Title: NCHELP Spring Conference
1NCHELP Spring Conference
Matt Snowling, CFA . 703.469.1196 .
msnowling_at_fbr.com
FBR Capital Markets Co.
- Outlook for the Student Loan Market
- June 9, 2009
2About FBR Capital Markets
- FBR Capital Markets Corporation (NASDAQ FBCM)
provides investment banking, merger and
acquisition advisory, institutional brokerage and
research services through its subsidiary FBR
Capital Markets Co. FBR Capital Markets
focuses capital and financial expertise on seven
industry sectors consumer diversified
industrials energy natural resources
financial institutions insurance real estate
and technology, media telecom. Asset
management and private wealth services are
provided by FBR Investment Management, Inc., and
mutual funds are provided by FBR Fund Advisers,
Inc. both companies are subsidiaries of FBR
Capital Markets Corporation. FBR Capital Markets
is headquartered in the Washington, D.C.
metropolitan area with offices throughout the
United States and in London. - Forward-Looking Statements
- This press release contains forward-looking
statements. All statements contained in this
press release, which are not historical fact, may
be considered forward-looking statements as that
term is defined in the Private Securities
Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Actual results
could differ materially from these
forward-looking statements as a result of the
risk factors described in the Company's filings
with the Securities and Exchange Commission, on
forms 10-K and 10-Q. In light of these risks and
uncertainties, there can be no assurance that the
forward-looking information contained in this
press release will in fact transpire. These
forward-looking statements represent the
Company's judgment only as of the date of this
press release. The Company does not have any
intention or obligation to update these
forward-looking statements.
3How Did We Get Here?De-leveraging of Financial
Markets
- Initial credit concerns in subprime mortgages
evolved into full-blown credit and liquidity
crises. - Auction-rate securities (ARS) markets begin
failing (February 2008) - Bear Sterns (March 2008)
- Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, AIG, Lehman (September
2008) - Money market fund breaks the buck
- De-leveraging of global financial markets
- Selling pressure on all asset classes as funds
unwind leveraged positions - Lack of liquidity worse for longer-duration bonds
regardless of collateral - Traditional buyers of student loan paper such as
SIVs and CDOs exiting market - Investors demanding higher unlevered returns
- Results in higher financing costs for student
lenders
4Remaining Investor IssuesUncertainty Holding
Back Investor Demand
- Market confusion regarding multiple government
liquidity programs - Lack of clarity on what role the private sector
will play in a 100 Direct Lending world - Servicing risk
- Uncertainty whether servicers will be around in
five years - Excess spread risk
- Widening CP/LIBOR spreads are reducing excess
spread protection - Higher returns on other AAA rated asset-backed
securities - Competition for investor dollars from credit
card, auto, mortgage-backed securities
5CP/LIBOR Spread Dislocation Government
Intervention in CP Markets Compressing Lender
Yields
Source FactSet and FBR Research
6Cost of ABS Funding for FFELP LoansFunding via
Securitization Market Has Become Prohibitively
High
Source Sallie Mae trust data and FBR Research
7Cost of ABS Funding for FFELP LoansGovernment
ABCP Facility Returned Funding to Historical
Spreads
Straight-A Funding
Source Sallie Mae trust data and FBR Research
8Credit Quality Also a Concern for Private Loans
Later Vintages Showing Accelerating Credit
Deterioration
Source Sallie Mae and First Marblehead trust
data and FBR Research
9Private Student Loan FundingCredit and
Structural Issues Make It Difficult to Finance
- Before 2008 Term funding (approximately 7.5
years) for private student loans was available
around 3-month LIBOR 0.25. - 2008 Securitization market completely closed for
private loan asset-backed deals. - 2009 Liquidity is returning, but funding costs
are significantly higher. - January Sallie Mae/Goldman Sachs issued a 1.5
billion 10.5-year private student loan facility _at_
3-month LIBOR 5.75 - May Sallie Mae issued 2.6 billion TALF-eligible
private student loan ABS _at_ 1-month LIBOR 6.00
(LIBOR 3.66 priced to call) - Original TALF financing available for only three
years, creating a duration mismatch - TALF II to provide financing for five years
should create more investor demand - Lenders raising rates to offset higher cost of
funds, but investors only funding senior part of
capital structure (AAA), leaving lenders to
finance 4050 of loans on their own. - On-balance-sheet/deposit funding is the most
viable source of financing until the
securitization market recovers. - Requires significant capital commitments
- Limited cash flows in early years of the loan
10Proposals to Fix FFELNo Clear Support Yet for
Alternative to 100 Direct Lending
- Presidents Budget
- 100 Direct Lending
- Private sector servicing, originations?
