Fermats Last Theorem

1
Fermats Last Theorem

• When x, y and z are whole numbers each raised to
  power of n, the sum of the first two can never
  equal the third when n is greater than 2.

2
Stirring Your Rice Pudding p.4

• Thomasina When you stir your rice pudding,
  Septimus, the spoonful of jam spreads itself
  round making red trails like the picture of a
  meteor in my astronomical atlas. But if you stir
  backward, the jam will not come together again.
  Indeed, the pudding does not notice and continues
  to turn pink just as before. Do you think this
  is odd?
• Septimus No.
• Thomasina Well, I do. You cannot stir things
  apart.

3
Determinism p.5

• Thomasina If you could stop every atom in its
  position and direction, and if your mind could
  comprehend all the actions thus suspended, then
  if you were really, really good at algebra you
  could write the formula for all the future and
  although nobody can be so clever as to do it, the
  formula must exist just as if one could.

• Near the end of the 18th century, French
  mathematician Pierre Simon de Laplace described
  determinism
• If an intelligence, for one given instant,
  recognizes all the forces which animate Nature,
  and the respective positions of the things which
  compose it, and if that intelligence is
  sufficiently vast to subject these data to
  analysis, it will comprehend in one formula the
  movements of the largest bodies of the universe
  as well as those of the minutest atom nothing
  will be uncertain to it, and the future as well
  as the past will be present to its vision.

4
Thomasinas New Geometry of Irregular Forms p.37

• Thomasina if there is an equation for a curve
  like a bell

5

• there must be an equation for one like a
  bluebell, and if a bluebell, why not a rose?...

6

• Do we believe nature is written in numbers?
• Septimus We do.
• Thomasina They why do your equations only
  describe the shapes of manufacture?
• Septimus I do not know.
• Thomasina Armed thus, God could only make a
  cabinet.

7

• Septimus He has mastery of equations which lead
  into infinities where we cannot follow.
• Thomasina What a faint-heart! We must work
  outward from the middle of the maze. We will
  start with something simple. I will plot this
  leaf and deduce its equation. You will be famous
  for being my tutor when Lord Byron is dead and
  forgotten.

8
Fractal Leaf
Fractal The result of an infinite number of
iterations of a given operation (equation) or set
of instructions.
9
Classical Maths vs. Modern Maths

• A great revolution of ideas separates the
  classical mathematics of the 19th century from
  the modern mathematics of the 20th. Classical
  mathematics had its roots in the regular
  geometric structures of Euclid and the
  continuously evolving dynamics of Newton. Modern
  mathematicswas forced by the discovery of
  mathematical structures that did not fit the
  patterns of Euclid and Newton. These new
  structures were regardedas pathological,as a
  gallery of monsters, kin to the cubist painting
  and atonal music that were upsetting established
  standards of taste in the arts at about the same
  time. Twentieth-century mathematics flowered in
  the belief that it had transcended completely the
  limitations imposed by its natural origins.

10

• Now, as Mandelbrot points out,Nature had played
  a joke on the mathematicians. The 19th-century
  mathematicians may have been lacking in
  imagination, but Nature was not. The same
  pathological structures that the mathematicians
  invented to break loose from 19th century
  naturalism turn out to be inherent in familiar
  objects all around us.

11
Algebra (to bind together) vs. Fractal (to break)

• There is a saying in Latin that to name is to
  know Nomen est numen. However, as the
  classical monsters were defanged and harnessed
  through my efforts, and as many new monsters
  began to arise, the need for a term became
  increasingly apparent. I coined fractal from the
  Latin adjective fractus. The corresponding Latin
  verb frangere means to break to create
  irregular fragments. It is therefore sensible
  and how appropriate for our needs! that, in
  addition to fragmented (as in fraction or
  refraction), fractus should also mean
  irregular, both meanings being preserved in
  fragment. Since algebra derives from the Arabic
  jabara to bind together, fractal and algebra
  are etymological opposites!
• -Benoit Mandelbrot

12

• For understanding complexity, they (Euclids
  mathematics) turn out to be the wrong kind of
  abstraction. Clouds are not spheres, mountains
  are not cones (Gleick 94).
• Simple shapes fail to resonate with the way
  nature organizes itself or with the way human
  perception sees the world (Gleick 116).

