Title: Dias nummer 1
1 Standardized case Record Concept and
Application Dr Anand Kapse, MD (Hom) Director,
Rural Homoeopathic Hospital, Palghar
2Evolution of Homoeopathic Philosophy
- Hahnemann
- Boenninghausen
- Kent
- Boger
- M L Dhawale
- Guru Shishya Parampara
3Dr.Samuel Hahnemann (1755 -18 43) The father of
Homoeopathy
4 Von Boenninghausen(1785 - 1864)The great
Generalist
5James Tyler Kent 1849 1916 The great Artist
A humble tribute to a teacher who opened fresh
vistas of clinical experience and knowledge
6DR. C. M. BOGER (1861 1935)
MASTER OF SYNTHESIS
A PHILOSOPHER-CLINICIAN
7Dr. M. L. Dhawale (1927 - 1987) A Born Teacher
Integration
Standardization
8Standardized Case Record (SCR)
Philosophy Practice
9Tri-coordinate Care The ICR way
10ACTION LEARNING
T
C ? A ? R
F
11SCR Integrated Approach
- Homoeopathic Philosophy
- Hahnemann
- Boenninghausen
- Kent
- Boger
- Clinical Knowledges
- Psychology/Psychiatry
- Indian Philosophy Geeta
12OBJECTIONS TO SCR
- Is it necessary to do all these complex things
for treating the patient with Homoeopathy? Do we
need all these knowledges for simple
prescriptions? - Where is the time?
- How can we take so much effort for one case?
- Why should we spend so much money on a case
record?
13Pursuit of Excellence Yogah Karmasu Kaushalam
- Costs of doing a thing
- Money
- Effort
- Time
- Costs of not doing a thing
- Destroy the finest instrument nature has evolved
after millions of years of experimentation The
Human Mind - Yukta as described in Geeta
- 1-6 Aphorisms of Organon
- Integrity as a way of life living
14Standardized Homoeopathic PracticePerceiving
the Totality consistently What it demands of a
Homoeopath?
- Sensitivity
- Empathy
- Capacity of resolution as well as discrimination
- Idealistic bent of mind
- Strong determination
- Disciplined mind
- Shun subjectivity steer towards objectivity
15Standardization of Individualization
- Objectivity implies standardization of response
to a stimulus - Mind as an instrument (Physician)
- Mind as an object of study (Patient)
- Sensitivity Controlled / Refined /
Sensitizations - Standards? Personal vs. Functional Fundamental
- Role of an Observer External / Internal
- Group Learning Case discussion
16SCR System Training of a Homoeopath
- Knowledge
- General
- Specific
- Skills
- Physical Examination
- Investigations
- IPD
- Attitude Care thru self dispersal not self
development
17Evolution of a Homoeopath
- Scientific
- Artistic
- Intuitive
18MODEL STEPS IN MANAGING A CASE THROUGH THE SCR
SYSTEM
19MODEL STEPS IN MANAGING A CASE THROUGH THE SCR
SYSTEM
20MEDICAL HISTORY FOR HOMOEOPATHIC
TREATMENTDirections for a written submission
- INTRODUCTION
- 1. For finding a correct homoeopathic remedy lot
of information with regard to the - (i) Complaints
- (a) Main as well as
- (b) Subsidiary and
- (ii) The person of the patient is
required. - 2. Incomplete information will make correct
choice difficult. You are therefore requested to
supply all information without keeping back
anything as irrelevant or of little importance.
The information you supply in the Note forms the
basis of further enquiry designed to assist you
in the further delineation of the problem. Full
co-operation therefore is requested. All
information supplied is, of course , strictly
confidential. - Since the enquiry can be time consuming process
and a lot of information is being collected we
require to record it systematically and at times
we may find it necessary to administer to you
further tests in which you are called upon to
write out further. To facilitate this we have
evolved a special procedure in which the
preliminary study is carried out by a physician
specially assigned to this job and when your Case
Record is ready we examine it to find out if it
is sufficient for instituting treatment or it
requires further detailed processing of
information and study of your case. If so we give
you a further suitable appointment for finalising
the line of treatment. - We are sure you be fully co-operating with us in
rendering you the best possible service.
