Title: The Neurologic Complications of HIV
1The Neurologic Complications of HIV
- Stephen Raffanti MD
- Comprehensive Care Center
- Vanderbilt University
- Presentation Prepared for VU Infectious Diseases
Fellows - Fall 2002
2Overview
- Epidemiology of Neurologic Disease
- Neuropathogenesis
- Clinical Manifestations
- Opportunistic Infections
- CNS Lymphoma
- Progressive motor syndromes
- Peripheral Neuropathy
- AIDS Dementia Complex
3EPIDEMIOLOGY
- Pre-HAART era revealed high incidence of
neurological disease 7-20 of initial AIDS
diagnoses, 39-70 prevalence in HIV/AIDS, gt70
in post mortem studies. - HAART era shows expected decrease in incidence
rates of neurologic OIs, CNS lymphoma and AIDS
Dementia Complex (ADC) (which may be occurring at
higher CD4 counts).
4Risk of Neurologic Disease in At-Risk Patients
- Condition Incidence
- PML 4
- Toxoplasmic Encephalitis 5-15
- Cryptococcal Meningitis 6-10
- CNS Lymphoma 7-10
- CMV encephal./radiculopathy 20-40 post
- AIDS Dementia Complex 15-30
- Distal Symmetric Peripheral gt30
- Neuropathy
- What is not known is how prolonged treatment with
or without immune response will affect the
incidence and manifestations of these diseases.
5Neuropathogenesis
- HIV is neurovirulent but not neurotropic
- Virus cannot productively infect primary neuronal
cell cultures - In situ hybridization doe not show significant
amount of free virus in brain tissue. - HIV can productively infect monocytes,
macrophages and possibly some glial cells - In acute infection meningial macrophages are
most involved - In later disease perivascular macrophages and
microglial cells predominate. - Infection results in a cascade of toxic
mediators - Cytokines, arachidonic acid derivatives, IFN,
interleukins and gp120 are all associated with
virus induced inflammation.
6Neuropathology
- Neuronal injury occurs as a result of
inflammatory process. - In the brain reactive astrogliosis, myelin
pallor, neuronal loss, alterations of dendritic
processes with most severe damage seen in the
deep gray matter (atrophy). - In the peripheral neuron degeneration of axons,
endoneurial perivascular inflammation (Distal
Symmetric Peripheral Neuropathy) or perivascular
inflammation with macrophage mediated segmental
demyelination (Inflammatory Demyelinating
Neuropathy).
7Clinical Manifestations
- Opportunistic infections
- Four most common account for over 90 of
clinically significant CNS infections
Cryptococcal meningitis, Progressive Multifocal
Leukoencephalopathy (PML), Toxoplasmic
encephalitis (TE), CMV encephalitis/radiculopathy.
- All four occur at patients identified at risk.
- All four have decreased incidence in HAART
responders. - All four may have a different long term course
with concurrent successful HAART.
8Clinical Case 1
- 43 year old bakery truck driver, CD4 88
cells/mm3, VL 16,900 copies/ml, presents with
headache, fever, nausea and some general malaise
of three weeks duration. Course has been waxing
and waning. Yesterday he felt relatively well. - PE shows uncomfortable patient, no focal
findings. T100.2.
9Clinical Case 1
- CT of head with/without contrast negative.
- LP yields OP of 220 mm H2O, WBC of 4 cells/mm3,
glucose 68 (80) mg/dl, protein 45 mg/dl and
positive india ink prep. - Serum reveals cryptococcal antigen 1256.
10Clinical Case 1
- How uncommon is the duration of his complaints?
The waxing and waning? - What predictors of a poor outcome does this case
have? Of a good outcome? - How common is the lack of classic meningial
signs? - Is it likely that an MRI would have been
abnormal? If so, would it have changed your
work-up?
11Cryptococcal Meningitis
- C. neoformans is an encapsulated yeast, inhaled
into the small airways where it usually causes
sub-clinical disease dissemination to the CNS is
not related to pulmonary response. - C. neoformans produces no toxins and evokes
little inflammatory response. The main virulence
factor is the capsule.
