Title: Pricing and Revenue Management
1- Pricing and Revenue Management
2Les Miserables
- The duty of the innkeeper is to sell to the first
comer, food, rest, light, fire, dirty linen,
servants, fleas, and smiles to charge for the
open window, the closed window, the chimney
corner, the sofa, the chair, the stool, the
bench, the feather bed, the mattress, and the
straw bed to know how much the mirror is worn
and to tax that and by five hundred thousand
devils, to make the traveler pay for everything,
even the fleas that is dog eats.
3Objective of this section
- Understand steps to better pricing
- Understand Competitive Value Analysis
- Review basics of revenue management
- Understand price customization
- Understand Value
4The Challenge of PricingTaxi
5There is no easy way to find out what the actual
true price of any car is. Oh sure, there is a
sticker price, but only a very naïve fungal
creature just arrived from a distant galaxy
would dream of paying this. In fact, federal
law now requires that the following statement
appear directly under the sticker price
WARNING TO STUPID PEOPLE DO NOT PAY THIS AMOUNT
-- Dave Barry
6 Assume that you go to make a reservation at the
luxury hotel you are loyal to and you find out
that they are charging you 50 per night more
than they usually do because they have only a few
rooms left. Please answer each of the questions
based on this knowledge.
- 60.3 claimed they definitely would ask about the
room rate the next time they made a reservation - 35.7 claimed they would definitely check rates
at other properties the next time they planned to
visit this hotel
7Steps to Better Pricing
- Assess what value your customers place on a
product or service - How to create value
- What is the economic value of this product or
service to customers - Case study on Coca-Cola
- Look for variation in the way customers value the
product - Do customers vary in their intensity of use
- Do customers use the product differently
- Does product performance matter more to some
customers, even if the application is the same
8Steps to Better Pricing
- Look for variation in the way customers value the
product - continued - How do differences in both perceived value and
non value factors influence price sensitivity and
divide customers into market segments - How can members of different segments be
identified prior to purchase - How can fences between segments be established
- How can the firm avoid violating legal constraints
9Steps to Better Pricing
- Assess customers price sensitivity
- - How could an effective marketing and
positioning strategy influence the
customers willingness to pay - - Market research techniques using Excel
- - Behavioral aspects of pricing
- Identify an optimal pricing structure
- Bundle pricing
10Steps to Better Pricing
- Consider competitors reactions
- Who are key current and potential competitors
- If competitors are currently in this market, what
actual transactional prices do they charge - Given competitors past behavior, personalities,
and organization structures, what is their goal
in pricing
11Steps to Better Pricing
- Consider competitors reactions - continued
- What are competitors strengths and weaknesses
relative to the firm - How might a firm use information to influence
competitors behavior in ways that would make its
goals more achievable or profitable
12Steps to Better Pricing
- Monitor prices realized at the transaction level
- - pricing across different channels
- Assess customers emotional response
- Analyze whether the returns are worth the cost to
serve
13Steps to Better Pricing
- Understand costs
- What is the incremental variable cost of sales
- At what levels of output will additional
expenditures on semi-fixed costs be required, and
how much will they be - What are the avoidable (not yet sunk) fixed costs
involved to offer this product at the proposed
price
14Steps to Better Pricing
- Understand Supply
- Cost structure
- Capacity utilization
- Product perishability
- Extent of product differentiation
- Number and diversity of competitors
- Impact of sales volume on cost
15Steps to Better Pricing
- Understand Demand
- Price sensitivity of selective demand
- Efficiency of price shopping
- Degree of brand loyalty
- Industry growth rate
- Buyer concentration
- Complementary product
16Steps to Better Pricing
- Understand Distribution Channels
17- Competitor Analysis and Positioning Key to
Pricing
18Index of Competitive Strength
The competitive advantages and disadvantages
which are shown in the matrix of competitive
advantages can be condensed into one single
index, the index of competitive strength. All
relative performances of the product on the
individual factors are weighted with their
importance and summed up.
