Title: Adolescent ADHD
1Adolescent ADHD
2Etiology
- ADHD is a heterogeneous behavioral disorder with
multiple possible etiologies - Neuroanatomic/ Neurochemical
- CNS Insults
- Genetic Origins
- Environmental factors
3Core Symptoms Areas
4DSM-IV CriteriaInattentionSix or more of the
followingmanifested often
- Inattention to details/
- makes careless mistakes
- Difficulty sustaining attention
- Seems not to listen
- Fails to finish tasks
- Difficulty organization
- Avoids tasks requiring sustained attention
- Loses things
- Easily distracted
- Forgetful
5ADHD DSM-IV CriteriaImpulsivity/HyperactivitySi
x or more of the following-manifested often
- Impulsivity
- Blurts out answer before questions is finished
- Difficulty awaiting turn
- Interrupts or intrudes on others
- Hyperactivity
- Fidgets
- Unable to stay seated
- Inappropriate running/climbing (restlessness)
- Difficulty in engaging in leisure activities
quietly - On the go
- Talks excessively
6Variation in symptoms
- Symptoms vary in
- Pervasiveness
- Frequency of occurrence
- Degree of impairment
7DSM-IV Diagnosis Criteria
- Symptom criteria must be met for past 6 months
- Some symptoms must be present before 7 years of
age - Some impairment from symptoms must be present in
2 or more settings - The symptoms lead to significant impairment
- Symptoms are not exclusively due to other mental
disorders
8DSM-IV Subtypes
- ADHD Predominantly Inattentive Type
- Criteria met for Inattentive but note for
impulsivity/hyperactivity - ADHD Predominantly Hyperactivity/Impulsivity Type
- Criteria met for impulsivity/hyperactivity but
not for Inattention - ADHD Combined Type
- Criteria are met for both inattention and
impulsivity/hyperactivity
9Impact and cost of ADHD
- ADHD in adult prison inmates25
- More drivers with ADHD
- Drove without a license
- Had license revoked or suspended
- Had multiple crashes(2)
- Had multiple traffic citations(3)
- Subgroups of ADHD with comorbid ODD/CD were at
highest risk
10Impact and cost of ADHD
- Despite similar educational levels and IQ scores,
individuals with ADHD not taking medication
display significantly more academic problems in
school (25 repeat a grade) and lower occupation
attainment
11Impact and cost of ADHD
- Parents of children with ADHD experience higher
level of stress, self blame, social isolation,
depression and marital discord - 63 of 144 caregivers after diagnosis of child s
ADHD changed work status
12??40????
- Laufer (1962) The behavior picture described
tends to disappear with maturation, anywhere
between twelve and eighteen years of age. - Mendelson et al (1971) Our findings suggest
that hyperactive children are generally behaving
in a more normal way by the time they enter their
teens - Wender (1995)the past decade researchers have
become convinced thatADHD is a common
psychiatric disorder in adults - Gadow and Weiss (2001) the validity of this
disorder is now beyond controversy.
13Diagnosis of Adolescent ADHD
- Still an observational diagnosis
- DSM-IV criteria thought threshold could be too
high - Likely 4/9 (Barkley et al., 2001)
- Shouldnt apply age 7 criteria (Applegate et al.,
1996) - Semi-structured interview should be done
- Measurement of impairment
14Pitfall in the diagnosis of adolescent ADHD --I
- Individuals (esp. girls) who tend to exhibit
fewer hyperactive symptoms - Individuals who exhibit mental rather than
physical restlessness - The ubiquity of inattentive and impulsive
behavior in normal adolescent life - Developmental relativity, age appropriateness
15Pitfall in the diagnosis of adolescent ADHD --II
- Self report Vs parental report
- Difficulty to obtain data from secondary school
teacher - Uncooperative adolescents
- Multiple comorbid disorder
- Shared features of other adolescent onset
psychiatric disorders - Life span with multiple stresses
16 Pitfall in the diagnosis of adolescent ADHD --III
- The uncertain validity of applying DSM-IV
diagnostic criteria for ADHD in adolescent - The difficulty of establishing impairment in
functioning due to ADHD for adolescent - Different definition of remission
