Annex E D2'4 Comment Resolution 2003Aug27 San Jose, CA

1
Annex E (D2.4) Comment Resolution2003Aug27San
Jose, CA
2
Annex E Comment Profile
3
Annex E CRG Resolution
4
Annex E Resolution Summary

• Comment 745 noted (perceived) text format
  idiosyncrasies found in section E.3 with rest of
  draft was withdrawn
• Text found in section E.3 of Annex E will be
  removed and moved to 802.1D specifications under
  802.17b project
• Comment 744 suggested removal of shall from
  section E.1.7 (RPR requirements for establishing
  conformance to 802.1D/Q)
• Comment accepted-modified
• Removal of shall from list of capabilities
  since the PICS refers to implementation/protocol
  testability.
• Annex E will be rendered shall-less.
  Consequently, it will become a normative clause
  with the PICS section removed

5
Annex E Resolution Summary

• Comment 741 requires chief editor to identify
  which text in the Overview clause (1.9) and
  Annex E (E.1.3, E.1.4) should be re-directed
  and/or removed
• Comments 754 and 755 deferred to WG to request
  guidance concerning the best representation of
  the logical bridging frame Tx and Rx requirements