treatment Discharge Status by Primary Drug
Problem
6118-Month Child Placement Outcomesby Parent
Primary Drug Problem
62Methamphetamine Implications for Workers
63MethamphetamineImplications for Workers
- Signs of Use and Warning Signs for Workers
- Oregons Response
64Signs of Use and Warning Signs for Workers
65Signs of Methamphetamine Use and Use of Other
Stimulants
- Euphoria
- Grinding of teeth
- Rapid breathing
- Sweating
- Hyperactivity
- Tremor - shaking hands
- Rapid or pressured speech
- Depression - when drug wears off
- Irritability, paranoia, suspiciousness
- Hallucinations
- Presence of drug paraphernalia
Source Crowell Webber (2001)
66Warning Signs for Workers
- Client is extremely irritable, suspicious, or
argumentative, or there is an escalation of
irritability -
- Regular client does not appear to know who worker
is -
- Evidence of paranoid thinking, delusions
-
- Client verbalizes implicit or explicit threat
against worker
Source Crowell and Webber (2001)
67Other Severe Signs of Meth Use
- Scratch marks or scabs, particularly on clients
hands and arms - may be evidence of tactile
hallucinations and indicate a prior episode of
stimulant psychosis - Severe damage to teeth and gums
- Drawn face and underweight
- Strong chemical odor - may indicate manufacturing
of meth
Source Crowell and Webber (2001)
68Natural Rewards Elevate Dopamine Levels
69Effects of Drugs on Dopamine Levels
Source Di Chiara and Imperato
70Denial Super-memory Imprinting
- Memory imprinting increases in power as dopamine
activity increases. - Addicts remember the good-times and fail to
remember the bad-times.
71Research on Cognitive Impairments of MA addicts
- Ability to manipulate information
(multi-relational or synthesis). - Ability to make inferences.
- Ability to ignore irrelevant information.
- Ability to learn new or recall information.
Hippocampus?
implications?
72Methamphetamine Snapshot Phenomenon Wurscher
Martin
Doesn't want recovery
wants recovery
Sad-case
Criminal
Psycho-case
73Oregons Response
74Oregon 2004
- 9,500 CW cases (kids)
- 50 connected to Meth
- Up to 75 in some counties
- Usually exaggerated because they are the most
Chaotic Cases - Major Media coverage
- Major Crime issue Labs ID theft
75Oregon CW Success
- CW - FIT Family Involvement Team
- CW - ART Addiction Recovery Teams
- CADCs
- Outreach Workers
- DHS Staff
- ASFA Video
76Oregon Response
- Governors Meth Task Force
- Legislative Response Labs Crushed Drug Court
TX increased - Pseudo RX Drug as of July-2006
- DHS Meth Response Team
77Summary
78Summary
- Methamphetamine is a dangerous drug with serious
physical, cognitive, and health consequences - The effects of long-term use are reversible with
prolonged abstinence - Treatment for methamphetamine is as effective as
treatment for other drugs
79Summary
- A high percentage of methamphetamine users are
women of child-bearing age - Meth accounts for 7 of treatment admissions
nationally, but in some States 30- 44 of women
admitted were admitted for methamphetamine
80Summary
- Scope of the problem
- The number of meth users is small compared to
other drugs and alcohol - Admissions increased through 2003
- Communities that have not experienced prior drug
problems may lack the resources to handle a meth
problem - Meth use may be leveling off
81Summary
- Parents use of methamphetamine puts their
children at risk - The best outcome for both child and parent is
achieved when -
- The parent receives immediate, effective
treatment and comprehensive services - The child receives immediate assessment and
services, as well as follow-up services
82Summary
- Child welfare workers must distinguish between
- Children whose parents use meth, and
- Children whose parents manufacture meth
- They must learn the established medical protocols
for children present in meth labs
83Summary
- We need early diagnosis and intervention for
children affected by meth before and after birth - We need comprehensive, timely, and
state-of-the-art treatment for parents referred
to treatment as a condition of keeping or
reunifying with their children - We need information systems that capture the
necessary data to support effective approaches
84For Further Information
85SAMHSA Resources
- Treatment Improvement Protocols (TIP 33)
- Best Practice Guidelines for Treatment of
Substance Abuse - Researched, Drafted, and Reviewed by Substance
Use Disorder Professionals -
86SAMHSA Resources
- KAP Keys Quick Guide
- Developed to accompany the TIP Series
- Based entirely on TIP 33
- Designed to meet the needs of busy clinicians for
concise, easily accessed how-to information - http//www.samhsa.gov
87SAMHSA Resources
- SAMHSAs Addiction Technology Transfer Centers
(ATTC) - Pacific Southwest ATTC
- http//www.psattc.org/events/cates/I/presentation
s/index.html - Methamphetamine 101 Etiology and Physiology of
an Epidemic
88ATTCs Introduction to Evidence-Based Treatments
for Methamphetamine
- CD-ROM Learning Tools
- DVD Training Module
- Produced by Applied Behavioral Health Policy at
the University of Arizona for the Pacific
Southwest ATTC - web www.psattc.org
89Contact NCSACW
- www.ncsacw.samhsa.gov
- Project Director
- Nancy Young, Ph.D.