21PRELIMINARY INFORMATION
- Please supply the following information as
standard routine - Name in full, Address, Date of Birth, Sex,
- Status (Single / Married / Widow-ed since /
Divorcee since), - Religion /Community/Sect, Vegetarian /
Non-vegetarian / Eggs, - Addictions, Tobacco, chewing/smoking, Tea,
Coffee, Beer, Whisky and liquors (please state
the quantity consumed daily ) - Educational career and qualifications.
- Occupation, current and previous with a full
description of responsibilities and job
satisfaction, address and tel. no. - Description of the current family set-up, full
description pertaining to all the members their
ages, location, work they are doing and your
relationship with responsibilities for them.
Include in your list those who have died stating
the age of death, the year and cause of the same. - Your daily routine from getting up in the morning
to retiring at night. Include in this your
dietary schedule furnishing full details in
respect of the quantities consumed. - Financial responsibilities and strains (present
as well as past). Difficulties experienced, Place
of work / Family set-up Social, give a full
account.
22CHIEF COMPLAINT
- Describe what bothers you most. Each trouble
should be detailed as under - 1. Full description of the trouble right from
the time of onset. Its subsequent development and
spread and response to treatments taken. This
should give full idea of - (i) Area affected location, extension, direction
of spread the march of events. - (ii) Sensation experienced in the area of
trouble. - (iii) Conditions that have brought on the
trouble examine the circumstance that obtained
just before or at the time of onset, paying
attention to physical as well as emotional
factors. - (iv) Conditions that increase the trouble or
those that afford relief. - (v) Other troubles experienced at the same time
along with the main trouble for example - .....perspiration/nausea/vomiting/gas
/with pains. - OTHER COMPLAINTS
- Describe here all other troubles you might be
having or have in the past experienced. - Each should be described fully as suggested above
for the 'CHIEF COMPLAINT'.
23PERSONAL DATA
- Give a full account of the following
- (1) Physical description of self
- (2) Emotional nature and intellectual
attainments and aspirations. Indicate to what
extent you have been able to realise them. Give a
clear cut picture of relationships with the
family members, friends and associations. Give a
full idea of your responsibilities in life and
what you feel about them. - (3) Reactions to surroundings.
- (a) Food desires and aversions, foods
that do not suit etc. - (b) General environment weather,
temperature, bath, recreations, addictions etc. - (c) Sleep and dreams
- (d) Sex ( inclusive of menstrual and
obstetric history ).
24- PREVIOUS ILLNESS
-
- Give a resume of the various illnesses you had
and to what extent these have any bearing on
present troubles. - FAMILY HISTORY
-
- Data concerning the parents, brothers and
sisters. State details concerning the health of
wife and children. - GENERAL COMMENTS
-
- Include here any items which have not been
included above. - ENCLOSURES
-
- 1. Medical Report and opinion on your
state of health from physician. - 2. Copies of Reports of investigations
done. - 3. X-ray plates, Electrocardiograms,
etc.
25SCR 10 MAIN DIVISIONS
- HISTORY PRESENT PAST
- PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
- PROVISIONAL DIAGNOSIS AND DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
- INVESTIGATION
- EVOLUTIONARY HAHNEMANNIAN TOTALITY
- ESSENTIAL EVOLUTIONARY TOTALTY
- REPERTORIAL TOTALITY
- PLANNING PROGRAMMING OF CASE
- THERAPEUTIC PROBLEM DEFINITION RESOLUTION
- CASE FOLLOW UP PROGRSS RECORD
26(No Transcript)
27III
C
D TO H
I
B
A
- EMOTIONAL
- INTELLECTUAL
- REACTIONS
- - EMOTIONS
- - INTELLECTUAL ACTIVITY
- - LIFE SITUATION
- ACTION
- - BEHAVIOUR
- - FUNCTIONING
II
APPEARANCE DIGESTION ELIMINATIONS MENSTRUAL
FUNCTION SEXUAL FUNCTION PREGNANCY, LABOUR,
PUERPERIUM DEVELOPMENT LANDMARKS PROBLEMS
- - PHYSICAL EXPRESSION
- ?
