Title: WHAT
1WHATS REALLY NEW IN BIPOLAR DISORDER, OCTOBER
2005
- OR WHAT I THINK IS IMPORTANT AND NEW
- (AND SOME OLD STUFF TOO)
2WHO AM I? WHERE AM I?
- MEDICAL DIRECTOR OF DAY HOSPITAL, PALOMAR
HOSPITAL, ESCONDIDO, CALIFORNIA PSYCHIATRIST,
PSYCHIATRIC CENTERS OF SAN DIEGO, ESCONDIDO - Pinnacle Of Career
- Admission to Medical School
- Joining PCSD
3(No Transcript)
4(No Transcript)
5 DISCLOSURES RESEARCH, LECTURES, CONSULTANT
- Lilly, Janssen, Wyeth-Ayerst, Servier, FHH
Foundation, Lundbeck, Organon, Alberta Heritage
Foundation Research, Astra-Zeneca, Biovail - Inspiration Dr. Ron Remick, Dr. Ernie McCrank,
My patients
6(No Transcript)
7MY DAILY AFFIRMATIONS
- Just for todayI wont sit in my living room all
day in my underwear Ill move the computer into
the bedroom
8(No Transcript)
9(No Transcript)
10(No Transcript)
11HISTORICAL REVIEW
- Aretaeus
- Kraepelin
- Leonhard
- Goodwin
- Akiskal
- Gorman met McCrank
12WHAT I LEARNED IN MY FIRST RESEARCH PROJECT
- NOTHING IN LIFE OCCURS IN A VACUUM, NOT EVEN
HEART DISEASE
13MOOD DISORDERS ARE DISORDERS WITH CYCLICAL
CHANGES IN MOOD, ENERGY AND BEHAVIOR
- It seems to me that it is more likely that Mood
Disorders are primarily energy disorders with
secondary mood and behavior dimensions
14DIAGNOSTIC ISSUES
- DSM IV puts primary emphasis on polarity (i.e.
history of mania or hypomania) rather than
cyclicity or recurrence - Depressive disorders are thus a meaningless
category because of 1. Defined by not bipolar
2. Too heterogeneous, patient with 2 episodes in
lifetime vs. someone with episodes every 12 to 24
months
15HIGHLY RECURRENT UNIPOLAR DEPRESSION (Clinical
Features)
- Family history of Bipolar Disorder (BD)
- Bipolar like age of onset (teens and 20s)
- High episode frequency (every 18-24 mo)
- Represents 25-35 of unipolar cases
- May convert to BD, but many dont, unless
receiving antidepressants without mood stabilizer - Patients respond to Li better than imipramine
- No category for these patients in DSM IV
16POTENTIAL BIPOLAR DIATHESIS
- Recurrent major depressive episodes
- Early age of onset (40 of patients before age 20
BD, of remaining 60, most have highly recurrent
unipolar depression) - Family history of BD
- Atypical depressive symptoms
- Brief depressive episodes
- Psychotic Depressive episodes
- Post Partum Depression
- AD induced hypomania/mania
- AD non-response or wear off
17PNEMONIC FOR MANIC SYMPTOMS - DIGFAST
- Distractibility
- Indiscretion (pleasurable activities)
- Grandiosity
- Flight of ideas
- Activity increase
- Sleep deficit (decreased need)
- Talkativeness (pressured speech)
18ALL QUESTIONS POSED TO BIPOLAR PATIENTS, ARE BEST
POSED TO THEIR RELATIVES
- At Least When It Comes To Mania
19(No Transcript)
20(No Transcript)
21Bipolar Disorder Symptoms areChronic and
Predominantly Depressive
146 bipolar I patientsfollowed 12.8 years
86 bipolar II patientsfollowed 13.4 years
Judd et al (2002) Archives of General Psychiatry
(59) 530-537
Judd et al (2003) Archives General Psychiatry.
(60) 261-269
22ANTIDEPRESSANT (AD) TREATMENT IN BIPOLAR VS.
UNIPOLAR DEPRESSION
- Ghaemi SN et. al. Am J Psychiatry
161163-165,2004 - Long term safety and effectiveness of ADs is
well established for unipolar, but not BD
patients. Short term efficacy is clear. - Tricyclics are not as effective for recurrence
as Li has been demonstrated - This study compared modern and older ADs in
Bipolar depression (41 patients) vs. Unipolar
depression (37 patients)
23AD TREATMENT TRIAL COMPARISON CONTINUED
- Short term non-response for BD at 51.3 vs.