- Syndromatic remission
- Symptomatic remission
- Functional remission
17Definition of ADHD Remission
18Adolescent and adult with ADHDBackground
- A source of controversy and uncertainty in ADHD
is the marked differences that have been observed
in male to female ration between pediatric and
adolescent samples - Gender ration in pediatric sample heavily favors
male 41 91 - Adolescent and adult samples have a more even
gender distribution - Differences in gender representation have
threaten the validity of the diagnosis of
Adolescent and adult ADHD
19Adolescent and adult with ADHDBackground
- Similar pattern of comorbidity had been
documented in boys and girls with ADHD - However, boys havegt2 fold increased rates of
disruptive behavior disorder - Disruptive behavior disorders drive clinical
referrals of children but not adults
20Follow up studies in ADHD
- Montreal study by Weiss and Hechtman (1993)
- New York Study by Mannuzza,Klein et al (1998)
- Swedish Study by Rasmussen and Gillberg (2001)
- Milwaukee Study by Barkley (2002)
21What predicts persistence of ADHD into
adolescence?(Biederman, Farone et al1996)
- Familiarity of the ADHD(OR 2)
- Presence of psychiatry comorbidity (conduct
disorder, mood or anxiety disorder) (OR 3) - Family adversity (paternal mental illness,
conflict in family) (OR 7)(plt0.001)
22Adolescent outcome
- decline in hyperactivity, improvement in
attention span and impulse control (Hart, Lahey,
Loeber, Applegate Frick, 1995) - 30-80 of ADHD children continue to display
symptoms in adolescence (Gittelman, Mannuzza,
1985 Barkley, Fischer et al, 1990) - 25-45 display oppositional or antisocial
behavior or CD (Biederman, Faraone et al 1996,
Biederman et al 1997)
23How are ADHD adolescents doing in school?
- 29.3 retained in a grade, 46.3 had been
suspended, 10 dropped out.(Barkley,
Fischer,1990) - ADHD adolescents had more academic
impairments(compared to baseline), lower IQ and
mathematics achievement scores and more learning
disabilities. - Fail to work independently well
- Poor organization and planning
- Poor time management
- Poor follow through
24Differential diagnosis of ADHD--comorbidity
alter the clinical presentation and may require
multiple treatment
- Coexisting conditions
- Conduct disorder
- Learning disorder
- Oppositional defiant disorder
- Bipolar affective disorder
- Epilepsy
- Tourette syndrome
25Comorbid disorders in ADHD adolescents
- High percentage of antisocial behavior, but low
rates of mood and anxiety disorders.(Weiss 1993
Mannuzza 1991) - 59 of ADHD adolescents had ODD, 43 had
CD(Barkley,1990) - Baseline comorbid CD significantly increase the
risk for CD and ODD, Bipolar Disorder and alcohol
and drug dependence on follow up. - Baseline comorbid major depression increased the
risk for ODD, Major Depression, Bipolar Disorder
and Agoraphobia. - Multiple anxiety disorder at baseline increased
the risk for Anxiety Disorder. - Youngster with non-comorbid ADHD had an increased
risk for ODD, Tic Disorder, and Language
disorder. (Biederman, Faraone et al, 1996)
26Comorbidity of adolescent ADHD
27Overlapping Diagnostic Criteria
28Psychiatry and Medical Disorders can mimic ADHD
- Mood Disorder
- Psychotic Disorder
- Adjustment Disorder
- Anxiety Disorder
- Learning/language Disorder
- Stress-related Disorder
- Developmental Disorder
- Sleep Apnea
- Substance Use Disorder
- Use of Other medications
- Seizure Disorder
- Vision problem
- Hearing Impairment
29How does having ADHD affect self esteem?
- ADHD individuals displayed lower self-esteem and
psychosocial adjustment by adolescents and lower
educational achievement and occupational status.
(Mannuzza, Klein,1995) - Lowered self esteem is part of the longitudinal
outcome of ADHD
30How are ADHD adolescents getting along with their
families?
- Parent-adolescent relationship between ADHD
teenagers and their parents are generally
characterized by increased conflict, negative
communication, distorted beliefs, and more
disengagement, especially when the adolescents
are diagnosed with ADHDODD.