19Example Importance Question
- Next, please think for a moment about the reason
for visiting a specific hotel in Las Vegas for
gambling. Please tell me how important each
reason is for you in your decision to visit one
specific property over another. Please use a 1
to 10 scale, where a 1 means the reason is not
at all important and a 10 means the reason is
very important in your decision to choose one
establishment over another for gambling. You may
use any number on this 1 to 10 scale. - Ask questions in random order
- How important is_______________in your decision
to choose one place to visit over another? - It is a place my friends like to go
20Example Attitude Question
- Now I am going to read you a list of features
that may or may not describe some of the hotels
in the Las Vegas area. Well use a 1 to 10
scale, where a 1 means it does not describe the
hotel at all and a 10 means describes the hotel
perfectly. If you have not been to the hotel
personally, please base your answers on what you
have heard, or what you believe to be true. - Ask questions in random order
- How well does this feature describe(brand to be
rated)? - It is a place my friends like to go
21Calculation of Competitive Index
- Sum the importance ratings for all features and
multiply by the number of scale points. (The
numbers are in column A in Table on next page) - For each attribute, multiple average importance x
average performance. Answers in Column C - Sum all numbers in column C
- Calculate the CSI as -- Total C/Total in A
- Repeat steps for competitor's see columns D and
E
22Calculation of Competitive Index
23Matrix of Competitive Advantages
Example Casino
high
Slot Club
Friendly Staff
Value of Promotions
Brand
Feel Safe
Service
Package
Level of Importance
Price
Good Entertainment
Non Smoking
low
Relative Performance
24Steps to Developing a Positioning Strategy
- Identify the competitors
- From customers point of view
- Different competitors in different segments
25Best Way to Define True Competitors
- Ask 50 100 customers at check-in, If you did
not stay here tonight, where would you stay? - Those hotels who, if they took a pricing action,
would force you to take a pricing action - Where do you currently walk guests?
26Best Way to Define True Competitors
- Based upon a definition of the core customer
different competitors for different segments - Avoid emotional opinions
27Steps to Developing a Positioning Strategy
- Determine how the competitors are perceived and
evaluated - Determine the competitors positions
- Critical to also have reference points for data
analysis
28- Identify competitive set
- Upper tier member of competitive market with a
rate premium above our hotel - Direct tier member of our competitive market,
with a rate price point approximately equal to
our hotel - Lower tier member of our competitive market,
with a rate price point below our hotel
29- Calculate for your three core customers in all
three competitive tiers a total of nine analysis - Three core customers
- Business transient
- Pleasure transient
- Group customer
- Thee competitive tiers
- Upper tier
- Direct tier
- Lower tier
30- Conduct competitive pricing analysis
- Shops for
- Local hotel reservations office
- Hotel 800 number
- GDS system
- Internet
- Shop for leisure peak, leisure non-peak, business
peak, business non-peak, group peak, and group
non-peak
31- Use chart to plot each competitors overall value
- Horizontal axis plot each competitors overall
value assessment - Vertical axis plot each competitors lowest
available retail rate obtained via blind shop - Center axis your hotel with rate equal to lowest
available retail price point
32(No Transcript)
33 53.16 Caesar
189
47.91 Bally
185
180
179
59.97 Rio
63.92 Boulder
43.41 Circus Circus
159
54.3 Fiesta
155
52.07 Excalibur
140
34Creating Loyalty (44)
Process
Exit
Exit
Exit
Value (Added and Recovery)
Communication
Exit
Fluid
35Value-Based Pricing
- Involves choosing a price after developing
estimates of market demand based on how potential
customers perceive the value of the product or
service. - Can satisfy diverse product strategies,
including, for example, market penetration or
profit maximization. - Should be the preferred pricing methodology
36Question Where Would You Buy Gas?
Station A Sells gasoline for 2.30 per gallon,
and gives a 0.10 discount if the buyer pays
with cash. Station B Sells gasoline for 2.20
per gallon, and charges a 0.10 surcharge if
the buyer pays with a credit card.
