Title: Relating Ethnicity and Culture to Healthcare Marketing
1Relating Ethnicity and Culture to Healthcare
Marketing
2Pamela L. SchneiderSenior VP, Client Services
DirectorRick Johnson Company, Inc.
3Our Agency Has a Plethora of Healthcare Experience
- Integrated Health Systems
- Hospitals
- Managed Care
- Physician Specialty Groups
- Clinics and Solo Practitioners
- Recruitment and Retention
- Community Healthcare Leadership
- The list goes on
4(No Transcript)
5 Lets Begin Today by Discussing Some
Statistics
6Percent of Persons Who Are American Indian and
Alaskan Native by County in New Mexico
36.9 to 74.7 Includes San Juan, McKinley and
Cibola Counties
10.9 16.3 Includes Rio Arriba, Sandoval and
Socorro Counties
Source United States Census Bureau Data
www.census.gov
NOTE Bernalillo County 13.5 of NM NA pop. or
23,623
7Percent of Persons who are Hispanic or Latino by
County in New Mexico
72.9 81.6 Includes Rio Arriba, Mora, San
Miguel and Gaudalupe Counties
44.9 63.4 Includes Taos, Colfax, Harding,
Santa Fe, Valencia and Socorro as well as Grant,
Hidalgo, Luna and Dona Ana Counties
Source United States Census Bureau Data
www.census.gov
Note Bernalillo County is 30.4 of NM Pop. or
236,285
8Percent of Persons who are Anglo in New Mexico by
County
Source United States Census Bureau Data
www.census.gov
9U.S. Census Data on Nativity and Language
Proficiency in New Mexico
Source United States Census Bureau Data
www.census.gov
10U.S. Census Data on Nativity and Language
Proficiency in New Mexico
Source United States Census Bureau Data
www.census.gov
11Other Population Statistics Census Bureau
1210 LEADING CAUSES OF DEATH IN THE AMERICAN INDIAN
Source The Center for Disease Control Website
www.webapp.cdc.gov
1310 LEADING CAUSES OF DEATH IN THE HISPANIC
POPULATION
Source The Center for Disease Control Website
www.webapp.cdc.gov
14Our DMA is One of the Top 15 Hispanic Markets in
the Country
Market /TV Households Hispanic Rank Los
Angeles 30 (1,585,390) 1 New York 15
(1,100,030) 2 Miami-Ft. Lauderdale 37
(550,190) 3 Houston 22 (399,220) 4 Chicag
o 12 (384,140) 5 Dallas-Ft. Worth 15
(324,120) 6 San Antonio 44
(317,810) 7 San Francisco Oak- SJ 13
(317,200) 8 Phoenix 16 (246,160) 9 Harl-W
slco-Brns-Mca 81 (232,270)
10 Albuquerque-Santa Fe 33 (206,710)
11
Source 2003 Nielsen Universe Estimates
15Approximately 38 of the DMA Population is
Hispanic
Total DMA Population 1,597,000 Hispanic
Percentage 38 Hispanic Population
602,000 Non-Hispanic Percentage 62 Non-Hispanic
Population 995,000
Source 2003 Nielsen Universe Estimates
16Hispanics Growing Twice as Fast as Non-Hispanics
A Rapidly Growing Population 1990 2000
Change Hispanic 579,224 785,386
32 Non-Hispanic 935,845 1,053,660 13
Source 1990 and 2000 Census (New Mexico state
population
17More Than Four Out of Five Hispanic Households
Speak Spanish
Speak Spanish 82 Speak English Only 18
Source 2003 Nielsen Universe Estimates
18More Than Four Out of Five Hispanic Households
Speak Spanish
- Conveying your message to your target audience
is accomplished most effectively in their
language of comfort. - The language of comfort is the language spoken
at home. - Spanish-language dominant Hispanics think and
feel in Spanish.
