Title: Eating Disorders: Assessment, Understanding, and Treatment Strategies
1Eating Disorders Assessment, Understanding, and
Treatment Strategies
- Terry Schwartz MD
- Medical Director UCSD Eating Disorders Program
- Asst Clinical Professor UCSD
- Elise Curry Psy.D.
- Program Manager
- UCSD IOP
2ASSESSMENT AND TREATMENT STRATEGIES FOR EATING
DISORDERS
- Terry Schwartz MD
- Medical Director UCSD Outpatient Eating Disorders
Program - Assistant Clinical Professor UCSD Dept Of
Psychiatry
3DSM IV Criteria for Anorexia Nervosa
- Preoccupation with body shape, weight/size
- lt85 ideal BW
- Fear of becoming fat despite low weight
- Loss of 3 consecutive periods in women
- Types restricting,binge/purge,purge
4Anorexia Nervosa
- Most homogenous psychiatric disorder
- 90-95 female
- Onset teenage years puberty
- Monotonous puzzling symptoms
- Poor response to treatment
- Highest mortality rate
- 50 to 80 contribution of genes
- Many women diet, few develop AN predisposing
factors
5DSM IV criteria for Bulimia Nervosa
- Recurrent episodes of binge eating, characterized
by eating an excessive amount of food within a
discrete period of time and by a sense of lack of
control over eating during the episode - Recurrent inappropriate compensatory behavior in
order to prevent weight gain, such as
self-induced vomiting or misuse of laxatives,
diurética, enemas, or other medications
(purging) fasting or excessive exercise - The binge eating and inappropriate compensatory
behaviors both occur, on average, at least twice
a week for 3 months - Self-evaluation is unduly influenced by body
shape and weight
6Psychological Correlates of Anorexia Nervosa
- Poor self concept
- Obsessive compulsive and avoidant personality
style - Perfectionistic, obsessive, harm avoidant traits
- Family dynamics enmeshment, anxiety,
- over-achievers
- Troubles with major life transitions
- an attempt to regress, avoid development
- Difficulty managing and expressing anger
- Cognitive distortions
- Ego-syntonic nature of disease
7Psychological Correlates of Bulimia Nervosa
- Poor self concept
- Chaotic developmental history, parental deficit
- ambiguous communication styles
- Affective regulation problems
- Cognitive distortions
- Ego-dystonic nature of disease
- Impulsivity, substance abuse, self harm, sexual
acting out, shop lifting
8Cognitive Flexibility
- Anorexia Nervosa
- ? Perceptual rigidity
- ? Cognitive rigidity
- AN Weight recovery
- No changes
- AN Full recovery
- Partial improvement in cognitive flexibility
tasks
- Bulimia Nervosa
- Slowness in cognitive shifting tasks
- Fluctuations in Perceptual task
9Scope of The Problem
- Prevalence increasing
- AN .5-2
- BN 3-4
- AN BN More common westernized cultures
- 10 of eating disordered individuals in treatment
are male - 5-20 of AN patients die (disorder or suicide)
-
10Scope of the problem continued
- Highest death rate from any mental health
condition (AN) - Increasing incidence in elementary age children
(8-11 year old) - The incidence of bulimia in 10-39 year old women
TRIPLED between 1988 and 1993. - There has been a rise in incidence of anorexia in
young women 15-19 in each decade since 1930.
