Improving Shareholder Value The Investors Approach to Freight Transportation PowerPoint PPT Presentation

presentation player overlay
1 / 26
About This Presentation
Transcript and Presenter's Notes

Title: Improving Shareholder Value The Investors Approach to Freight Transportation


1
(No Transcript)
2
Improving Shareholder ValueThe Investors
Approach to Freight Transportation
Laurie Hahn, CFA Deutsche Bank Securities,
Inc. Airfreight Surface Transportation Team
November, 2002
3
Summary
  • What Drives Investment in Freight Transportation?
  • Setting the Economic Backdrop
  • Sector Trends Blueprints for Success
  • Translation to Market Performance Valuation
  • Conclusion
  • QA

4
What Drives Investment in Freight Transportation?
  • Over Time, Stock Performance Broadly Anticipates
    Economic Cycle
  • Long Term Themes a Factor in Investment Selection
  • Consolidation Big get bigger
  • Outsourcing is of increasing importance as supply
    chain becomes more complicated.
  • Globalization Nations increasingly cooperative
    in post 9/11 environment, entrance of China to
    WTO.
  • Investment Community Still Reeling from Stock
    Market Volatility, Looking For Ideas
  • What Will the Market Reward in this Choppy
    Environment?
  • Earnings Visibility
  • Performance Consistency
  • Transparency
  • Strong Cash Flow
  • Ability to Generate Growth in Tough Times
  • Delivering Growth to the Bottom Line

Source Factset, Bloomberg.
5
Current Investor Focus is Economy
  • Investors Approach Freight Transportation Sector
    as a Cyclical Industry, Even Though Some Sectors
    are More Growth Oriented
  • Economic Outlook Manufacturing Recovery
    Stalled, Consumer Slowing Down
  • Few Freight Transportation Companies Escaped
    Unscathed from Global Economic Malaise, but Some
    Fared Better than Others.
  • Key Themes among Top Performing Companies
  • Cost Management
  • Ability to Grow Market Share
  • Internal
  • External
  • Fiscally Fit Balance Sheets
  • Market Share Dominant
  • Trustworthy, Forthright Management Team

Source Factset, Bloomberg.
6
Setting The Economic Backdrop Domestic
  • U.S. Economy is in Recovery, but Biggest Concern
    is Potential for Double Dip.
  • Economic data showing improvement, but recent
    indicators have hit an air pocket.
  • Inventories remain lean.
  • Manufacturing leading indicators slowing.
  • Biggest risk is the potential for a double dip
    recession if end demand does not follow through
    significantly enough to sustain a recovery.
  • The forecasted economic recovery is underway, but
    the strength of the economic indicators bears
    watching for signs of renewed weakness.
  • Early cyclical stocks remain in favor with
    investors keeping a watchful eye on near-term
    results while taking a longer-term view of
    recovery.
  • Have consumers stretched their dollars as far as
    they will go?

Source Bureau of Economic Analysis, Bloomberg.
7
Setting The Economic Backdrop International
  • International trade rebounding, but West Coast
    port lockout muddling trends.
  • Globalization and reliance on the U.S. negatively
    impacted trade flows, but leading indicators have
    turned positive.
  • U.S. import and export activity expanding.

Source ISM Survey
8
Setting The Economic Backdrop International
Could Lag Domestic
  • International ocean volumes disrupted by West
    Coast lockout, but underlying trends indicate
    recovery
  • U.S. economic recovery providing boost to
    international trade and ocean volumes.
  • Relative strength in consumer spending drives
    imports of goods from Asia, reflected in strength
    at West Coast ports.
  • Threat of work stoppage/slowdown by
    Longshoremans union could have driven some
    pre-shipping.
  • However, backlog is being cleared and volumes are
    getting back on track.

Source AAR, Port of Long Beach
9
Setting the Economic Backdrop Airfreight Could
Lag Ground
  • Domestic airfreight in recovery, comparisons
    getting easier
  • Underlying demand weak
  • reduces need for expedited service.
  • shift from air to ground.
  • Lower capacity available due to impact of 9/11.
  • FAAs actions are for the protection of the
    passenger, freight garnering little attention.
  • International airfreight volume recovering, but
    some related to West Coast disruptions
  • Before 9/11/01, weakness fuelled by reduced IT
    spending.
  • After 9/11/01, same conditions exacerbated by
    reduced reliability of passenger airlines, both
    U.S. and foreign carriers.
  • Freight diversions from ocean to air now driving
    short-term strength.

