,

1
?????????????? ????????? ???????????? ?
???????? ?????????? ??????

• ??????, 22.10.2008 ?.
• ???. ?-? ???????? ??????
• ????????? ? ??, ?????

2
??????????

• ???????? ?? ????????????
• ????????? ????????
• ??????????????? ????????
• ???????? ??????????? - ?????????
• ??????????? ????????????????? -
  ??????????????????

3
???????? ?? ????????????

• Economics Strategy History
  Philosophy International Law
• Thucydides Aquinas
• 16th
• 17th Machiavelli Grotius
  
• 18th Smith
• 19th Marx Clausewitz
  Rousseau Kant
• 20th Imperialism theories History
  of Diplomacy
• Geography Geopolitics
• WWI The birth of the discipline
• 1920-30s IDEALISM
• WWII REALISM Traditionalism
  First Debate
• 1950s Functionalism
• Natural sciences SCIENTISM
  (Behavioralism, FPA)
  Second Debate
• 1960s Peace research
  Realism revisited Third
  Debate
• 1970s Dependency (Marxism) NEOREALISM LIBERALISM
  
• 1980s Critical theory
  Rationalism
  INSTITUTIONALISM
• Humanities Feminism Fourth debate
• 1990s Postmodernism CONSTRUCTIVISM
• 2000s Postructuralism Developed Game theory
  Fifth Debate?
  

4
2. ????????? - ????????

• ?????????
• ??? ? ??? ?? ?? ???????? ???????? ?????
• ?????? ?? ??????? ????????????? ?????? ???? ?????
• ???????? ?? ?????????????? ?????
• ???????? ?? ????????

5
2. ????????? - ????????

• ????????
• ?? ?????? ?? ?? ???????? ?? ?? ???????? ?? ????
  ????? ?????? ?? ?????, ? ????? ??
• ?????????? ???????? ?? ???????? ?? ?????????
  ??????
• ???? ?????? ?????????? ?? ????????? ???????
• ?? ?? ?????????, ?????? ??????? ?? ?? ??????? ?
  ???? ?? ???????.

6
2. ????????? - ????????

• ????????
• ?????????? ????????????? ????? ??????????????
  ???????, ????????????? ???????, ????????????
  ???????, ????????? ???????, ?.?.
• ?? ?? ?? ????????? ???????????? ?????? ?????? ??
  ?? ??????? ????????????? ???????
• ?? ???????? ????????????? ???????? ?? ??????????
  (??????? ?? ?????????)

7
2. ????????? - ????????

• ????????
• ???????? ?? ???????????? ???????? ?? ???????? ??
  ?????? ?? ??????????? ????? ?? ?????????
• ???? ?????? ???????? ??????? ?? ?????
  ????????????? ? ???? ???????, ?????????? ???????

8
2. ????????? - ????????

• ????????
• ??????????? ?? ????????????? ??????? ? ?????????
  ???????? ?? ???????? ?? ?????? (???????)
• ????????? ?? ??????? ????????? ?? ???????
  ???????????? ?? ??????? (??????)

9
2. ????????? - ????????

• ????????
• ?????? ???? ?? ???? ?? ???? ????????? ??? ??????,
  ?? ??????? ?????? ????? ?? ??????? ??? ?????? ?
  ?????????? ?? ??????? ????????
• ?????? ? ?????????, ??? ???? ?????????? ??
  ?????????? ??? ?????? ??, ?? ?? ????? ??
  ?????????? ? ?????????? ?? ????? ?? ????????? ??
  ??????? ??? ?????????? ?? ???????

10
3. ??????????????? - ??????????

• ???????????????
• ????????, ??????????? ??????? ? ??.
• ???????? ?? ?????????????? ???????? ???????
  ????????? ?? ??????????????? ???????? ?????, ? ??
  ???????? ?? ???????????? ?????? ?????? ??? ??????
  ?? ?????????? ? ????????.

11
3. ????????????????? - ??????????

• ?????????? (???????????????)
• ?????? ?????????? ?? ??
• ??????? a priori ??????
• ??????????????????? ?????? ??????????/??????????
  ??????/?????
• ????????/????????????? ??????
• ??????? ?? ???????? ???????? (?????? ?? ????????
  ????????)

12
4. ???????? ??????????? - ?????????

• ???????? ????????? ????????
• ?????? ?????? ??????, ??????, ??????????
• ????????? ???? ??????, ??-????? ???????? ??
  ????????? ???????
• ????????? ???? ?????? ?? ??????? ?? ??????.

13
4. ???????? ??????????? - ?????????

• ???????????
• ???? ?? ?????????? ????????????????
• a) ?????????? ?? ????????? ??????? ?? ?? ???? ??
  ??????????????? ?????????, ?? ? ??
  ??????????????????? ? ??????????????? ?????????

14
4. ???????? ??????????? -?????????

• ???????????
• ?) ?? ?????????? ???????? ????? ?????????
  ????????? ??????? ?.?. ???????? ????????? ??
  ???????? ??? ?????? ????????
• ?) ???, ?????? ?????????? ??????????
  ????????????????,???????? ???? ? ??????????? ??
  ?????????? ?? ???????????
• ?) ????.??????????? ?? ?????, ??? ???? ???????
  ??????? ??? ? ?????????? ??????????? ?? ????????.

