Title: Oak Brook Hills Marriott Resort
12008
Symposia Series 1
- Oak Brook Hills Marriott Resort
- Oak Brook, Illinois
- April 5, 2008
1
1
2Peripheral Arterial Disease Keeping Pace With
Current Diagnostic and Treatment Options
- Joshua A. Beckman, MD
- Assistant Professor of Medicine
- Harvard Medical School
- Brigham and Womens Hospital
- Boston, Massachusetts
2
3Faculty Disclosure
- Dr Beckman honorarium Bristol-Myers
Squibb/Sanofi Pharmaceuticals Partnership
3
4Learning Objectives
- State the clinical manifestations of PAD
- Perform ankle-brachial index measurements in
patients at risk for PAD - Describe medical treatments for improving leg
symptoms in patients with PAD
PAD peripheral arterial disease.
5PAD Prevalence in the
Primary Care Office Setting
NHANES1 Age gt40
4.3
The prevalence of PAD in primarycare clinics
was almostin high-risk patients
San Diego2 Mean age 66
11.7
30
NHANES1 Age 70
14.5
Rotterdam3 Age gt55
19.1
Diehm4 Age 65
19.8
PARTNERS5 Age gt70, or between 50-69 with history
of diabetes or smoking
29
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
NHANES National Health and Nutrition
Examination Survey PARTNERS PAD Awareness,
Risk, and Treatment New Resources for Survival
Program. 1. Selvin E, et al. Circulation.
2004110738-743 2. Criqui MH, et al.
Circulation.198571510-515 3. Meijer WT, et al.
Arterioscler Thromb Vasc Biol. 199818185-192 4.
Diehm C, et al. Atherosclerosis.
200417295-105 5. Hirsch AT, et al. JAMA.
20012861317-1324.
5
6What Is PAD?
- Atherosclerotic occlusion of the arteries to the
legs - PAD may be asymptomatic or present with atypical
symptoms - Common, but often overlooked
- Associated with significant morbidity and
mortality
www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/dci/Diseases/pad.
7VIDEO CLIP Predilation ArteriogramBilateral
Iliac Artery Stenosis Severe Aortic
Atherosclerosis
- Courtesy Michael R. Jaff, DO
- Director, Vascular Center
- Massachusetts General Hospital
- Boston, Massachusetts
8Predilation ArteriogramBilateral Iliac Artery
Stenosis Severe Aortic Atherosclerosis-VIDEO
8
9PAD Scope of the Problem
- Exact prevalence is unknown
Includes MI and angina pectoris. CHD coronary
heart disease MI myocardial infarction. AHA.
Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics2008 Update.
www.americanheart.org Hiatt WR. N Engl J Med.
20013441608-1621. .
10PAD increases the risk of CHD death by
approximately
Use your keypad to vote now!
11PAD Increased Risk of Mortality
Patients with large-vessel PAD are at 6 the
risk of dying from CHD compared with patients
without PAD
10.0
8.0
6.6 (2.9-14.9)
6.0
Relative Risk of Death (95 CI)
4.0
3.1 (1.9-4.9)
2.0
0.0
Death From CHD
All-Cause Mortality
Cause of Death
ABI 0.8. ABI ankle-brachial index. Adapted
from Criqui MH, et al. N Engl J Med.
1992326381-386.
12Case Study
13 Patient Profile
Scenario 1
- 58-year-old Latino male
- Presents to the clinic after referral from
emergency department where he was evaluated and
discharged after an episode of chest pain - Coronary event ruled out by lab and diagnostic
studies - Construction worker with no health benefits
14 Current History
- Complains of fatigue and inability to maintain
current productivity at the work site - Mild leg pain
- Remembers being told his sugar was a little
high - Reports he is not on any medications
- Reports he does not drink alcohol
- Smokes 1 pack/d x 30 years
15 Physical Examination
- Results
- Height 5 ft 9 in
- Weight 190 lb
- BMI 28.1 kg/m2
- Waist circumference 40 in
- Blood pressure 130/85 mm Hg
- Pulse 72 bpm
BMI body mass index.
16Which element of the patients history creates
the highest index of suspicionfor PAD?
- Age
- Diabetes
- Ethnicity
- Hypertension
- Smoking
Use your keypad to vote now!