11Primary Causes of Death in Patients with Eating
Disorders
12Outcome Data for EDs
- Data mixed results due to design of studies
- AN 10 yr 50 rec, 20-30 improved but still
symptomatic, 10-20 chronic, up to 10 mortality - BN 10yr 50-70 rec, 30 some improvement, 20
chronic
13Outcomes for EDS
- Some studies show ave of 7 years to rec
- Less than 1 year of treatment has poorer
prognosis - Chronicity, OCPD, purging in AN associated with
worse outcome
14Biological underpinnings of eating disorders
- Genetics
- Neurobiological correlates
- Neuropsychiatric
- Brain imaging in AN
15Genetic Correlates of Bulimia Nervosa
- Twin studies
- 5ht2A receptor gene alteration
- Family history of affective, anxiety, substance
abuse d/o
16Genetic Correlates in Anorexia Nervosa
-
- Family and twin studies
- Serotonin receptor gene
- Variation in Dopamine 2 receptor gene
- Chrom 1 and 10
- Family history of OCD, OCPD, AN
-
17Neuroendocrine correlates of Bulimia Nervosa
- Serotonin (5HT1A receptor)
- Endogenous opiate response to binge purge
- ?DA
18Neuroendocrine Correlates of Anorexia Nervosa
- Serotonin (5HT2A receptor)
- Dopamine
- Endogenous opiate response to starvation
- Hypothalamus dysfunction (satiety, amenorrhea)
19Altered Dopamine function and psychiatric
correlates
- Compare normal to psychiatric conditions
- AN increased DA sensitivity, hyper responsive
- Addict reduced DA sensitivity, takes a lot to
stimulate - Obesity DA sensitivity inversely proportional to
weight (high weight, low DA sensitivity)
20Altered Reward Processing in Women Recovered from
Anorexia Nervosa
- RAN may have difficulties differentiating
positive and negative feedback. - The exaggerated activity of the caudate, a region
involved in linking action to outcome, may
constitute an attempt at strategic rather than
hedonic means of responding to reward stimuli. - Researchers hypothesize that individuals with AN
have an imbalance in information processing, with
impaired ability to identify the emotional
significance of a stimulus, but increased traffic
in neurocircuits concerned with planning and
consequences. - Wagner A., Aizenstein H., Venkatraman V. ,Fudge
J, (2007) Altered Reward Processing in Women
recovered from Anorexia Nervosa. Am J Psychiatry
2007 1641842-1849
21Neuropsychiatric correlates of Eating Disorders
- Iowa gambling task AN vs CW Differences seen on
fMRI - AN Neuropsych testing difficulties with set
shifting, flexibility - AN Detail focus, to the point of missing global
(Janet Treasure) - AN vs BN
- Use in clinical practice
22Dopamine function and motivation/behavior
- DA cell fires in response to salient
environmental stimuli (rewarding, aversive,
novel) - DA encodes motivation and appropriate choices
- Part of apparatus that makes value judgments and
makes correct decision in response to a stimuli - Disturbances of brain DA - altered activity,
reward, motivation
23Iowa Gambling Task
- CW distinguished between wins and losses
- AN have similar response to wins and losses
- Perhaps overactive DA response to both Wins and
Losses - Difficulty discriminating positive and negative
stimuli? - Clinical implications
- AN may be unable to discriminate pleasurable and
aversive stimuli - May be very oversensitive to stimuli
- Cannot learn easily learn from experience
- May explain why it is difficult to use reward to
motivate people with AN
24Nancy Zuckers work on Social Cognition in AN
- Experimental Tasks
- 1) Rec ANs rated people as heavier than they
are. Faces less attractive (like Autism) - 2) Rec AN valued faces less than controls, valued
heavy bodies less, valued thin bodies more. - 3) Free viewing eye tracking AN spent less time
on eyes and more time on the mouth (like autism)
25Kate Tchanturias work on AN and Theory of Mind
- ANs were impaired on social cognitive tasks.
- Emotional theory of mind to know what someone
else is feeling. - ANs showed impairment in the ability to infer
about another persons thoughts, beliefs, or
intentions. - Similarities to autism reduced empathy and
increased ability to systematize
26Treatment Implications
- Practice social problem solving (process group)
- Assertiveness role plays
- Practice social problem solving in ambiguous
social situations like friend making, dating etc. - Practice decision making.