Source 2003 Nielsen Universe Estimates
19But Its More than Just Spanish
ñ
20Its About Reaching Them with Relevance
- Its necessary to connect with target consumers
- Emotionally
- Rationally
- Intellectually
- Culturally
- To connect in these ways, you must know about
their level of acculturation
21Acculturation, Not Assimilation
- Assimilation
- A group leaves culture and customs behind and
adopts culture and customs of another group - Acculturation
- A group adopts or borrows customs and traits from
another culture
22Acculturation is Defined as
- Change resulting from contact between cultures
- The process by which people adopt or borrow
customs and traits from another culture - A merging of cultures as a result of prolonged
contact - Mutual influence of different cultures in close
contact
Source Acculturation Microsoft Encarta Online
Encyclopedia 2000 Strategy Research Corp. Webster
New World Dictionary, Third College Edition
23Key Indicators of Acculturation
24Latino Acculturation Values (L.A.V.s.)
UNACCULTURATED
ACCULTURATED
Success Family/group satisfaction
Success Personal Achievement
Obedience/ attached to traditions
Class distinction/ authority
Freedom/ open to change
Equality
Collectivism
Individualism
Avoidance of direct confrontation
Assertiveness/ aggressiveness
Cooperation/ respect
Competition
Control over destiny
Fatalism
25Latino Acculturation Stratification
UNACCULTURATED
ACCULTURATED
CROSSCULTURER
CULTURAL LOYALIST
CULTURALINTEGRATORS
CULTURAL EMBRACER
(TM)
-
- Foreign Born
- Resident
- Spanish
- Preferred
- Professional
- Aspirational
- U.S. Born
- 2nd, 3rd Generation
- English
- Preferred
- Latino Proud
- Retro-acculturation
- Influential
- Foreign Born
- Recent arrival
- Spanish
- dependent
-
- Traditional values
- U.S. Born
- First generation
- Bilingual
- Bicultural
- Professional
- Fashion-forward
- In touch with roots
26Acculturation Nationally Among Hispanic Adults 18
Source Strategy Research Corp.
27Albuquerque is Highly Acculturated Market
- Top 3 Most Acculturated Markets in U.S.
- San Antonio
- Albuquerque
- San Francisco
28Acculturation Among HA 18 - Albuquerque
Source Strategy Research Corp.
Source Strategic Research Corp. 2002
29Factors Influencing Acculturation
- Employment
- Length of Residency in U.S.
- Language Use/Preference (home and work)
- Birthplace of Parents
- Education
- Generation U.S. Born (1st, 2nd, 3rd, etc)
- Media Preferences (Spanish or English)
- Values and Attitudes
30Research Shows
- Advertising to Hispanics in English is not as
effective as speaking to them in Spanish - Spanish language commercials have better ad
recall. (61) - Hispanics have better comprehension of
Spanish-language commercials (57). - Spanish commercials are 4.5 times more
influential in making purchases decisions.
Source Roslow Research Group Inc., Spanish vs
English Advertising Effectiveness Among Hispanics
2000
31Ethnicity is defined asrel of, relating to,
or originating from the traits shared by members
of a group as a product of their common heredity
and cultural tradition(s)
32Culture is defined as synbreeding,
cultivation, polish, refinementrel
development, education, learning enlightenment
refinement, breeding, erudition, manners, class
33Culture-Sensitive Healthcare Hispanic
34- Hispanic
- The term Hispanic was created by the U.S.
Census Bureau in 1970 as an ethnic category for
persons who identify themselves as being of
Spanish origin. - Hispanic denotes neither race nor color, and
a Hispanic may be White, Black or American
Indian - Many members of the younger Hispanic population
demographic now prefer the term Latino.
35- Hispanic
- The classification Hispanic includes people
of many different origins and cultures. - Although there is a unifying thread of language
and some cultural similarities inherited from
the Spanish settlers There is also a
tremendous variety within the Hispanic community
36 Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
Your Hispanic Patients
37- Show respeto
- People from many Hispanic cultures offer (and
expect to receive) deference on the basis of
age, sex and status. - Patients will naturally offer respeto to the
health provider, an authority figure with high
social, educational, and economic status. - In return, patients rightfully expect to be
treated with respect. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
38- The Healthcare Provider Shows respeto by
- Addressing Adults by title and family name
(Mr./Señor, Mrs./Señora Y, or Madam/Doña) - Shaking hands at the beginning of each meeting.