17PAD Common Risk Factors
?Lesser risk
Greater risk ?
Diabetes
4.05
Smoking
2.55
Patients with diabetes are at a 4x higher risk
of developing symptomatic PAD versus the general
population
Hypertension
1.51
Total cholesterol (10 mg/dL)
1.10
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Age gt40 years
PAD diagnosis based on ABI lt0.90. Newman AB, et
al. Circulation. 199388837-845.
18PAD Prevalence Increases With Age
Rotterdam Study (ABI lt.9) San Diego
Study (PAD by noninvasive tests)
60
50
40
Patients With PAD ()
30
20
10
0
55-59
60-64
65-69
70-74
75-79
80-84
85-89
Age Group (y)
Creager M, ed. Management of Peripheral Arterial
Disease. Medical, Surgical and Interventional
Aspects. 2000.
19San Diego Population Study PAD and Ethnicity
Criqui MH, et al. Circulation. 20051122703-2707.
20REACHScope of the Problem Cerebro- and
Cardiovascular Disease
63 of PAD patients had polyvascular disease N
7013
Cerebro-vascular
Coronary artery
14.2
9.5
39.4
Peripheral artery
Polyvascular disease
PAD patients with polyvascular disease had
concomitant symptomatic cerebrovascular disease
and/or CVD. REACH REduction of Atherothrombosis
for Continued Health. CVD cardiovascular
disease. Bhatt DL, et al. Presented at ACC
Scientific Session March 6-9, 2005 Orlando,
Fla.
21What is the next step in assessing the patient
for possible PAD?
- ABI testing
- Differential diagnosis for leg pain
- Lipid/endocrine panel
- Vascular laboratory tests
Use your keypad to vote now!
22PAD Intermittent Claudication
Not Always Present
Patients With PAD
PARTNERS up to 90 of patients with PAD would
be missed if healthcare providers relied solely
on classic symptoms of intermittent
claudication Healthcare providers should
routinely ask about atypical symptoms In
patients with ABI 0.9.
Asymptomatic PAD 40
Symptomatic PAD 60
Typical Symptoms(Intermittent Claudication) 10
Exercise calf pain Not present at rest Relieved
within 10 minutes by rest
Atypical Symptoms50 Occlusion may develop
slowly, allowing collateral circulation to develop
AHA. Heart Disease and Stroke Statistics2008
Update. www.americanheart.org Criqui MH, et al.
Vasc Med. 1996165-71 Hirsch AT, et al. JAMA.
20012861317-1324.
23PAD Diagnostic Critical Pathway
Clinical Evaluation History and Physical
- Referral to Vascular Lab
- Assessment of location/ severity is desired
- Patients with poorly compressible vessels
- Normal ABI where PAD suspicion is high
- Vascular Lab Evaluation
- Segmental pressures
- Pulse volume recordings
- Treadmill
PAD Diagnosis
PAD Diagnosis
Adapted from American Diabetes Association.
Diabetes Care. 2003263333-3341.
24Simple Questions to Ask Your Patient Who Has
Symptoms of PAD
Do you walk?
If you do not walk, why not?
Do you have pain in either leg when you walk?
How far can you walk?
How far do you walk without stopping?
What stops you when you are walking?
Have you had any poor or non-healing leg or foot
wounds?
Olson KWP, et al. J Vasc Nurs. 20042272-77.
25PAD Physical EvaluationDifferential Diagnosis
in Patients With Intermittent Claudication
- Calf
- Venous occlusion
- Chronic compartment syndrome
- Nerve root compression
- Bakers cyst
- Hip/thigh/buttock
- Hip arthritis
- Spinal cord compression
- Foot
- Arthritis
- Buerger disease
Adapted from Schmieder FA, et al. Am J Cardiol.
2001873D-13D.
26PAD Physical Examination
Additional examination by palpation and
auscultation to detect abnormal aortic aneurysm
or bruit
Gey DC, et al. Am Fam Physician. 200469525-532.
27 Physical Examination Results
- CV RRR S1 and S2 with no murmurs or gallops
- Chest clear to A/P
- Abdomen rotund, but no pulsatile masses or
distention - Vascular no bruits upper extremity
pulsesnormal limits - Lower extremity pulses reveal normal femoral
bilaterally - Right popliteal, DP, and PT palpable
- Left shows decreased popliteal, DP, and PT
- Musculoskeletal no evidence of foot ulceration
or dependent rubor - Neurologic sensory function intact in upper and
lower extremities
DP dorsalis pedis PT posterior tibial.
