Title: BDO SEIDMAN, LLP
1BDO SEIDMAN, LLPSDecember 2004 FINANCIAL
REPORTING UPDATESEC Matters
2FASB Activities
- Statement 151, Inventory Costs
- Amends ARB 43 to clarify that abnormal amounts of
idle facility expense, freight, handling costs,
and spoilage are current period costs - Effective for inventory costs incurred during
fiscal years beginning after June 15, 2005
3FASB Activities
- Statement 123R, Share-Based Payment
- Requirements
- Use fair value-based method of accounting for
transactions in which employee services received
are exchanged for either - Equity, or
- Liabilities based on FV of companys equity or
that may be settled by issuance of such equity
4FASB Activities
- Statement 123R, Share-Based Payment
- Current Literature to be Impacted
- Supersedes APB 25 and related interpretations
- Amends SFAS 123, however, does not change
accounting for transactions with nonemployees
(EITF 96-18 still applies) - Does not change accounting for ESOP plans under
AICPA Statement of Position 93-6 - Amends SFAS 95 with respect to excesstax benefits
5FASB Activities
- Statement 123R, Share-Based Payment
- Changes from Exposure Draft
- Effective for quarters after 6/15/05 for public
companies, quarters after 12/15/05 for S-B filer - Reverts to original Statement 123 conclusions
- No preference for particular option-pricing
models - Limited offset of excess and deficient tax
benefits - Straight-line amortization OK for awards with
graded vesting - Conditions for noncompensatory plans
6FASB Activities
- Statement 123R, Share-Based Payment
- Transition
- Public Companies
- Modified prospective method
- Apply new accounting to all awards granted after
effective date - Apply Statement 123 to awards granted after 1994
but not vested as of effective date - Restatement of prior years permitted, but not
required
- Private Companies
- Pure prospective method
- Apply new accounting to all awards granted after
effective date (fiscal years beginning after
12/15/05)
7FASB Activities
- Statement 123R, Share-Based Payment
-
- Planning Considerations
- Carefully weigh the consequences of accelerating
vesting - Consider alternative compensation
strategies--shift to restricted stock versus
options
8FASB Activities
- Statement 152, Accounting for Real Estate
Time-Sharing Transactionsan amendment of FASB
Statements No. 66 and 67 - Amends Statements 67 and 68, to refer to the
guidance in SOP 04-2 - Effective for financial statements for fiscal
years beginning after June 15, 2005
9FASB Activities
- Statement 153, Exchanges of Nonmonetary
Assetsan amendment of APB Opinion No. 29 - Eliminates the APB 29 exception for nonmonetary
exchanges of similar productive assets and
replaces it with a general exception for
exchanges of nonmonetary assets that do not have
commercial substance - Effective for nonmonetary asset exchanges in
fiscal periods beginning after June 15, 2005
10EITF Consensus Position Reached in November
- 03-13 -- Applying the Conditions in Para.42
Statement 144 in Determining Whether to Report
Discontinued Operations - Classification as a discontinued operation is
appropriate only if the ongoing entity - Has no continuing direct cash flows
- Does not retain an interest, contract, or other
arrangement sufficient to enable it to exert
significant influence over the disposed
components operating and financial policies
after the disposal transaction
11Section 404 Reporting Update
- 3rd round of PCAOB FAQs (11-22-04)
- Framework for evaluating deficiencies
- Further acceleration deferred for one year
- 45 day deferral of 404 reporting for accelerated
filers - If public equity float lt 700 million and
- Fiscal Y/E from 11/15/04 2/28/05
- Rest of 10-K due at regular date
12Acceleration Deferral
- Revised accelerated filing deadlines for Forms
10-K and 10-Q by accelerated filers
For Fiscal Years Ending On or After Form 10-K Deadline Subsequent Form 10-Q Deadline
December 15, 2002 90 days after fiscal year end 45 days after fiscal quarter end
December 15, 2003 75 days after fiscal year end 40 days after fiscal quarter end
December 15, 2004 75 days after fiscal year end 40 days after fiscal quarter end
December 15, 2005 60 days after fiscal year end 35 days after fiscal quarter end
13Other SEC/PCAOB Activities
- SEC staff FAQ New 8-K rules
- (http//www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/form8kfaq.ht
m) - SEC staff FAQ Independence rules
(http//www.sec.gov/info/accountants/ocafaqaudind1
21304.htm) - Securities Act reform proposal
- Communications
- Registration process
- Final prospectus delivery
- PCAOB tax services proposal would prohibit
- Tax shelter work
- Tax services to officers
14AICPA SEC Conference Themes
- Weve improved but need to do better
- Financial reporting should be a communication
exercise not a compliance exercise - Rules are the floor not the ceiling
- Preparers can enhance quality without more rules
- Staff recognizes many requirements are new
- Do not expect perfection
- Do expect total commitment to the change process
15Communication Exercise
- Contingencies
- No disclosure before the charge
- Zero accrued until settlement
- Financial instruments disclosures
- Disjointed, cover pieces, spread out, dont tie
to F/S - Hard to relate disclosures to F/S
- Message Say whats needed to communicate, even
if not specifically required
16Communication Improvement Ideas
- Direct method cash flows reporting
- Pensions dont use smoothing mechanisms
- Disclose expense by nature (salaries, etc.)
- Depreciable lives (stratify cost by life)
- MDA Tables, real insight
- Reasons for structured transactions
- Would you have what you need to invest?