12Cryptococcal Meningitis
- Clinical manifestations
- headache (70-90), fever (60-80), malaise (76),
stiff neck (20-30), photophobia (6-18),
seizures (5-10) nausea. - Average duration of symptoms is 30 days.
- Predictors of poor outcomes are altered mental
status, increased opening pressure, WBClt20
cells/mm3. - Diagnosis made by CSF examination with india ink
(74-88), Crypto Ag serum/CSF (99), CSF culture.
- Level of Crypto Ag is not indicative of severity
of disease or a marker of response to therapy.
Serum Crypto Ag can rule out clinical disease in
HIV positive but not negative patients.
13Cryptococcal Meningitis
- Therapy
- Acute Ampho B (0.7-0.8 mg/kg/d) for 14 days with
or without 5-FC 25 mg/kg QID, then Fluconazole
400 mg/d for 8-10 weeks. - Maintenance Fluconazole 200 mg/d. D/C with
immune reconstitution (?). - Repeated lumbar puncture for OP gt 250 mm.
- Alternatives with liposomal preparations.
- No controlled trials on stopping maintenance in
the setting of immune reconstitution.
14Case 1
- Patient was started on Ampho 5-FU. Received
total dose of 1 gram ampho, 1 week 5-FU. LP
performed three times to relieve pressure. Pt
started on fluconazole 400 mg/day. - Currently on dual PI-based salvage therapy. 4
years out from Crypto. VL 3,435 copies/ml, CD4
468 cells/mm3. Remains on fluconazole. - No further relapses of cryptococcus.
15Clinical Case 2
- 31 year old dental hygienist brought to ED with
new onset seizures. CD4 122 cells/mm3, VL 22,000
copies/ml. Family reports 10 days of increasing
fever, some obtundation, social withdrawal. - PE reveals post-ictal, febrile female with poor
dentition, questionable LUE weakness.
16Clinical Case 2
- MRI of head shows multiple ring-enhancing lesions
in the right basal ganglia and cortico medullary
junction. - Toxoplasma IgG serology is positive.
- Patient recovers somewhat in ED with marked LUE
weakness, slow mentation.
17Clinical Case 2
- Is the diagnosis made? Would other studies be
appropriate? - Is Toxo IgM likely to be positive?
- Would a CT have been as sensitive as an MRI to
pick up the lesions? - Is a PET scan warranted?
- Is a brain biopsy warranted?
18Toxoplasmic Encephalitis
- T. gondii is a ubiquitous intracelluar protozoan,
definitive host is the cat (millions of oocysts
are excreted daily in cat feces during acute
infestation!). AIDS pts can become infested
either through direct contact with cat feces or
ingesting tissue cysts in undercooked meat. - Clinical disease is reactivation disease 30 of
AIDS patients with baseline serology will
develop TE if not given prophylaxis. - Seroprevalence varies greatly nationally and
internationally (10-40 US, gt70 France,
developing countries) - Most clinical disease occurs at below 100 CD4
cells /mm3 but 20 in 100-200 cell range. - Pathology ranges from localized granulomatous
process to diffuse necrotizing encephalitis.
19Toxoplasmic Encephalitis
- Clinical presentation includes focal neurologic
deficit (50-89), seizures (15-20), fever (56),
generalized cerebral dysfunction,
neuropsychiatric abnormalities. - Diagnosis is often presumptive based on
characteristic lesions, clinical course, risk
strata and positive serology. - Presumptive diagnosis is considered confirmed by
tissue sample or response to TOXO therapy in
appropriate time frame. - Patients should show clinical response -- neuro
deficits, not necessarily fever or headache -- by
day 5 (50), day 7 (70), and day 14 (90). In
contrast, patients with CNS lymphoma all had
worsening of signs or symptoms by day 10 of
therapy.
20Toxoplasmic Encephalitis
- Treatment (for at least 6 weeks, 80-90
response) - Acute Sulfadiazine (4-8 gm/d) or Clindamycin
(600 mg q6h) - Plus
- Pyrimethamine (100-200 mg load then 50-75mg/d)
with folinic acid (10-20 mg/d) - Less proven regimens macrolides (azithromycin,
clarithromycin) or atovaquone (750 mg QID) plus
pyrimeth and folinic acid - Maintenance Without maintenance therapy relapse
rate is 50-70 per year. Maintenance dose is
lower for sulfadiazine therapy, same dose for
clindamycin - Maintenance therapy may be discontinued if on
HAART with CD4gt200 x 3mos for primary and gt6 mos
for secondary prophylaxis.
