Title: Propeller Club Geneva, January 26th 2006
1Propeller ClubGeneva, January 26th 2006
21.- Freight market characteristics 2.- Freight
economics 3.- Using freight derivatives 4.-
Market outlook oil shipping
3Freight specificities
- Freight is a commodity but all commodities are
not born equal - 1gt Oil, coal, ore, veg oil, chemicals, etc.
- These commodities can be stored, at a financial
cost, defining cash carry - 2gt Electricity, emissions, broadband, weather
and freight - No storage !
- 3gt The specificity of freight, beyond SD
variables (new buildings and scrappings), is that
offer can be increased with routing and speed,
and can only be reduced by slowing the speed and
staying at anchor. - 4gt Hence a higher volatility than most commodities
4Market participants
- Over the last 3 years, the market has been
through a concentration cycle, through mergers
acquisitions and the creation of pools. - 50 of apparent market is covered by 5 players,
on all segments - On the other side, oil majors have furthered
their concentration But the oil market remains
more fragmented than shipping. - 5 years ago, charterers and owners were fighting
over ½ WS point, whereas today the market can gap
10 20 points. - Another reason for record volatility
5Volatilities (30 days annualised)
TD3 Av. 65.16
WTI Av. 34.72
EUR/USD 9.8
6From Fixed Prices to Price Formula?
SHIPPING MARKET
OIL MARKET
1975/1985 Long Term Contracts OSP
1980s A Fixed Price per Spot Cargo
1987 Indexation to a Crude Oil Reference
7Oil Price Formula
1987 Indexation to a Crude Oil Reference
How does it work ?
8Oil Price Formula
9A Shipping Price Formula?
WAF / CHINA
10Oil Paper vs Physical ratio
Future contracts daily volumes in M bbl per day
11 OIL DIFFERENT MARKET PARTICIPANTS TRADE
DIFFERENT TIME HORIZONS
Refiners
55
T R A D E R S
50
End-Users
45
40
USD/BBL
35
Producers
30
Utilities
25
20
15
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
12 FREIGHT WILL DIFFERENT MARKET PARTICIPANTS
TRADE DIFFERENT TIME HORIZONS ?
350
Ship owners Charterers Traders Bankers Refiners
300
250
200
WS
150
100
50
0
M
J
S
D
M
J
S
D
M
J
S
2003
2004
2005
13Market players
LONG FREIGHT
SHORT FREIGHT
SHIPOWNER
END USER
EP CO.
TRADER
TRADER/OWNER
REFINER
INTEGRATED OIL CO.
141.- Freight market characteristics 2.- Freight
economics 3.- Using freight derivatives 4.-
Market outlook oil shipping
15What are our cash flows made of ? The DNR concept
X
minus
minus
Number of days
X
X
Flat rate function ( ,
)
16Factors influencing shipping profitability
-
- FACTOR HEDGING INSTRUMENT
- Ws rate FFAs
- Bunker consumption Fuel oil swaps
- Harbour dues Forex
17 TD3 Term Structure
18Bunkers Term Structure
350
Barges FOB Rotterdam for fuel oil 3.5 S.
300
250
200
USD/MT
150
100
50
0
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
191.- Freight market characteristics 2.- Freight
economics 3.- Using freight derivatives 4.-
Market outlook oil shipping
20Back to basics whats hedging about after all ?
Expected Cash Flow
Probability
Cash Flow
21Tweaking the cash flows curve through hedging
tools
100 hedged
50 hedged
Probability
Unhedged
Cash Flow
22Other tools, other ways to transform our risk
profile
Probability
Unhedged
Cash Flow
23 An example among many the floor option
- We may decide to purchase a Floor on the freight
route so as to insure a minimum rate and get - a full protection against a drop in market
prices - and the full benefit of market up movements (no
opportunity cost) - by paying the Option Premium required for such a
price insurance policy.
24Price (WS)
125
120
Floor 100 WS
We buy a 100 Floor
115
110
105
100
95
90
85
Premium 5 WS
80
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
DEC
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
Volume (KMT/Month) 10 10
10 10
25Price (WS)
We do not have to pay
We receive
Result (WS)
Volume (KMT/Month) 10
10 10 10
26HOW CAN WE USE FFA TO MAXIMISE REVENUE IN A BULL
MARKET
WS
Equivalent vessel sold _at_ Nov avg - ws25 170
Oct 24th
27Hedging to reduce volatility
Forward Market Valuation
10.0
9.0
8.0
7.0
67 HEDGE
6.0
5.0
4.0
33 HEDGE
3.0
2.0
NO HEDGE
1.0
0.0
70
80
90
100
110
120
130
140
14.1
16.7
19.4
22
24.6
27.3
29.9
For Bunker _at_ 210
11.5
281.- Freight market characteristics 2.- Freight
economics 3.- Using freight derivatives 4.-
Market outlook oil shipping
29Shipping market summary
- Exxon Valdez / Erika / Prestige pollutions have
led to single hull phase out - 9/11 prompted the FED to lower interest rates
- Massive newbuilding program shipyards are
saturated 3 years forward - Economic growth (USA/China/India) boosted world
oil demand and transportation demand - In 2004 shipping markets have been strong with
record values - (WS) VLCC 330 / SUEZ 400 / AFRA 400
- Ships trading value (M) VLCC 125 / SUEZ 78
/ AFRA 62 - 2005 from a record high to a record low in the
shortest time followed by range trading 60/100
before present rally
30Growth in oil supply/demand
31Crude tankers fleet
CRUDE FLEET EVOLUTION
(DWT)