28How often do you perform ABIs for patients who
have a similar clinical profile?
Use your keypad to vote now!
29PAD Diagnostic Critical Pathway
Clinical Evaluation History and Physical
- Referral to Vascular Lab
- Assessment of location/ severity is desired
- Patients with poorly compressible vessels
- Normal ABI where PAD suspicion is high
- Vascular Lab Evaluation
- Segmental pressures
- Pulse volume recordings
- Treadmill
PAD Diagnosis
PAD Diagnosis
Adapted from American Diabetes Association.
Diabetes Care. 2003263333-3341.
29
30PARTNERS Incorporating ABI Into Primary Care
After Clinicians Participated in PARTNERS
88
Clinicians thought it feasible to incorporate ABI
into daily practice
Mohler ER, et al. Vasc Med. 20049253-260.
31ABI Indications
American Diabetes Association. Diabetes Care.
200422181-189.
32Concept of ABI
Systolic blood pressure in the leg should be
approximately the same as that in the arm
Leg Pressure
Therefore, the ratio of systolic blood pressure
in the leg versus the arm should be approximately
1 or slightly higher
1
Arm Pressure
ABI is 95 sensitive and 99 specific for
angiographically diagnosed PAD
Adapted from Weitz JI, et al. Circulation.
1996943026-3049.
33ABI Video
- Vascular Disease Foundation
34ABI Video
34
35ABI Workshops
- CME/CEaccredited demonstrations available
- throughout the day
36 ABI Results
- Diagnostic intervention
- Evaluate vascular status ABI results
- Right 1.00
- Left 0.56
37 Treatment Rationale
- The lower the ABI, the greater the risk of
cardiovascular events - Patients with critical leg ischemiathe most
severe clinical manifestation of PADwho have the
lowest ABI values have an annual mortality of 25
Hiatt WR. N Engl J Med. 20013441608-1621.
38 Patient Consultation
- You tell your patient he has
- PAD
- A serious disease
- The cause of his walking problem
- A marker for the systemic disease
atherosclerosisand he is at risk for heart
attack or stroke
39Appropriate management of this patient should be
to
- Treat symptoms
- Reduce CV risk
- Treat symptoms then address CV risk reduction
- Simultaneously treat symptoms and reduce CV risk
Use your keypad to vote now!
40PAD 2-Pronged Management Strategy
Patient Management Requires BOTH Approaches
Simultaneously
- Treatment of Symptoms
- Objective
- Reduce symptoms to increase mobility, exercise
tolerance, functional capacity - Exercise
- Pharmacology therapy (cilostazole)
- Selective use of interventional therapy
- Risk Reduction of Ischemic Events
- Objective
- Reduce risk of events causing morbidity and
mortality - Control risk factors
- Antiplatelet therapy (clopidogrel)
Kempczinski RF, et al. In Rutherford RB, ed.
Vascular Surgery. 1989 Clagett GP, et al. Chest.
1995108431S-443S McDermott MM, et al. Surg
Clin North Am. 199575581-591.
41Despite its prevalence and cardiovascular risk
implications, only 25 of patients with PAD are
undergoing treatment!
PAD Undertreated
- In a recent study of 1733 patients with known
PAD - 33 were taking a beta blocker
- 29 were taking an ACE inhibitor
- 31 were taking a statin
- Of those with diabetes, only 46 had an A1C of
lt7
ACE angiotensin-converting enzyme. AHA. Heart
Disease and Stroke Statistics2008 Update.
www.americanheart.org Rehring TF, et al. J Vasc
Surg. 200541816-822.
42Management PlanRisk Reduction
- Appropriate management includes
- Smoking cessation
- Blood pressure control
- Antiplatelet therapy
- Exercise program
- Order lipid/metabolic profiles
- Follow-up in 1 month
43PAD Aggressive Risk Factor ModificationSmoking
Cessation
40
35
PlaceboNicotine replacement Bupropion Bupropion
andnicotine replacement
30
25
Percentage of Patients Abstaining
20
15
10
5
0
6 Months
12 Months
- Sustained-release bupropion alone or in
combination with nicotine patch significantly
improved long-term smoking cessation rates
compared with either nicotine patch alone or
placebo - Abstinence rates were higher (not statistically
significant) with combination therapy than with
bupropion alone
Jorenby DE, et al. N Engl J Med. 1999340685-691.