• Thomasina was right, in abandoning Euclidean
  geometry.
• Thomasina Mountains are not pyramids and trees
  are not cones. God must love gunnery and
  architecture if Euclid is his only geometry. p.84

13
New Geometry of Irregular Forms

• Hannah I, Thomasina Coverly, have found a truly
  wonderful method whereby all the forms of nature
  must give up their numerical secrets and draw
  themselves through number alone. This margin
  being too mean for my purpose, the reader must
  look elsewhere for the New Geometry of Irregular
  Forms discovered by Thomasina Coverly. p.43

14
Fractal Ferns
15
Iterated Algorithms p.43

• Hannah Whats an iterated algorithm?
• Valentine ...its an algorithm thats been
  iterated. The left-hand pages are graphs of
  what the numbers are doing on the right-hand
  pages. But all on different scales. Each graph
  is a small section of the previous one, blown up.
  Like youd blow us a detail of a photograph, and
  then a detail of the detail, and so on, forever.
  Or in her case till she ran out of pages.

16

• Iteration To repeat a process over and over
  again. Some involve algebraic equations or
  mathematical functions, others involve computer
  algorithms.

• Valentine You have some x-and-y equation. Any
  value for x gives you a value for y. So you put a
  dot where its right for both x and y. Then you
  take the next value for x which gives you another
  value for y, and then youve done that a few
  times you join up the dots and thats your graph
  of whatever the equation is. p.44

17

• Algorithm Simply described, a finite list of
  well-defined instructions for accomplishing some
  task that, given an initial state, will terminate
  in a defined end-state.
• The word algorithm is derived from
  Al-Khowarizmi. Al-Khowarizmi wrote books on
  arithmetic and algebra, borrowing Hindu ideas and
  symbols for numerals, as well as Mesopotamian
  concepts and Euclids geometrical thought --
  Aczel, Amir D. Fermats Last Theorem.

18
Hannah And is that what shes doing?

• Valentine Whats shes doing is, every time she
  works out a value for y, shes using that as her
  next value for x. And so on. Like a feedback.
  Shes feeding the solution back into the
  equation, and then solving it again. Iteration,
  you see.
• Hannah And thats surprising, is it?
• Valentine Well, it is a bit. Its the technique
  Im using on my grouse numbers, and it hasnt
  been around for much longer than, well, call it
  twenty years. When Thomasina was doing maths it
  had been the same maths for a couple of thousand
  years. Classical. And for a century after
  Thomasina. Then maths left the real world
  behind, just like modern art, really. Nature was
  classical, maths was suddenly Picassos. But now
  nature is having the last laugh. The freaky
  stuff is turning out to be the mathematics of the
  natural world. p.44

19

• Valentine If you knew the algorithm and fed it
  back say ten thousand times, each time thered be
  a dot somewhere on the screen. Youd never know
  where to expect the next dot. But gradually
  youd start to see this shape, because every dot
  will be inside the shape of this leaf. It
  wouldnt be a leaf, it would be a mathematical
  object. But yes. The unpredictable and the
  predetermined unfold together to make everything
  the way it is. p.47

20

• Hannah This feedback, is it a way of making
  pictures of forms in nature? Just tell me if it
  is or it isnt.
• Valentine To me it is. Pictures of turbulence
  growth change creation its not a way of
  drawing an elephant, for Gods sake!
• Hannah So you couldnt make a picture of this
  leaf by iterating a whatsit?
• Valentine Oh yes, you could do that. p.47

21

• The unpredictable and the predetermined unfold
  together to make everything the way it is.

22

• The world displays a regular irregularity
  (Gleick 98).

23
Valentines Grouse

• It seems that most of what is interesting in the
  natural world, and especially in the biological
  world of living things, involves nonlinear
  mathematics. Biologists - working on the ups
  and downs of animal population - were among the
  first to see that not only can simple rules give
  rise to behavior which looks very complicated,
  but the behavior can be so sensitive to the
  starting conditions as to make long term
  prediction impossible (even when you know the
  rule) -- May, Robert M. From Newton to Chaos.