- MENTAL STATE
- INTERPRETATION
FIGURE 2 S C R M A J O R A R E A S
- P R E S E N T H I S T O R Y
28Chief Complaint Associated Complaints
29III PATIENT AS A PERSON
- PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS
- Appearance
- Digestion
- Eliminations
- Menstrual Function
- Sexual Function
- Pregnancy, Labour, Puerperium
- Developmental Landmarks Problems
- Diet Daily Routine
30B. MENTAL STATE
- 1. Emotional
- 2. Intellectual
- 3. Reactions
- - Emotions
- - Intellectual Activity
- - Life-Situation
- 4. Action
- - Speech
- - Behaviour
- - Functioning
- Sleep Dreams
- Diagnostic net
- Mental State Interpretation Psychodynamic
Psychosomatic
31- C REACTIONS PHYSICAL FACTORS
- TIME
- POSITION AND MOTION
- METEREOLOGICAL
- SENSORY INPUTS
- PHYSIOLOGICAL FUNCTIONS
- D FEVER TOTALITY
- E ORIGINAL UNMODIFIED PICTURE
- F CHRONOLOGICAL SEQUENCE
- PAST HISTORY PERSONAL/FAMILY
- PHYSICAL EXAMINATION
- PROVISIONAL CLINICAL DIAGNOSIS DIFFERENTIAL
DIAGNOSIS - INVESTIGATIONS
32PROCESSING OF THE CASE
- Classification of Symptoms
- Evolutionary Hahnemannian Totality (Page 74)
- Conceptual Image and Miasmatic Expression (Pages
75-83) - Essential Evolutionary Totality (Page 84-85)
- Repertorial Totality (Page 86-89)
- Remedy Correspondences and Selection (Page 90-93)
- Planning and Programming of Treatment (Page
94-99) - Therapeutic Problem Definition and Resolution
(Page 100-101)
33 LIST OF STANDARD NOTATIONS
- Aggr lt
- Amel gt
- Present
- Absent A
- Changeable C
- Decrease D
- Erratic E
- Fluctuating F
- Good G
- Increased I
- Same S
- lt Followed by Status Quo S
- gt Followed by Status Quo
- lt Followed by gt
- Abrupt disappearance of symptoms
34RECOMMENDED READINGS
-
- In order to operate successfully the SCR System,
the Homoeopathic physician will need to be fully
conversant with all the works of Hahnemann,
Boenninghausen, Hering, Kent, Close, Boger and
Roberts. - An efficient Research Worker will have read
all these in the original, inclusive of
translation and with full comprehension. Persons
with less time and energy at their disposal
should be in a position to have an effective
compromise by reading the following - Dhawale, M. L. Principles and Practice of
Homoeopathy Volume 1 Homoeopathic Philosophy and
Repertorization - 2. Dhawale, M.L. (Ed) I. C. R. Symposium Volume
Hahnemannian Totality
35Standardized Homoeopathic PracticeICR
Publications
36ICR PUBLICATIONS
37INSTITUTE OF CLINICAL RESEARCH PUBLICATIONS
- 1. Principles and Practice of Homoeopathy
Volume1 Homoeopathic Philosophy and
Repertorization - 2. I. C. R. Operational MANUAL
- 3. Life Living
- 4. I.C.R. Symposium Volume on Integrated
- Hahnemannian Totality
- 5. Perceiving - 1
- 6. Paediatrics In Homoeopathy An Approach
- 7. First I. C. R. Conference On Education Theme
- Action Learning
38I. C. R. EDUCATIONAL PRACTICE Series
- 1 Continued Homoeopathic Medical Education The
I.C.R. Approach - 2 Concept of Man and Homoeopathic Medical
Education - 3 Integrated Homoeopathic Practice
- 4 Standardized Case Record 1984
- 7 Perceiving Man I.C.R. Training Groups.
- 8 Correspondence Learning Program
- 9 Principles Practice of Professional
Competence The I. C. R. Way - 10 Professional Education Training
39PRINCIPLES PRACTICE OF HOMOEOPATHY PART I
HOMOEOPATHIC PHILOSOPHY REPERTORIZATION
- 1.A Unique, masterly, Scientific presentation of
Hahnemannian Homoeopathy as evolved by
Boenninghausen, Kent, Close, Boger, Tyler and
Roberts. - 2.Extensive presentation of Repertorization with
Case - Demonstrations. - 3.Presentation of Standardized homoeopathic
Practice with the S.C.R. System at the I.C.R. -
- 4.Effective Management of Structural Disorders
through better utilization of Potency-energy in
effecting restoration of co-ordinate balance
between Form, Function and Structure.