Unipolar at 31.6 - Manic switching less in BD patients taking mood
stabilizers (31.6 vs. 84.2) - Cycle acceleration only occurred in BD depression
(25.6), with new rapid cycling in 32.1 of
patients - Late response loss, or tolerance was 3.4Xs more
frequent in BD depression - Cycle acceleration, rapid cycling and response
loss were not prevented by mood stabilizers - In general, modern ADs did not have lower
negative outcomes than Tricyclic's
24AD TREATMENT TRIAL COMPARISON CONCLUSION
- An unfavorable cost/benefit ratio is indicated
for the use of AD therapy in the treatment of
Bipolar depression - This studies distressing numbers are significant,
considering that many clinicians, and even most
guidelines are suggesting both short and
long-term use of ADs for Bipolar depression
25A 52 WEEK OPEN-LABEL CONTINUATION STUDY OF Ltg.
IN THE TREATMENT OF BIPOLAR DEPRESSION
- McElroy SL et. al. J Clin Psychiatry 65204-210,
2004 - Bipolar depression is more frequent, lasts
longer, and is more difficult to treat than mania - Ltg is a novel anticonvulsant that has been shown
to be effective in the acute treatment of Bipolar
depression. This study is a 52 week, open-label
continuation of that original trial
26A 52 WEEK OPEN-LABEL CONTINUATION STUDY OF Ltg.
IN THE TREATMENT OF BIPOLAR DEPRESSION CONTINUED
- The study group were BD I patients with an
episode of Major Depression that had completed a
7 week dbl. bld. Plc. Controlled Ltg.
intervention, and were then invited to enter this
study, receiving 100-500 mg./day of Ltg. - Of the 135 patients completing the acute study,
124 (92) entered the continuation study - MADRS, CGI measures were applied at 4, 12, 24,
36, and 52 weeks
27A 52 WEEK OPEN-LABEL CONTINUATION STUDY OF Ltg.
IN THE TREATMENT OF BIPOLAR DEPRESSION CONTINUED
- Of the 124 patients entered, 77 had received Ltg
and 47 had received placebo during the acute
study - The mean duration of Ltg. exposure was 10.4
months, and mean modal dose was 187 mg/d. - 56 of the patients completed the trial
- There was a significant and sustained improvement
over time. 84 achieved remission by week 4, and
episodes of mania/hypomania were reduced from the
previous year - Headache was the most common drug-related adverse
event
28A 52 WEEK OPEN-LABEL CONTINUATION STUDY OF Ltg IN
THE TREATMENT OF BIPOLAR DEPRESSION CONCLUSION
- Ltg was effective in 1 year of open label
treatment as adjunctive or monotherapy, and
provided sustained improvement without mood
destabilization - The issue of remission is studied in many
psychiatric disorders, but it may be most
critical in BD
29LAMOTRIGINE RASH
- Can cause severe skin reactions (i.e. Steven
Johnson Syndrome SJS, Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis
TEN) - Recent data from German Rash Registry show only
1/10,000 (almost all neurology patients) - Registry lists many other agents (9 antibiotics,
4 anticonvulsants) ahead of Ltg
30CARDIAC DISEASE AND DEPRESSION
31PRELIMINARY RANDOMIZED, DBL BLD, PLACEBO
CONTOLLED TRIAL OF PRAMIPEXOLE (MIRAPEX) ADDED TO
MOOD STABILIZERS FOR TREATMENT RESISTANT BD
DEPRESSION
- Goldberg et. al. Am J Psychiatry 161564-566,2004
- Pramipexole, a dopamine agonist, may have AD
properties. Efficacy and safety were assessed in
this study - 22 depressed outpatients with non-psychotic BD
were randomly assigned to placebo or Pramipexole
at max. dose of 1.7 mg./d for 6 weeks. HDRS
(response at 50 improvement) and CGI were used
32PRELIMINARY RANDOMIZED, DBL BLD, PLACEBO
CONTOLLED TRIAL OF PRAMIPEXOLE (MIRAPEX) ADDED TO
MOOD STABILIZERS FOR TREATMENT RESISTANT BD
DEPRESSION CONTINUED
- 83 of Pramipexole and 60 of placebo patients
completed the study - Response rates in the Pramipexole and placebo
groups were 67 and 20 respectively - Pramipexole patients also had greater mean
improvements in CGI scores - One patient DCed Pramipexole because of the
emergence of hypomania (the only adverse effect
drop-out)
33PRELIMINARY RANDOMIZED, DBL BLD, PLACEBO
CONTOLLED TRIAL OF PRAMIPEXOLE (MIRAPEX) ADDED TO
MOOD STABILIZERS FOR TREATMENT RESISTANT BD
DEPRESSION CONCLUSION
- Pramipexole appears to be effective and safe for
the treatment of Bipolar depression - Bipolar depression has emerged as one of the most
important and difficult conditions to treat.
