Title: Improving Shareholder Value The Investors Approach to Freight Transportation
1(No Transcript)
2Improving Shareholder ValueThe Investors
Approach to Freight Transportation
Laurie Hahn, CFA Deutsche Bank Securities,
Inc. Airfreight Surface Transportation Team
November, 2002
3Summary
- What Drives Investment in Freight Transportation?
- Setting the Economic Backdrop
- Sector Trends Blueprints for Success
- Translation to Market Performance Valuation
- Conclusion
- QA
4What Drives Investment in Freight Transportation?
- Over Time, Stock Performance Broadly Anticipates
Economic Cycle - Long Term Themes a Factor in Investment Selection
- Consolidation Big get bigger
- Outsourcing is of increasing importance as supply
chain becomes more complicated. - Globalization Nations increasingly cooperative
in post 9/11 environment, entrance of China to
WTO. - Investment Community Still Reeling from Stock
Market Volatility, Looking For Ideas - What Will the Market Reward in this Choppy
Environment? - Earnings Visibility
- Performance Consistency
- Transparency
- Strong Cash Flow
- Ability to Generate Growth in Tough Times
- Delivering Growth to the Bottom Line
Source Factset, Bloomberg.
5Current Investor Focus is Economy
- Investors Approach Freight Transportation Sector
as a Cyclical Industry, Even Though Some Sectors
are More Growth Oriented - Economic Outlook Manufacturing Recovery
Stalled, Consumer Slowing Down - Few Freight Transportation Companies Escaped
Unscathed from Global Economic Malaise, but Some
Fared Better than Others. - Key Themes among Top Performing Companies
- Cost Management
- Ability to Grow Market Share
- Internal
- External
- Fiscally Fit Balance Sheets
- Market Share Dominant
- Trustworthy, Forthright Management Team
Source Factset, Bloomberg.
6Setting The Economic Backdrop Domestic
- U.S. Economy is in Recovery, but Biggest Concern
is Potential for Double Dip. - Economic data showing improvement, but recent
indicators have hit an air pocket. - Inventories remain lean.
- Manufacturing leading indicators slowing.
- Biggest risk is the potential for a double dip
recession if end demand does not follow through
significantly enough to sustain a recovery. - The forecasted economic recovery is underway, but
the strength of the economic indicators bears
watching for signs of renewed weakness. - Early cyclical stocks remain in favor with
investors keeping a watchful eye on near-term
results while taking a longer-term view of
recovery. - Have consumers stretched their dollars as far as
they will go?
Source Bureau of Economic Analysis, Bloomberg.
7Setting The Economic Backdrop International
- International trade rebounding, but West Coast
port lockout muddling trends. - Globalization and reliance on the U.S. negatively
impacted trade flows, but leading indicators have
turned positive. - U.S. import and export activity expanding.
Source ISM Survey
8Setting The Economic Backdrop International
Could Lag Domestic
- International ocean volumes disrupted by West
Coast lockout, but underlying trends indicate
recovery - U.S. economic recovery providing boost to
international trade and ocean volumes. - Relative strength in consumer spending drives
imports of goods from Asia, reflected in strength
at West Coast ports. - Threat of work stoppage/slowdown by
Longshoremans union could have driven some
pre-shipping. - However, backlog is being cleared and volumes are
getting back on track.
Source AAR, Port of Long Beach
9Setting the Economic Backdrop Airfreight Could
Lag Ground
- Domestic airfreight in recovery, comparisons
getting easier - Underlying demand weak
- reduces need for expedited service.
- shift from air to ground.
- Lower capacity available due to impact of 9/11.
- FAAs actions are for the protection of the
passenger, freight garnering little attention. - International airfreight volume recovering, but
some related to West Coast disruptions - Before 9/11/01, weakness fuelled by reduced IT
spending. - After 9/11/01, same conditions exacerbated by
reduced reliability of passenger airlines, both
U.S. and foreign carriers. - Freight diversions from ocean to air now driving
short-term strength.
