IEEE 802.11 TGv November Agenda

1
IEEE 802.11 TGv November Agenda

• Date 2007-11-15

Authors
2
Abstract

• This presentation contains the IEEE 802.11 TGv
  agenda and motions for November 2007.

3
TGv November 2007

• Call Meeting to Order
• Policies and Procedures, Attendance reminder
  http//newton.events.ieee.org
• IEEE Patent Policy http//standards.ieee.org/bo
  ard/pat/pat-slideset.ppt
• Are there any patent claim(s)/patent application
  claim(s) and/or the holder of patent
  claim(s)/patent application claim(s) that the
  participant believes may be essential for the use
  of that standard? Minute any responses that were
  given, specifically the patent claim(s)/patent
  application claim(s) and/or the holder of the
  patent claim(s)/patent application claim(s) that
  were identified (if any) and by whom.
• Affiliation FAQ - http//standards.ieee.org/fa
  qs/affiliationFAQ.html
• Anti-Trust FAQ - http//standards.ieee.org/resour
  ces/antitrust-guidelines.pdf
• Ethics - http//www.ieee.org/portal/cms_docs/abou
  t/CoE_poster.pdf
• IEEE 802.11 Policies and Procedures -
  http//www.ieee802.org/11/DocFiles/06/11-06-0812-0
  3-0000-802-11-policies-and-proceedures.htm
• IEEE 802 Policies and Procedures -
  http//www.ieee802.org/policies-and-procedures.pdf
  

Read slide deck Note especially items 7
11
4
TGv Agenda

• Monday 930 1100 (Ad-hoc)
• Call to Order, IP info, query
• Comment Resolution TIM Broadcast

• Wednesday 1600 1800
• Comment Resolution- General (Clause 5) M.
  Montemurro
• Comment Resolution - Event
• (30) 07-2636 Jamming Co-located Interference

• Monday 1600 1800
• Approve Agenda
• Chairs Welcome, Status, Review of Objectives
• Motions Approve Waikoloa, telecon, ad-hoc
  minutes
• Comment Resolution TIM Broadcast
• Comment Resolution
• (30) 07-2684 Overlapping BSS Proposal, G. Smith

• Thursday 800 1000
• Comment Resolution Co-located Interference
• Comment Resolution Traffic Generation
• Comment Resolution STA Statistics
• (30) 07-2710 Channel Allocation E. Qi CID 102

• Thursday 1030 1230
• Straw Poll on 07-2737
• Comment Resolution STA Statistics

• Tuesday 1030 1230
• Comment Resolution Diagnostics, Virtual AP

• Thursday 1330 1530
• Comment Resolution
• Motions
• Plans for January
• TIM Element Qi
• Adjourn

• Tuesday 1600 1800
• Motions Adopt 1.02, resolutions from telecons,
  ad-hoc
• Comment Resolution Event

(estimated time)
Attendance reminder http//newton/ for each
timeslot Documents https//mentor.ieee.org/8
02.11/documents
5
November Meeting Status Objectives

• TGv Status
• Draft 1.02 available, incorporates editorial
  comment, resolutions approved in September
• LB 108 Comments available in 11-07-2368
• November Meeting Objectives
• Comment Resolution
• Hear Presentations
• Progress towards Letter Ballot

6
Documents for 07/2368 comment resolution
Based on proposed resolutions agreed to on con
calls and ad-hoc
7
TGv Schedule History

• Wireless Network Management SG formed Jan 2004
• Wireless Networks Management TG formed Nov 2004
• Call for proposals Sept 2005
• Base line accepted - January 06
• Submissions addressing objectives - Started in
  March 06
• TG Ad-Hoc Draft Internal Review - October 06 to
  present
• Internal review of Draft 0.05 446 comments
  (06/1615)
• Internal review of Draft 0.08 95 comments
  (07/0310)
• Internal review of Draft 0.10 - 281 comments
  (07/0594)
• LB 108 Results 132 yes -77 no -38 abstain, 63
  approval, needs 75, fails
• Comments in 11-07-2368

8
TGv D1.0 Content Summary

• BSS Transition Management for Network Load
  Balancing
• Co-located Interference Reporting
• Diagnostic Reporting
• Event Reporting
• Flexible Broadcast/Multicast service
• Multicast Diagnostics Reporting
• Multiple BSSID Support
• Multiple SSID
• Proxy ARP
• Presence and Location
• TIM Broadcast
• TFS
• Sleep Mode
• Approximately 180 Pages of content