Beyond Ltg., the choices are complex and poorly
supported by sufficient data - Larger randomized and controlled studies are now
needed to further assess this study
34(No Transcript)
35GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF MANAGEMENT
- Use life charts to monitor illness
- Remember, it is basically a depressive disorder,
even though all of the new meds are anti-manic
drugs - Issue is preventing recurrence
- ADs can induce mania and/or cycling
- Keep in mind high suicide risk with BD
- Never forget the therapeutic relationship
36WHAT IS THE THERAPEUTIC RELATIONSHIP?
- The psychodynamic features of the pharmacotherapy
relationship can never be overlooked - Without attention to elements such as
transference, pharmacotherapy can have reduced
value - As in all therapeutic relationships, a working
alliance must be established to allow the
treatment to proceed with greatest effectiveness
37WHAT IS THE THERAPEUTIC RELATIONSHIP, CONTINUED?
- The pharmacotherapeutic alliance can be tested
and strengthened when discussing goals of
treatment discussing side effects the potential
for abuse with this patient the clinicians
availability for the resolution of medication and
non-medication difficulties - Attention to the therapeutic alliance also
involves consistency availability willingness
to discuss and explain alternatives
38WHAT IS THE THERAPEUTIC RELATIONSHIP, CONTINUED?
- Transference issues include Idealization
initially with the physician being authoritative
and knowledgeable, and a provider of coherent and
non-judgmental explanation, with no confrontation
of looking inward or need to face past and
present painful experiences - Unfortunately, the inconsistent and sometimes
limited results of the medication, can be more
than disappointing to the hopeful patient - Some times the initial positive transference can
lend itself to the undermining of psychotherapy,
and even splitting. If under-recognized, it can
undermine all of the treatment
39WHAT IS THE THERAPEUTIC RELATIONSHIP, CONTINUED?
- Counter-transference needs to be recognized and
understood - Issues like discouragement the desire for
treatment to proceed more quickly or with less
pain to control the patient or to give some
thing tangible to the patient during a hopeless
or helpless impasse.
40(No Transcript)
41TREATMENT OF BREAKTHROUGH DEPRESSION
- Li has modest effect
- Lamotrigine (Ltg) has more robust effect
- Olanzapine very small effect (perhaps through
non-specific anti-anxiety, ant-insomnia effect) - Quetiapine has large effect, that appears to be
specific for depression (?study data)
42HOW DO YOU DISTINGUISH BIPOLAR FROM BORDERLINE
AND FACTITIOUS DISORDER?
- Bipolar Spectrum Disorder has considerably more
denial - Bipolar Spectrum Disorder has much less interest
in any treatment, but particularly psychotherapy
43 - WHY IS THERE SO MUCH DISABILITY IN BIPOLAR
DISORDER?
44(No Transcript)
45Seroquel is not yet indicated in Canada for the
treatment of bipolar disorder
- Information presented within may contain data not
supported by the current product monograph.
Please consult the product monograph for
prescribing information.