15
4. ???????? ??????????? - ?????????

• MARXISM
• ?????? ?? ????????????
• ?????? ?? ????????????
• ?????? ?? ?????????? ??????? ?????? ?????????

16
5. ??????????? ????????????????? - ??????????????

• ???????????
• ????????? ????? ???????????? ????????? ??
  ?????????????? ???????? ??????????? ??????? ??
  ?????????
• ????????? ???????? ?????????? ?????? ????????????
  ?? ????????, ??? ???? ? ???????? ?????? ?? ????
  ???????.

17
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ???????????
• ????? ???????? ? ????????? ??????????
  ???????????? ?? ?????
• ??????? ?? ????????? ???????????????? ? ??????
  / ????????? / ????????

18
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ???????????
• ?????? ? ?????? ???????? ?? ???????????
• a) ????????? ?????????? ?? ????????? ?? ?????????
  ? ???????, ?????? ?????? ?????? ???????
  ??????????? ?? ?????????.

19
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ???????????
• ?) ??????????? ?? ???????? ??????????? ?????????
  ?? ??????? ???????
• ?) ?????? ??????? ?? ??????? ?????????, ???
  ???????????? ? ?????????, ?????? ?????????.

20
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ???????????
• ???????? ?? ??????????? ?? ???????? ?? ??????????
  ?? ?????? ?? ??????

21
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ?????????????????
• ???????????? ?? ??????? ???????????? ??????? ??
  ?????????
• ?????????????? ?????????? ????? ?? ????????
  ???????? ?? ?????? ?? ????????? ???????
• ???????????? ????? ?? ??????????? ?? ?????????
  ??????? ?????? ?????? ? ????? ?????????
  ??????????? ? ????????? ?????????.

22
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ?????????????????
• ??????? ?? ???????? ?? ??????????? ?? ???? ??
  ???? ?????? ??????????, ?? ???? ?? ???? ?????????
  ??????????? ??????????? ?? ???????????????? ?
  ???? ?????? ?? ?????????, ????? ? ???????,
  ????????? ?? ??????????? ?? ?????????? ?????? ?
  ????????? ?? ????????? ????????? ?? ???????????
  ?? ???????

23
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ???????????????
• ???????? ???????????? ?? ??????? ???????? ?
  ????????? ?? ???????? ?? ?????????
• ???????????? ? ??????????? ?? ??????????????
  ??????? ?? ???????????????? ?????????
  ?????????? ?????????, ????????? ????????? ??
  ?????????? ?? ???

24
5. ??????????? ????????????????? -
???????????????

• ???????????????
• ???????? ?? ??????????? ????? ?? ???????? ?
  ???????? ??????????, ?? ?? ?????? ???? ?????????
  ? ???? ??????? ? ?????????????? ? ???????????? ??
  ?????? ? ?????????

25

• ??????? ?? ????????

?
?
??
-???????????? ????? ???-?????????? ???? ? ??

• ?????? ???? ? ??
• ???e

• ?????? ???? ?? ? ???

26
1. ???????? ?? ????????????

• Economics Strategy History
  Philosophy International Law
• Thucydides Aquinas
• 16th
• 17th Machiavelli Grotius
  
• 18th Smith
• 19th Marx Clausewitz
  Rousseau Kant
• 20th Imperialism theories History
  of Diplomacy
• Geography Geopolitics
• WWI The birth of the discipline
• 1920-30s IDEALISM
• WWII REALISM Traditionalism
  First Debate
• 1950s Functionalism
• Natural sciences SCIENTISM
  (Behavioralism, FPA)
  Second Debate
• 1960s Peace research
  Realism revisited Third
  Debate
• 1970s Dependency (Marxism) NEOREALISM LIBERALISM
  
• 1980s Critical theory
  Rationalism INSTITUTIONALISM
• Humanities Feminism Fourth debate
• 1990s Postmodernism CONSTRUCTIVISM
• 2000s Fifth Debate?
  Developed Game Theory

27
1. ???????? ?? ????????????

• Economics Strategy History
  Philosophy International Law
• Thucydides Aquinas
• 16th
• 17th Machiavelli Grotius
  
• 18th Smith
• 19th Marx Clausewitz
  Rousseau Kant
• 20th Imperialism theories History
  of Diplomacy
• Geography Geopolitics
• WWI The birth of the discipline
• 1920-30s IDEALISM
• WWII REALISM Traditionalism
  First Debate
• 1950s Functionalism
• Natural sciences SCIENTISM
  (Behavioralism, FPA)
  Second Debate
• 1960s Peace research
  Realism revisited Third
  Debate
• 1970s Dependency (Marxism) NEOREALISM LIBERALISM
  
• 1980s Critical theory
  Rationalism
  INSTITUTIONALISM
• Humanities Feminism Fourth debate
• 1990s Postmodernism CONSTRUCTIVISM
• 2000s Postructuralism Developed Game theory
  Fifth Debate?