21Case 2
- Patient initially treated empirically for
toxoplasmic and bacterial encephalitis with sulfa
and levofloxacin. GI intolerance hampers
treatment. Undergoes biopsy which confirms
diagnosis of toxoplasmosis. Patient responds to
clindamycin-based therapy. - Starts on HAART and responds clinically,
virologically, and immunologically. Patient
gains weight, well-being and is rechallenged with
sulfa which she tolerates. Remains well on
maintenance therapy and HAART.
22Case 3
- 33 year old unemployed substance abusing male is
brought to the ED after he was found wandering
near the mission. - PE reveals cachectic, obtunded male with
dysarthria. T 100.4, CD4 14 cells/mm3, VL
648,000 copies/ml.
23Case 3
- MRI shows single 4 cm enhancing lesion involving
the corpus callosum. No peri-lesional edema is
present, no mass effect. - Patient is stable but obtunded.
- Lumbar puncture is performed.
24Case 3
- What studies would you perform on the CSF?
- Could a definitive diagnosis be made without
brain biopsy?
25Primary CNS Lymphoma
- B-cell malignancies, high-grade (73).
- Occurs in extremely immunocompromised hosts (CD4
lt 50 cells/mm3), unlike systemic NHL. - Common signs include focal neuro deficits
(38-78), altered sensorium (57), seizures
(21), cranial nerve defects (13). - 50 of patients will have single lesions, usually
in the the gray matter. Toxo lesions are usually
multiple, smaller and associated with basal
ganglia but the two entities cannot be
distinguished by imaging alone.
26Primary CNS Lymphoma
- Diagnosis is based on clinical presentation,
neuroimaging, CSF studies, and brain biopsy. - CSF PCR for EBV is sensitive (66-99) and
specific (60-99). - Treatment is radiation /- chemotherapy.
- Response is related to stage of disease and
control of HIV.
27Case 3
- Toxo serology negative. PCR for EBV negative.
PET scan hypermetabolic. Neurosurgery confirms
that lesion is not accessible. Patient does not
respond to empiric therapy for toxoplasmic and
bacterial encephalitis. - Patient becomes more obtunded. Family refuses
further work-up or treatment. - Patient is enrolled in Hospice where he dies 2
weeks later
28Case 4
- 42 year old mechanic is seen in clinic
complaining of left side weakness and visual
disturbance. CD4 98 cells/mm3, VL 234,000. - PE shows a somewhat slow speaking man, afebrile,
with left upper and lower extremity weakness and
homonymous hemianopsia. Disc margins are crisp.
29Case 4
- MRI of the head shows diffuse white matter
lesions affecting subcortical area bilaterally.
Parietal-occipital disease is noted on the left
side. No enhancement is seen no mass effect. - CSF shows normal opening pressure, a protein of
50 mg, glucose of 82, WBC 6.
30Case 4
- What other test(s) would you order on the CSF?
- How typical was this presentation for PML?
31Progressive Multifocal Leukoencephalopathy (PML)
- PML is a demyelinating disease of the central
nervous system caused by infection of
oligodendrocytes by JCV, a papovavirus. - JCV does not infect neurons but has been detected
in urogenital cells, B lymphocytes in the spleen
and bone marrow, and in peripheral blood
lymphocytes. - By age ten, 40-60 of the population have
antibodies to JCV. Disease occurs only in the
severely immunocompromised. Acute disease has
not been documented. - Pathology shows multifocal demyelination with
hyperchromatic enlarged oligodendroglial nuclei
and enlarged bizarre astrocytes. - Lesions can occur anywhere but typically are
found in the white matter, most often in the
parietal-occipital regions. The gray matter may
be involved as well as the cerebellum, brainstem
and rarely spinal cord.
32Progressive Multifocal Leukoencephalopathy (PML)
- Clinical disease occurs in patients with advanced
disease and onset may be insidious, over several
weeks. - Clinical signs and symptoms include hemiparesis
(43), cognitive defects (22), speech deficits
(28),visual deficits (16), sensory deficits
(14), and seizures (5). - Clinical hallmark of disease is patient with
focal neurologic defect, white matter disease and
no mass effect.
