Title: BOMA Edmonton Industry Breakfast
1Web-Based Tools and ReportingTo Improve
Operations
- BOMA Edmonton Industry Breakfast
- September 9, 2005
- Chris Vilcsak
- President, Solution 105 Consulting Ltd.
2Solution 105
- Founded in 1999
- Full Spectrum Utility Management
- Electricity, Natural Gas, Water
- Procurement Services (750 million of purchases)
- Detailed Billing Audits (identified over 10
million in errors) - Budget Creation and Variance Reporting (prepare
budgets for clients totaling more than 100
million per year variances 1) - Load Profiling
- Online Reporting and Tracking
- Submetering, Cost Allocation Statements
- Tailored Solutions
3Why Look at Utility Management Tools and Services?
- Due Diligence and Auditing Requirements
- Staff Retention Becoming Critical Priority
- Costs are Increasing Fast!
- Rates are More Complex Than Ever
- Monitoring and Reporting Should Focus on Accuracy
and Efficiency - Outsource to Experts
- Time is the Resource of Concern
4Due Diligence andDetailed Auditing
5Due Diligence and Auditing
- Driven by Sarbanes-Oxley Act from US
- SEC implemented in August 2002
- Effectively, CEOs and CFOs of all publicly
traded companies in the US must represent that
their financial filings are fair and correctly
stated - Tenants and shareholders want accuracy
- Boards of Directors and Executive Managers must
ensure delivery - Utility costs have bottom-line, Net Income impact
6Due Diligence and Auditing
- Errors are not usually in math on the bill, but
instead within the numbers themselves - Simply tracking usage and cost figures is not
Auditing but should highlight gross errors - Detailed Auditing requires
- use of source data
- ability to re-construct utility bill
7Monitoring and ReportingTools and Services
8Detailed Budget Creation
- Creation of initial models
- Effects of weather, tenancy, operational changes
are taken into account - Hourly usage budgets are created for
interval-metered sites - Retail charges are applied
- Regulated charges are applied
- Budgets are summarized and reported
- Reports available on-line
9Budget Variance Analysis Reports
- Sensitivities to weather, tenancy are known from
modeling work - Actual weather is applied to model
- Adjusted budget figures are determined
- Variances are reported and analyzed
- Load profile deviations are highlighted
- Recommendations are made
- HVAC, lighting sweeps, etc.
10Energy Efficiency Projects
- Models create independent baseline figures
- BOMAs Go Green initiative requires baselines
- Government programs (CBIP, ERA/P) do as well
- Comparison of actual to adjusted budget figures
indicates energy savings arms-length reporting - Applying detailed rates (and rate changes)
provides cost savings and indicates where
deviations are caused by rate changes
11Benchmarking
- BVARs can feed into utility tracking, enabling
benchmarking reports - Benchmark against different parameters
- Usage / square foot
- Usage / student
- Cost / usage
- Cost / square foot
- Cost / student
- Identify best in class or justify capital s
12Example Benchmarking
13Utility Bill Tracking ToolBillSmarts.com
- Web-based billing templates
- Can be entered by S105 or your staff
- First-level bill auditing capability
- Enables benchmarking and portfolio analysis
- Used with interval or consumption meters
- Full reporting capabilities
14Submetering
- Usage/cost allocation to business units or
tenants in facilities (Tim Hortons) - Submeters on certain equipment can be used to
improve efficiency (e.g. chiller plant
optimization) - S105 can tie into any major submetering system
(Carma, Quad, Intellimeter) - Read-and-bill statements / invoices
15Real Time Feeds
- S105 able to take real-time feeds into system via
hardware or software routines - Allows for real-time indication of savings due to
short-term operational changes - Comparing readings from real-time and utility
meters may indicate metering issues - Demand limits can be set for alarming
- Price alarms also available
16Operational Examples
- Load Flexibility will maximize benefits
- On-site generation
- Chilled water storage
- HVAC / BAS (Building Automation System) upgrades
17Example On-site Generation
18Example Energy Reduction
19Example HVAC Balancing
20Future Changes
- Smart meters will flatten system profile
- Savings for peak reduction efforts will be lower
- Effect should be smoother long-term pricing
- Changes to power markets in Pacific NW
- Higher pricing in neighboring market (double?!?)
- Expect pressure on AB pricing as a result
- Continuation/growth of incentive programs
- Growth in customer participation
- Utility costs are increasing
21Utility Costs are Increasing
- Use futures market as indicator
- Recent Futures for Power and Gas
- Q4 05 Q1 06 2006
- Natural Gas (/GJ) 11.36 12.20 10.00
- Electricity (/MWh) 86.50 83.75
72.50 - 6x16 112.50 109.00 94.25
- Note Electricity prices shown are for 7x24
profiles. Cost of 86.50/MWh are the same as
8.65 cents/kWh. Price source BP Canada Power
Weekly
22Questions?
23Procurement Issues
24Contract Terms Conditions - Risks
- Volume Risk
- Price Risk
- Ability to transfer / assign
- Other Risks
- Counterparty/Credit Risk
- Performance Risk
- Force Majeure (Unit Contingency) Risk
- Miscellaneous
25Volume Risk
- Want to buy correct volume
- Structure will affect coverage
- Load following 100
- Block/structured balanced coverage
- Understand how energy efficiency savings will be
handled - Portfolio approach lessens volume risk
26Price Risk
- Real-Time and Short-Term Price Changes
- AB, ON price changes can be huge (x200)
- Load flexibility is the key
- An issue only on exposed load
- Long-Term Price Changes
- What happens if market moves either way?
27Transfer/Assignment Issue
- Property segment buy/sell/trade activity
- Contract buy-out impact
- Limited if market does not move
- Positive value if energy market pricing rises
- Negative value if energy market pricing drops
- Assignee credit worthiness is an issue
- May be difficult to split out a site from a
multi-site agreement
28Other Risks
- Counterparty/Credit Risk
- Enron
- Most of focus will be on customer risk
- Note that retailer licence prudential
requirements may only cover a fraction of a
percent of their total exposure - Performance Risk
- Enron
- Billing
- Additional services offered (demand response,
etc.)
29Other Risks
- Force Majeure or Unit Contingency Risk
- A fixed price may not really be fixed
- What happens if retailers purchased generation
is not available due to unit outage? - Miscellaneous Risks
- Take or Pay
- Account management services
- Billing
- Limiting options for energy efficiency
- Regulatory changes
30Credit Issues
- Payment history not as much an issue
- Term offered may be affected
- Release of financials a problem for
privately-held companies - Down payments or performance bonds
- Trigger to provide future collateral
- Parental guarantees may be requested
31Questions?