31Adolescent ADHD and substance use
- Persistence of ADHD symptoms, family history and
comorbid CD high prediction of drunkenness and
daily smoking - Among different symptom cluster in ADHD,
inattentiveness is most predictive of substance
use
32ADHD studies
33Developmental outcome and developmental course
research
- Developmental outcome studyidentifying a cohort
of children that meet diagnostic criteria for
ADHD and follow them prospectively to determine
whether they are at increased risk for any number
of negative developmental outcome - Developmental course study whether the symptoms
of ADHD persist into adolescent
34Developmental outcome studies
- Thorley (1984)Childhood hyperactivity was
associated with an increased risk for PD,
antisocial behavior, peer relationship,
educational difficulties,as well as continued HIA
symptoms - Clampit and Pirkle (1983) psychostimulants maybe
effective in ADHD adolescents - Barkley et al (1993) children with ADHD are at
increased risk for a variety of negative
developmental outcome in adolescence and
adulthood. - Barkley et al (2002) the educational,
occupational, and psychosocial risks are
associated with a childhood diagnosis of ADHD
relative to both normal and clinical control
populations.
35Limitations of developmental outcome studies
- It remains unclear whether
- ADHD symptomatology may interfere with normal
development process, including parent-child
relationships, peer relationship and/or academic
performance that in turns increase the risk of
negative outcome, or - ADHD may facilitate the onset and persistence of
other behaviors/psychiatric disorder that
increase the risk for negative outcome.
36The importance of developmental course study
- Clarify the mechanism linking childhood ADHD to
later negative developmental outcome - An improved understanding of the developmental
course of ADHD symptomatology would provide
information for the construction of
developmentally sensitive diagnostic criteria
37Developmental course studies
- Diagnostic retention studies
- Symptom trajectory studies
- MacCallum et al (2002) repeated measures data
of a continuous variable provide more information
than a dichotomous diagnosis
38Diagnostic retention studies
- Hill and Schoener (1996)meta-analysis of 9
diagnostic retention studies. Rate of ADHD
desisted by 50 every 5 years(beginning at 9) - Barkley(1998)s criticize 1. Many of the studies
included were initiated prior to the
establishment of formal diagnostic criteria for
ADHD. 2. Not enough studies were included.
39Symptom trajectory studies
- Hart et al(1995) 1. Hyperactive-impulsive
symptoms significantly declined with increasing
age, whereas inattention symptoms did not. 2.
Conduct problems predicted persistence of ADHD
symptom. 3.Developmental changes in ADHD symptom
did not vary as a function of informants 4.
Psychosocial and pharmacological interventions
did not reduce ADHD greatly. - Biederman (1998)1.Children and adolescent ADHD
did not differ in the mean number of ADHD
symptoms. 2.Clinical phenotype is the same in
adolescent and children. - Biederman (on the same sample,2000) HIA
decreased significantly as age increased.
40Developmental Trajectories of Brian volume
abnormalities in youth with ADHD
- Design MRI case control study
- M152 youth with ADHD and 139 controls of both
genders - Objectives assess volumetric changes overtime in
medicated vs unmedicated youth with ADHD and
controls - Catellanous JAMA 2002 288-1740
41Developmental Trajectories of Brian volume
abnormalities in youth with ADHD
- Main Findings
- Smaller brain volumes in all regions
independently of medication status - Smaller total cerebral (-3.2)and cerebellar
(-3.5) volumes - Volumetric abnormalies(except caudate) persistent
with age - No gender differences
- Volumetric findings correlated with severity of
AHDH
42Developmental Trajectories of Brian volume
abnormalities in youth with ADHD
- Conclusions
- Genetic and or early environmental influences on
brain development in ADHD are fixed,
nonprogressive and unrelated to stimulant
treatment
43Maturation lag hypothesis
- Satterfield JH(1973,1984)ADHD children have more
slow activity and less activity in the high
frequency band---signs of immaturity reflecting a
delayed brain maturation that could be normalized
with age,or a deviation of brain maturation. - Giedd JN(2001)ADHD cerebellum is significantly
smaller than control. - Lou (1984)SPECT findingmaturational lags of CNS
resulting from delayed myelination. - Castellanos (2002)gray matter shows complex
developmental curves with a preadolescent
increase but a post adolescent decrease.
44Limitations of developmental course studies
- Sample characteristics predominantly males in
clinic referred sample - Course of ADHD symptomatology differs as a
function of comorbidity? - The need to better understand whether reductions
in ADHD(due either to sex and/or advancing age)
are associated with specific changes in
functional impairment that result from ADHD. - Design issues
- Wide age range
- Time adjacent study that did not consider the
functional form that characterizes this change
over time
45More limitations
- Heterogeneity ADHD is not a homogenous disease
- Mendelson et al (1971)1/2 improved over time, ¼
partial improved, ¼unchanged - Loney (1981)developmental delay, developmental
decay, continual display - Lambert (1987,community cases)20 remitters,
residuals 37, persisters (43) - Hechtman of Montreal sample(1993)1/3 normal
outcome, 1/2continual symptoms with function
impairment, a minority experienced serious
outcome.