37Examples
- Which do you choose? A____ or B____
- A. Receive 50
- B. 55 chance of receiving 100 45 chance of
earning nothing
38Examples
- Which do you choose? C____ or D____
- C. Loose 20
- D. 20 chance of loosing 100 80
- chance of losing nothing
39Answer to Previous Question Pertains to Prospect
Theory
40Daniel Kahneman Toasting Noble Prize
41Prospect Theory Basic Idea
- Value is associated not with actual levels of
consumption, but with anticipated changes in well
being - Buyer assesses prospective decision outcomes
(prospects) by mentally categorizing them as
either gains or losses relative to reference point
42Explanation
- Station A sets reference point at 2.30 and then
rewards buyers who pay cash that is a gain
relative to the reference point - Station B first establishes a reference point at
- 2.20 and then penalizes buyers who use credit
cards a loss relative to the reference point - This is in contrast to economic theory that
predicts that gains and losses of equal size are
valued the same
43Positive Value
Value Function
Station A (2.30 0.10)
1.0
Gains
Losses
1.6
Reference Point (state of well being)
Station B (2.20 .10)
Negative Value
44Examples
- Which do you choose? A____ or B____
- A. Receive 50
- B. 55 chance of receiving 100 45 chance of
earning nothing - Which do you choose? C____ or D____
- C. Loose 20
- D. 20 chance of loosing 100 80
- chance of loosing nothing
45Answer
- If you chose A in Question 1, then you should
choose C in Question 2 - If you chose B in Question 1, then you should
choose D in Question 2 - How many had a reversal?
46Rationale for Answers
- Prospect theory states that people are risk
adverse (e.g., conservative) when considering
gains in contrast, more naturally inclined to
risk a loss than to pay even the expected value
of avoiding it.
47Positive Value
Value Function
Gains
Losses
Reference Point (state of well being)
Negative Value
48Economic Theory versus Prospect Theory
- Economic Theory
- Gains and losses of equal size treated the same
(e.g., 100 gain to 100 loss)
- Prospect Theory
- loss judged more painful than a gain of equal
value (e.g., loss of 100 more painful than a
gain of 100)
49Economic Theory versus Prospect Theory
- Economic Theory
- People are consistent in their decision making
-
- Prospect Theory
- If people perceive they are in the gain domain,
they will act conservatively - If people are in the loss domain, they will tend
to take more risks
50Economic Theory versus Prospect Theory
- Economic
- Expected utility of uncertain outcome is weighted
by its probability
- Prospect
- Expected utility of uncertain outcome is
multiplied by a decision weight ?(p) where ? - 1. Impossible events are discarded ?(0)0
- 2. Low probabilities are over weighted while
moderate and high probabilities are under
weighted (e.g., odds of being involved in an
airline crash versus car accident)
51Prospect Theory Implications
- Increasingly larger gains are incrementally less
pleasurable (10 to 20 great 110 to 120 not as
great) - Increasingly larger losses are incrementally less
painful (and smaller losses are almost as painful
as slightly larger losses) - The displeasure associated with losing a certain
amount (e.g., of money) is generally greater than
the pleasure associated with winning the same
amount (e.g., of money)
52Implications
- Once consumers have agreed to spend a certain
amount of money, getting to pay more is easier
than one would think - Goal for is to move the reference point beyond
price to something that can gain a competitive
advantage e.g., brand, type of ingredients,
service, etc.
53Positive Value
Value Function
Gains
Losses
Reference Point (state of well being)
Negative Value
54Prospect Theory Leads to Framing
55Framing
Buyers frequently form frames of reference when
making buying decisions, and these frames of
reference in turn influence how buyers respond to
price and product information.
56Goal of Understanding Frames of Reference
1. Change the relationship between
what customers perceive they pay and what they
perceive they get in return. And manage this
relationship
57Example -1 Change the relationship between what
customers perceive they pay and what they
perceive they get in return.
- Option 1 Oliva Cameroon Cigar for 15
- Option 2 Oliva Cameroon (Figurado, 6 ½ inch x 60
ring) made by Oliva Cigar Co. Nicaragua - The Authentic Cameroon Wrapper gives this boxed
pressed figurado a pronounced aroma of nuts, with
hints of cocoa and coffee. - It is medium-bodied, but not exceedingly
strong. 15
58Example-2 Change the relationship between what
customers perceive they pay and what they
perceive they get in return.
- Option 1 Selection of teas from wooden box 1.95
- Option 2 Fresh pot of Lapsang Souchong
black-smoked tea - From the Fujian province of China, this black
tea is full ancient history and flavor! Smoky
smooth character is achieved through the smoking
process over pine and oak fires. 3.95
59Example-3 Change the relationship between what
customers perceive they pay and what they
perceive they get in return.