Source Air Transport Association
10
Fuel Prices Trending Higher
  • Fuel prices now above 2001 levels.
  • Fuel prices swinging back to a negative to
    earnings as comparisons become difficult.
  • Outlook uncertain due to prospect of war with
    Iraq.
  • Most companies protected from current rise in
    fuel prices to some degree by derivative hedging,
    advance purchase contracts, and/or fuel
    surcharges.

Source Energy Information Administration.
11
Railroad Sector
  • Yield Improvement and Cost Control Focus Could
    Drive Dramatic Operating Leverage.
  • Eastern rails stand to benefit the most, as
    service levels improve and excess costs taken
    out.
  • Western and Canadian rails could improve margins,
    but earnings recovery will likely be less
    dramatic.
  • Risk remains for price discounting in some
    commodities.
  • Market Share Gains over Long Term Driven by Truck
    Conversion, and Possibly Consolidation.
  • Service enhancements make rails more attractive
    to truck customers.
  • Small acquisitions likely, long-term possibility
    of West-East merger, in which case Eastern rails
    would likely be targets.
  • Focus on Improving Service Levels, Cost
    Reductions.
  • Most rails improving service levels dramatically,
    Eastern rails have most upside potential here.
  • Reducing excess costs, railroad retirement reform
    helping to lower labor expenses.
  • Increased Attention Given to Alliances and
    Inter-Line Agreements.
  • Provides market share opportunities without the
    complications of a large scale merger.
  • Fuel Prices Back at Higher Levels.

12
Long Term Industry Trends Risks
  • Excess Capacity Plagues Railroad Industry.
  • Track and revenue equipment are biggest problems.
  • Fleet and track rationalization programs.
  • Rails replacing older equipment with new, higher
    horsepower locomotives, higher capacity freight
    cars.
  • Focus Improved Returns, Earning Cost of Capital.
  • Capital intensive nature of business and years of
    depressed earnings have caused anemic returns.
  • Most railroads are not earning their cost of
    capital.
  • In the near term, the U.S. economy will drive
    returns.
  • Capacity rationalization, operating improvements,
    and yield enhancement will drive returns.
  • Key to attaining long-term adequate returns is
    reducing overall capital investment in the
    industry.
  • Focus on Long-Term Pricing Improvements.
  • Pricing will follow consistent improvements in
    service levels.
  • More premium products garner higher prices.
  • Labor Concerns
  • Negotiations ongoing due to unresolved issues.
  • One-day strike possible, but likely immaterial .
  • Aggressive Pricing
  • Irrational competition still risk, particularly
    in West.
  • Eastern carriers most rational, Western carriers
    still competitive on coal, auto, and chemicals
    contracts.
  • What if Economy Falls into Double Dip Pattern?
  • Potential significant, but less than in previous
    cycles, as inventories remain lean.
  • Monetary and Fiscal stimulus.
  • Commodity Risks
  • Coal remains spotty, but comparisons improving.
  • Long term coal outlook solid.
  • Grain crop outlook poor, but high prices could
    boost grain exports out of inventory in U.S., so
    carloads may rebound later this year or early
    2003,
  • Automotive volumes currently strong.
  • We still fear that automotive manufacturers may
    have robbed Peter (2003 sales) to pay Paul
    (2001/2002 sales) with recent financing
    incentives.

13
Blueprint for Success Railroad Sector
  • Efficient, fluid railway network
  • Well thought our operating plan
  • Capable, up to date IT systems
  • Measurable operating parameters
  • Superior service levels
  • Leads to higher prices
  • Ability to compete with trucks
  • Yield management strategy
  • Rational pricing
  • Focus on most profitable rail moves
  • Innovative product development
  • Products that compete with truck service
  • Products that focus on fastest growing areas (I.e
    intermodal)
  • Truck alliances
  • Streamlined network
  • Reduce excess capacity
  • Sell non-core assets
  • Ability to translate operating performance to
    superior returns
  • Potential to earn cost of capital
  • Positive free cash flow generation
  • Improving balance sheet
  • Strengthening cash balances
  • Reasonable debt level
  • Superior cost management
  • Well-respected, capable management team

