Legal and Documentalistic Subelements

1
V Legislative XML Workshop Towards European
standards for legislative documents and
knowledge Italy, Florence, 14 16 June 2006
Legal and Documentalistic Subelements Remarks on
Biagiolis Concept of Legal Provisions
by Harald Hoffmann - Friedrich Lachmayer METADAT
A-1110 Vienna, Simmeringer Hauptstraße 24
2
Carlo Biagioli structures legal texts by
creating subelements (provisions). This
methodical approach is effective as it provides
for specific results (e.g. deontic
consequences). Our contribution tries to
differentiate between legal and documentalistic
subelements. Target is to achieve a synthesis
between them, resulting in a new concept of
legal acts and their subelements, a new role of
legal ontologies, enabling automatic generation
of consequences, and in a more comfortable user
interface.
3
Legal Act
Meaning
Text
4
Legal Act
Meaning
Interpretation
Text
5
(No Transcript)
6
eDocument
Legal Act
Meaning
Meaning
Text
Text
7
eDocument
Legal Act
Meaning
Meaning
Text
Text
8
eDocument
Legal Act
Meaning
Meaning
Text
Text
9
Legal Act
10
Legal Act
Legal Subelements
11
Legal Act
how to create the subset? ex ante ex post
Legal Subelements
12
Meaning
Meaning
Text
Text
Article
Legal Term
13
eDocument
Meaning
Text
14
Documentalistic Subelements
15
eDocument
how to create the subset? ex ante ex post
Documentalistic Subelements
16
Meaning
Meaning
Text
Text
Article
Legal Term
17
(No Transcript)
18
(No Transcript)
19
(No Transcript)
20
Ontology of Norms
Ontology of eDocuments
21
Ontology of Norms
Ontology of eDocuments
Ontology of doc. Provisions
Ontology of leg. Provisions
22
Ontology of Norms
Ontology of eDocuments
Ontology of doc. Provisions
Ontology of leg. Provisions
23
Metasystem
Ontology of Norms
Ontology of eDocuments
Ontology of doc. Provisions
Ontology of leg. Provisions
24
(No Transcript)
25
Proposal for Diskussion
Legal Act
eDocument
26
Ontology of Norms
Ontology of eDocuments
Ontology of synthetical Provisions
27
Metasystem
Ontology of Norms
Ontology of eDocuments
Ontology of synthetical Provisions
28
Legal Act
eDocument
29
Potential Direction Synthesis of Entities
Legal Act
eDocument
synth. Provision
Meaning
Text
30
Legal Act eDocument
Legal Act
eDocument
synth. Provision
Meaning
Text
31
Proposal for Diskussion
Automatic Generation of Consequences
Legal Act
eDocument
synth. Provision
Meaning
Text
32
Ontologies
Automatic Generation of Consequences
Legal Act
eDocument
synth. Provision
33
Ontologies
Automatic Generation of Consequences
Legal Act
eDocument
synth. Provision
34
Ontologies
Automatic Generation of Consequences
Legal Act
eDocument
synth. Provision
User
35
Ontologies
Automatic Generation of Consequences
Legal Act
eDocument
synth. Provision
User
36
Legal Ontology
Automatic Generation of Consequences
New Concept of Legal Acts
and Provisions
Comfortable User Interface
37
Harald.Hoffmann _at_metadat.com Friedrich.Lachmayer
_at_ metadat.com