Software Comparison

1
Software Comparison
2
Needs

• Recognises a variety of file formats (graphics,
  sound and video)
• Allows interaction with media
• Easy to use but allows complex constructs
• Management of media
• Print media and text

3
Applications of Multimedia

• CBT
• Point of sale materials
• Product demos
• Information kiosks
• Games
• Edutainment
• Internet

4
Requirements

• Standalone, runtime executable
• Internet support
• Import wide range of file formats
• Media manipulation
• Animation controls
• Standard user interface controls
• Useable interface to handle complexity

5
Measures

• Flexibility Power
• in meeting varying development needs

• Usability
• productivity
• speed at which something can be developed
• intuitiveness
• need for use of manuals or other help facilities
• satisfaction
• features of product

6
Problems

• Generally difficult to use - many sophisticated
  interactive elements
• Lack of standardisation
• diverse operating methods, dependence on
  terminology
• Visual logic display workspace
• Language dependence

7
Established Multimedia Authoring.....

• Timeline
• Director

...Tools and Types
8
Flow chart approach

• Provides a diagrammatic overview
• Visual logic display - good for producing complex
  applications
• Can create complex applications without need for
  scripting
• Quick and easy to create basic structure
• Can be difficult to learn due to over use of
  dialogue boxes and the many tools

9
Timebased

• Good for sequential events
• Drag drop media elements to assemble
• Easy to create film loops
• Provides fine control for animation
• Complex systems allow jumps, interactivity,
  navigation
• Above usually reliant on scripting
• Poor visual guide to structure of application
  excepting linear structures

10
Authorware (Interactive Studio)

• Lacks versatile animation tools
• Provides good control over interactivity
• Uses icons which represent tools
• Uses two windows
• 1. Design - flowchart metaphor using icons and
  text to show application structure
• 2. Presentation - to preview application

11
Authorware
12
Dazzler Deluxe (v4.0)

• Highly visual and object oriented
• Uses responses palette to add interactive
  controls (action and responses tools)
• No scripting required
• Uses dual windows design presentation
• Easy to set window action properties
• Finished applications packaged for distribution,
  CD, network,(even upload to a Website)

13
Dazzler Deluxe v4.0
14
Macromedia Director

• Applications created known as movies
• Consists of 3 main windows
• Cast - thumbnail view of media elements
• Stage - where media elements (cast members) are
  assembled and viewed
• Score used to control animation of cast members
• Film loop feature
• Interactivety relies on Lingo scripting
• Editing for text and bitmap graphics
• Wide range of transition effects

15
Director
16
Toolbook Instructor

• Designed to create highly interactive,
  standards-based e-learning content
• Can import a variety of media
• Standard question types
• Custom templates
• convert your content to HTML, DHTML, and
  JavaScript
• can automatically be exported to native Web
  formats

17
Toolbook Instructor
18
Conclusion

• Choice will be influenced by
• Budget
• Time constraints
• Type of intended application
• Existing technical expertise
• Intended distribution media