44Meta-Analysis PAD Aggressive Risk Factor
ModificationSupervised Exercise
AMA has published a CPT code for supervised PAD
rehabilitation (93668)2
- Greatest improvement
- Sessions lasted gt30 min
- 3 sessions/week
- Walk to near-maximal pain
- gt6-month program
CPT current procedural terminology. 1. Gardner
AW, et al. JAMA. 1995274975-980 2. Kanjwal MK,
et al. JK Practitioner. 200411225-232.
45HOPE PAD Aggressive Risk Factor
ModificationAntihypertensive Therapy
- Benefit seen independent of anti-hypertensive
effect
Relative Risk in Ramipril Group
HOPE Study Investigators. N Engl J Med.
2000342145-153.
46Which of the following would you recommend for
the pharmacologic management of his PAD?
- Aspirin
- Cilostazol
- Clopidogrel
- Pentoxifylline
Use your keypad to vote now!
47PAD Antiplatelet and Vasodilator Therapy
ACCP American College of Chest Physicians ASA
aspirin CAPRIE Clopidogrel Versus Aspirin in
Patients at Risk of Ischemic Events CCB
calcium channel blocker CHF chronic heart
failure GI gastrointestinal TTP thrombotic
thrombocytopenic purpura. Adapted from Gey DC,
et al. Am Fam Physician. 200469525-532.
48CAPRIEClopidogrel Versus ASA MI, Ischemic
Stroke, or Vascular Death
16
8.7 Overall RRR (P .045)
ASA Clopidogrel
5.83
12
5.32
(N 19,185)
8
Cumulative Event Rate ()
Subjects had a recent MI, recent ischemic stroke,
or symptomatic PAD
4
0
0
3
6
9
12
15
18
21
24
27
30
33
36
Months of Follow-up
Median follow-up 1.91 years
ITT analysis. ITT intention to treat RRR
relative risk reduction. CAPRIE Steering
Committee. Lancet. 19963481329-1339.
49CAPRIESafety Profile
- Although the risk of myelotoxicity with
clopidogrel appears to be low, this possibility
should be considered when a patient receiving
clopidogrel has fever or another sign of
infection. - Patients with a history of ASA intolerance were
excluded from CAPRIE. -
- Data on file, Sanofi-Synthelabo Inc. PLAVIX
Prescribing Information. sanofi-aventis/Bristol-M
yers Squibb Company 2007. -
50Tolerability Profile
CAPRIE
ASA-intolerant patients excluded 2.5 of
patients receiving clopidogrel. Data on file,
Sanofi-Synthelabo Inc. PLAVIX Prescribing
Information. Sanofi-aventis/Bristol-Myers Squibb
Company 2007.
51Laboratory Results
Scenario 2
- Lipid panel
- Total cholesterol 276 mg/dL
- LDL-C 170 mg/dL
- HDL-C 29 mg/dL
- Triglyceride 280 mg/dL
- A1C 9.2
- FPG 204 mg/dL
- BUN 19 mg/dL creatinine 1.2 g/dL
BUN blood urea nitrogen FPG fasting plasma
glucose HDL-C high-density lipoprotein
cholesterol LDL-C low-density lipoprotein
cholesterol.
52PAD Aggressive Risk Factor ModificationDiabetes
and Hyperlipidemia
Gey DC, et al. Am Fam Physician. 200469525-532
Hiatt WR. N Engl J Med. 20013441608-1621
Norgren L, et al. J Vasc Surg. 200745S5A-S67.
53Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study PAD
A1C and Diabetes
A1C levels 1st tertile lt5.9 2nd tertile
6.0-7.4 3rd tertile gt7.5
Log rank P value .0006
0.06
0.05
0.04
Probability of PAD-Related Hospitalizations
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
Years of Follow-up
Selvin E, et al. Diabetes Care. 200629877-882.
54Heart Protection Study PAD Aggressive Risk
Factor ModificationLipids
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1.4
Simvastatin Better
Placebo Better
. HPS Collaborative Group. MRC/BHF. Lancet.