- 20 billion of savings over five years per
education budget - 94 billion of savings over 10 years per CBO
estimate - Private sector services loans
- Extending ECASLA
- Loan Participation/Purchase Program
- Funding via government supported Asset-Backed
Commercial Paper Conduit (Straight-A) - Generated 11 billion of savings to the
government - Sallie Mae Proposal
- Hybrid of Presidents plan and Loan Purchase
Program - Private sector originates and services loans,
default prevention - Lenders sell loans to Department of Education
within 120 days for a fee (initially 75 per
loan) - Servicing is retained for eligible lenders
- Estimated to produce 90 of savings proposed
under the Administrations plan
11Long-Term OutlookProjections for the Student
Loan Industry
- FFEL program as we know it is gone
- Term funding is not available at economically
viable spreads - Direct or indirect government support is required
to access funding - Do not expect a fix in the CP/LIBOR spread
- Likely to cost the government approximately
700 million to 1 billion - Spreads are beginning to improve
- Expect the majority of the loans originated under
the Participation-Purchase Program to be sold
back to the government - The government will become dependent on the new
revenue sources created by the loans, which will
be hard to give up. - Projected 94 billion of savings under the
Administrations plan will not be realized - Savings dependent on Treasury rates remaining low
- 10-year Treasury rates up 1.00 from February
levels - Cumulative defaults likely to exceed 11.9
projected for FFEL and 10.8 projected for DL - Without risk-sharing, the government will assume
the burden of higher defaults - Will create a funding shortfall in future budgets
that the government will need to fill
12Long-Term OutlookContinued
- Converting more than 4,000 schools to the Direct
Loan Program by July 2010 will be logistically
risky. - Numerous stakeholders are involved from schools,
students, lenders, service providers, and
government. - Delay in implementation would cost approximately
10 billion in the first year. - Opportunity is to modify Administrations
proposal - Need to achieve similar savings
- Requires government ultimately owning the loan
- Reduce operational risk, maintain school choice
- Requires utilizing existing FFEL infrastructure
to provide origination, servicing, default
prevention, and borrower education services
13Boston100 Federal Street, 29th Floor Boston, MA
02110617.757.2900 Dallas2100 McKinney Avenue,
Suite 1940 Dallas, TX 75201469.341.1200 Houston
600 Travis Street, Suite 6070 Houston, TX
77002713.343.1000 Irvine (Los Angeles)18101 Von
Karman Ave., Suite 950 Irvine, CA
92612949.477.3100 New York299 Park Avenue, 7th
Floor New York, NY 10171212.457.3300
San Francisco4 Embarcadero Center, Suite 1950
San Francisco, CA 94111415.248.2900 London,
UKFBR International, Ltd.8th Floor, Berkeley
Square HouseBerkeley SquareLondon WIJ
6DB011.44.20.7409.5300
FBR Capital Markets CorporationMetropolitan
Washington, D.C. Headquarters1001 Nineteenth
Street North . Arlington, VA 22209703.312.9500 T
. 703.312.9501 F . www.fbrcapitalmarkets.com
NOTE Not all services are available from all
offices.