40PRINCIPLES PRACTICE OF HOMOEOPATHY PART I
HOMOEOPATHIC PHILOSOPHY REPERTORIZATION
- 5.Integral Presentation of Homoeopathic Medical
Education and Training as an expression of
Patient-Care, Learner-Care and Knowledge-Care. -
- 6.A Self-Study Evolutionary Learning System for
Principles and Practice of Homoeopathy when
combined with the other I.C.R. Publications. -
- 7.Experientially structured on the Philosophy and
Methodology evolving at the Homoeopathic
Post-Graduate Association (1952), Bombay
Homoeopathic Medical College (1968-70), National
Institute of Homoeopathy (Calcutta), Institute of
Clinical Research (1975-87) and Fr. Muller's
Homoeopathic Medical College, Mangalore
(1985-87). - Used in many Homoeopathic Colleges as essential
reading. -
41ICR OPERATIONAL MANUAL
- Essential companion for all learners wishing to
master the S.C.R. SYSTEM. Covers all the
operational aspects of SCR structure, function
all the methods employed at ICR during clinical
enquiry.
42ICR OPERATIONAL MANUAL
- THE THEME
- INTRODUCTION TO SCR SYSTEM
- THE "CASE" IN HOMOEOPATHIC PRACTICE PROBLEM -
DEFINITION PROBLEM-RESOLUTION - PROBLEM - DEFINTION, PROBLEM - RESOLUTION,
INTERVIEW - PLAN RENDERING IT OPERATIONAL - TRAINING OF THE UNPREJUDICED OBSERVER
- A. TRANSACTIONAL RECORD
- B. 5 COLUMN STRIP ANANLYSIS
- C. C.S.E.F.
- THE STANDARDISED CASE RECORD
- STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION
- RECORDING SECTION
- PROCESSING SECTION
- FOLLOW UP AND FOLLOW UP ANANLYSIS
43ICR OPERATIONAL MANUAL
- PSYCHOLOGICAL ABSRCTION TEST ("PAT" TEST)
- SPHP
- CCF CCE
- STANDARDISED INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE STUDY OF DATA
PERTAINING TO A PATIENT
44I.C.R. SYMPOSIUM VOLUME ON HAHNEMANNIAN
TOTALITY
- PART I
- Introduction
- Atlas Contains an excellent ATLAS of Charts on
Remedies and various aspects of Homoeopathy -
- PART II
- Area A- Philosophical Foundations
- Area B- Perceiving The Mental State
- Area C- Perceiving Miasmatic Evolution
-
45I.C.R. SYMPOSIUM VOLUME ON HAHNEMANNIAN
TOTALITY
- PART III
- Area D- Perceiving Scientific Method
Repertorization - PART IV
- Area E- Artificial Drug Disease Production
- Area F- Artificial Drug Disease Perceiving
-
- PART V
- Area G- Perceiving Practice Standardization of
Individualization - Area H-The Standardized Homoeopathic Physician
Perceiving Production
46I.C.R. SYMPOSIUM VOLUME ON HAHNEMANNIAN
TOTALITY
- The volume is a collection of Papers making a
significant original contribution to the theory
practice of Scientific Homoeopathy. The authors
speak from their rich clinical experience and
with utter conviction about what they are
expounding. -
- Collectively, all the Areas cover the entire
field by Homoeopathy its theory, practice and
education. Each area covers its own central theme
in depth, as well as establishing links with the
other areas.
47LIFE LIVING
- This remarkable book presents in a novel way the
heart of Dr. Dhawale's clinical experience. In
its first Section he presents the philosophy that
he evolved as a practicing Clinician rooted in
the Indian ethos. In the second Section he
presents 15 word-pictures of the conflicts facing
some of the remarkable people who came to him for
treatment. -
- Life Living is a unique system of Training in
Perceiving Man the Unknown. It assumes that Man
is Knowable provided we acquire the sight to read
his purpose, the inter-relationships he evolves
through the Roles in his areas of Work, Family
and Social life and the correlations he effects
to achieve integration. This understanding
permits us to design the Circumstance to which
the man will respond in a peculiar manner.