- Option 1 Our standard room for 240
- Option 2 Or, an upgrade to superior from for
only 15 more. -
How is a better way to write this?
60Example-4 Change the relationship between what
customers perceive they pay and what they
perceive they get in return.
- Research shows that a significant number of
consumers DO place a value on the X brand e.g.,
for a 10 premium 56 of business travelers and
38 leisure travelers are very likely to choose
Brand A - Goal is to concentrate not on the price, but the
components of the brand that consumers desire - Give customer choice
61Example-5 Change the relationship between what
customers perceive they pay and what they
perceive they get in return.
- Focus on the features of the menu item that are
different from what consumer can buy at home
e.g., Kobe beef
62Ways To Frame Purchase Decisions
- Structure transactions to reflect gains and
avoid losses - Present price last after descriptions
- endow potential buyers
63 2 Change Way Frame Decisions
64Example 1
- Let customer know the cost of not booking and
paying now that is, give the difference between
current booking class and the next level up
65Examine How We Quote Rates
- We always quote low to high, which sets reference
point low and the other prices a loss - If we quote high price first, then other prices
are a gain
66Example 2
- Make it simple for customer to see options and
trade-offs
67This slide shows how prices change depending upon
day of flight key here is that customer sees the
options and can make choices
68Figure 3
69(No Transcript)
70(No Transcript)
71Note departure and return are bundled Customers
knows price but has to buy prepackaged schedule
72Customer chooses by schedule but does not know
price
73Customer can easily get both price and schedule
and therefore it is easy to make choice
74Example 3
- Frame decision outcomes in terms of gains or
losses - do not discuss benefits of buying the product,
but discuss the consequences of not buying the
product
75Example 4
- Frame by Bundling Gains and Losses
- un-bundle gains
- bundle losses
76Frame by Un-bundle Gains
- Packages such as London for Free use of free
bundles gain list all the components separately - Ability to purchase upgrades by segment (e.g.,
seat on UK to USA different utility than seat on
USA to UK) - Check-in time use of lounge
77Frame by bundle losses
- Should we quote rates that include all taxes and
airport fees? - What losses that can be bundled?
78Hotel Examples?
79Example of Research Study Undertaking
- Test Condition Bundling Added
- Utilize proper opening dialogue
- Listen to callers requests
- Ask repeat guest question and determine reason
for stay - Provide normal sales strategy
- At time of purchase, ask the following
80Example of Research Study Undertaking
- For an extra 15 we can offer an amenities
package that includes - no phone access charge,
- 10 free local phone calls,
- free received faxes,
- free sent faxes,
- free internet access,
- one 3-minute call to call home (may call anywhere
in the world).
81Examples of current research
- Test Condition Willingness to Pay for
Guaranteed Bed Type - At time of purchase, read the following
- As you are probably aware, hotels only guarantee
a room, they never guarantee what the bed type in
the room will be. The reason for this pertains
to the fact that the bed inventory is limited and
fixed. Since guests arrive at different
intervals, room assignments are made on a first
come first serve basis. This means that the bed
type you would like to have may not be available.
For an extra 20 we can guarantee that no matter
what time you arrive, the bed type you requested
will be available.
82Examples of current research
- Test Condition Willingness to Pay for
Guaranteed Bed Type - Other test conditions
- At what price would this guarantee service be so
expensive that you would not consider purchasing
this service? - At what price would this guarantee service be
expensive, but you still would consider
purchasing this service? - What price would you expect this hotel to charge
for the guarantee of a bed type?
83Framing and Reference Price Formation
84Hotel Example Would You Choose?
- Staying at the Venetian Hotel in Las Vegas for a
vacation Staying two nights 3036 rooms - Which Would You Choose?