14
Truckload (TL) Sector - Survival of the Fittest
  • TL industry remains a more difficult operating
    environment compared to the LTL industry.
  • Tentatively recovering economy.
  • Weak used truck values..little change on this
    front, but engine emissions deadline and possible
    associated purchases in used truck market could
    provide long needed support to used tractor
    values.
  • Rising operating costs.
  • Higher insurance rates, especially in light of
    9/11.
  • Higher equipment costs-potentially higher
    maintenance costs as equipment trade cycle is
    lengthened versus higher capitalization costs as
    carriers relaize losses or lower gains on sale of
    equipment.
  • Several carriers accelerating depreciation
    schedules - adds excess costs.
  • Spectre of new engine emissions could increase
    costs for companies by as much as 5,000 per
    tractor.
  • Downturn causing shakeout in industry, creating
    opportunity for dominant players.
  • Convergence of weak economy and rising costs
    could create a truckload renaissance over the
    next few years.
  • Pricing still weak for core carriers, but most
    are now trying to extract rate increases of 2 to
    4 from select customers and lanes.
  • We believe the core carriers have the
    resources/economies of scale to emerge from
    downturn and benefit over the long term by way of
    better pricing conditions and market share gains.

15
Long Term Industry Trends Risks
  • Capacity Rationalization.
  • Rising costs.
  • Stringent control of fleet additions.
  • New barriers to entry
  • Insurance
  • Lack of Financing
  • Record company failures.
  • Pricing Discipline.
  • Broad effort by TL participants to raise prices.
  • Recognition of necessity to recoup higher costs.
  • Tighter capacity shifting pricing power to
    carriers
  • Core Carrier Consolidation.
  • Alive and well as supply chain becomes more
    complex.
  • Security concerns following 9/11.
  • Driven by simple need for large scale capacity
  • Private Fleet Conversions
  • Driver Shortage
  • Likely to return to forefront.
  • Will ultimately lead to higher labor costs.
  • Owner operator market may be permanently
    impaired.
  • What if Economy Falls into Double Dip Pattern?
  • Potential significant, but less than in previous
    cycles, as inventories remain lean.
  • Monetary and Fiscal stimulus.
  • Will Price Increases Cover Cost Increases?
  • Insurance cost increases have not abated.
  • Labor costs could rise over the long term.
  • New emissions standards pushing up cost of
    equipment.
  • Weak used tractor values have pushed up the
    overall cost of equipment replacement.
  • Regulatory Issues
  • New engines - higher overall cost, lower fuel
    efficiency, reduced warranty.
  • Hours of service rules may come back to haunt the
    industry.

16
Trucking Company Failures Could Drive 20 of
Capacity Out of Market
  • Difficult operating environment forcing many
    small truckers out of the industry.
  • Failures have skyrocketed over the past few
    quarters and dont seem to be letting up.
  • Several large failures have occurred or may be
    imminent Trism, Patriot, Burlington Motor
    Carriers, and Transit Group.
  • Long term benefits to our universe include
    rational capacity, improved pricing power, and
    market share gains.

Source ATA, A.G. Edwards, Dun Bradstreet
17
Blueprint for Success Truckload Sector
  • Dominant leadership position in the industry
  • Broad geographical coverage
  • Superior service levels
  • Ability to provide capacity
  • Yield Management
  • Rational pricing
  • Rational capacity management
  • Successful acquisition strategy and integration
    record
  • Proven internal growth track record
  • Aggressively taking market share
  • Ability to manage growth profitably
  • Well-respected, capable management team
  • Stringent cost management
  • Superior purchasing power
  • Control of discretionary costs
  • Ability to recruit and retain drivers
  • Managing through counter-cyclical driver shortage
  • Operating ratio in the low 90s or 80s
  • Earnings growth in line to better than top-line
    growth
  • Flexible balance sheet with reasonable debt
    levels
  • Facilitates growth
  • Allows flexibility in tough times

18
Less-than-Truckload (LTL) Sector - Christmas Came
Early this Year
  • Failure of major national carrier driving
    dramatic market share gains, primarily at the
    national LTL carriers but to a lesser extent at
    the regional LTL carriers.
  • The most important implication for the industry
    is a healthier pricing environment.
  • Operating leverage could drive dramatic earnings
    growth in near term at the national LTL carriers
    despite the soft economy.
  • We expect further momentum to build once a more
    robust economic recovery is underway.
  • The key to the health of the LTL industry today
    is a healthy pricing environment brought about by
    capacity rationalization.
  • CF closure likely to clean up any remaining
    competitive pricing conditions that resulted from
    the weak economy.
  • All carriers implemented general rate increases
    of 5 to 6 ahead of peak shipping season.
  • Upcoming contract negotiations likely to reflect
    tight capacity situation created by CF closure.
  • Expense management techniques and service levels
    have improved in the last decade, particularly at
    the unionized carriers.

