Developing Identity in the Balkans

1
Developing Identity in the Balkans

• Russian 275

2
Basic information

• Instructor George Gutsche
• gutscheg_at_u.arizona.edu
• http//russian.arizona.edu/courses/balkans
• Office hours TTh 330-430 or by appointment
• D2L

3
Introduction to an area of the world that is

• Complicated
• Dangerous
• Rich in tradition and history
• Linguistically and culturally diverse
• Multi-national

4
News

• Elections in Serbia implications for Kosovo
• Pipeline agreement Bulgaria and Russia

5
Balkan Familiar Faces
6
People

• Rade erbedija (Rade Sherbedzija)
• Goran Vinjic (Goran Visnjic)
• Slobodan Miloevic

7
Special characters (for Slavic)

• zhe
• C che
• C ch(ee)
• sha
• Miloevic

8
What are the Balkans?

• Mountains (Stara planina)
• Peninsula

9
Defining the Balkans

• Balkan lt balak (Trk) mountain
• Balkan Mountains Stara Planina (Old Mountains)
  in Bulgaria Haemus Mountains (Latin name)
• Balkan geographic zone begins south of the Sava
  R. and Danube R. to Mediterranean, Adriatic and
  Aegean Seas (but can also include Slovenia and
  Romania)

10
Mountain Ranges
11
The Bigger Picture
12
Balkan Countries

• Albania
• Bulgaria
• Greece
• Hungary and Turkey
• Romania (Rumania)
• Yugoslavia (Croatia, Serbia, Montenegro,
  Bosnia-Hercegovina, Macedonia, Slovenia)

13
Yugoslavia Now

• Croatia
• Bosnia-Herzegovina
• Serbia (plus Kosovo, Vojvodina)-Montenegro
• Kosovo protectorate (formerly part of Serbia)
• FYROM (Republic of Macedonia)
• Slovenia

14
Kosova (Kosovo) (Currently a protectorate)
15
General Summary

• Balkans subject to numerous influences
• Extreme linguistic diversity
• Extreme variety in belief systems
• Rich intermix of cultures and genetics

16
Key Terms

• Balkanization
• Ethnicity
• Identity
• Nationality

17
Balkanization

• Result of division into small often hostile units
• Historical basis in Balkan wars 1911-13
• Primarily used to refer to regions or territories
• Pejorative

18
Languages of the Balkans

• Serbian, Croatian, Bosnian Slavic
• Bulgarian Slovenian Macedonian Slavic
• Albanian
• Unique
• Dacian or Illyrian (speculative)
• Rumanian (Romanian) Romance
• Greek Helenic
• Turkish Turkic
• Romany Sanskrit (Indo-Iranian)

19
Alphabets

• Latin
• Cyrillic
• Greek
• Latin Plus

20
Important facts

• Languages dont respect national borders
• Borders often change
• Empires leave their mark

21
Kaplan

• Vivid examples of Balkan violence
• Uses significant quotes by natives
• Message something special about the Balkans?
• Is it more susceptible to violence?
• Is it more extreme in its nationalism?

22
Kaplans Interests

• Tendencies toward conflict strong feelings
• Historical-cultural monuments
• Journalistic-travel accounts of the 20th century
  (West, Reed)
• Jewish experiences in the Balkans

23
Kaplan Problems?

• Prologue Nazism, for instance, can claim Balkan
  origins. Among the flophouses of Vienna, a
  breeding ground of ethnic resentments close to
  the southern Slavic world, Hitler learned how to
  hate so infectiously. xxiii

24
Pec Monastery Complex
25
Michael Palin Film on The New Europe

• Series
• Slovenia, Croatia, Bosnia, Kosovo

26
Croatian Islands (Hvar)
27
Eating with natives

• Tito references?
• Prime Minister and President 1945-80
• Controversial, charismatic
• Hero or Ruthless Dictator?

28
On to Dubrovnik and Bosnia
29
Empires in Contact and Conflict

• Pre-classical and classical antiquity
• Roman
• Byzantine Empire
• Ottoman Empire
• Austrian and Austro-Hungarian Empire

30
Identity

• Set of characteristics by which something is
  recognizable or known
• Set of behavioral or physical characteristics by
  which a person is recognizable as a member of a
  particular group
• Quality (or condition) of being the same as
  something else
• Set of enduring personality traits

31
Constructing identity

• Abstract notion with philosophical implications
• Construction and constructing overused and
  misleading terms
• Ordinary terms (like choosing and changing
  and developing) are more precise and more
  useful
• Identities are often assigned, with or without
  your permission or awareness

32
Essential Point

• Construction talk motivated by desire to
  de-emphasize identity as a given from birth
• Construction is often preceded by social
• Descriptions are not the same as constructions
  we (and others) identify ourselves differently in
  different contexts

33
Ethnicity

• Condition belonging to a particular ethnic group
• Ethnic pertaining to a subgroup within a
  social-cultural system that claims or is accorded
  special status on the basis of a set of traits.
• Traits are complex and variable, and can include
  religious, linguistic, ancestral (genetic), and
  physical characteristics

34
Nationality

• Status belonging to a particular nation by
  origin, birth, or naturalization
• Status having common origins or traditions
• Status considered to constitute a nation
• National character
• Status existing as a politically autonomous
  entity

35
Nationalism

• Promoted in times of stress
• Divisive encourages Us/Them thinking
• Blurs distinctions what people share and what
  divides them