- A Luxury suite room at 159 and then for an
additional 30 you get guaranteed room on a high
floor with a strip view - B Luxury suite room with guaranteed room on a
high floor for 189, or room for 30 less
anywhere in the hotel
85Hotel Example
- Venetian Hotel in Las Vegas
- Manipulation
- Quote 159 first (option A previous slide)
- Quote 189 first (option B previous slide)
- Two Teams
- Team 1 conversion 21.9 calls 1813
- Team 2 conversion 21.2 calls 1654
86Hotel Example
- Upgrades
- 159 quoted first 13.59 upgraded (option A)
- 189 quoted first 20.55 upgraded (option B)
- Translates 31,878 extra revenue for the month to
the bottom line
87Restaurant Study
88Study Design
- Eight different menus
- Type of description
- Modest/Detailed
- Number of items
- Three per category/Two per category
- Prices
- High prices/Low prices
23
89Spinach and Feta Dip
- Modest Description
- Spinach and Feta Cheese with Tomatoes and
Pinenuts - Detailed Description
- Organic Spinach Sautéed in Garlic and Combined
with Authentic Athenian Feta Cheese, Sun Ripened
Yellow Tomatoes and Toasted Pinenuts
90MENU DESIGN
Menu One Detailed Menu Descriptions, High
Price, 3 Choices Menu Two Detailed Menu
Descriptions, Low Price, 3 Choices Menu
Three Detailed Menu Descriptions, High Price, 2
Choices Menu Four Detailed Menu Descriptions,
Low Price, 2 Choices Menu Five Modest Menu
Description, High Price, 3 Choices Menu
Six Modest Menu Description, Low Price, 3
Choices Menu Seven Modest Menu Description,
High Price, 2 Choices Menu Eight Modest Menu
Description, Low Price, 2 Choices
91Hypothesis Two Items Each Menu Category
Ho1 X value (high price with detailed description) X value (high price with modest description) Mean 4.74 4.26 p.083
Ho2 X value (low price with detailed description) X value (low price with modest description) Mean 4.99 4.74 P.369
Ho3 X value (high price with detailed description) X value (low price with detailed description) Mean 4.74 4.99 P.315
Ho4 X value (high price with modest description) X value (low price with modest description) Mean 4.26 4.74 p.113
Ho5 X value (high price with detailed description) X value (low price with modest description) Mean 4.74 4.74 p1.00
92What Influence Buyers Reference Prices
- Current Price Influences
- Past Price Influences
- Purchase Context Influences
- Prices of similar items
- Price considering cost of making item yourself
931. Current Price Influences
- Product-Line Pricing
- Adding a premium product to the product line may
not necessarily result in overwhelming sales of
the premium product itself. It does, however,
enhance buyers perceptions of lower-priced
products in the product line and influences
low-end buyers to trade up to higher-priced items
94Product Line Pricing Example Wine
95Product Line Pricing Example Wine
96Anchoring
- The idea is that when a person must make a
judgment, he or she starts with an initial,
approximate judgment - an anchor. This
judgment gets the person in the ball-park.
Then, in view of other considerations, the person
arrives at a final judgment by adjusting away
from that initial assessment
97Our top room is a Park Avenue Suite decorated
with an elegant European accent. This suite is
900 Sq. Ft. The suite is designed with the
business traveler in mind. Suites feature a
separate parlor with a wet bar and refreshment
center, an oversized working desk, 2 multi-line
speaker phones with call waiting, voicemail,
data-port, fax machines, Lodgenet Entertainment
System with movies and CD Library. These rooms
overlook 56th street or the city view of 57th
street. The bedroom can be closed off from the
living room. The king size bed includes five down
pillows with satin-banded Egyptian cotton
Pillowcases. Suites sell for 995.00. Position
following second Our 2nd room type is the
Metropolitan Suite. This suite is 700 Sq. Ft.
Position following third Our 3rd room type
is the Executive Suite. This suite is 600 Sq. Ft.
98Current Price Influences - continued
- Suggested Reference Prices
- State a price charged previously
- State a price charged by a competitor
- State suggested retail price
99Example of item being tested
- If consumers are always told the normal rate, and
then provided with a discount from that rate,
they will remember the normal rate, not the
discount rate. In addition, when the invoice is
provided to the client at check-out, the normal
price will be printed. At the end the discount
will be subtracted. We should see a rise in
"overall price value" compared to when customer
only sees the price paid.
