Architecture Research Methods ARCH 5365 GW Chapter 12, Epilogue

1
Architecture Research MethodsARCH 5365GW
Chapter 12, Epilogue

• Gary W. Smith, 2006

2
Case Studies and Combined Strategies

• Definition an empirical inquiry that
  investigates a contemporary phenomenon within its
  real-life context

3

• Characteristics of a case study
• a focus on cases IN their contexts
• the capacity to explain causal links
• can help with theory development
• incorporation of multiple sources of evidence
• results can be generalizable to theory

4

• STRENGTHS
• Focus on the embeddedness of the case in its
  context
• Capacity to explain causal links
• Richness of multiple data sources
• Ability to generalize to theory
• Compelling and convincing when done well.

5
WEAKNESSES

• Potential for over-complication
• Causality likely to be multi-faceted and complex
• Challenge of integrating many data sources in
  coherent way
• Replication required in other cases
• Difficult to do well fewer established rules and
  procedures than other research designs

6

• Good Case Studies
• DO NOT simply take what is written about a
  subject and repeat it verbatim
• DO describe in verbal detail a subject, building
  or details form and/or function as it relates to
  ones argument (DESCRIPTIVE)
• DO analyze a subject, building or detail for
  information important to ones reasons and
  evidence (EXPLANATORY)
• DO look for salient facts or contextual reasons
  for its form, materials or construction methods
  (EXPLORATORY)