9
TGv Timeline Updated May 17, 2007

• Initial Working Group Letter Ballot July 07 -
  completed
• Re-circulation Working Group Letter Ballot
  January 08
• Form Sponsor Ballot Pool July 08
• Initial Sponsor Ballot September 08
• Re-circulation Sponsor Ballot November 08
• Final WG/EC Approval May 09
• Final WC Approval July 09
• RevCom/Standards Board Approval September 09
• IEEE Publish October 09

10
Known January Presentations

• 11-07-xxxx

11
Discussion- Ad-hoc follow-up

• CID 93, 1370 (TFS)
• CID 258, 927, 928, 929 (TFS) Why is the
  optimization of including the elements needed?
  Saves a frame exchange.
• Propose to remove the TFS and Sleep Mode element
  from re-association.
• Discuss removing additional elements from
  re-association in Atlanta.
• Atlanta discussion Most elements in these frames
  are related to capabilities. Makes sense to
  remove FBMS Request, TFS, Sleep Mode Check with
  Menzo on TIM Broadcast
• CID 1191 (General) Too many IEs
• Already proposed to move Event Request, Event
  Response, Diagnostics Request and Report
  Potentially also FBMS Request, FBMS Response, TFS
  Request, Response, Depending on discussion above
• Atlanta discussion The TG should not engineer an
  amendment-specific solution to the eventual
  exhaustion of the element ID space. The
  resolution is straightforward, last value/bit is
  a special bit, next octet is for expansion.
  Decline.
• CID 1520, 1671, 1846 (Sleep Mode) 1000TUs or
  seconds
• CID 1949, 1426, 817, 1399, 1498, 1649, 1824
  (Presence)
• Traffic Generation CIDs 1565, 1720, 1891
  similar
• Annex CID 224 MIB variable applies to
  Neighbor Report, or to Neighbor Report Element?

12
January Meeting Planning

• Objectives
• LB 108 Comment Resolution
• Hear Presentations
• Letter Ballot on Draft 2.0
• Conference Call(s)
• Ad-Hoc meeting

13
Motion 1

• Move to adopt the agenda in 11-07-2728-01-000v-Nov
  ember-2007-agenda.
• Mover Unanimous
• Seconder
• Result

14
Motion 2

• Move to approve the meeting minutes in
  11-07-2475-02-000v-minutes-tgv-Waikoloa-meeting-se
  p-07.
• Mover Emily Qi
• Seconder Qi Wang
• Result Unanimous

15
Motion 3

• Move to approve the meeting minutes in
  11-07-2626-03-000v-TGv-Oct-Nov-07-telecon-meeting-
  notes, 11-07-2721-01-000v-Nov-07-ad-hoc-meeting-n
  otes, and 11-07-2818-00-000v-minutes-tgv-atlanta-m
  eeting-nov-07-mon-ad-hoc
• Mover Allan Thomson
• Seconder Menzo Wentink
• Result Unanimous

16
Motion 4

• Move to adopt TGv Draft 1.02 as the TGv draft.
• Mover Emily Qi
• Seconder Qi Wang
• Result Unanimous

17
Motion 5 (Adopt resolutions agreed to at con
calls and ad-hoc)

• Move to adopt the comment resolutions for
  comments indicated below, and include the
  indicated text changes into the TGv draft.
• 07-2634-01 (Annex) CIDs 219, 220, 225, 254,
  270, 552, 553, 1398
• O7-2498-02 (Event) All accepted
• 07-2558 -02 (FBMS) All accepted, counter
  and declined
• 07-2525-04 (General) CIDs 1290. 1285, 1282,
  1321, 1406, 1584, 1433, 1230, 1141, 1153
• 07-2559-02 (Presence) - All accepted, counter
  and declined
• 07-2484-01 (Proxy ARP) CIDs 1261, 1532, 1684,
  1858, 1988
• 07-2533-03 (Roaming Management) CIDs 98, 462,
  465, 471, 645, 665, 753, 918, 919, 947, 952,1004,
  974, 1033, 1036, 1064, 1067, 1166, 1178, 1359,
  1363, 1353, 1405
• 07-2561-04 (Sleep Mode) CIDs 170, 328, 355, 489,
  495, 502, 505, 510, 546, 590, 693, 763, 764, 810,
  879, 934, 945, 1029, 1108, 1190, 1896, 1201,
  1380, 1434, 1585, 1957, 1960, 1961, 1962, 1989
• 07-2712-03 (TFS) - All accepted, counter and
  declined
• 07-2625-03 (Virtual AP) 59, 108, 128, 164, 165,
  214, 872, 234, 884, 949, 950, 951, 1006, 1191,
  1204, 1256, 276, 283, 360, 443, 608, 620, 623,
  624, 625, 627
• Mover Emily Qi
• SeconderAllan Thomson
• Result 10-1-3

