DNA%20wg%20meeting%20@%20IETF71

1
DNA wg meeting _at_ IETF71
2
Agenda

• 1510 Agenda bashing - 2 minutes
• 1512 Document status and scribes - 3 minutes
• 1515 Simple DNA protocol presentation - 15
  minutes
• 1530 Simple DNA protocol discussion - 20 minutes
  
• Call for adoption and measuring consensus (Jari
  Arkko)
• 1550 Tentative options - 5 minutes
• 1555 Way forward with complete DNA solution - 5
  minutes

3
WG document status

• draft-ietf-dna-protocol
• In v07
• Pending reclassification to Experimental
• Will be discussed in wg
• draft-ietf-dna-tentative
• Expired
• Used for Optimistic DAD (RFC4429)
• Will be revved
• draft-ietf-dna-frd
• Expired
• Will be revved once the protocol goal is achieved

4
Adoption call

• Should we adopt draft-krishnan-dna-simple-03 as
  WG document?
• Yes. (It is a good starting point for a
  deployable solution)
• No. (Kill it, the fundamental approach is wrong)
• Not ready. (The fundamental approach is OK but a
  much better procedure exists for doing the same
  thing)

5
Consensus call

• What do we do with draft-ietf-dna-protocol-07?
• Publish as Informational ( minor edits to remove
  code point requirements)
• Publish as Historic immediately
• Complete current PS work and improve to publish
  as Experimental
• No (Let it die a horrible death)
• Should we continue working on the tentative
  options in the dna wg
• Yes.
• No, punt them off to 6man

6
Reviews

• Thanks to
• Bernard Aboba,
• Thomas Narten,
• Jari Arkko,
• Jin Hyeock Choi, and
• Julien Laganier
• for their reviews.
• We need more eyes on the document.
• If you volunteer, I promise you some nice cookies
  next meeting

7
Thanks for attending

• Questions? Comments?