A Twoparty Bargaining Model

1
A Two-party Bargaining Model
Self-determination Movement
Central Government

Independence/State Capture
Suppression/Direct Rule
Complete territorial autonomy/quasi-independence
Local self-government
0
Bargaining SpaceSelf-government for
Self-determination Movement
-
2
A Model of Vertically Layered Authority
Supra-state Government
Central Government
State Government
Regional Government
Provincial Government
District Government
Local Government
3
Figure 1 Self-governance Arrangements in Belgium
Head of State
FEDERAL CHAMBERS Chamber of Representatives and
Senate
Federal Government of Belgium
Judicial System
Federal Government
Regions and Communities
WALLOON REGION Council and Government
JOINT INSTITUTIONS OF THE FLEMISH REGION AND
FLEMISH COMMUNITY Flemish Council and Flemish
Community Government
BRUSSELS REGION Power-sharing Regional Council
and Government Council and Government of the Fr
ench Community Commission, the Flemish Community
Commission, and the power-sharing Joint Community
Commission
GERMAN-SPEAKING COMMUNITY Council and Governme
nt
FRENCH COMMUNITY Council and Government
Provinces
Provincial Council and College
Provincial Council and College
Local Authorities
Local Council and College
Local Council and College
Local Council and College
4
Figure 2 Self-governance Arrangements in Bosnia
and Herzegovina
Office of the High Representative
Parliamentary Assembly (House of Representatives
and House of Peoples)
Collective Presidency Council of Ministers
Constitutional Court
Central Bank
State Institutions
Entity Institutions
Parliament of the Bosnian-Croat Federation (House
of Representatives and House of Peoples)
Presidency of the Bosnian-Croat Federation
Government of the Bosnian-Croat Federation
National Assembly of the Republika Srpska
Presidency of the Republika Srpska
Government of the Republika Srpska
Judicial System
Judicial System
Cantonal Institutions
Cantonal Legislatures
Cantonal President Cantonal Government
Judicial System
Municipal Institutions
Municipal Governing Council
Municipal Executive
Judicial System
Municipalities
5
Figure 3 Self-governance Arrangements in Sudan
National Legislature (National Assembly and
Council of States)
Power-sharing National Executive (Presidency and
Council of Minister)
Constitutional Court, National Supreme Court,
National Courts of Appeal, other Courts and
Tribunals
Various Institutions and Commissions
Central State Institutions
Legislature of Southern Sudan
Power-sharing Executive of Southern Sudan
Supreme Court of Southern Sudan, Courts of
Appeal. Other Courts and Tribunals
Southern Institutions
State Legislatures
State Governor State Power-sharing Executive
State Judicial System
State Institutions
Local Government Institutions (Structures to be
determined)
6
Figure 4 Self-governance Arrangements in the
Philippines
Congress
Cabinet National Security Council
Judicial System
State Institutions
Autonomous Region of Muslim Mindanao
Regional Assembly (popularly and corporately
elected)
Regional Governor and Vice Governor
Power-sharing Cabinet Power-sharing Executive Cou
ncil
Judicial System
Provincial Assembly
Provincial Governor
Provincial Government
Regional Courts District Courts
Barrangay Courts
Municipal Assembly
Mayor
Municipal Government
Barrangay (local community) Head
Local Assembly
Local Government
7
Figure 5 Self-governance Arrangements in the
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern
Ireland
Head of State
Houses of Parliament (sovereign)
Cabinet
Judicial System
State Institutions
Power-sharing Institutions in Northern Ireland
Assembly
EXECUTIVE First and Deputy First Minister Minist
ers
Executive Committees
Judicial System
Town Clerk and Chief Executive
Local Authorities
Council
8
Figure 6 Self-governance Arrangements in Italy
Head of State
PARLIAMENT Chamber of Representatives and Senat
National Government of Italy
Judicial System
National Government
Region of Trentino-Südtirol
Powersharing Provincial Government
Power-sharing Provincial Assembly
Judicial System
Powersharing Provincial Government
Power-sharing Provincial Assembly
Judicial System
Province of South Tyrol
Local Government
Local Authorities
Local Assembly
9
Figure 7 Self-governance Arrangements in Moldova
State Institutions
Parliament of the Republic of Moldova
President and Government of the Republic of
Moldova
Judicial System
Peoples Assembly
Governor of Gagauzia Executive Committee of Gagau
zia
Judicial System
Gagauz Autonomy Institutions
Districts (Rayons)
Head of Administration Appointed by the Governor
of Gagauzia (1998-2003)
CouncilElected, but reporting directly to the
central government (2003-)
10
Figure 8 Self-governance Arrangements in Papua
New Guinea
Head of State Governor General of Papua New
Guinea
State Institutions
National Parliament of Papua New Guinea
National Executive
Judicial System
Bougainville autonomy institutions
Legislature
Executive
Judicial System
Local Government(Structures to be determined)
11
Figure 9 Self-governance Arrangements in Ukraine
State Institutions
Parliament of the Republic of Ukraine
President and Government of the Republic of
Ukraine
Judicial System
Parliament
Executive
Autonomous Republic of Crimea
Territorial Communities
Head of Local Self-government Executive Body
Council
12
Figure 10 Self-governance Arrangements in
Macedonia
Head of State
Assembly
Government of Macedonia
Judicial System
State Institutions
Municipal Institutions
Council
Mayor Governing and Administrative Organs
Judicial System
Neighbourhood Self-government
13
Figure 11 Self-governance Arrangements in Kosovo
Special Representative of the United Nations
Secretary-General
Municipal Administrator
Kosovo Central Authority
Assembly
President of KosovoGovernment of Kosovo
Judicial System
Ombudsperson
Independent Bodies and Offices
Municipal Institutions
Municipal Assembly
President and Deputy Presidents of
MunicipalityChief Executive Officer and Board of
Directors of Municipality
Judicial System
14
Variation in the Vertical Layering of Authority
15
Structural and Functional Symmetry and Asymmetry
of Institutions
16
Combinations of Horizontal and Vertical
Power-sharing
17
Power Allocation in Self-governance Regimes
18
Coordination Mechanisms in Self-governance
Regimes
19
Entrenchment of Self-governance Institutions
20
Forms of State
21
Provisions for Final Status Settlement