46Implications
- Clinicians working with substance abuse
populations, conduct disordered populations and
head injury populations should be alert for ADHD. - ADHD is a lifelong disorder
47Treatment options in comorbid ADHD
- Assess and treat all disorders
- Prioritized treatment
- Treatment of ADHD almost always involves the
treatment of comorbidity - Order of treatment
- Most debilitating symptoms first
- Consider interactions of symptoms and side
effects of stimulants - Simple case monotherapy
- Complex case- combined treatment
48Use of Ritain
- Absolute range per dose5-30 mg
- Weight-based dose range per day 0.3-2.0mg/kg
- There is no research to indicate more medicine
with higher body weight - Dose of medicine varied with individuals
metabolism, severity of ADHD symptoms, presence
of comorbid conditions, behavior characteristics
and natural environment
49Side effect of Ritalin and its management
- Anorexia(generally lunch)-give with meals, snacks
- Insomnia- move dosing earlier, use of clonidine,
TCA - Mood disturbance- evaluate for mood disorder,
assess timing of mood to r/o wear off effect - Tic disorder- assess for underlying tics, stop
and rechallenge - Headache- lower dose, change prep, consider beta
blocker - Psychosis- rare, reassess dose and comorbid
- Delay growth spurt- drug holiday if inattentive
form
50Non-stimulant pharmacotherapy
- TCA
- 60-70 effective, but generally less effective
than stimulants - Bupropion
- First line for ADHD substance abuse/cigarette
use - Maybe helpful in ADHD mood lability
- Clonidine
- Useful in ADHD tics
- Use at night for ADHD related sleep problem
- Concerns of sudden death case report of 4
children(clonidine MPH)
51Treatment of ADHD with MDD
- Depression disorder
- If MDD is severe, then it is the focus of
treatment - If MDD is less severe or not primary, use
stimulant trial first - After stimulant trial, evaluate the depressive
symptoms - If depressive symptoms continue, use
antidepressant or psychotherapeutic treatment - SSRI effective for depression but not ADHD
- If depressive symptoms subsided, continue
stimulants - Bupropion and TCA have antidepressant activity in
adult, but utility in pediatric use had nor been
established(5 cases of sudden death in younger
children)
52Treatment of ADHD with anxiety disorder
- Differentiate the relationship between ADHD and
anxiety disorders - Start with a stimulant trial
- If ADHD symptoms improve, but anxiety symptoms
persisted, apply psychosocial intervention - If the anxiety symptoms does not improve with the
psychosocial intervention, consider adding SSRI
to the stimulants.
53Treatment of ADHD with tics disorder
- High comorbidity of ADHD (50-70 TS patients)
- Onset of ADHD before tics
- Stimulants are highly effective in the treatment
of ADHD in these patients and in the majority of
patients tics do not increase - Start the stimulant treatment after proper
informed consent - If tics worsen markedly, move on to an
alternative stimulants - If tics do not worsen, and ADHD symptoms respond,
remain on the stimulants - To treat the tics, consider combine medication,
clonidine and guanfacine may be tried first
54Treatment of ADHD with conduct disorder and
aggression
- It stimulant did not reduce antisocial behavior
despite the attenuation of the ADHD symptoms, use
mood stabilizer(Li or divalproex sodium), or
Clonidine in addition to stimulants(Frazier,
1999)(4 deaths with the combination of Stimulants
and Clonidine) - Use of Clonidinestart with 0.05mg at bedtime,
never more than 0.3 mg per day. Never use in
patients with family history of sudden death,
repeated fainting or arrhythmias. - If aggression is severe, and is in immediate
danger, use atypical neuroleptics, such as 0.5mg
QD Risperidone, to the stimulants
55Prevention of Abuse potential of stimulants in
adolescents
- Locked the medicine, keep a record
- Do not use one students medicine on another
- Avoid sending medicine to school
- Use Concerta paste, taken once daily
56Oslon, 1959
- Those who surprised us seems to take a longer
time to travel a given road, but that road has
been kept open by parents and teachers who felt
it worthwhile.