Show Me the Data (SMTD) Priority Setting Chapter

1
Show Me the Data (SMTD)Priority Setting Chapter

• HIV Prevention Planning Council
• June 11, 2009

Presenters David Gonzalez and Steve Muchnick
2
Motion to Approve the Priority Setting Chapter

• The SMTD Committee moves that the HPPC approve
  the Priority Setting chapter for inclusion in the
  2010 San Francisco HIV Prevention Plan.

3
Chapter Purpose

• To outline the priority populations for HIV
  prevention funding in San Francisco based on
  local epidemiologic data.
• The chapter complements the Community Assessment
  chapter.
• The HPPC uses a blend of data analysis and
  community values to determine priorities, which
  are described throughout the chapter.

4
Details of HPPC Involvement

• December 2007
• HPPC approved moving from 8 BRPs to 5 BRPs
• HPPC approved the concept of the Priority Setting
  Considerations Box
• December 2008
• HPPC approved criteria for Drivers
• HPPC approved all BRPs except placement of
  Transmales who have sex with Males
• March 2009
• HPPC approved including Transmales who have sex
  with Males in BRP 1
• HPPC approved Resource Allocation Recommendations
• May 2009
• HPPC approved criteria for Subpopulations
  Cofactors
• HPPC approved guidelines for the Priority Setting
  Considerations Box

5
You Are Here
HPPC approved BRPs

• The chapter is the documentation of what the HPPC
  has already voted to approve.

HPPC approved criteria for drivers
HPPC approved resource allocation
recommendations
HPPC approved criteria for subpopulations and
cofactors
HPPC approved guidelines for Priority Setting
Considerations Box
HPPC votes on Priority Setting chapter
6
Section I The Current Model and Its History (pp.
2 4)

• Content
• Describes the evolution of the Priority Setting
  Model from 1995 to 2010.
• Provides an overview of the components of the
  Model, as well as its strengths and limitations.

7
Section II Priorities for 2010 (pp. 5 10)

• Content
• Provides an overview of priorities and how to
  interpret them.
• Describes the importance of Drivers and
  Prevention with Positives.
• Presents the entire Priority Setting Model.

8
Section III Background and Rationale (pp. 11
18)

• Content
• Outlines the six steps of the Model.
• Provides the background and rationale for each
  step in the Model.
• Shows the results when each step of the Model is
  applied.

9
Appendix 1 Changes to BRPs from 2004 to 2010 (p.
19)

• Content
• Provides detail on how the 2010 BRPs have changed
  from the 2004 BRPs.

10
Appendix 2 Process for Determining Drivers,
Subpopulations, and Cofactors (pp. 20 22)

• Content
• Provides detail on the committee process for
  identifying and prioritizing drivers,
  subpopulations, and cofactors.

11
Motion to Approve the Priority Setting Chapter

• The SMTD Committee moves that the HPPC approve
  the Priority Setting chapter for inclusion in the
  2010 San Francisco HIV Prevention Plan.

12
2009 SMTD Committee Members

• Pedro Arista (co-chair)
• Jackson Bowman
• Lauren Enteen
• Arcelia Gomez
• Isela Gonzalez
• David Gonzalez

• Yavante Thomas-Guess
• Steve Muchnick
• Tei Okamoto
• Tracey Packer
• Frank Strona (co-chair)
• Jose Gabriel Tungol

• HPS Staff Eileen Loughran, John Melichar, Erik
  Dubon
• HarderCompany Staff Willow Schrager