17Internal Control Reporting (Section 404)
- Benefits (fewer restatements) outweigh the costs
- Open dialog in the spring identify best
practices and ways to streamline - Concern re cost to small companies
- Expect material weaknesses
- Should not prompt severe reactions
- Keys are full disclosure and remediation
- Implementing new accounting standards
18Accounting Consultations
- Generally permitted, provided not construed to be
bookkeeping - A/S-2 raises concerns as to whether
- Providing advice pre-empts a company from
demonstrating it has adequate controls over
accounting and F/S preparation - Failure to perform flawlessly indicates a
significant deficiency or material weakness - Firms have adopted a variety of approaches
- PCAOB did not intend to stop accounting
discussions between companies and their auditors
19404 Reporting Material Weaknesses
- Disclose identified M/Ws in 10-K (dont wait
until 10-K/A) - M/W in ICFR ineffective DCPs? (usually)
- Revise Item 307 and 308(c) if necessary
- New M/W in 10-K/A
- Restatement
- Disclose (in plain English)
- What the problem is and what it impacts
- How and when you plan to remediate
20404 Reporting 45 Day Deferral 10-K/As
- Two 404 reports
- Revised (full) 302 certifications
- Revised Item 307/308(c) if necessary
- Consent if necessary
- S-2/S-3 ineligible until 10-K/A filed
- Can file S-8 and rely on Rule 144 before 10-K/A
filed
21SEC Staff Hot Buttons
- Materiality project
- Wont affect 2004 reporting
- Material out of period adjustments require
restatement - Pension accounting
- Substantive plan
- Discount rate
- Mortality tables
22SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)
- Modifications of Conversion Options in
Convertible Debt - Under EITF 96-16, if the the present value of the
cash flows of modified debt differs from the
present value of the cash flows of the original
debt by more than 10, the modification should be
treated as an extinguishment - The analysis should compare the fair value (not
just the intrinsic value) of the conversion
option immediately before and after the
modification
23SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)Statement 115,
Accounting for Certain Investments in Debt and
Equity Securities
Transfers to and from the trading account should
be rare
- NOT ACCEPTABLE
- To enact a change in an investment strategy
- To achieve accounting results more closely
matching economic hedging strategies - To reposition portfolio due to expected economic
outlook
- ACCEPTABLE
- Upon the adoption of a new standard
- Change in statutory requirements
- A significant business combination that alters
investing strategy - An unusual situation highly unlikely to recur in
near term
24SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)Statement 115,
Accounting for Certain Investments in Debt and
Equity Securities
Accounting for Other Than Temporary Impairments
of Certain Investments The effective date of
recognition and measurement provisions of EITF
03-1 is deferred Continue to follow GAAP
including SAB Topic 5.M, until FASB completes
project Assessment and disclosure provisions of
EITF 03-1 remain effective
25SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)
- Conceptual Differences Between Statements 141 and
142 - The determination of fair value under 141 differs
from the useful life under 142. - 141 bases valuation on traditional notion of fair
value, e.g., marketplace participants (willing
buyer and seller, etc.). - 142 bases the intangibles assumed life on its
utility to the company. - SEC staff accepts this difference
- Valuation of the intangible should not be changed
under 141 even if the useful life was limited to
its company-specific utility under 142.
26SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)
- Accounting for Contingent Tax Benefits
- Companies should disclose amount of recorded and
unrecorded tax liabilities pursuant to Statement
5. - The Staff does not consider potentially alerting
the IRS to uncertain deductions via these
disclosures to be an acceptable reason for
non-compliance with GAAP and SEC rules. - The FASB will soon expose, for public comment, an
interpretation on this topic.
27SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)
- Changes in Circumstances and the Impact on
Revenue Recognition - Companies must continually assess whether their
current accounting policies properly reflect the
economics of their sales transactions. - Software example Repeated software upgrades to
existing products may change conclusion that the
software is only incidental. - Companies should have procedures and controls in
place to ensure accounting policies evolve
concurrently with the business. - This will improve financial statement reliability
and comparability for industries with complex
revenue models such as the technology sector.
28SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)
- Nonmonetary Exchange Transactions That Culminate
the Earnings Process - Two main issues to be determined timing of
recognition and income statement classification. - Timing based on Concept Statement 5 and SAB
Topic 13 criteria, e.g., earned and realizable,
delivery or performance, etc. - Classification based on Concept Statement 6,
e.g., revenue treatment is only appropriate if
the inflow is derived from activities that
constitute ongoing major or central operations.
Otherwise, classify as gain.
29SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)
- Accelerated Vesting of Option Grants Prior to the
Adoption of Statement 123R - Under APB 25, accelerated vesting of underwater
options generally does not result in additional
expense. - However, any unrecognized compensation on the
date of acceleration of in-the-money options
would be recognized immediately. - Under FAS 123, the company would be required to
disclose the effect of accelerating the
unamortized portion of unvested underwater
options in their pro forma footnotes. - Upon adoption of 123R using the MPA, compensation
expense would be reduced or eliminated since
acceleration mitigated the impact of existing
underwater, unvested options.
30SEC Staff Hot Buttons (Cont.)
- Accelerated Vesting of Option Grants Prior to the
Adoption of Statement 123R (Cont.) - The SEC staff views this treatment consistent
with previously expressed views regarding
structured transactions which are specifically
designed to achieve certain accounting goals. - Accordingly, the staff expects disclosures of
such transaction to be robust and transparent.
Language to the effect of during fiscal 2004
certain of the companys stock options were
modified to accelerate vesting would be
considered insufficient.