19
Blueprint for Success Less-than-Truckload Sector
  • Dominant leadership position in the industry
  • Broad product offering
  • Broad geographical coverage
  • Superior service levels
  • Strong business plan
  • Barriers to entry
  • Market penetration (density)
  • Strong IT capabilities
  • Yield management
  • Costing system
  • Annual general rate increases
  • Increased focus on mid-sized accounts
  • Well-respected, capable management team
  • Focus on growth markets
  • Regional market growing faster than national
    (JIT, regionalized distribution patterns)
  • Specialized/premium products
  • Cost management
  • Ability to react quickly to volume changes
  • Managing costs on a more variable basis
  • Strong cash flow generation
  • Positive free cash flow
  • Growing EBITDA
  • Strengthening balance sheet
  • Significant cash balances
  • Reasonable debt levels

20
Airfreight and Logistics Sector
  • Long-term themes of outsourcing, mode neutrality,
    globalization, and consolidation should benefit
    the best in class airfreight and logistics
    providers.
  • Given the disruption associated with 9/11, Supply
    Chain Management more important than ever.
  • Modal shift to less expensive delivery options
  • International Airfreight to Ocean Freight
  • Domestic Airfreight to Ground Transportation
  • Fuelled by weak economy but may be a longer-term
    trend
  • Weak U.S. economy filtered into international
    economies, pressuring global logistics players.
  • Transaction volume weak.
  • Bid process lengthening, decision makers
    paralyzed by events of 9/11.
  • International recovery could lag domestic
  • Softest industries include technology and
    telecommunications.
  • Asset based airfreight carriers suffered the
    most, particularly the heavy freight carriers
  • Integrators were somewhat cushioned by broad
    product mix and ability to offer deferred/ground
    delivery services
  • Variable cost business model may not be so
    variable after all.
  • How deep do you want to cut?
  • Can you respond to a pickup in activity?
  • Costs of doing global business rising with new
    security measures following 9/11

21
Blueprint for Success Logistics Sector
  • Dominant leadership position in the industry
  • Broad product offering
  • Broad geographical coverage
  • Specific market niche
  • Strong business plan
  • Barriers to entry
  • Blue-chip customer/vendor base
  • Successful acquisition strategy and integration
    record
  • Well-respected, capable management team
  • Top-line growth in excess of industry growth
  • Stable net revenue margins
  • Rising operating margin
  • Earnings growth in line to better than top-line
    growth
  • Strong cash flow generation, positive free cash
    flow and growing EBITDA
  • Strong balance sheet with significant cash
    balances and little to no debt

22
Blueprint for Success Airfreight Sector
  • Dominant leadership position in the industry
  • Broad product offering
  • Ability to provide deferred/ground service in
    weak environment
  • Broad geographical coverage
  • Strong business plan
  • Barriers to entry
  • Blue-chip customer/vendor base
  • Capacity management
  • Successful acquisition strategy and integration
    record
  • Well-respected, capable management team
  • Top-line growth in excess of industry growth
  • Effective discretionary cost management
  • Ability to react quickly to volume changes
  • Earnings growth in line to better than top-line
    growth
  • Strong cash flow generation
  • Positive free cash flow
  • Growing EBITDA
  • Strong balance sheet
  • Significant cash balances
  • Reasonable debt level

23
Transportation Sub-sector Valuations
Source Factset.
24
Conclusion
  • Investors View Transportation from Cyclical
    Standpoint
  • Favor High Quality Companies with Stable
    Earnings, Compelling Long-Term Prospects
  • Capitalize on Longer-Term Growth Themes
    Consolidation, Globalization, Outsourcing
  • Marketplace Will Reward Companies with
    Outstanding Fundamentals and Growth
    Characteristics

25
QA
26
(No Transcript)
Write a Comment
User Comments (0)
About PowerShow.com