- Using usted rather than the informal tu for
you, when speaking Spanish. - Making eye contact, without necessarily
expecting reciprocation, since some (especially
rural) patients may consider it disrespectful to
look the health provider, an authority figure,
in the eye. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
39- The Healthcare Provider Shows respeto by
- Speaking directly to the patient, even when
speaking through an interpreter. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
40- Show personalismo.
- Patients from many Hispanic cultures expect to
establish a personal, one-on-one relationship
not to be confused with an informal
relationship with the health provider. - Although establishing a relationship based on
personalismo may seem time-consuming, it can
actually save time and prevent negative
outcomes. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
41- The Healthcare Provider Shows personalismo by
- Treating patients in a warm and friendly but
not unduly informal manner. - Showing genuine interest in and concern for
patients by asking them about themselves and
their family. - Sitting close, leaning forward and using
gestures when speaking with the patient. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
42- Involve the Family in Decision Making and Care.
- Families are a source of emotional and physical
support and are expected to participate in
important medical decisions. - The definition of la familia is much broader
in most Hispanic cultures than in Anglo cultures - La familia may show loyalty and support by
gathering at the hospital. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
43- Accept a different sense of time.
- Many people from Hispanic cultures have what
might be called a global or indefinite sense
of time rather than an exact sense of day and
hour in making and keeping appointments. - Similarly in presenting a complaint, they may
not be able to attach a specific calendar date
to the onset or conclusion of a medical
complaint or an event. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
44- Accept a different sense of time.
- They may instead be able to link the event to a
season, a phase of the moon, or a particular
occurrence, such as a holiday or celebration. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
45- Take pains to establish understanding and
agreement. - Many patients sense of respect for authority
may cause them to avoid conflict or
confrontation with the health provider by saying
too readily that they understand how to take a
medication or will follow a treatment plan. - The health provider must ensure that
understanding is achieved and must try to gain
real acceptance of the treatment plan and a
commitment to follow it. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
46- Respect the spiritual side of physical
complaints. - Many Hispanic patients complain that health
practitioners, by discounting supernatural and
psychological causes of complaints, offer only a
fragmentary approach to care. - To these patients, this amounts to treating the
symptoms, not the disease itself. - Practitioners are advised to ask their patients
what they believe to be the cause of a complaint
and to refrain from ridiculing or discounting
the patients belief in supernatural or
psychological causes. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
47 Potential Culture-Related Health Concerns Among
Hispanic Populations Source Virginia
Techs Office of Multicultural Affairs Home Page
48- Persons from some Hispanic cultures may have
tendency toward certain health concerns because
of cultural factors. - Specific concerns include
- High incidence of teenage pregnancy
- Low incidence of breast feeding
- Where breast feeding is practiced, a tendency
to do so for a short period and to introduce
solid foods earlier than recommended - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
49- Specific concerns include
- Very low intake of vitamin A.
- Alcohol abuse, especially by young Mexican
males (abetted by cultural taboos against female
disclosure of alcohol use). - Drug use at levels higher than among
non-Hispanic Whites. - A high prevalence of undetected
non-insulin- dependent diabetes - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
50- Specific concerns include
- A high incidence of tuberculosis (recommend
aggressive screening - A high risk for mental health problems such as
depression, anxiety, and substance abuse. - Dietary concerns due to
- High consumption of fats (often lard,
especially for lower income people) and fried
foods - A traditional diet high in carbohydrates from
beans and rice or corn tortillas - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
51- Specific concerns include
- Dietary concerns due to
- Low intake of green or leafy vegetables and/or
milk and eggs, especially in conjunction with
increased consumption of meat and fast foods as
acculturation occurs. - Little tradition for recreational physical
exercise outside the context of field or other
physical labor. - Excessive reliance on Azarcon which is about 90
percent lead, as a home remedy for
gastrointestinal/intestinal complaints. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
52- Specific concerns include
- Sharing with family and friends, of hypodermic
needles and syringes, which in Mexico are often
used to administer vitamins, medications, and
contraceptives. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
53- Folk Beliefs of Some Hispanics About Health and
Illness That Can Affect Care and Treatment - Good health is a matter of luck that can easily
change. Sick persons may be the innocent
victims of fate, with little responsibility
for taking action to regain health. - Illness may be the result of negative forces in
the environment or a punishment for
transgressions. - Balance and harmony are important to health and
well-being. Illness may be the result of an
imbalance. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
54- Folk Beliefs of Some Hispanics About Health and
Illness That Can Affect Care and Treatment - The natural and supernatural worlds are not
clearly distinguishable, and body and soul are
inseparable. Telling a patient that an illness
is all in the mind is meaningless because there
is little or no distinction between somatic and
psychosomatic illness. - Cure requires family participation and support.
