Comets and Asteroids: Destroyers and Creators

1
Comets and Asteroids Destroyers and Creators

• Paul J. Thomas
• Department of Physics and Astronomy
• University of Wisconsin - Eau Claire

2
Asteroids
Ida and Dactyl, from the Galileo spacecraft
3
The Asteroid Belt
4
Comets
Comet Hale-Bopp
5
The Kuiper Belt and Oort Cloud
6
The Surface of a Comet
Rosetta/Philae landing on Churyumov-Gerasimenko
(2014)
Giotto flyby of Halley (1986)
7
Organic Molecules in Comets and Asteroids

• Carbonaceous chondrite asteroids are 3-5 organic
  by mass.
• 3 of organic asteroidal carbon is amino acids.
• Halley dust is 30 organic by mass.
• Halley gas is 14 organic by mass.

8
The Early Terrestrial Environment

• Earliest fossil evidence for life 3.8 Gya.
• Heavy Bombardment ended 3.8 Gya.
• Did comet impacts deliver water and organic
  molecules important for the origins of life?

9
Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9
10
Asteroid 1997XF11

• 2 km diameter asteroid.
• Brian Marsden (Harvard) calculated 2028 close
  approach of 40,000?180,000 km!
• Paul Chodas and Don Yeomans (JPL) revised this to
  80,000?2,500 km.
• Still, it will almost certainly hit Earth
  eventually...

11
June 30, 1908 Tunguska Airburst

• Shock waves felt 60 km away.
• 2200 km2 area of felled trees.
• No central crater, but stand of trees stripped of
  bark and leaves.

12
The Tunguska Epicenter
13
Tunguska Blast Site

• Butterfly pattern consistent with incidence
  angle of ?45º, airburst height of 10 km (Zotkin
  and Tsikulin, 1966 Korobeinikov et al., 1976)

14
Meteor Crater, Arizona

• 50,000 years old.
• 15 MT event.
• Iron asteroid.

15
15 MT Airburst Models
16
Airbursts
Tunguska, 1908
Once in 300 years
17
Small Terrestrial Impacts
Once in 10,000 years
Barringer Meteor Crater, 50,000 y
18
Large Terrestrial Impacts
Once in 100,000 years
Gosses Bluff, 143 My
19
Civilization-Ending Impacts
Vredefort, 1,970 My
Once in a million years
Manicouagan, 210 My
20
Extinction-Level Events
Once in a 100 million years
Chicxulub, 65 My
21
Spacewatch Telescopes
0.9 and 1.8 m telescopes discover 20 Near Earth
Asteroids/year
Spacewatch telescope, Kitt Peak, Arizona
1994 GK
1994 GL
1994 XM1
22
One thing Armageddon got right

• Mr. President, NASAs budget for hunting the sky
  for asteroids is only a million dollars a year
  and - excuse my language - its a real big-assed
  sky out there.
• NASAs Executive Director, Dan Truman
• (Billy Bob Thornton)
• Opening weekend grosses
• for Deep Impact 41.1 million
• for Armageddon 34.8 million

23
The Threat is Real

• In any year
• Probability of 1/100,000 of Earth being hit,
  without warning, by an undiscovered NEO 1 km in
  diameter.
• Probability of 1/1,000 to 1/100 of Earth being
  hit, without warning, by an undiscovered NEO 60
  m in diameter.
• These unknown NEOs currently pose a far greater
  risk than any known NEO.
• Rick Binzel, Ted Bowell, Clark Chapman, Paul
  Chodas, Paolo Farinella, Al Harris,
  Andrea Milani, David Morrison, Steve Ostro, Don
  Yeomans