Systematic response-analysis delivers us the
evidence we need to support our estimates we now
know an aspect of the man which has been evading
us. Judicious expansion and intensification of
our Investigation reveals to us the Man, bit by
bit. This, provided we do not get disturbed by
the sights that resemble us too closely
48LIFE LIVING
- Awareness of our good selves, the book delivers.
Further, it trains us to evolve Sensitivity as
well as Sensibility essential for perceiving. -
- This is what Mr. Badri Narayan, a well-known
artist says about the book "The reflections on
life and living are perhaps attempts to
articulate a range of experience connected with
investigation and subsequent treatment of those
needing a return to a state of well-being in
totality for the art of healing is concerned
with action that makes men whole. The healthy
body and the sound mind are inter-acting forces.
49LIFE LIVING
- The book evolves a concept of a "Consulting
Physician" more comprehensive than the one
prevailing in present-day medical practice. The
present work is especially relevant in these days
of over-specialization in many disciplines its
goal is a balanced, pragmatic amalgam of mind,
spirit and matters that is, the search for the
transformation of the abject state brought about
by one's own endeavors at irresponsibility. We
are also made aware of the complex nature of
man's most prized tool - the mind - to help solve
his predicament. - The journey of life is both outgoing and
incoming simultaneously in figurative terms, to
the landscapes of exteriority and the pathways of
interiority. For, as James Joyce writes in the
Ulysses ".... every life is many days, day
after day. We walk through ourselves, meeting
robbers, ghosts, giants, old men, young men,
wives, widows, brothers-in-love. But always
mostly ourselves." -
50PERCEIVING - 1
- AREA A PERCEIVING TOTALITY
- AREA B PERCEIVING MAN
- AREA C PERCEIVING GROUPS
- AREA D PERCEIVING EDUCATION
- AREA E PERCEIVING PROFESSIONAL COMPETENCE
- AREA F PERCEIVING RESEARCH
- AREA G PERCEIVING MANAGEMENT
- AREA H PERCEIVING HOMOEOPATHIC MATERIA MEDICA
- AREA I PERCEIVING RURAL HEALTH
- AREA J PERCEIVING LIFE
51PERCEIVING - 1
Perceiving 1 is a collection of Papers and
Lectures, which represent some of Dr. Dhawales
unique insights. The Papers range over a wide
range in the field of Homoeopathic Practice,
Education and Research. Perceiving as a
phenomenon has three aspects 1. The object to be
perceived 2. The Instruments or the medium of
perceiving, and 3. The perceiver. All these
objects can and do influence the process and the
outcome profoundly. Optical illusions are a
result of a deviation or a manipulation in one of
the three. Purification of all three, on the
other hand, will result in an unusual clarity of
vision. That is perceiving at its best.
52PERCEIVING - 1
In the clinical setting, perceiving is the most
crucial process. Perceiving what troubles the
patient, perceiving the patient as a person,
perceiving the similimum perceiving
predominates. And who perceives? Perception is
done by the senses through the nerves. It is a
physiological process. Perceiving is done by the
self through the mind it is a psychological
process. What clouds the mind? What clarifies
it? What role does Hahnemanns Unprejudiced
Observer play in this process? How to train the
mind to perceive the patient truly
well? Perceiving 1 handles all these issues and
many others.
53PERCEIVING - 1
Homoeopathy treats the individual not the
disease. Clinical Research in Homoeopathy,
therefore, has to be based on quality and not
quantification as in other systems of medicine.
Dr. Dilip B. Dikshit in Mumbai worked out the
ideas that Dr. Dhawale was forever propounding,
in the case of Leprosy with phenomenal results.
This can be applied by any individual doctor in
his private clinic, too. The Papers in Area
FPerceiving Research speak of this and put
forward an operable system in this area.
54PERCEIVING - 1
What links the patient, the physician and the
remedy-portraits in the H.M.M. is the pain, the
suffering of the patient. Dr. Dhawale says,
H.M.M. is a pure record of pathos. The writings
in Area H Perceiving Homoeopathic Materia Medica
focus on the core issues in the perceiving and
application of the HMM. Indeed, these writings
have been the base on which clinicians the world
over have built the further edifice of all the
remedy pictures currently in vogue.