18
Motion 6

• Move to adopt the TIM Broadcast category
  accepted, counter and declined comment
  resolutions in 11-07-2789-06-000v-proposed-comment
  -resolutions-for-tim-broadctas, except for CIDs
  1537, 1539, 1692, 1694, 1863, 1865, and in CID
  2006, change from 1-256 to 0-255 and in CID
  196, change the resolution to Declined and
  include the indicated text changes into the TGv
  draft.
• Mover Menzo Wentink
• Seconder Emily Qi
• Result 13-0-6 Passes

19
Motion 7

• Move to adopt the TIM Broadcast category
  comment resolutions in 11-07-2789-06-000v-proposed
  -comment-resolutions-for-tim-broadctas, for CIDs
  1537, 1539, 1692, 1694, 1863, 1865 and include
  the indicated text changes into the TGv draft.
• Mover Menzo Wentink
• Seconder Allan Thomson
• Result 12-0-5 Passes

20
Motion 8

• Move to adopt the following Event category
  comment resolutions in 11-07-2498-03-000v-LB-108-E
  vent-comment-resolutions, and include the
  indicated text changes into the TGv draft.
• CIDs 110, 394, 779, 780, 1044, 1143, 1173, 1937,
  1941, 111, 113, 114, 115, 205, 384, 801, 802,
  900, 901, 1115, 1174, 1234, 1263, 1264, 802,
  1012, 1263, 1265, 1270, 1331, 1408, 1413, 1549,
  1550, 1551, 1704, 1705, 1706, 1875, 1876, 1877
• Mover Jiyoung Huh
• Seconder Emily Qi
• Result 10-0-2 Passes

21
Motion 9

• Move to adopt the following Diagnostics
  category comment resolutions in
  11-07-2729-01-000v-lb-108-comment-resolutions-diag
  nostics, and include the indicated text changes
  into the TGv draft.
• CIDs 8, 57, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 150, 151, 152,
  154, 157, 203, 206, 210, 211, 267, 289, 310, 311,
  312, 319, 329, 335, 398, 601, 649, 651, 652, 655,
  686, 687, 688, 1116, 1423, 1199, 1243
• Mover Alex Ashley
• Seconder Emily Qi
• Result 8-0-4 Passes

22
Motion 10

• Move to adopt the following Co-located
  Interfence category comment resolutions in
  11-07-2506-03-000v-LB108-comment-resolutions
  co-located interference, and include the
  indicated text changes into the TGv draft.
• CID 592, 611, 612, 613, 614, 785, 911, 994, 995,
  1128, 1129, 1278, 1279, 1431, 1432, 1728, 1731,
  1732, 1735, 1737, 1738, 1739, 1741
• Mover Emily Qi
• Seconder Menzo Wentink
• Result 10-0-6 Passes

23
Motion 11

• Move to adopt the following Co-located
  Interfence category comment resolutions in
  11-07-2506-03-000v-LB108-comment-resolutions
  co-located interference, and include the
  indicated text changes into the TGv draft.
• CID 1034
• Mover Allan Thomson
• Seconder Menzo Wentink
• Result 6-3-7 Motion Fails

24
Motion 12

• Move to resolve CIDs 130, 172, 175, 362, 363,
  1037, 1191, 1237, 1255 with the following
  resolution
• Declined. The elements currently defined are
  either included in multiple frames, or could be
  included in additional frames in the future. When
  extension to the element ID space is needed, a
  mechanism such as that used for the Extended
  Capability element can be introduced, and will
  apply to all ongoing and future amendments.
• Mover Alex Ashley
• Seconder Emily Qi
• Result 10-2-7 Motion passes

25
Motion 13

• Move to resolve CID 9 in the Diagnostics
  category comment resolutions, with accepted,
  and a resolution of include the text changes in
  11-07-2876-01-000v-Proposed-resolution-to-CID-9
  into the TGv draft.
• Mover Alex Ashley
• Seconder Bob Miller
• Result 6-5-6 Fails

26
Motion 14

• Move to adopt the TFS category CID 93, 1370
  comment resolutions, in 11-07-2712-04-000v-lb-108-
  comment-resolutions_TFS, and include the
  indicated text changes into the TGv draft.
• Mover Emily Qi
• Seconder Allan Thomson
• Result 9-0-4 Passes

