Title: IW SMART MANUFACTURING CONFERENCE SMART GLOBALIZATION
1IW SMART MANUFACTURING CONFERENCESMART
GLOBALIZATIONSTRATEGIC GLOBAL SITING
- Moderator Anand Sharma, TBM Consulting Group
- Panel Paul Adelberg, Hayward Pool
Products - Ron Hicks, Lantech Inc.
(A/O) May 04 - Keith Bernard, Applica
Inc. - June 14, 2004
2THE GLOBAL MANUFACTURING LANDSCAPE IN 2004
FACTORS BEARING ON THE PROBLEM
- POLITICAL, ECONOMIC, SOCIAL TENSION
- EMPOWERED CONSUMER
- ACCESS TO ON-LINE COMMERCE
- DEMANDING CUSTOMIZATION
- SEEKING NEXT GENERATION PRODUCTS NOW!
- COST, QUALITY, RESPONSIVENESS TRADE OFFS
- EROSION OF MASS PRODUCTION AS WE KNEW IT
- METAMORPHOSIS IN SOURCED NATIONS COST V/S
PARTICIPATION
3OUTSOURCING IS TOP OF MIND EVERYONES LOOKING
FOR ANSWERS
- Outsourcing is the economic topic du jour.
While there is plenty of talk about the concept
of outsourcing, fewer are stories about how
manufacturers actually do it. - The Manufacturer, April 2004
- Maytag dishwashers have Chinese motors, Mexican
wiring and are assembled in an American factory.
Some refer to this manufacturing approach as a
triad strategy. - The Wall Street Journal, Oct. 6, 2003
- Outsourcing shows no signs of fading. The surge
in offshore outsourcing has attracted the
attention of American politicians worried about
the loss of jobs at home - The New York Times, May 9, 2004
4DYNAMIC STRATEGIC TRIAD
? ? ?
U.S. EUROPE
KEY SITING FACTORS TO CONSIDER???
ASIA
MEXICO
? ? ?
? ? ?
5KEY SITING FACTORS ?
- ? ?
- ORGANIC EXTERNAL
- ? ? PRODUCT/PART COMPLEXITY ? DEMAND
- ? LEAD TIME/JIT PRESSURES ? CURRENCY
FLUCTUATION - ? DEGREE OF CUSTOMIZATION/ ? WORKFORCE
ELEVATION - LOCALIZATION FACTOR
- ? STABILIZATION OF WORKFORCE ? X FACTORS
(DOCK STRIKES, - TERROR, WAR, TYPHOON)
- ? ? COMPETITIVE
PRESSURES - ?
-
- ? ? ?
?
62001 Gross National Product (US billions)
- USA 10,082 Growth (01/99) 8.7
- Germany 1,846 Growth (01/99) -12.2
- UK 1,424 Growth (01/99) -2.3
- France 1,310 Growth (01/99) -9.3
- China 1,159 Growth (01/99) 17
- Mexico 618 Growth (01/99) 28.8
- Brazil 504 Growth (01/99) -9.2
- India 481 Growth (01/99) 18.5
7Total Hourly Compensation
- Country 1995 2001 Change
- Germany 30.27 22.86 -25
- USA 17.19 20.32 18
- Brazil 5.61(98) 3.02 -43
- Mexico 1.65 2.34 42
- India 0.50 0.61 22
- China 0.41 0.40 -2
- Source US dept. of labor (Other for India
China)
8Global Triad Sourcing Strategy
Labor/Hour .40-.60 Range
Labor/HOUR 2-4 Range
Labor/Hour 12-20 RANGE
Low Cube, Low Value, High Labor Content, High
Design Stability and Mature Products Mature
(Garden Variety) Components
Medium Cube, Value and Labor Content, Medium
Design Stability and Semi custom Products Sub
Assemblies with High Variety
High Cube, High Value, Low Labor, Mass
Customization ( Highly custom / New Products ),
Typically Low Volume High Variety
9STRATEGIC GLOBAL SITING
- EVOLVING WISDOM
- TWO, THREE OR FOUR-WAY STREET
- GLOBAL TRIAD INSURANCE POLICY?
- LEAN VALUE CHAINS GOING LOCAL MAKING AND
SELLING IN MULTIPLE VENUES - SOLUTION MUST BE TAILORED TO PRODUCT/MARKET
- MUST BE AGILE AND CREATIVE
10WHOS GETTING IT RIGHT?
- DELL
- MAYTAG
- TOYOTA
- APPLICA (Panelist)
- HAYWARD (Panelist)
- LANTECH (Panelist)
11It is not the strongest of species that survive,
nor the most intelligent but the ones most
responsive to change
Charles Darwin
Circa 1859 origin of
species
12PANEL OF OUTSOURCING VETERANSLessons in Global
Sourcing China, Mexico, the World
- PAUL ADELBERG -- HAYWARD POOL PRODUCTS
- RON HICKS -- LANTECH
- KEITH BERNARD -- APPLICA INC.