20023607-22.
55Laboratory Results
Scenario 3
- Lipid panel
- Total cholesterol 276 mg/dL
- LDL-C 170 mg/dL
- HDL-C 29 mg/dL
- Triglyceride 280 mg/dL
- A1C 9.2
- FPG 204 mg/dL
- BUN 32 mg/dL creatinine 2.4 g/dL
56Patient Consultation
- Discuss with the patient that his renal function
is deteriorating - Recommend renal consultation
- Urinary albumin excretion test ordered
- Consideration may be given to renal arteriogram
- To determine presence of renal artery stenosis
leading to diminished renal blood flow
57PAD When to Refer
- Primary care team is not confident making the
diagnosis or lacks resources to make such a
diagnosis - Patient has continued symptoms despite a
reasonable trial and adherence to best medical
therapy - Patient has critical limb ischemia (rest pain,
gangrene, or ulceration)
58PAD Diagnostic Critical Pathway
Clinical Evaluation History and Physical
- Referral to Vascular Lab
- Assessment of location/ severity is desired
- Patients with poorly compressible vessels
- Normal ABI where PAD suspicion is high
- Vascular Lab Evaluation
- Segmental pressures
- Pulse volume recordings
- Treadmill
PAD Diagnosis
PAD Diagnosis
Adapted from American Diabetes Association.
Diabetes Care. 2003263333-3341.
59Vascular Laboratory Results Segmental Pressures
- Segmental pressures can help localize lesion
- Considered abnormal when there is a
- gt20 mm Hg difference between adjacent
segments within the same leg and between the
original segment and the corresponding segment on
the contralateral leg
Brachial Brachial artery
Upper thigh Proximal femoral
artery
Lower thigh Distal femoral artery
Calf DP, PT, and proximal arteries
Ankle PT or DP artery
Holland T. Ostomy Wound Manage. 20024838-40,
43-46, 48-49.
60Vascular Laboratory Test Pulse Volume Recordings
Provides Segmental Waveform Analysis,
a Qualitative
Assessment of Blood Flow
UpperThigh
LowerThigh
Calf
Ankle
Normal
Normal tracingincludes initial systolic peak
with a dicrotic wave on the down slope
PAD
Abnormal tracing characterized by a rounded
systolic peak that is lower, as well as the lack
of a dicrotic wave on the downslope
Data provided by Mark Creager, MD. Holland T.
Ostomy Wound Manage. 20024838-40, 43-46, 48-49.
61Treadmill Test Function Testing to Aid Diagnosis
Clinical Evaluation History and Physical
Suspect PAD
Atypical Symptoms for PAD
ABI
Normal ABI With Typical Symptoms of Claudication
- Treadmill Function Testing
- Patients with claudication will normally display
a drop in ankle pressure after exercise - May also be used to assess treatment efficacy and
evaluate overall physical function
PAD Diagnosis
Adapted from American Diabetes Association.
Diabetes Care. 2003263333-3341.
62Positioning of Dilating Balloon
- Courtesy Michael R. Jaff, DO, Director, Vascular
Center Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston,
Mass.
62
63VIDEO Postprocedure Restoration Iliac Vessel
Lumen
- Courtesy Michael R. Jaff, DO
- Director, Vascular Center
- Massachusetts General Hospital
- Boston, Massachusetts
64Postprocedure Restoration Iliac Vessel
Lumen-VIDEO
64
65Q A
66PCE Takeaways
67PAD in Primary Care Underdiagnosed and
Undertreated
- Prevalence is high, yet clinician awareness of
PAD diagnosis is relatively low - ABI can identify PAD
- PAD is a reliable warning sign that a patient is
at high risk for life-threatening cardiovascular
and cerebrovascular events - Aggressive lifestyle changes and drug therapy
can save lives
Hirsch AT, et al. JAMA. 20012861317-1324.
68Will you use ABI testing to diagnose patients at
risk for PAD?
- Extremely likely
- Very likely
- Somewhat likely
- Not likely
Use your keypad to vote now!
69BreakClinical Application Workshops
69
702008
Symposia Series 1
- Oak Brook Hills Marriott Resort
- Oak Brook, Illinois
- April 5, 2008
70
70