24
Chaos Theory and Population Biology

• It seems likely that much complexity and
  apparent irregularity seen in nature derives from
  simple but chaotic rules.
• Ultimately, the mathematics of chaos offers new
  and deep insights into the structure of the world
  around us -- May, Robert M. From Newton to
  Chaos.
• Chaos Theory is about finding the underlying
  order in apparently random data -- Rae, Gregory.
  Chaos Theory a Brief Introduction.

• Valentine Ive got a graph real data and Im
  trying to find the equation which would give you
  the graph if you iterated it. p.45

25
Chaos

• The simplest rules or algorithms or mathematical
  equations, containing no random elements
  whatsoever, can generate behavior which is as
  complicated as anything we can imagine.
• It says that a situation can be both
  deterministic and unpredictable like a storm
  system (unpredictable without being random or
  attributable to very complicated causes).
• -- May, Robert M. From Newton to Chaos.

26

• Simple as the rules may be in themselves, these
  chaos-generating equations have the property of
  being nonlinear.
• With linear equations, one can predict what comes
  next, or guess ahead. But Nature draws itself
  differently and uses nonlinear equations.

• Valentine Its how you look at population
  changes in biology. Goldfish in a pond, say.
  This year there are x goldfish. Next year
  therell be y goldfish. Some get born, some get
  eaten by herons, whatever. Nature manipulates
  the x and turns it into y. Then y goldfish is
  your starting population for the following year.
  Your value for y becomes your next value for x.
  The question is what is being done to x? What
  is the manipulation? Whatever it is, it can be
  written down as mathematics. Its called an
  algorithm. p.45

27

• Valentine its not nature in a box. But it
  turns out the population is obeying a
  mathematical rule.
• Hannah The goldfish are?
• Valentine Yes. No. The numbers. Its not
  about the behaviour of fish. Its about the
  behaviour of numbers. This thing works for any
  phenomenon which eats its own numbers
• Hannah Does it work for grouse? p.45

28
Noise

• Valentine Theres more noise with grouse.
• Hannah Noise?
• Valentine Distortions. Interference. Real data
  is messy. Theres a thousand acres of moorland
  that had grouse on itbut nobody counted the
  grouse. They shot them. So you count the grouse
  they shot. But burning the heather interferes,
  it improves the food supply. A good year for
  foxes interferes the other way, they eat the
  chicks. And then theres the weather. Its all
  very, very noisy out there. Very hard to spot
  the tune
• Hannah Why did you choose them? (grouse)
• Valentine The game books. My true inheritance.
  Two hundred years of real data on a plate. p.46

29

• Human was the music,
• Math was the static
• -- John Updike, as quoted in Chaos by James Gleick

30

• Valentine The unpredictable and the
  predetermined unfold together to make everything
  the way it is. Its how nature creates itself,
  on every scale, the snowflake and the snowstorm.
  It makes me so happy. To be at the beginning
  again, knowing almost nothing. People were
  talking about the end of physics. Relativity and
  quantum looked as if they were going to clean out
  the whole problem between them. A theory of
  everything. But they only explained the very big
  and the very small. The universe, the elementary
  particles. p.48

31
The Very Big
(Macro)

• as complicated as anything we can imagine.
• attributable to very complicated causes.
• The universe
• Valentine predicting events at the edge of the
  galaxy p.48

32
And The Very Small
(Micro)

• Atoms
• Elementary particles
• Valentine inside the nucleus of an atom p.48

33
The Ordinary-Sized Stuff

• Valentine The ordinary-sized stuff which is our
  lives, the things people write poetry about
  clouds daffodils waterfalls and what
  happens in a cup of coffee when the cream goes in
  these things are full of mystery, as mysterious
  to us as the heavens were to the Greeks. p.48

34

• Water dripping from a faucet is called chaotic.
  It is virtually impossible to predict when the
  next drop will fall -- Atkatz, David. Newton,
  Determinism, and Chaos.

• Valentine We cant even predict the next drop
  from a dripping tap Each drip sets up the
  conditions for the next, the smallest variation
  blows prediction apart p.48

Its the best possible time to be alive, when
almost everything you thought you knew is wrong.
-- Valentine Coverly
35

• Thomasina Did you not like my rabbit equation?
  It eats its own progeny.
• Septimus I did not see that. p.77

• Valentine Its about the behaviour of numbers.
  This thing works for any phenomenon which eats
  its own numbers p.45