33Progressive Multifocal Leukoencephalopathy (PML)
- Diagnosis rests on clinical picture, neuro
radiologic findings, CSF findings and tissue
histopathology. - PCR for JCV in the CSF is a specific but variably
sensitive technique for supporting diagnosis.
Sensitivity ranges from 30-61, specificity 99. - Distinguishing PML from ADC may be difficult, but
more rapid onset, lack of cognitive dementia
findings (slow mental processing), focal
neurologic deficits and extensive subcortical
disease suggest PML. - Treatment efforts have been largely unsuccessful.
HAART may be beneficial. Ongoing trials
evaluating cytosine arabinoside (ARA-C) are
enrolling patients. Scattered reports have
suggested some response. Approximately 7 of
patients resolve without any treatment these
patients generally have less compromised immune
status.
34PET/SPECT SCANS and CNS Lesions in AIDS
- 20 patients with AIDS and contrast enhancing
lesions 7/8 Toxo pts. had PET scans, 7 had
hypometabolic lesions. 6 pts. with lymphoma had
hypermetabolic scans. 7 patients had varied
results (Pierce 1995). - SPECT scans in 37 AIDS patients with intracranial
lesions 12 had increased intense focal uptake
all twelve had Bx proven lymphoma. 25 had no
uptake 24 had TOXO by clinical , one had MTB
abscess (Ruiz 1996). - 24 patients with AIDS and CNS mass lesions by
MRI were evaluated with SPECT. 8 had lymphoma
and all had scans, 7/10 Toxo pts had negative
scans. 1 pt. with Blasto and 3 with PML had
negative scans. MTB had /- scan. (Barker 1997)
35Brain Biopsy in CNS Lesions in AIDS
- Brain biopsy should be considered
- In presumptive TE when empiric therapy fails
- In rapidly progressing single lesion disease
- In patients with a clinical picture of TE but a
reliable history of sulfa-based PCP prophylaxis - In patients receiving corticosteroid therapy.
- In patients with unexplained potentially
treatable lesions. - Other pathogens/conditions to be considered
lymphoma, bacterial including T. pallidum, BA,
PML, MTB.
36Case 4
- LP is performed twice, PCR for EBV is negative x
2, PCR for JCV is positive in one lab negative in
other. - Brian biopsy reveals findings consistent with
PML. - Patient is started on new ART regimen with mother
administering meds. Neurological deterioration
slows. Patient plateaus at near total care
status. CD4 increase to 338 cells/mm3, VL lt400
copies/ml.
37Case 5
- 41 year old artist from Kentucky presents with
rapidly progressing bilateral lower extremity
weakness, urinary retention and lower back pain.
CD4 33 cells/mm3. - PE shows wasted male c/o back pain, flaccid
paralysis of both legs, saddle anesthesia,
DTRs in both legs are absent.
38Case 5
- What characteristics of this presentation suggest
that something relatively rare is occurring? - What diseases are included in the differential?
- What is your next few studies and how rapidly
should they be done?
39Case 5
- Contrasted MRI of the spine shows diffuse
enhancement of the cauda equina and the conus and
clumping of nerve roots (ice storm sign). - CSF reveals 14,000 WBC, 90 PMN, glucose 34mg/dl,
protein 240 mg/dl. - Retinal examination shows findings c/w CMV
retinitis. - PCR studies are not available.
40Progressive Motor Syndromes in HIV
- CMV polyradiculomyelitis is a rare (lt2) disease
presenting in patients with advanced AIDS as
rapidly progressive flaccid paralysis of lower
extremities which includes back pain,
urinary/fecal retention, sensory abnormalities. - Diagnosis is based on clinical features,
characteristic CSF and MRI findings and evidence
of CMV disease (retinal, PCR in blood or CSF). - Most patients were described in the pre-HAART era
and survival was poor, with variable response to
therapy. - Although there are no large controlled studies,
scattered reports indicate that treatment with
ganciclovir plus foscarnet may be superior to one
agent alone.