The familys role is to indulge the patient,
provide unconditional love and support, and
participate in health care decision making. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
55- Folk Beliefs of Some Hispanics About Health and
Illness That Can Affect Care and Treatment - While education and training may be somewhat
important, what truly matters is the caregivers
gift or calling for curing illness. - Moaning, far from being a sign of low tolerance
to pain, is a way to reduce pain and to share it
with interested others. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
56- Folk Beliefs of Some Hispanics About Health and
Illness That Can Affect Care and Treatment - Diseases may be divided into Anglo and
traditional diseases and may be either natural
or unnatural. - Many people mix and match modern medicine and
traditional care, consulting modern health
providers for Anglo and natural diseases, and
folk healers for traditional and unnatural
diseases. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page
57American IndianNative American
58- Culture-Sensitive Healthcare American Indian
- The term American Indian refers to members of
Indian Tribal nations who live in the United
States. - Native American, a term that has become
unpopular among American Indian groups, refers
to American Indians, Eskimos, and Aleuts as one
racial ethnic group. - Fact The Native American group as a whole is
expected to reach 4.3 million by 2050. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
59- Culture-Sensitive Healthcare American Indian
- The majority live in Oklahoma, California,
Arizona and New Mexico. - Poverty is higher than in the rest of the
population and continues to increase. - In 1979, 27 of the American Indian population
lived below the poverty line by 1989 this
figure had grown to 31, by 1999 this figure had
grown again to 33. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
60- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Make the Patient Welcome. First meetings are
important. - Extend a warm greeting and smile.
- Shake hands, introduce yourself, and allow the
patient to do the same (thereby showing respect
to his or her ancestors) - Thank the patient for having chosen your health
facility. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
61- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - A western style handshake is appropriate and
appreciated, dont be surprised if it is
returned by an unusually weak or strong one. - The traditional Navajo greeting is not to shake
hands, but to extend the hand and gently touch
the other persons hand. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
62- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Use Eye Contact Judiciously.
- Prolonged eye contact is considered a sign of
disrespect and should be avoided. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
63- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Take Your Time.
- It is important to spend time with the patient
and to avoid appearing hurried or nervous. - Patients often travel great distances at great
financial hardship to see a physician if the
physician spends only five or ten minutes with
them, the message is clear and negative. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
64- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Speak Plainly.
- Avoid medical or other terms that may not be
understood, but at the same time, dont talk
down to the patient or appear to treat him or
her as a child. - A soft concerned voice will do much to make the
patient feel at ease. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
65- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Respect Silence.
- Be concise and give the patient time to reflect
on what you are saying. - Dont try to fill up the time.
- American Indians are taught the value of
silence and may also need time to mentally
translate what they hear into their own
language. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
66- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Understand Tribal Diagnosis.
- The patient may have come to you following
diagnosis by a tribal diagnostician. - Due to this, the patient may be unfamiliar with
the technique of identifying the specific
location of pain. - Instead of asking the patient, Where is the
pain?, ask the patient to point to the most
intense area of pain. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
67- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Accommodate Tribal Healing.
- Patients may wish to perform certain tribal
healing ceremonies, even in the hospital. - Try to accommodate these healings as a way to
improve both the patients and the familys
confidence in the care. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
68- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Show Special Respect to the Elderly.
- Great respect is given to the elderly, in spite
of taboos connected with death. - Caregivers gain approval by treating the
elderly with kindness and respect and not
appearing to criticize or scold them. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
69- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Think Carefully About Family Care.
- Poverty, distance from the medical facility,
and taboos against dying in the home may make it
impractical to release to the family a patient
needing long-term or terminal care. - Discuss options with the family and try to
ascertain attitudes about home care before
releasing a person into the family care. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
70- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Involve the Extended Family.
