Comparative study of Bryonia and Pulsatilla

1
Comparative study of Bryonia and Pulsatilla

• By S.P.Roy.
• www.homeopathytimes.com

2
Bryonia and PulsatillaSimilarities

• Both have anxiety during acute conditions.
• Both have bitter taste in equal degree.
• Both have ailments from gastric derangements.
• Both have coated tongue (Bry-with thirst,
  Puls-without thirst).
• Both have agg after eating

3
Bryonia and PulsatillaSimilarities

• Both have agg from heat
• Both have amel from pressure
• Both have amel from cold bathing(Puls may have
  agg from wet cold)
• Both have gastric and rheumatic affections

4
?Bryonia Pulsatilla?Differences

• Irritable and angry people
• Dark hair and complexion
• Muscular, slender robust body
• Mans remedy

• Affectionate and gentle people, mild yet
  irritable, tearful
• Light hair and complexion
• Fleshy body
• Womans remedy

5
?Bryonia Pulsatilla?Differences

• Ailments from anger
• Jaundice
• Generally thirsty
• Generally constipation
• Menses profuse and long lasting

• Ailments from grief
• Chlorosis
• Generally thirst less
• Generally diarrhea
• Menses scanty and short duration

6
?Bryonia Pulsatilla?Differences

• Mucous membranes mostly dry, from lips to anus
• Coryza dry
• Coated tongue with thirst
• Motion agg

• Discharges from mucous membranes thick, bland
  yellowish green
• Coryza fluent
• Coated tongue without thirst
• Motion amel

7
?Bryonia Pulsatilla?Differences

• Aversion open air
• Redness of diseased parts
• Acute rheumatism, agg motion

• Inclination for open air
• Blueness of diseased parts
• Wandering acute rheumatism, agg during rest

8
?Bryonia Pulsatilla?Differences

• Children dislike to be carried
• Complaints during day
• Better in evening
• Agg from vegetable food

• Children like to be carried
• Complaints during evening and night
• Worse in evening
• Agg from fat food

9
?Bryonia Pulsatilla?Differences

• Rheumatism does not shift
• Rarely chilly
• Rarely restless
• Frequently weak

• Rheumatism shift from joint to joint
• Rarely chest pain
• Frequently restless
• Rarely weak

10
?Bryonia Pulsatilla?Differences

• Rarely feet coldness
• Acts more on arteries and synovial membranes
• Indicated in gout

• Rarely indicated in septic states, e.g typhoid
• Acts more on veins
• Indicated in hemorrhoids