Nature and Society

1
Nature and Society
2
Nature

• Nature
• Social creation
• Physical reality
• Our understanding is necessarily social
• Our understanding changes over time and across
  space
• i.e., nature as dangerous nature as spiritual
  health
• Major concern
• human impacts on nature and the resulting
  consequences for humans

3

• Interest in society/Nature has increased
  significantly since the early 1970s
• Events
• Environmental disasters, e.g., 3-mile island
  nuclear leak, Love Canal, Cuyahoga River
  (Cleveland)
• Writings
• Rachel Carsons Silent Spring
• A book about the negative effects of pesticides

4
Recent evolution of environmental thought

• 2nd Earth Summit
• 1992, Rio de Janeiro
• Commission on Sustainable development
• Some improvement
• International monitoring institutions
• Phasing out of leaded gasoline
• Rising scientific and popular interest in
  environmental issues

5
IPAT

• Our impact on the environment
• IPAT
• I impact on Earths resources
• P population
• A affluence, as measured by per capita income
• T a technology factor

6
Nature-Society Interactions

• Technology
• Defined as
• Physical artifacts (e.g., machines)
• Activities (e.g., steelmaking)
• Knowledge or know-how (e.g., biological
  engineering)
• Affects the environment
• harvesting of resources
• wastes from the manufacturing
• wastes from the consumption

7
US Environmental Philosophies

• Judeo-Christian tradition
• Man (sic) is superior to nature
• Nature should be tamed or dominated
• Nature exists for our use
• Man (sic) as Stewart over nature
• Need to maintain a healthy environment

8
Henry David Thoreau (1817-62)

• Emphasized the interrelatedness of the natural
  world
• Food Chain Species depend upon other species to
  survive
• e.g., fish depend on flies
• Power of nature
• Might overthrow humanity if left unchecked

9
Henry David Thoreau (1817-62)

• Nature as antidote
• to the negative effects of technology on U.S.
  landscapes and character
• Romanticism
• All creatures are infused with a divine presence
• That commands respect
• And comes from humble participation in the
  natural community

10
Ralph Waldo Emerson

• Transcendentalism
• People should rise above nature and the
  limitations of the body
• To where the spirit dominates the flesh
• Mystical and spiritual life replaces the
  primitive and savage one

11
George Perkins Marsh

• Humans are significant agents in environmental
  change
• Conservation
• Natural resources should be used wisely
• We should be good Stewarts of the environment
• Preservation
• Certain species, habitats and resources should
  remain off-limits to humans
• Irrespective of the resource value

12
The Ancient Cross Timbers
Cross Timbers (red) and Post Oak Savanna (green)
forest types along the eastern margin of the
southern Great Plains.
13
Contemporary Environmental Groups

• Conservation oriented
• Environmental defense fund
• World watch institute
• Nature conservancy
• Sierra club
• Tactics
• Work within the law

• Preservation
• Earth First
• Tactics
• Extralegal
• E.g., spiking trees

14
Greenpeace

• Greenpeace
• Focus on environmental polluters
• International in scope
• Combines both legal and extra-legal strategies

15
Other ideas of nature

• Environmental Ethics
• Society has a moral obligation to treat nature
  according to the rules of moral behavior that
  exist for treating human beings
• Animals, vegetation, rocks etc. have certain
  rights that are independent of us

16
Other ideas of nature

• Patriarchy
• Social ideas that value men more highly than
  women is the root cause of our environmental
  problems
• Deep ecology
• Self realization humans must recognize that we
  are part of the non-human world
• Biospherical egalitarianism the biosphere is
  the central focus of all life and all its
  components deserve respect

17
Other ideas of nature

• Environmental Justice
• The geography of pollution is the result of the
  structural inequities of society
• Where do we locate the polluting factory?
• Or the landfill?
• Or the highway?
• Or the light rail line?