- Extended family plays an important role in
healthcare decision making. - Often many family members will appear with a
patient who is to be admitted for a hospital
stay. - Include family members when decisions regarding
treatment options are needed. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
71- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Involve the Extended Family.
- Very often, a patient will postpone surgery
because the consent of the family leader, often
the eldest female must be obtained first. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
72- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Accept a Different Sense of Time.
- Most American Indians are present-oriented and
take a casual approach to clocks and time, which
is viewed as a continuum with no beginning and
no end. - Poses difficulties with regulation of
medication. - Watch telling the patient to take medications
with meals, as the patient may have three meals
today, two meals tomorrow and four the meals the
day after that. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
73- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Accept a Different Sense of Time.
- Many Indians are task-conscious rather than
time- conscious, paying more attention to
finishing task than to a clock or to an
appointment schedule. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
74- Keys to a Good Professional Relationship with
American Indian Patients - Give and Expect Generosity.
- Indian culture discourages competitive behavior
and encourages giving, sharing, and cooperation. - Generosity and doing things for others are
regarded highly. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
75- Potential Culture-Related Health Concerns Among
American Indians - Average life expectancy of 71.1 years lower
than all other races in the United States. - Many health problems and the high incidence of
accidents and suicides. - The Infant death rate is high, a fact
attributed to a high incidence of diarrhea and a
harsh physical environment. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
76- Potential Culture-Related Health Concerns Among
American Indians - Women may choose not to seek prenatal care,
because pregnancy and birth are considered
normal processes and health facilities are
associated with illness and disease. - Pregnant Navajo women are forbidden to attend
traditional healing ceremonies to avoid contact
with illness or disease. - Hold your maternal and child care clinics in a
location separate from other clinical services. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
77- Potential Culture-Related Health Concerns Among
American Indians - A high incidence of non-insulin-dependent (Type
II) diabetes increased dramatically in New
Mexico. - American Indians are genetically predisposed to
the disease triggered by a radical change in
eating habits and increase in obesity among this
population. - Myocardial infarction incidence is higher among
Navajo men and a gradual increase among Navajo
women. - Alcoholism among this population is very high.
- Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
78- Potential Culture-Related Health Concerns Among
American Indians - Fetal Alcohol Syndrome is also fairly high
among this population. - Navajo children have low length-for-age and
high weight-for-length measures because of
suboptimal nutrition. - Of the 10 leading causes of death among
American Indians, 5 are related to diet. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
79- Religious and Spiritual Beliefs That Can Affect
Care and Treatment - Tribes share a number of fundamental health,
illness, and illness prevention beliefs. - Life comes from the Great Spirit (or Supreme
Creator) and all healing begins with him. - Man is a threefold being made up of body, mind
and spirit. - Health or wellness is due to a preservation of
harmony among the body, heart, mind and soul. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
80- Religious and Spiritual Beliefs That Can Affect
Care and Treatment - Tribes share a number of fundamental health,
illness, and illness prevention beliefs. - Plants and animals, as well as humans, are part
of the spirit world that exists alongside, and is
intermingled with, the physical world. - Death is not an enemy but a natural phenomenon of
life - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
81- Navajo Application of These Beliefs
- Navajo society is matriarchal - Women hold a
higher position than men - Focus of Navajo traditional religion is on
maintaining a harmonious relationship with all
living things. - Illness is thought to result from improper
thought and behavior affecting oneself as well as
the external, natural world of plants, animals,
and the environment. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
82- Navajo Application of These Beliefs
- Illness also is attributed to an improper use of
ceremonies. - As a rule, Navajo may not seek medical care for a
number of discomforts and acute illnesses for
which a non-Navajo would seek relief. - Illness, like death, is simply viewed and
accepted as a natural part of life. - Source Virginia Techs Office of Multicultural
Affairs Home Page Updated 2002
83Marketing and Advertising to Hispanic and Native
American Populations Be culturally sensitive and
aware Spanish language spots (radio or television
should be produced specifically for the market
and not a lift of the English spot) Native
Americans can be spoken to in their own language
on radio (much tougher there are many different
dialects within the state) Source Virginia
Techs Office of Multicultural Affairs Home Page
Updated 2002