TG1 LB11 Comment Resolution Summary

1
Project IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless
Personal Area Networks (WPANs) Submission Title
Comment Resolution for D0.92 of 802.15.1 Draft
Standard Date Submitted 10 July
2001 Source Tom Siep Company Address
Voice(972) 496-0766, FAX ,
E-Mailtom.siep_at_ieee.org Re WPAN-802.15.1
LB11 Comment Resolution Results Abstract This
presentation represents the results of the
deliberations of the Ballot Resolution Committee
for comments received in Letter Ballot
11 Purpose Inform the WG Notice This
document has been prepared to assist the IEEE
P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion
and is not binding on the contributing
individual(s) or organization(s). The material in
this document is subject to change in form and
content after further study. The contributor(s)
reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw
material contained herein. Release The
contributor acknowledges and accepts that this
contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may
be made publicly available by P802.15.
2
LB11 Comment Resolution

• LB11 was a Recirculation Ballot
• The Recirculation Ballot Review process
  considers
• Changes made to the Draft D0.9.2 since the last
  ballot.
• The must to shall modification
• Minor editorial changes
• Unresolved negative comments from the previous
  ballot
• All comments were resolved in LB10. Resolutions
  were either
• Accepted
• Declined
• One voter was unsatisfied with the disposition of
  his comments, but a decline letter was sent and
  that resolved the outstanding comments

3
LB 11 Comment Analysis

• 13 New comments
• 3 Carried forward from LB10
• 44 Carried forward from LB8
• No comments on changes made from LB10 to LB11
  were made

4
Consideration of LB11 Comments

• The BRC considered all comments lodged against
  the draft
• 48 were editorial and would not prevent the
  proper implementation of interoperable systems
• 12 were technical but have been considered and
  declined before
• All declines were re-considered and previous
  decisions were confirmed
• There were no new never-before-seen technical
  comments

5
Going Forward

• MOTION The Working Group instructs the Chair of
  802.15 to submit Draft D0.9.2 to the SEC for
  review to forward the Draft to Sponsor Ballot.
• Moved Tom Siep
• Second Michael Camp
• Vote
• For
• Against
• Abstain
• NOTE All comments from LB10 that were declined
  and not withdrawn will be forwarded with the
  draft in document 01310r4aP802-15_WG-LB11-Comment
  -Form.pdf