Source Air Transport Association
10Fuel Prices Trending Higher
- Fuel prices now above 2001 levels.
- Fuel prices swinging back to a negative to
earnings as comparisons become difficult. - Outlook uncertain due to prospect of war with
Iraq. - Most companies protected from current rise in
fuel prices to some degree by derivative hedging,
advance purchase contracts, and/or fuel
surcharges.
Source Energy Information Administration.
11Railroad Sector
- Yield Improvement and Cost Control Focus Could
Drive Dramatic Operating Leverage. - Eastern rails stand to benefit the most, as
service levels improve and excess costs taken
out. - Western and Canadian rails could improve margins,
but earnings recovery will likely be less
dramatic. - Risk remains for price discounting in some
commodities. - Market Share Gains over Long Term Driven by Truck
Conversion, and Possibly Consolidation. - Service enhancements make rails more attractive
to truck customers. - Small acquisitions likely, long-term possibility
of West-East merger, in which case Eastern rails
would likely be targets. - Focus on Improving Service Levels, Cost
Reductions. - Most rails improving service levels dramatically,
Eastern rails have most upside potential here. - Reducing excess costs, railroad retirement reform
helping to lower labor expenses. - Increased Attention Given to Alliances and
Inter-Line Agreements. - Provides market share opportunities without the
complications of a large scale merger. - Fuel Prices Back at Higher Levels.
12Long Term Industry Trends Risks
- Excess Capacity Plagues Railroad Industry.
- Track and revenue equipment are biggest problems.
- Fleet and track rationalization programs.
- Rails replacing older equipment with new, higher
horsepower locomotives, higher capacity freight
cars. - Focus Improved Returns, Earning Cost of Capital.
- Capital intensive nature of business and years of
depressed earnings have caused anemic returns. - Most railroads are not earning their cost of
capital. - In the near term, the U.S. economy will drive
returns. - Capacity rationalization, operating improvements,
and yield enhancement will drive returns. - Key to attaining long-term adequate returns is
reducing overall capital investment in the
industry. - Focus on Long-Term Pricing Improvements.
- Pricing will follow consistent improvements in
service levels. - More premium products garner higher prices.
- Labor Concerns
- Negotiations ongoing due to unresolved issues.
- One-day strike possible, but likely immaterial .
- Aggressive Pricing
- Irrational competition still risk, particularly
in West. - Eastern carriers most rational, Western carriers
still competitive on coal, auto, and chemicals
contracts. - What if Economy Falls into Double Dip Pattern?
- Potential significant, but less than in previous
cycles, as inventories remain lean. - Monetary and Fiscal stimulus.
- Commodity Risks
- Coal remains spotty, but comparisons improving.
- Long term coal outlook solid.
- Grain crop outlook poor, but high prices could
boost grain exports out of inventory in U.S., so
carloads may rebound later this year or early
2003, - Automotive volumes currently strong.
- We still fear that automotive manufacturers may
have robbed Peter (2003 sales) to pay Paul
(2001/2002 sales) with recent financing
incentives.
13Blueprint for Success Railroad Sector
- Efficient, fluid railway network
- Well thought our operating plan
- Capable, up to date IT systems
- Measurable operating parameters
- Superior service levels
- Leads to higher prices
- Ability to compete with trucks
- Yield management strategy
- Rational pricing
- Focus on most profitable rail moves
- Innovative product development
- Products that compete with truck service
- Products that focus on fastest growing areas (I.e
intermodal) - Truck alliances
- Streamlined network
- Reduce excess capacity
- Sell non-core assets
- Ability to translate operating performance to
superior returns - Potential to earn cost of capital
- Positive free cash flow generation
- Improving balance sheet
- Strengthening cash balances
- Reasonable debt level
- Superior cost management
- Well-respected, capable management team
14Truckload (TL) Sector - Survival of the Fittest
- TL industry remains a more difficult operating
environment compared to the LTL industry. - Tentatively recovering economy.