41Progressive Motor Syndromes in HIV
- Inflammatory Demyelinating Neuropathy (IDP) can
present very early in disease as AIDP (Acute
IDP), with rapid progressive involvement of
muscles of two or more limbs. Sensory
involvement may precede motor. Course may
resemble GBS. - Chronic IDP (CIDP) is a slower progressive,
principally motor, syndrome of the lower
extremities which may have relapsing course over
several months. - Nerve conduction study (NCS) shows slow nerve
conduction velocities and findings c/w primary
demyelination. Some axonal degeneration may be
present. AIDP findings may be less pronounced.
Sural nerve bx results show perineural edema,
perivascular infiltrates and macrophage mediated
segmental demyelination. CMV inclusion in
Schwann cells have been identified in late stage
CIDP. - Treatment options include plasmapheresis, IV Ig,
prednisone which have all shown efficacy but are
often of temporary benefit. Up to 15 of
patients will resolve without specific therapy.
42Progressive Motor Syndromes in HIV
- HIV associated myelopathy is a rare (lt4)
manifestation of advanced disease which presents
with leg stiffness, falling, and slowness of gait
and slowly progresses to bowel/bladder
dysfunction, paraplegia. - Hyperreflexia and spasticity are common.
- Imaging and CSF are normal except for mildly
elevated protein. - Pathology shows vacuolar myelopathy with little
inflammation. - Treatment is supportive and rehabilitative.
43Progressive Motor Syndromes in HIV
- Other causes of motor weakness include
- Cord lesions caused by infectious/neoplastic
processes are usually more fulminant, have
discrete sensory levels, include back pain, may
involve thoracic or cervical spine and should
have imaging or CSF findings c/w diagnosis. - Patients from endemic areas should be tested for
HTLV-I co-infection. - Rarely, mononeuritis multiplex may present as
motor weakness.
44Case 5
- Patient is hospitalized and ganciclovir induction
therapy is started. Severe cytopenia results and
patient is switched to foscarnet. Neurologic
decline rapidly progresses to paraplegia and
coma. - Patient expires 8 days later.
- Autopsy is refused.
45Case 6
- 38 year old real estate agent presents
complaining of numbness, tingling and pain in the
feet and lower legs progressing over several
months. - CD4 424, VLlt400, medications include stavudine,
didanosine, and nelfinavir. - PE shows relatively well male, motor strength
intact, normal light touch perception and
vibration. Gait normal.
46Case 6
- What other questions would you ask about the
pain? What other physical sign might you
illicit? - What is the differential for the pain in the
lower extremities? - What factors are favoring neuropathy?
- What factors argue against Distal Symmetrical
Peripheral Neuropathy (DSPN)? - What other tests would you order?
47Case 6
- Patient describes pain as burning, starting at
the soles and involving the dorsum of both feet.
Walking is impaired at times due to pain. He has
not bumped into walls or fallen down. - Achilles DTRs are absent. Patellar reflexes are
intact. Babinski is absent. Proprioception is
intact. - Serum B12 normal, RPR non-reactive.
- EMG/NCS shows mild axonal degeneration. No
evidence of demyelination.
48Peripheral Neuropathy
- Two most frequent types DSPN and toxic
neuropathy. - Clinical manifestations are similar. Both
present with sensory symptomatolgy with little
sensory dysfunction. Both usually involve the
lower extremities, show absent Achilles DTRs and
axonal degeneration on NCS. Patients can have
negative NCS/EMG and abnormal findings on skin
biopsy and examination of epidermal nerve fibers.
Differentiating between the two syndromes is
based on history and concurrent meds.
49Peripheral Neuropathy
- DSPN is a frequent (30) complication of advanced
HIV. Course is gradually progressive and may be
severe enough to disable patient. Factors
associated with DSPN include low CD4 count, high
viral load, concurrent ADC. - Toxic neuropathy is associated with
antiretrovirals and other medications. Factors
associated with toxic neuropathy include length
of time on neurotoxic medications, pre-existing
neuropathic syndrome, concurrent administration
of multiple neurotoxic agents. - Both syndromes are now thought to be part of a
mitochondrial toxicity phenomenon.