- Create social competence training for skill
building (Autism research)
27Brain Imaging in OCDSaxena 2003
- Structural (CT, MRI) variable findings
- Resting PET FDG
- OFC is involved in sensory integration, in
representing the affective value of reinforcers,
and in decision-making and expectation.2 In
particular, the human OFC is thought to regulate
planning behavior associated with sensitivity to
reward and punishment. - 5 of 9 studies elevated metabolism in OFC
- 3 found elevated activity in basal ganglia,
thalamus - PET FDG before/after SSRI, CBT, neurosurgery
- 8 of 10 pre to post-treatment studies decreases
in OFC and/or caudate in responders to treatment - Symptom provocation using PET, fMRI consistent
increases in glucose metabolism or rCBF in OFC,
caudate, anterior cingulate, thalamus - Suggestion of dysfunction of OFC-subcortical
circuits
28Primary taste cortex (rostral insula) represent
taste (temperature, texture) of food in the mouth
that is independent of hunger, and thus of reward
value. Secondary regions (orbitofrontal cortex,
OFC) compute the hedonic value of foodRolls, 2005
29Recovered AN Altered fMRI Response to food
challenge
- Pictures food anterior cingulate cortex and
medial prefrontal (Uher 2003)-anxiety/stress - Taste sugar and water insula, caudate-putamen,
anterior cingulate (Wagner 2007) - Taste sugar and artificial sweetener insula,
caudate (Oberndorfer, Frank, in preparation)
30Psychopharm in EDs
31Pharmacology for AN
- No drug has been FDA approved for AN
- No drug has shown major improvement in the
starvation phase - Meds tried and failed for appetite enhancement
(typical antipsychotic, Li, THC derivatives) - SSRIs generally not helpful in acute starvation,
though some benefit on comorbid disorders
32Pharmacology for AN Continued
- Prozac mixed data for rec-AN
- Atypical antipsychotic medications
- GI meds to aid physical symptoms
- BCP/hormones no evidence of benefit
33Pharmacology for BN
- Serotonin re-uptake inhibitors
- ?SNRIs
- AEDs (topiramate, ?zonisamide)
- Antipsychotics
- Mood stabilizers
- reglan, H2 blockers
- ?? Stimulants (with caution)
34BREAK
35Medical Consequences of AN and BN
36Physical Complications of Anorexia Nervosa
37Physical Complications of Anorexia Nervosa, Cont.
38Physical Complications of Anorexia Nervosa, Cont.
39Physical Complications of Bulimia Nervosa
40Physical Complications of Bulimia Nervosa, cont.
41Amenorrhea and Osteopenia
- Most serious complication of prolonged amenorrhea
is osteopenia, or reduced bone mass
42Osteopenia and Osteoporosis
- Osteopenia refers to decreased quantity of
normally mineralized bone - Osteoporosis is clinical syndrome consisting of
decreased bone mass, disruption in normal bone
architecture with decreased bone strength,
pathological fractures, pain and disability - Osteoporosis defined as greater than 2.5 SD below
the mean for young adult women - Osteopenia 1-2.5 SD below young adult ref
43Bone Density and Fractures
- Each SD decrease in bone density doubles the
fracture risk - DEXA is most widely used method for measuring
bone density - May be compared with age-matched children and
adolescents (Z scores)
44Bone Loss Treatment Strategies
- No therapies proven effective for bone loss in
women with AN. - Estrogen/BCPDecision on estrogen
individualized, but no convincing data that
estrogen alone increases bone density in AN
population.May give false sense of security! - Potential therapies under study
- IGF-I
- DHEA
- Testosterone
- Bisphosphonates
45Osteoporosis Treatment
- Weight gain
- Calcium supplementation improves bone mass
(1500-2000mg/day) - Vitamin D
- Moderate weight-bearing exercise increases bone
mass - When medically stable, wt bearing exercises 3-4
times per week
46Medical/Psychiatric evaluation and treatment
strategies for Anorexia Nervosa
- Assess for comorbidity
- /- Serotonin reuptake inhibitors
- Atypical antipsychotics
- Reglan, h2 blockers
- Screening labs electrolytes, Ca, Mg, Phos,
BUN/Cr, CBC, LFTs, TFTs, UA, hematology - Bone densomitry (DEXA)
- ECG
-
47Medical evaluation for Bulimia Nervosa
- Assess for comorbidity
- Screening labs electrolytes, Ca, Mg, Phos,
BUN/Cr, CBC, LFTs, TFTs, UA, hematology - Dexa
- ECG
- Dental
-
-
48AN Hospital vs Outpatient TreatmentFrom
American Psychiatric Association Guidelines for
the Treatment of Eating Disorders
49Referral to Higher level of care
- Pt is failing lower level.