100Current Price Influences - continued
- Consider the following airline prices seen on
Internet for round-trip - London to Paris 310
- Paris to Prague 288
- Nice to Prague 289
- London to Nice 310
- Given above prices, answer following questions
- 1. What price would you expect to pay to fly
from London to Prague _____ - 2. What is the most you would pay _____
- 3. What is a fair price _____
1012. Past Price Influences
- Past price paid has a particularly strong
influence on the reference price because it is
more likely to be recalled as a frame of
reference than past prices that were observed in
advertising
1022. Past Price Influences - continued
- Implications of Previous Slide
- Numerous small price increases for frequently
purchased items more likely to be accepted than
are infrequent large increases - Need to always state actual price and discount
from that otherwise, low promotional prices can
establish low reference prices for judging the
value of later purchases
1033. Purchase Context Influences
- You are lying on the beach on a hot day. All you
have to drink is warm water. For the last hour
you have been thinking about how much you would
enjoy a nice cold bottle of your favorite
imported beer. A companion gets up to make a
phone call and offers to bring back a beer. The
only near by place where beer is sold is a small,
run-down grocery store. He asks what the maximum
price you are willing to pay. If the price is
higher, he will not buy it. - What price do you tell him? _____
1043. Purchase Context Influences
- You are lying on the beach on a hot day. All you
have to drink is warm water. For the last hour
you have been thinking about how much you would
enjoy a nice cold bottle of your favorite
imported beer. A companion gets up to make a
phone call and offers to bring back a beer. The
only near by place where beer is sold is a resort
hotel. He asks what the maximum price you are
willing to pay. If the price is higher, he will
not buy it. - What price do you tell him? _____
1053. Purchase Context Influences continued
- Use context as a frame of reference that makes
the price seem fair or reasonable - e.g., 8 hours tossing and turning trying to get
comfortable, versus good night sleep - e.g., a day at the office
- e.g., What is your time worth to drive versus
- to fly to airport that is not
convenient?
1064. Prices of similar items (e.g., if consumers
think there is no difference, then there is a
problem)5. Price considering cost of making
it yourself
1076. Price Differentials
- Scenario A You are a purchasing agent for a
large organization. You have ordered for your
own use a new electric typewriter with special
features, which will cost 1,000. A friend
discovers that the identical typewriter is
available from another vendor for 600. Would
you cancel the current order and switch to the
other vendor? (Assume that canceling the current
order and initiating a new one will take one of
the purchasing clerks who works for you about
one-half day. Assume that there are no other
costs such as a loss of good will or delay in
delivery.) - Would you cancel the current order and switch
to the other vendor? - Yes _______ No _________
108- Scenario B You are a purchasing agent for a
large organization. You have ordered a new word
processor with special features, which will cost
20,000. Your purchasing department discovers
that the identical word processor is available
from another vendor for 19,600. Would you
cancel the current order and switch to the other
vendor? (Assume that canceling the current order
and initiating a new one will take one of the
purchasing clerks who works for you about
one-half day. Assume that there are no other
costs such as a loss of good will or delay in
delivery.) - Would you cancel the current order and switch
to the other vendor? - Yes _______ No _________
109- Scenario A the difference is 40, whereas in
Scenario B the difference is 2, even though the
absolute difference in both is 400 - Implications
- the perception of a price change depends on the
percentage, not on the absolute difference - there is a threshold above and below a products
price at which price changes are ignored
110- When quoting rates, quote price differences
instead of whole rate e.g., 320 versus 290.
For 30 less get.
1117. Framing Price Differences
- Look at the two pairs of prices below and quickly
answer the question For which pair of prices is
the lower price more of a bargain? - Higher Price Lower Price
- First Pair 0.89 0.75
- Second Pair 0.93 0.79
- Your answer _____
112- Perceptions of Odd Price Endings
- Buyers use left most digits in a price and round
up to form a quick reference point to evaluate
the actual price against. - Previous example second pair seems to have
better discount. - (first pair 8-7 1 second pair 9-7 2 if
figure same in first column, then look at second
column) - In reality, difference is a greater percentage
of the price in the first pair (18.6 vs. 17.7)
113Objective of this section
- Understand steps to better pricing
- Understand Competitive Value Analysis
- Review basics of revenue management
- Understand price customization
- Understand Value