46Dosing Schedule
Day
8-56
5-7
4
3
2
1
600
400
300
200
100
50
Quetiapine 600 mgat bedtime
Quetiapine 300 mgat bedtime
300
300
300
200
100
50
Placebo at bedtime
Calabrese et al, APA 2004
47Study Overview
- Eight-week, multicenter, double-blind,
randomized, fixed-dose, placebo-controlled
monotherapy study - Study population outpatients with DSM-IV bipolar
I or bipolar II disorder, with or without rapid
cycling, in a major depressive episode - Study groups quetiapine 600 mg/d, quetiapine
300 mg/d, placebo - Conducted at 39 centers in the United States
Calabrese et al, APA 2004
48MADRS Change From Baseline
Study Week
1
2
4
3
6
5
7
8
Mean Change From Baseline
plt0.001 vs placebo
49HAM-D Change From Baseline
Study Week
1
2
4
3
6
5
7
8
Mean Change From Baseline
plt0.001 vs placebo
50HAM-D Item 1 Change From Baseline
Study Week
1
2
4
3
6
5
7
8
Mean Change From Baseline
ITT, LOCF
plt0.01 plt0.001 vs placebo
51Response Rate (?50 decrease in MADRS)
plt0.01 plt0.001 vs placebo
52Remission Rate (MADRS ?12)
plt0.01 plt0.001 vs placebo
53Effect Size Change in MADRS
Large (0.8)
Quetiapine 600 mg
0.75
Quetiapine 300 mg
0.64
Medium (0.5)
Small (0.2)
54HAM-A Change From Baseline
Study Week
1
2
4
3
6
5
7
8
Mean Change From Baseline
plt0.05 plt0.01 plt0.001
55Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) Change
From Baseline
Quetiapine 600 mg n170
Quetiapine 300 mg n172
Placebo n169
Improvement
Mean Change From Baseline
plt0.001 vs placebo
56Quality of Life (Q-LES-Q) Change From Baseline
Improvement
Mean Change From Baseline
Quetiapine 600 mg
Placebo
Quetiapine 300 mg
plt0.001 vs placebo
57Efficacy Summary
- Quetiapine was found to be effective for a broad
range of depressive and anxiety symptoms - Quetiapine was found to be effective in improving
quality of sleep - Quetiapine was found to be effective in improving
quality of life
58(No Transcript)
59Common Adverse Events (gt10 patients and 2x
placebo rate)
Adverse Event Quetiapine 600 mg n180 Quetiapine 300 mg n179 Placebo n180
Dry mouth () 40.6 44.1 7.8
Sedation () 32.2 29.6 6.1
Somnolence () 24.4 27.4 8.3
Dizziness () 22.8 16.8 8.3
Constipation () 11.1 11.7 4.4
Safety, LOCF
Calabrese et al, APA 2004
60Treatment-Emergent Mania
Patients
Quetiapine 600 mg n180
Placebo n180
Quetiapine 300 mg n179
Treatment-emergent mania adverse event of mania,
or YMRS ?16 at 2 consecutive visits or last visit
61Change in Weight
Quetiapine 600 mg Quetiapine 300 mg Placebo
Mean change (kg) 1.6 1.0 0.2
gt7 increase in weight () 11 10 3
Safety, LOCF
62Serum Glucose (Fasting)
Quetiapine 600 mg Quetiapine 300 mg Placebo
Baseline mg/dL 86 87 87
Endpoint mg/dL 92 90 90
Safety, LOCF
63Sexual Adverse Events
Patients
Quetiapine 600 mg n180
Placebo n180
Quetiapine 300 mg n179
Safety, LOCF
64Safety Summary
- The rate of treatment-emergent mania with
quetiapine was no greater than with placebo - Common adverse events included dry mouth,
sedation/somnolence, and dizziness - Quetiapine was associated with minimal weight
change - Quetiapine was not associated with significant
change in serum glucose levels - The safety profile of quetiapine in this
population was consistent with previous studies
65Conclusions
- Quetiapine was found to be effective and well
tolerated as monotherapy in bipolar depression
with a rapid onset of action - Quetiapine improves a broad range of mood and
anxiety symptoms - Quetiapine was found to be effective in improving
the quality of sleep and quality of life in
patients with bipolar depression
66(No Transcript)
67 Pearls
- Screen for bipolar disorder in every depressed
and anxious patient - Early diagnosis and treatment will lead to
improved quality of life and will slow the
progression ofbipolar disorder through the life
cycle - Atypical agents such as quetiapine (Seroquel) are
effectivemood stabilizers
68EXCELLENT BOOKS
- An Unquiet Mind, by Kay Jamieson, PH.D.
- A Brilliant Madness, by Patty Duke
- Plato Not Prozac! Applying Eternal Wisdom To
Everyday Problems, by Lou Marinoff PH.D. - The Moral Animal, by Robert Wright
- Mind Over Mood, Greenberger et al.
- Agitated Depression, Koukopolis, Clinics of
North America - Creating True Peace Thich Nhat Hahn