55PERCEIVING - 1
Dr. Dhawale believed, along with many other
professionals with a social conscience, that
physicians should make an extra effort to reach
our less fortunate brethren and help them through
our medical skills. He also presented that the
rural-tribal population is closer to Nature and
hence more responsive to Homoeopathy, which is a
natural system of medicine. Hence rural
health-care also enriches the participating
clinicians in the experience it affords. Area I
Perceiving Rural Health presents Dr. Dhawales
basic ideas in this area, along with the draft
outline of a whole system for rural-tribal
health-care. We are glad to let you know that we
follow in his footsteps in the rural-tribal belt
of Palghar-Manor near Mumbai.
56PERCEIVING - 1
The book is a must for a physician busy in his
consulting, the teacher professing the noble task
of influencing young minds in the right direction
that Homoeopathy entails and the clinical
research worker who is on the path to break new
ground in the treatment of a variety of
challenging clinical conditions
57PAEDIATRICS IN HOMOEOPATHY AN APPROACH
- A distillate of the Homoeopathic expertise of
Dr. Dilip Dikshit the Paediatric acumen of
Dr. Ramsubramanian -
- A result of 2 1/2 years of hard work by the team
of I.C.R. Physicians -
- Backed by results with Homoeopathic treatment
that has stood the tests of - Consistency
- Quality and quantity care
- Cost effectiveness.
-
- Path-finding, revolutionary therapeutic
strategies
58PAEDIATRICS IN HOMOEOPATHY AN APPROACH
- Protocols on the Homoeopathic management of
common Paediatric conditions like - Acute Diarrhoeal Disorders,
- Lower Respiratory Tract Infections,
- Fevers,
- Atopic Dermatitis Respiratory
Allergic Disorders, - Pertussoid Cough,
- Pain in abdomen, Evening Colic,
- Pyoderma etc.
-
- Explores the role of Homoeopathy in a surgical
condition like intussusception - Contains basic Paediatric Information
-
- Practice-oriented approach
- Invaluable for Homoeopaths, as more than 40 of
the practice is in Paediatrics - Useful for Practitioners, Teachers, Students,
Interns
59THE I.C.R.EDUCATIONAL PRACTICE SERIES 1 - 10
- The Institute of Clinical Research, Mumbai
(I.C.R.) was established in 1975 to bring about a
revolution in the conduct and teaching of
Homoeopathic Medical Practice, Education
Research. How was this revolution to be
initiated? Dr. M. L. Dhawale, the Founder -
Director, perceived the need for the student of
Homoeopathy to be thoroughly grounded in
Scientific Practice based firmly on the
principles enunciated in the Organon of Medicine
and subsequently elaborated by giants like
Boenninghausen, Kent, Boger, Roberts, Close etc.
60THE I.C.R.EDUCATIONAL PRACTICE SERIES 1 - 10
- At the same time, Dr. Dhawale was a man abreast
of the times. A master clinician himself, he was
aware of the rapid developments occurring in the
field of Clinical Medicine. An avid and inquiring
reader, he was fully conversant with the latest
advances in Educational philosophy and
methodology in general and pertaining to Medical
Education. He found himself in excellent company
when he discovered that the Case ----gtgt Concept
method he was teaching at the ICR in Mumbai was
the favored approach to Medical Education by the
Western Reserve University in North America.
61THE I.C.R.EDUCATIONAL PRACTICE SERIES 1 - 10
Dr. Dhawale thus devised a unique integration at
the ICR comprising of Traditional Homoeopathic
Philosophy, Modern clinical medicine and Advanced
Educational Philosophy Technology. It was clear
to him that the needed to put down the essentials
of this approach for the benefit of a) Those
who wished to acquaint themselves with what the
ICR stands for in Homoeopathic Medical Practice,
Education Research. b) Those who having
joined any of the ICR programs wish to seek a
direction they should adhere to in the course of
their study. c) Finally, those who conduct the
ICR program need to continually develop
themselves and supervise their students to
constantly push back the Frontiers of Knowledge'
so that they remain in the vanguard of change.