- Pts weight loss is continuing in spite of
treatment - Pt is unable to stop bingeing/purging.
- Pts physical symptoms warrant greater
supervision (fainting, dehydration, heart
palpitations) - Pt is resisting current level of care
50REFEEDING COMPLICATIONS
- Normal food
- Peripheral edema
- Bloating or discomfort
- Reflux
- Rare gastric dilitation
- Nasogastric feeding
- Seldom indicated
- Nasal, esophageal erosion
- Central hyperalimentation
- Rarely indicated
- Pneumothorax, infection, metabolic disturbances
51Eating behavior in AN After weight restoration
- Hypermetabolic even after weight restoration
- RAN need 50 to 60 kcal/kg/day
- BAN need 40 to 50 kcal/kg/day
- 50 kg women 2000 to 3000 kcal/day
- Probably normalizes in long term
- Probable contribution to high rate of relapse
- Degree of osteopenia depends on age of onset and
duration of amenorrhea - Adolescence is critical time for bone mass
acquisition - Approx 60 of peak bone mass is accrued during
adolescence - Little net gain in bone mass after 2 yrs
post-menarche - Peak bone mass achieved by end of second decade
- Stereotypic food choices, ritualized eating,
calorie counting - Delusionary quality
- Nothing else is more important
52Methods of Treatment
- Regular Weight restoration
- 2 to 3 lbs/wk inpatient
- 1 to 2 lbs/wk day-hospital
- 1 lb/wk outpatient
- Nutritional Teaching
- Provide patient support
- Prevention from vitamin and mineral deficiency
- Prevention of osteoporosis
- Aim for high Ca intake
- Vitamin D to aid in Ca absorption vegetarians
may need supplements - Eat iron-containing foods, especially important
for vegetarians
53lunch
54Countertransference Issues
- Feeling angry at the patient for not recovering
- Thinking this is willful behavior
- Blaming the parents
- Feeling incompetent
- Giving up hope for the patient
- Not taking the disorder seriously
55Coping with Countertransference Issues
- Practice patient acceptance The average recovery
rate is 7 years. - Have compassion for the suffering
- of the patient.
- See their behavior as part of the disorder, not
personal toward you. - Practice good self-care.
56Important tips for physicians when talking to
patients with EDs
57Live Demo
58Process live demo
59Obesity/BED
60Binge Eating Disorder
- Recurrent episodes of binge eating (see BN)
- The binge eating episodes are associated with
three (or more) of the following - Eating much more rapidly than normal
- Eating until feeling uncomfortably full
- Eating large amounts of food when not feeling
physically hungry - Eating alone because of being embarrassed by how
much one is eating - Feeling disgusted with oneself, depressed, or
very guilty after overeating - Marked distress regarding binge eating is present
- 2 days/week for 6 months
61Obesity
- BMI gt 30
- 32.2 of American adults, increasing in children
- Increasing in past 30 years by 50 per decade
- Major successful treatment advances in treatment
of complications of obesity, but minimal success
in treatments for obesity itself
62Is Obesity a psychiatric disorder (BED)?
- Medical/Metabolic issues
- Am J Psych 2007 Issues for DSM V Should
obesity be included as a brain Disorder - Major limitation to treatment of obesity is long
term behavioral compliance - Diets major cause of ED, including BED (recall
starvation study) - Individual biological risks genetic/heritability
63BED and Neurochemistry
- Serotonin, endogenous opiates, cannabinoids
- Certain foods impact nucleus accombens DA,
opiate - Neuropsych similar to addicts ie follow immed
reward over long term results during gambling
type tasks (with excitable reward)
64Food for affect regulation
- Neurochemical stimulation
- Anxiety, depression, anger, boredom, agitation
etc - Endogenous response to food (or starvation) may
predispose to AN or BED/BN
65Literature Review Treatment for BED
- International J of EDs May 2007
- 26 studies reviewed Med plus BWL, meds alone,
BWL alone - Meds plus BWL best, short term
66Psychosocial treatments
- CBT
- CBT plus BWL
- BWL alone
- Group therapy
- Indiv therapy
- 12 step/self help
67Medical treatments for BED/obesity
- No magic pill!
