BIM Execution Plan

1
JAKE POLLACK STRUCTURAL OPTION AE 897G SENIOR
THESIS
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
2
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
PURPOSE AND FEATURES FUNCTION
ACADEMY SCALE 1,000,000 SF 656
MILLION CONSTRUCTION DESIGN-BID-BUILD
OCTOBER 2010 DECEMBER 2013
150
MAPS.GOOGLE.COM
536
95
3
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
INTRODUCTION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
PROJECT TEAM OWNER NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF
CONSTRUCTION AND DESIGN CONSTRUCTION
TURNER CONSTRUCTION ARCHITECT PERKINS
WILL STRUCTURAL ENGINEER ROBERT SILMAN
ASSOCIATES MEPF ENGINEER WSP FLACK KURTZ
4
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE EXISTING SYSTEM
EXISTING FLOOR SYSTEM
EXISTING FRAMING SYSTEM
EXISTING FOUNDATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
15
30
30
5
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE EXISTING SYSTEM
X-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
6
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE EXISTING SYSTEM
Y-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
7
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE PROBLEM
TYPICAL EXISTING MOMENT CONNECTION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
TYPICAL EXISTING HSS CBF CONNECTION
8
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE PROBLEM
TYPICAL EXISTING MOMENT CONNECTION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
TYPICAL EXISTING HSS CBF CONNECTION
9
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE SOLUTION
X-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
10
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE SOLUTION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
Y-FRAME
11
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE SOLUTION
ARCHITECTURE
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
CONSTRUCTABILITY

• MATERIAL COST (SHAPES)
• FABRICATION SCHEDULING AND COST
• LABOR SCHEDULING AND COST

12
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE THESIS REDESIGN
THESIS X-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS X-FRAME DETAIL CONCENTRICALLY BRACED
CONNECTIONS

• INCLUDES
• BEAM W30X99
• COLUMN W14X370
• BRACE 2L4X4X½
• GUSSET ¾

13
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE THESIS REDESIGN
THESIS X-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS X-FRAME LOAD PATH CONCENTRICALLY BRACED
CONNECTIONS
14
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE THESIS REDESIGN
THESIS Y-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS Y-FRAME DETAIL CHEVRON BRACED CONNECTIONS

• INCLUDES
• BEAM W24X76
• STIFFENERS ¾
• BRACE W14X82
• GUSSET ¾

15
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE THESIS REDESIGN
THESIS Y-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS Y-FRAME DETAIL CHEVRON BRACED LOAD PATH
16
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE THESIS REDESIGN
THESIS Y-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS Y-FRAME DETAIL DIAGONAL BRACED CONNECTIONS

• INCLUDES
• BEAM W24X76
• COLUMN W14X370
• BRACE W14X82
• GUSSET ¾

17
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
THE THESIS REDESIGN
THESIS Y-FRAME
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS Y-FRAME DETAIL DIAGONAL BRACED LOAD PATH
18
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
ARCHITECTURE
DESIGN INTEGRATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
19
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
ARCHITECTURE
ORIGINAL NORTH ELEVATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS NORTH ELEVATION
20
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
ARCHITECTURE
ORIGINAL SOUTH ELEVATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS SOUTH ELEVATION
21
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
ARCHITECTURE
3D ELEVATION
ORIGINAL DESIGN WINDOW ELEVATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
15
30
THESIS DESIGN WINDOW ELEVATION
15
22
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
ARCHITECTURE
3D ELEVATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
23
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
ARCHITECTURE
CONSTRUCTABILITY
3D ELEVATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
24
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
COST AND SCHEDULE
FABRICATION, LABOR AND MATERIAL NEEDS
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
25
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
COST AND SCHEDULE
FABRICATION AND LABOR MAN-HOURS
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
26
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
COST STUDY
ORIGINAL COST
THESIS COST
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
27
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
COST STUDY
ORIGINAL COST
THESIS COST
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
28
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
COST AND SCHEDULE
THESIS REDESIGN TOTAL SYSTEM COST
827,408.92 LABOR 1,320 MAN HOURS
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
ORIGINAL DESIGN TOTAL SYSTEM COST
1,606,325.97 LABOR 4,116 MAN HOURS
29
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
COST AND SCHEDULE
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS REDESIGN PERCENTAGE OF TIME
SAVED 68 PERCENTAGE OF COST SAVINGS 48
TOTAL TIME SAVED 2,796 HOURS TOTAL COST
SAVINGS 778,917.05
30
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
CONCLUSION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
X-FRAME
MOMENT
CONCENTRICALLY BRACED
31
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
CONCLUSION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
Y-FRAME
HSS CONCENTRICALLY BRACED
W-SHAPED CHEVRON BRACED
32
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
CONCLUSION
ORIGINAL NORTH ELEVATION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS NORTH ELEVATION
33
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
CONCLUSION
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION
THESIS REDESIGN TIME PERCENTAGE SAVINGS
68 COST PERCENTAGE SAVINGS 48 TIME TOTAL
SAVINGS 2,796 HOURS TOTAL COST SAVINGS
778,917.05
34
NEW YORK POLICE ACADEMY COLLEGE POINT, NEW YORK
PRESENTATION OUTLINE
INTRODUCTION EXISTING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM PROBLEM
STATEMENT PROBLEM SOLUTION THESIS
REDESIGN ARCHITECTURAL IMPACT COST AND SCHEDULE
IMPACT CONCLUSION

SPECIAL THANKS TO
QUESTIONS