You see a Dark Apple, I see Non-Newtonian Field

1
You see a Dark Apple, I see Non-Newtonian Field
HongSheng Zhao _at_St Andrews, SUPA
This is NOT an Apple (Magritte) ? Lets call the
whole thing Potato-Tomato (Armstrong)
2
Resume _at_2004 LCDM
MOND

• Solar System ?
• Tides on Globulars dSph
• Rot. curves HSB/LSB
• Lensing by Ellipticals
• HubbleExp./SNIa
• Large-scale structure

3

• TeVeS born (Bekenstein 2004)
• Einstein-like metric, extra scalar field
• In a quasi-static system with a weak
  gravitational field, ? ? ?lumf
• dt2 (12?) dt2 - (1-2?) ( dx2 dy2 dz2 )
• DM view ? ? ?lumfDM

4
Updated Resume TeVeS
dt2 (12?) dt2 - (1-2?) ( dx2 dy2 dz2 )

• Solar System
• Tides on Globulars dSph
• (zhao 06)
• Rot. curves HSB/LSB
• (zhao, famaey 06)
  
• Lensing by Ellipticals (zhao,bacon,taylor,
  horne)
• HubbleExp./SNIa (zhao, skordis,
  mota 06)
• Large-scale structure

5
Analogy Polarisied DielectricM?? Q

• Field E g -?F
• F Charges
• Polarised Dipoles
• Displacement D µ E E P
• TeVeS glum g - ScalarField
• DM view microscopic dipoles,
• extra field view polarisation field
• 1-to-1
• ?. ?s? f 4?G?
• ?.? Flum

6
? u say DM, I say Scalar,? u say gDM , I say
?fteves u say NFW, I say µ(?f) , lets call the
whole thing
Pioneer Anomaly a-1 10-10m/s2
7
?CDM ??WDM ? See-Saw DM?
McGaugh 05, PRL
8
Predict Cosmology without further tuning
9
Connecting Cosmology with Galaxies
(Zhao,Famaey,ApJL)
Solar System
Early Universe
SNeIa
Edge of galaxies
10

• Hubble expansion in TeVeS

You say ?, I say f, You say ODM, I say Gf
11
As good as ?CDM, but no ?!
12
Matching Horizon, Distance, H0, BBN,
13
Updated Resume LCDM TeVeS

• Pioneer Anamoly ?
• Tides on Globulars dSph
• (zhao 06)
• Rot. curves HSB/LSB
• (zhao, famaey 06)
  
• Lensing by Ellipticals (zhao,bacon,taylor,
  horne)
• HubbleExp./SNIa (zhao, skordis,
  mota 06)
• 3rd peak in CMB

Stay-tuned
14
Conclusion

• A co-variant theory exists
• whose Lagrangian fixed by fitting galaxies Vcir
  and solar system (a0 ,ap )
• Predicts correct
• late acceleration and
• horizon at z1000 without fine-tuning.
• Time to take TeVeS seriously.