- Sibutramine
- Orlastat
- Acomplia
- Phentermine
- Gastric Bipass
- Stimulants
68Medical treatments for BED/obesity continued
- No magic pill!
- ? SSRIs, SNRIs
- ?Wellbutrin
- ? Topiramate
- ? Zonisamide
69What about psych meds and weight gain
- Need to know and be truthful with ED patients!
- SSRIs
- SNRIs
- Atypical Antipsychotic Medications
- Typical Antipsychotic Medications
- Mood Stabilizers
- TCAs, MAOIs
70BREAK
71Eating Disorders in special populations
72ED IN KIDS TEENS
73What about the kids?
- Pre-pubertal Eating Disorder
- Childhood Onset Eating Disorder
- Early Onset Eating Disorder
74What Are We NOT Talking About?
- DSM-IV Feeding and Eating Disorders of Infancy or
Early Childhood - Pica
- Rumination Disorder
- Feeding disorder of infancy or childhood
75Anorexia NervosaDSM-IV
- Refusal to maintain body weight above a minimally
normal weight for age and height. lt85 of IBW - Intense fear of gaining weight or becoming fat
- Disturbance in the way ones body weight or shape
is experienced - Amenorrhea absence of at least three consecutive
menstrual cycles
76Weight Loss vs Weight Maintenance
- DSM-IV criteria excludes children who have not
reached the critical level of lt85 - Failure to gain appropriate weight with growth
- Malnutrition can lead to poor growth
77Body Image
- May be more tricky to assess
- How can it be evaluated?
- Childrens expression of body image
- Standard tools
- Clinical Interview
- Somatic symptoms
- Abdominal pain or discomfort
- Feeling of fullness
- Nausea
- Loss of appetite
78Amenorrhea
- Primary vs Secondary
- Pubertal delay
- Evaluation may include pelvic ultrasound
- Height
- Weight
- Weight/height ratio
- Ovarian volume
- Uterine volume
- Conventional target weight and weight/height may
be too low to ensure ovarian and uterine maturity
79Alternative Criteria for ED in Children
Byant-Waugh and Lask 1995
- Alternative classification for the range of
eating disorders of childhood - Excessive preoccupation with weight or shape
and/or food intake which is accompanied by
grossly inadequate, irregular or chaotic food
intake
80Byant-Waugh and Lask 1995 Criteria for Anorexia
Nervosa
- Failure to make appropriate weight gains, or
significant weight loss - Determined weight loss (e.g., food avoidance,
self-induced vomiting, excessive exercising,
abuse of laxatives). - Abnormal cognitions regarding weight and/or
shape. - Morbid preoccupation with weight and/or shape.
81Related ED Behaviors in Children
- Anorexia nervosa
- Food avoidant emotional disorder
- Selective eating
- Functional dysphagia
- Bulimia nervosa
- Pervasive refusal syndrome
82Early behavioral risk factors for EDs
- PICA BN
- Picky Eater BN, some AN
- Digestive problems AN
- Subsyndromal symptoms of EDs can predate
83Incidence and Demographics
- Anorexia in this age range is considered to be
rare, but appears to be increasing - Males may constitute a higher proportion of cases
in childhood as opposed to in adolescence or
adulthood - 19-30 of childhood cases
- 5-10 of adolescent or adult cases
84WHY?
85Biological
- Genetics
- Higher rate of AN, BN and ED NOS in first degree
relatives - Cross-transmitted
- High heritability
- Medication
- Trials suggest serotonin and dopamine systems
contribute
- Imaging
- Gordon et al, 1997
- 15 girls ages 8-16 with AN
- Regional cerebral blood blow radioisotope scans
- 13/15 had unilateral temporal lobe hypoperfusion
- Lask et al, 2005
- significant association between unilateral
reduction of blood flow in the temporal region
and - impaired visuospatial ability,
- impaired visual memory
- enhanced speed of information processing
86Psychological
- Personality traits
- Anxious
- Obsessional
- Perfectionistic
- Susceptibility factors
- Obsessions
- Perfectionism
- Symmetry
- Exactness
- Negative affect, harm avoidance
- Preoccupations with weight, body image and food
87SOCIAL
88Prognosis
- Long term follow up of patients with early onset
anorexia nervosa (Bryant-Waugh et al, 1987) - 30 children with anorexia nervosa followed for
mean duration of 7.2 years - Mean age at onset 11.7 years
- 19/30 (60) with a good outcome
- 10/30 remained moderately to severely impaired
- Poor prognostic factors included
- Early age at onset (lt11 years)
- Depression during the illness
- Disturbed family life and one parent families
- Families in which one or both parents had been
married before
89Treatment Challenges (especially for the very
young)
- Very little data or literature on treatment
- Few inpatient or outpatient programs for kids
under 12 or 13 years old - Only 1 we are aware of.