- Weak used truck values..little change on this
front, but engine emissions deadline and possible
associated purchases in used truck market could
provide long needed support to used tractor
values. - Rising operating costs.
- Higher insurance rates, especially in light of
9/11. - Higher equipment costs-potentially higher
maintenance costs as equipment trade cycle is
lengthened versus higher capitalization costs as
carriers relaize losses or lower gains on sale of
equipment. - Several carriers accelerating depreciation
schedules - adds excess costs. - Spectre of new engine emissions could increase
costs for companies by as much as 5,000 per
tractor. - Downturn causing shakeout in industry, creating
opportunity for dominant players. - Convergence of weak economy and rising costs
could create a truckload renaissance over the
next few years. - Pricing still weak for core carriers, but most
are now trying to extract rate increases of 2 to
4 from select customers and lanes. - We believe the core carriers have the
resources/economies of scale to emerge from
downturn and benefit over the long term by way of
better pricing conditions and market share gains.
15Long Term Industry Trends Risks
- Capacity Rationalization.
- Rising costs.
- Stringent control of fleet additions.
- New barriers to entry
- Insurance
- Lack of Financing
- Record company failures.
- Pricing Discipline.
- Broad effort by TL participants to raise prices.
- Recognition of necessity to recoup higher costs.
- Tighter capacity shifting pricing power to
carriers - Core Carrier Consolidation.
- Alive and well as supply chain becomes more
complex. - Security concerns following 9/11.
- Driven by simple need for large scale capacity
- Private Fleet Conversions
- Driver Shortage
- Likely to return to forefront.
- Will ultimately lead to higher labor costs.
- Owner operator market may be permanently
impaired. - What if Economy Falls into Double Dip Pattern?
- Potential significant, but less than in previous
cycles, as inventories remain lean. - Monetary and Fiscal stimulus.
- Will Price Increases Cover Cost Increases?
- Insurance cost increases have not abated.
- Labor costs could rise over the long term.
- New emissions standards pushing up cost of
equipment. - Weak used tractor values have pushed up the
overall cost of equipment replacement. - Regulatory Issues
- New engines - higher overall cost, lower fuel
efficiency, reduced warranty. - Hours of service rules may come back to haunt the
industry.
16Trucking Company Failures Could Drive 20 of
Capacity Out of Market
- Difficult operating environment forcing many
small truckers out of the industry. - Failures have skyrocketed over the past few
quarters and dont seem to be letting up. - Several large failures have occurred or may be
imminent Trism, Patriot, Burlington Motor
Carriers, and Transit Group. - Long term benefits to our universe include
rational capacity, improved pricing power, and
market share gains.
Source ATA, A.G. Edwards, Dun Bradstreet
17Blueprint for Success Truckload Sector
- Dominant leadership position in the industry
- Broad geographical coverage
- Superior service levels
- Ability to provide capacity
- Yield Management
- Rational pricing
- Rational capacity management
- Successful acquisition strategy and integration
record - Proven internal growth track record
- Aggressively taking market share
- Ability to manage growth profitably
- Well-respected, capable management team
- Stringent cost management
- Superior purchasing power
- Control of discretionary costs
- Ability to recruit and retain drivers
- Managing through counter-cyclical driver shortage
- Operating ratio in the low 90s or 80s
- Earnings growth in line to better than top-line
growth - Flexible balance sheet with reasonable debt
levels - Facilitates growth
- Allows flexibility in tough times
18Less-than-Truckload (LTL) Sector - Christmas Came
Early this Year
- Failure of major national carrier driving
dramatic market share gains, primarily at the
national LTL carriers but to a lesser extent at
the regional LTL carriers. - The most important implication for the industry
is a healthier pricing environment. - Operating leverage could drive dramatic earnings
growth in near term at the national LTL carriers
despite the soft economy. - We expect further momentum to build once a more
robust economic recovery is underway. - The key to the health of the LTL industry today
is a healthy pricing environment brought about by
capacity rationalization. - CF closure likely to clean up any remaining
competitive pricing conditions that resulted from
the weak economy. - All carriers implemented general rate increases
of 5 to 6 ahead of peak shipping season. - Upcoming contract negotiations likely to reflect
tight capacity situation created by CF closure. - Expense management techniques and service levels
have improved in the last decade, particularly at
the unionized carriers.