50Peripheral Neuropathy
- Medications which cause neuropathy include
zalcitabinegtdidanosinegtstavudine, metronidazole,
INH, vincristine, dapsone. - Treatment options include
- d/c of offending agents (sx may worsen
initially), - Treatment with amitriptyline, mexilitine,
carbamazepine, and gabapentin, narcotics,
acupuncture. Randomized trials have demonstrated
efficacy for lamotrigine and human nerve growth
factor.
51Case 6
- Patients HAART is switched to zidovudine/lamivudi
ne/ abacavir plus nevirapine. Symptoms worsen
and patient is started on amitriptyline titrated
to 150 mg qd. Patient has minimal improvement
and is switched to gabapentin which he does not
tolerate. Patient remains on current HAART with
VLlt400 copies/ml, CD4 544 cells/mm3. - Neuropathic pain is currently managed with
amitriptyline 100 mg/day and short acting
narcotics for exacerbation. Patient also uses
shoe inserts.
52Case 7
- 64 year old owner of a construction company is
seen for first visit after being hospitalized for
PCP. He was diagnosed with HIV disease during
this hospitalization. His wife and children
state that although he had been doing fine
until he got sick with pneumonia he isnt as
perky as he used to be. - CD4 18 cells/mm3, VL gt750k.
53Case 7
- What questions would you ask to get a sense of
how well his CNS is functioning? - What findings on physical exam would you pay
special attention to? - If physical exam has no focal findings what other
tests would be warranted?
54Case 7
- PE reveals a quiet thin man who lets his wife
answer most questions. His only complaint is
soreness at a prior IV site. - Neuro exam shows no focal defects except for
absent Achilles reflexes, hyperreflexia
elsewhere. Fundoscopic exam reveals one cotton
wool spot O.D. - Pt is alert but apathetic, short term memory is
greatly impaired, response time is slow, fine
motor is impaired, gait is awkward with postural
difficulty. Rhomberg is negative, cerebellar
signs are not apparent, slow pursuit eye movement
is impaired.
55AIDS Dementia Complex (ADC)
- Extremely common (30) complication of advanced
disease. - Characterized by cognitive, motor and behavioral
changes. - Spectrum ranges from early mild forgetfulness to
global amnesia. - Signs of progressive dementia are not present in
early asymptomatic individuals.
56AIDS Dementia Complex
- EARLY LATE
- Cognition
- Inattention Global Dementia
- Reduced Concentration
- Forgetfulness
- Motor
- Slow fine repetitive Paraplegia
- Clumsiness
- Ataxia
- Behavior
- Apathy Mutism
- Altered personality
- (agitation)
57AIDS Dementia Complex
- CT and MRI typically show cerebral atrophy,
widened cortical sulci and enlarged ventricles. - CSF not specific, CSF HIV viral load may
correlate but high levels also found in pts
without ADC. - Differential includes CMV encephalitis, diffuse
presentations of lymphoma, toxoplasmic
encephalitis and psychosis. - Treatment is aggressive treatment of underlying
HIV, possibly with more CSF penetrating regimens
(no controlled trials supporting this). Response
to treatment should be rapid and lack of response
should warrant re-evaluating diagnosis.
58CMV Encephalitis
- Rare complication of very advanced HIV disease.
- Differs from ADC by steep slope of neurologic
decline. May include fever, delirium, somnolence
and cranial nerve involvement. - Imaging may reveal meningeal and periventricular
enhancement. - Concurrent evidence of CMV disease may be helpful
in making diagnosis. - Course is rapidly fatal if not treated.
59Case 7
- MRI shows cortical atrophy, no enhancement.
Ophthalmologic evaluation confirms cotton wool
retinopathy only. - Patient is started on zidovudine, lamivudine, and
nevirapine. At 4 week follow up patient has
gained 21 pounds, is outgoing, and gait has
improved. Viral load is 4,228.
60Neurologic Disease in HIV
- Few common syndromes account for majority of
manifestations. - A targeted history and physical examination
usually points to etiology or direction of
work-up. - Mild to moderate dementia is often missed by
superficial exam. - Few presentations require emergent work-up
- Post-HAART neurologic disease may present
differently and have different markers of risk
(nadir CD4 count, peak viral load, host factors). - Non-HIV related neurologic disease will become
more important with aging, treated population.