27
Motion 15

• Move to adopt the following Multicast
  Diagnostics category comment resolutions in
  11-07-2509-03-000v-LB108 Multicast Diagnostics
  comment resolutions, and include the indicated
  text changes into the TGv draft.
• CID 586, 610, 799, 1545, and in the 11.20.1 text
  for CID 1545, change shall send to sends
• Mover Alex Ashley
• Seconder Emily Qi
• Result 9-0-4 Passes

28
Motion 16

• Move to instruct the editor to create TGv draft
  1.03 incorporating all changes to TGv draft D
  1.02 approved at the November 2007 meeting.
• Mover Allan Thomson
• Seconder Qi Wang
• Result 18-0-1 Passes

29
Motion 17

• Move to authorize
• A TGv ad-hoc meeting January 11,12 (Fri-Sat) 2008
  in Taipei.
• Mover Alex Ashley
• Seconder Qi Wang
• Result 2-1-13

30
Motion 18

• Move to authorize
• TGv Teleconferences on November 29, December 6,
  December 13, at 1400 Eastern for 2 hours.
• December 18 2007, January 3, January 10, 2008 at
  1800 Eastern for 2 hours
• Mover Emily Qi
• Seconder Qi Wang
• Result Unanimous

31
Motion

• Move to adopt the STA Statistics category
  accepted, counter and declinedcomment
  resolutions in 11-07-2501-02-000v-lb 108 comment
  resolution, and include the indicated text
  changes into the TGv draft.
• Mover
• Seconder
• Result

32
Motion

• Move to incorporate normative text from
  11-07-xxxx-xx-000v-name into the TGv draft.
• Mover
• Seconder
• Result

33
Motion

• Move to adopt the comment resolutions in
  11-07-0xxx-01-000v-tgv-description for CID and
  incorporate the indicated text changes into the
  TGv Draft.
• Mover
• Seconder
• Result

34
Motion

• Believing that the TGv draft D1.02 and all
  motions and resolutions adopted during the
  Atlanta plenary will satisfy all 802.11 WG rules
  for letter ballot, Moved,
• To instruct the editor to create D1.03
  incorporating all approved motions and
  resolutions,
• To request the 802.11 WG chair to conduct a
  15-day confirmation ballot on D1.03,
• To request the 802.11 Working Group to renumber
  TGv Draft D1.03, if the confirmation ballot
  succeeds, as D2.0 and authorize a 30-day Letter
  Ballot asking the question Should TGv draft D1.0
  be forwarded to Sponsor Ballot?
• Mover
• Seconder
• Result

35
Motion

• Believing that the TGv draft 2.0 will satisfy all
  IEEE 802.11 WG rules for letter ballot, Moved,
• To request that the IEEE 802.11 Working Group
  authorize a 30-day Working Group Letter Ballot on
  Draft P802.11v D2.0.
• Mover
• Seconder
• Result

36
Straw Poll

• TGv should hold the authorized ad-hoc before the
  January meeting
• Yes 1
• No 5
• Chair asked for guidance, as interest was very
  low. Authorized ad-hoc will not be held.

37
Straw Poll

• The xxx requirement should
• Remain in progress yellow
• Be marked as No progress clear
• Move to inactive list

38
Straw Poll

• I prefer the following resolution to CID 1520,
  1671 and 1846.
• Option 1 The Max Idle Period field indicates the
  time period during which a STA  refrains from
  transmitting frames to its associated AP without
  being disassociated. The time period is specified
  in units of 1000TUs.
• Option 2 The Max Idle Period field indicates the
  time period during which a STA  refrains from
  transmitting frames to its associated AP without
  being disassociated. The time period is specified
  in units of seconds.
• Option 1
• Option 2
• Abstain

39
Straw Poll - 1

• I prefer the following approach for 07-2710
  Channel Allocation for P2P
• Option 1Via Beacon/Probe Response - 8
• Option 2 Via Public Action frame -3
• Option 3 Option 1 Option 2 - 4

40
Straw Poll -2

• Do you support the idea of enhancing the current
  TGv co-located interference reporting mechanism
  to consider the impact of co-located jamming
  interference?
• Yes - 10
• No - 7

41
Straw Poll - 3

• Would you like to see a normative text proposal
  that has clear definition of
• co-located jamming interference,
• Yes, 7 No 3
• explicit indication of co-located jamming
  interference
• Yes, 4 No 7
• channel access procedure after the jamming
  interference?
• Yes, 3 No 9
• All 3 listed above
• Yes, 5 No 8

42
Straw Poll - 4

• Would you like to see a specification of the
  minimum delay between the end of jamming
  interference and the start of frame transmission
  from the reporting STA?
• Yes 4
• No 8

43
References