Novel Strategies for

1
Novel Strategies for Research Revenue Benchmarks
and The Limits of Growth
Tris Parslow Emory University
2
(No Transcript)
3
A Benchmark Group of 12 Medical Schools
NIH Rank in 2001

• 1 Johns Hopkins
• 2 Univ Penn
• 4 Washington Univ
• 5 Yale
• 7 Baylor
• 8 Duke
• 12 Univ Pittsburgh
• 13 Stanford
• 15 Univ N Carolina
• 16 UAB
• 18 UT-Southwestern
• Vanderbilt
• 23 Emory

4
NIH per Funded PI at Benchmark Schools (2001)
Includes K-, R-, P- and U-Series Grants Only
600
Hopkins
Penn
550
500
450
Number of NIH-funded investigators
Wash. U
400
Yale
Pitt
Duke
350
Baylor
Stanford
300
UNC
UAB
Vanderbilt
UT-SW
250
100
150
200
250
300
350
Total NIH Support (M)
Source R Dingledine
5
NIH per Funded PI at Benchmark Schools (2001)
Includes K-, R-, P- and U-Series Grants Only
600
Hopkins
Penn
550
500
Mean 565K per PI
450
Number of NIH-funded investigators
Wash. U
400
Yale
Pitt
Duke
350
Baylor
Stanford
300
UNC
UAB
Vanderbilt
UT-SW
250
100
150
200
250
300
350
Total NIH Support (M)
Source R Dingledine
6
Shades of the Past! (c.f. 1996)
Mean 540K per PI
Source R Dingledine
7
NIH per Funded PI at Benchmark Schools (2001)
Includes K-, R-, P- and U-Series Grants Only
600
Hopkins
Penn
550
Mean 565K per PI
500
450
Number of NIH-funded investigators
Wash. U
400
Yale
Pitt
Duke
350
Baylor
Stanford
300
UNC
Emory
UAB
Vanderbilt
UT-SW
250
100
150
200
250
300
350
Total NIH Support (M)
Source R Dingledine
8
NIH per Funded PI at Benchmark Schools (2001)
Includes K-, R-, P- and U-Series Grants Only
600
Hopkins
Penn
550
500
450
Number of NIH-funded investigators
Wash. U
400
Yale
Pitt
Duke
350
Baylor
Stanford
300
th
10
rank 201M, 366 PIs
UNC
UAB
Vanderbilt
UT-SW
250
100
150
200
250
300
350
Total NIH Support (M)
Source R Dingledine
9
NIH per Funded PI at Benchmark Schools (2001)
Includes K-, R-, P- and U-Series Grants Only
600
Hopkins
Penn
550
Mean 565K per PI
500
450
Number of NIH-funded investigators
Wash. U
400
Yale
Pitt
Duke
350
72 PIs
Baylor
Stanford
300
39M
UNC
Emory
UAB
Vanderbilt
UT-SW
250
100
150
200
250
300
350
Total NIH Support (M)
Source R Dingledine
10
Sharp increase in NIH funding at larger
institutions
Sharp Increase in NIH Funding for Large Schools
400
350
300
Total NIH Funding in 2003 (M)
250
200
150
100
Total Research Space in 2003 AAMC Survey
Source R Dingledine
11
Size matters for NIH rankings
Size Matters for NIH Rankings
NIH Research Rank in 2003
Total Research Space (thousand NASF)
in 2003 AAMC Survey
Source R Dingledine
12
Size matters for total research funding
Size Matters for Total Research Funding
From 2003 AAMC Survey
Total Research Funding ( million)
Total Research Space (thousand NASF)
Source R Dingledine
13
Pathology Lab Medicine at Emory
14
NIH Awards 1996 2004 Emory Dept of Pathology
18
16
14
12
10
Millions
8
6
4
2
0
15
NIH Awards 1996 2004 Departments of Pathology
18
Emory
16
10
Minn
14
Yale
11
UCSF
12
UCSF
Minn
16
Mich
10
Millions
Columbia
Columbia
8
19
19
6
19
20
20
4
21
2
0
16
2003
2005
Asst 1.8 M 5.7 M Assoc 2.6 M 3.9
M Prof 6.7 M 8.1 M R or K 11.2 M 15.3
M P or U 0.3 M 2.5 M Non-NIH 1.7 M
3.8 M
17