13OVERVIEW
- FOUNDED 1923
- LEADING MANUFACTURER OF FILTRATION SYSTEMS AND
FLUID CONTROL EQUIPMENT - MANUFACTURING FACILITIES IN EUROPE, NORTH
AMERICA, SOUTH AMERICA, ASIA
14OUTSOURCING MOTIVATION
- SEVERE PRICE PRESSURE
- KNOCK-OFFS COUNTERFEITERS
- PROTECT HAYWARD MARKET SHARE
- INITIALLY PURELY DEFENSIVE!
15OUTSOURCING STRATEGY
- GAIN CONFIDENCE FROM IN-HOUSE SALES STAFF AND
CUSTOMERS - DUPLICATE TOOLING NO INTERRUPTION OF SERVICE
- NO DEVIATIONS FROM EXISTING B/M
- PRODUCT TRANSPARENT TO OUR CUSTOMERS
- ESTABLISH BASELINE SAVINGS CRITERIA
- OUTSOURCING PRODUCT CRITERIA
- LIMIT PRODUCTS TO A ITEMS ONLY
- LONG LIFE-CYCLE
- NO IMMINENT ENGINEERING CHANGES
- LOW CUBE, LABOR INTENSIVE (WE THOUGHT)
16ACTION PLAN FOR CHINA SUPPLIERS
- VISIT HAYWARD TOP MANAGERS
- OBSERVE AND REPLICATE MANUFACTURING PROCESSES
- TRAIN CHINA PERSONNEL IN STANDARD WORK
- SUPPLY CAPABILITY REPORTS
17ACTION PLAN AT HAYWARD
- VISIT VENDOR PLANTS IN CHINA
- TRAINING SESSIONS
- PRODUCTS USE STANDARD WORK AND HAYWARD STANDARDS
- TEST EQUIPMENT DUPLICATED AND SUPPLIED TO CHINA
VENDORS - ARRANGED AND NEGOTIATED WITH U.S. SUPPLIERS TO
SUPPLY AND SERVICE CHINA VENDORS
18ACTION PLAN AT HAYWARD (CONTD)
- USE INDEPENDENT THIRD-PARTY INSPECTION COMPANY
INITIALLY ON ALL PRODUCTS - KAIZEN EVENT WITH OUTSOURCE TEAM
- WRITE STANDARD WORK FLOWCHART
- GENERATE RFQ
- REQUEST FOR QUOTE CHECK LIST
19RESULTS
- OPPORTUNITIES
- USE IDLED CAPACITY FOR GROWTH NO ADDITIONAL
CAPITAL - FORCING U.S. PLANTS TO BE INNOVATIVE BY APPLYING
LEAN PRINCIPLES TO DRIVE DOWN COSTS REDUCING
OUTSOURCING
20LANTECH INC.--COMPANY SITUATION
- PRIVATELY HELD PACKAGING EQUIPMENT COMPANY
- PRODUCT DRIVEN, MARKET LEADER
- GROWING NUMBER OF COMPETITORS MOVING INTO NORTH
AMERICAN MARKET - DESPITE AGGRESSIVE WASTE REDUCTION PROGRAM
DECLINING MARGINS - VISION TO BECOME GLOBAL LEADERS IN INDUSTRY
21OUTSOURCING ACTIONS
- CONDUCTED RESEARCH AND INITIATED DIRECT MATERIAL
PROCUREMENT FROM COUNTRIES AND REGIONS WHERE BEST
PRODUCTS (MATERIAL) AVAILABLE AT BEST VALUE - INITIATIVE BEGAN 18 MONTHS AGO
- CHINA PRIMARY TARGET
22ISSUES
- WHICH COUNTRIES PROVIDE THE BEST VALUES ON A
COMMODITY-BY-COMMODITY BASIS - WHAT REGIONS WITHIN A COUNTRY ARE THE BEST
CHOICES FOR SOURCING COUNTRIES ARE NOT
HOMOGENOUS - DISCOVERY PROCESS URGENT
23SOURCING SITE CONSIDERATIONS
- PRICE ? TIME ZONE
- LOGISTICS ? WARM HEART
- CULTURE ? FLEXIBILITY
- TECHNICAL EXPERTISE ? CREATIVITY
- CAPACITY ? GOVERNMENT INCENTIVES
- POLITICAL PREDICTABILITY
24SUMMARY
- DIG DEEP
- GO TO EXPERTISE AND CAPACITY
- LOOK FOR THE WARM HEART
- COUNT ALL COSTS
25Applica Overview
- Applica manufacturer and marketer of branded
small electric appliances and innovations to
include kitchen , home , pet , pest and personal
care products.
Sales Revenue/ 2003 640 mm NYSE APN
Retail Brands
Professional Brands
26(No Transcript)
27Out Sourcing Experience
28Lessons Learned
- Keep Abreast of the Global Manufacturing
Environment - - Things Change
- Choose Your Suppliers Wisely
- - Or you may find that your are doing their job
- Develop and Communicate a Cross- Functional Plan
- - Or Things will get out of Control Quickly
- For ApplicaWe intend to maintain dual
manufacturing locations. - - China and Mexico
-