- 714-505-3525
- Government Project Officer
- Sharon Amatetti, SAMHSA/CSAT
- 240-276-1694
- sharon.amatetti_at_samhsa.hhs.gov
90References
- Anglin, M., Burke, C., Perrochet, B., Stamper, E.
Dawud-Noursi, S. (2000). History of the
methamphetamine problem. Journal of Psychoactive
Drugs, 32(2), 137-141. - Brecht, M.-L., M. D. Anglin, et al. (2005).
"Coerced Treatment for Methamphetamine Abuse
Differential Patient Characteristics and
Outcomes." The American Journal of Drug and
Alcohol Abuse 31(2) 337. - Brecht, M.L.(2004) Women and Methamphetamine
Characteristics, Treatment Outcomes. Presentation
to the Center - For Substance Abuse Treatment, State
Systems Development Conference. August 13. - Cohen, Judith, Ph.D. Presentation to NASADAD,
June 2005. - Colorado DEC. Retrieved from www.colodec.org/decp
apers/Documents/DEC20Medical20Protocol.pdf - Crowell and Webber, 2004. Retrieved from
www.drugfreeinfo.org/PDFs/strengthensupervision.pd
f. - Dixon, S.D., Bejar, R. (1989).
Echoencephalographic findings in neonates
associated with maternal cocaine and
methamphetamine use Incidence and clinical
correlates. Journal of Pediatrics, 115(5 Pt 1),
770-778. - Ferguson, T. (2001). Overview of medical
toxicology and potential exposures to clandestine
drug laboratories in California. Paper presented
to the Minnesota Department of Health. - Lundahl, L.H., Keenan, P., Schuster, C.R.,
Johanson, C.E. (2004, June). Neurocognitive
function in chronic high dose methamphetamine
abusers following long term abstinence. Poster
session presented at the 66th Annual Scientific
Meeting of the College on Problems of Drug
Dependence, San Juan, Puerto Rico. - Mason, A. P. 2004. Methamphetamine labs.
Presented at the annual conference of the North
Carolina Family-Based, Services Association. - Obert, J.L., London, E.D., Rawson, R.A. (2002).
Incorporating brain research findings into
standard treatment An example using the Matrix
Model. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment,
23(2), 107-113. - Office of Applied Studies, Substance Abuse and
Mental Health Services Administration, Treatment
Episode Data Set (TEDS). - Office of Applied Studies, Substance Abuse and
Mental Health Services Administration, National
Survey of Alcohol and Drug Use During Pregnancy,
2002 and 2003.
91References
Oro, A.S., Dixon, S.D. (1987). Perinatal
cocaine and methamphetamine exposure Maternal
and neonatal correlates. Journal of Pediatrics,
571-578. Rawson, Richard, Ph.D., Presentation to
SAMHSA, August 2005. Rawson, R., Anglin, M.D.
(1999, June). Methamphetamine New knowledge, new
treatments. Retrieved April 2004, from the UCLA
Integrated Substance Abuse Programs Web site
http//www.uclaisap.org/slides/Index46/index.htm S
imon, S. (1999). Cognitive impairment in
individuals currently using methamphetamine.
Retrieved April 2004, from the UCLA Integrated
Substance Abuse Programs Web site
http//www.uclaisap.org/slides/Index46/sld034.htm
Smith, L., Yonekura, M.L., Wallace, T., Berman,
N., Kuo, J., Berkowitz, C. (2003). Effects of
prenatal methamphetamine exposure on fetal growth
and drug withdrawal symptoms in infants born at
term. Journal of Developmental and Behavioral
Pediatrics, 24(1)17-23. Shah, R. (2005, June).
From NASADAD presentation Thompson, P.M.,
Hayashi, K.M., Simon, S.L., Geaga, J.A., Hong,
M.S., Sui, Y., et al. (2004). Structural
abnormalities in the brains of human subjects who
use methamphetamine. Journal of Neuroscience,
24(26), 6028-6036. Vaughn, C. (2003). Get up to
speed on methamphetamine use. NCADI Reporter.
Retrieved from http//www.health.org/newsroom/rep/
215.aspx Vega et al (1993), Profile of Alcohol
and Drug Use During Pregnancy in California,
1992. Volkow, N.D., Chang, L, Wang, G.J.,
Fowler, J.S., Leonido-Yee, M., Franceschi, D., et
al. (2001b). Association of dopamine transporter
reduction with psychomotor impairment in
methamphetamine abusers. American Journal of
Psychiatry, 158, 377-382. Young, Nancy K., Ph.D.
Testimony before the U.S. House of
Representatives Government Reform Subcommittee on
Criminal Justice, Drug Policy, and Human
Resources, July 26, 2005. Zickler, P. (2000).
Brain imaging studies show long-term damage from
methamphetamine abuse. NIDA Notes, 15(3).