• Cancer
• Cardiovascular
• Epithelial Biology
• HIV / SIV
• Immunology
• Neuroscience
• Microbial Path
• Transfusion Med
• Basic Cell Molec

18
Limits to Growth
SPACE ! MONEY!

• Start-up Costs
• Bridge Funds
• NIH Salary Cap Effort Rules
• Shared Equipment Maintenance
• Unfunded Indirects
• Cost-Sharing
• Computers IT Support
• Etc.

19

• Clinical Revenues
• Endowments
• Philanthropy
• Indirects
• Institutional Support

20
Georgia Cancer Coalition (GCC)

• Not-for-Profit 501(c )(3) corporation
• Founded 2001, headquarters Atlanta
• To coordinate Georgias share of the
• National Tobacco Settlement Trust Fund

21
Georgia Cancer Coalition (GCC)

• Not-for-Profit 501(c )(3) corporation
• Founded 2001, headquarters Atlanta
• To coordinate Georgias share of the
• National Tobacco Settlement Trust Fund

22
(No Transcript)
23
Georgia Cancer Coalition (GCC)
Distinguished Cancer Clinicians and Scientists

• For Out-of-State Recruitments ONLY
• Asst Profs 50K /yr X 5 yrs
• Assoc Profs 100K /yr X 5 yrs
• Full Profs 150K /yr X 5 yrs
• Nominated by Universities
• Selected by Panel of Representatives
• from ACS, CDC, Dept Comm Hlth,
• and GA public private Universities

24
Georgia Research Alliance (GRA)

• Public/Private Partnership, founded 1990
• (State Univs Foundns Companies)
• To recruit out-of-state scientists to lead
• extraordinary programs of research
  development with high potential economic
  impact for Georgia
• Advanced Communications
• Computers
• Nanotechnology
• Biosciences

25
Georgia Research Alliance (GRA)

• 400 M invested to date in
• Technology Incubators
• Venture Lab
• Innovation Grants for faculty
• Specialized Labs
• (e.g., the Emory Vaccine Center)
• Leveraged 2 Billion
• in federal private funds
• 5000 new technology jobs
• 120 new companies founded

26
Georgia Research Alliance (GRA)
GRA Eminent Scholars

• For Out-of-State Recruitments ONLY
• Endowed Professorships
• Start-up Packages
• Nominated by Universities
• Selected by Panel of University Presidents
• and Corporate CEOs
• (e.g., BellSouth, UPS, SunTrust, GA Power)

27
Georgia Research Alliance (GRA)
GRA Eminent Scholars
More than 50 appointed to date, including (at
Emory)

• Rafi Ahmed
• Xiaodong Cheng
• Xiaoping Hu
• Mike Kuhar
• Sam Speck
• Eric Hunter

28

• Cancer
• Cardiovascular
• Epithelial Biology
• HIV / SIV
• Immunology
• Neuroscience
• Microbial Path
• Transfusion Med
• Basic Cell Molec

29

• Cancer
• Cardiovascular
• Epithelial Biology
• HIV / SIV
• Immunology
• Neuroscience
• Microbial Path
• Transfusion Med
• Basic Cell Molec

GCC
GRA
30
(No Transcript)
31
FY2001 NIH funding mix
Mean per NIH grant
Total per category
140
1.2
120
1.0
100
0.8
80
Million
Million
0.6
60
40
0.4
20
0.2
0
0.0
training research centers contracts
training
research
centers
contracts
(F,T,K) ( R ) (G,M,P) (U)
Emory
benchmarks