- Little data or clinical experience
- Family Therapy
90Family therapy
- Maudsley Family Therapy
- Systemic Family Therapy
91Family Therapy
- Required with Adolescents
- Maudsley Family Therapy
- Systemic Family Therapy
- Couples
- Family involvement to motivate pt for treatment
(case example)
92Systemic Family Therapy
- Underlying belief if you fix the system, the
symptom will no longer be needed. - The eating disorder is serving a function in the
family. - The symptom bearer is trying to help the family
(unconsciously).
93Methods for Systemic Family Therapy
- Circular questioning
- Therapist is curious observer, not expert.
- Discuss communication patterns within the family.
- Involve all family members in the discussion,
even small children. - Do not pathologize family or symptom bearer.
94Maudsley Family Therapy
- Behavioral Family Therapy
95Maudsley Family Therapy
- Agnostic toward etiology
- Involves parents, rather than a parent-ectomy
- Food is medicine
- Initial focus on symptoms
- Parents are responsible for weight restoration.
- Non-authoritarian therapist stance
- Separation of child from illness
96Maudsley Family Therapy
- Phase I (sessions 1 - 10) Weight restoration,
re-feeding focus. - Phase II (sessions 11 - 16) Transfer control
back to adolescent gradually. - Phase III (sessions 17 - 20) Focus on adolescent
developmental issues, termination.
97Maudsley Family Therapy
- Session 1 Funeral session
- Goals engage the family, obtain history of how
AN came to be, find out how AN has affected each
family member, assess family functioning, reduce
blame, raise anxiety concerning AN. - Interventions Greet family in sincere but grave
manner, externalize the AN, orchestrate intense
scene, charge parents with the task of re-feeding.
98Session 2 Family Meal
- Instructions to parents bring a meal that would
be appropriate for your childs nutritional
needs. - Goals assess family structure as it may affect
ability of parents to re-feed patient, provide an
opportunity for parents to successfully feed
patient, assess family process during meal. - Interventions bring the symptom alive and
present in the room, one more bite, align patient
with siblings for support.
99Males and EDS
100Males and EDs
- Less common than in females, but increasing
(approx 10 of EDS occur in men) - They have a job or profession that demands
thinness. Male models, actors. - Cultural pressures to be V shaped
101Males and EDS
- More in common with female EDs than differences
- Lower testosterone may predispose to ED
- Fears regarding sexuality
- More common in homosexual men
- Conflict over sexual identity
- Avoidant, passive, negative reactions from peers
as children
102Males and EDs
- Athletes/profession with weight requirements
- 110 male to female ratio
- BED similar rates male/female, though women more
distressed about it, more guilt
103Males and EDs
- They were fat or overweight as children
(different than females). - They have been dieting. Dieting is one of the
most powerful eating disorder triggers for both
males and females.
104Males and EDs
- They participate in a sport that demands
thinness. Runners and jockeys are at higher risk
than football players and weight lifters. - Wrestlers who try to shed pounds quickly before a
match so they can compete in a lower weight. - Body builders are at risk if they deplete body
fat and fluid reserves to achieve high definition
105Special Assessment and Treatment Strategies for
Chronic AN
- Problems accumulate, may become irreversible
after as early as 6 mos - Poor Prognosis
- Risk benefit assessment of ED
- Harm reduction
106Treatment issues in Chronic EDs
- Legal aspects
- Case examples
107Q and A, discussion