19Blueprint for Success Less-than-Truckload Sector
- Dominant leadership position in the industry
- Broad product offering
- Broad geographical coverage
- Superior service levels
- Strong business plan
- Barriers to entry
- Market penetration (density)
- Strong IT capabilities
- Yield management
- Costing system
- Annual general rate increases
- Increased focus on mid-sized accounts
- Well-respected, capable management team
- Focus on growth markets
- Regional market growing faster than national
(JIT, regionalized distribution patterns) - Specialized/premium products
- Cost management
- Ability to react quickly to volume changes
- Managing costs on a more variable basis
- Strong cash flow generation
- Positive free cash flow
- Growing EBITDA
- Strengthening balance sheet
- Significant cash balances
- Reasonable debt levels
20Airfreight and Logistics Sector
- Long-term themes of outsourcing, mode neutrality,
globalization, and consolidation should benefit
the best in class airfreight and logistics
providers. - Given the disruption associated with 9/11, Supply
Chain Management more important than ever. - Modal shift to less expensive delivery options
- International Airfreight to Ocean Freight
- Domestic Airfreight to Ground Transportation
- Fuelled by weak economy but may be a longer-term
trend - Weak U.S. economy filtered into international
economies, pressuring global logistics players. - Transaction volume weak.
- Bid process lengthening, decision makers
paralyzed by events of 9/11. - International recovery could lag domestic
- Softest industries include technology and
telecommunications. - Asset based airfreight carriers suffered the
most, particularly the heavy freight carriers - Integrators were somewhat cushioned by broad
product mix and ability to offer deferred/ground
delivery services - Variable cost business model may not be so
variable after all. - How deep do you want to cut?
- Can you respond to a pickup in activity?
- Costs of doing global business rising with new
security measures following 9/11
21Blueprint for Success Logistics Sector
- Dominant leadership position in the industry
- Broad product offering
- Broad geographical coverage
- Specific market niche
- Strong business plan
- Barriers to entry
- Blue-chip customer/vendor base
- Successful acquisition strategy and integration
record - Well-respected, capable management team
- Top-line growth in excess of industry growth
- Stable net revenue margins
- Rising operating margin
- Earnings growth in line to better than top-line
growth - Strong cash flow generation, positive free cash
flow and growing EBITDA - Strong balance sheet with significant cash
balances and little to no debt
22Blueprint for Success Airfreight Sector
- Dominant leadership position in the industry
- Broad product offering
- Ability to provide deferred/ground service in
weak environment - Broad geographical coverage
- Strong business plan
- Barriers to entry
- Blue-chip customer/vendor base
- Capacity management
- Successful acquisition strategy and integration
record - Well-respected, capable management team
- Top-line growth in excess of industry growth
- Effective discretionary cost management
- Ability to react quickly to volume changes
- Earnings growth in line to better than top-line
growth - Strong cash flow generation
- Positive free cash flow
- Growing EBITDA
- Strong balance sheet
- Significant cash balances
- Reasonable debt level
23Transportation Sub-sector Valuations
Source Factset.
24Conclusion
- Investors View Transportation from Cyclical
Standpoint - Favor High Quality Companies with Stable
Earnings, Compelling Long-Term Prospects - Capitalize on Longer-Term Growth Themes
Consolidation, Globalization, Outsourcing - Marketplace Will Reward Companies with
Outstanding Fundamentals and Growth
Characteristics
25QA
26(No Transcript)