[e-mail]

1
??????????????????????????????

• ???????????
• ?????
• jong_at_cs.nccu.edu.tw
• ????????

2
??????????

• ????? (E-Voting)?????(I(nternet)-Voting)??????????
  ?,??????I-Voting????????????????
• ????????I-Voting??????????????????????????????,???
  I-Voting???????????????????????????
• ?????????I-Voting??????????????????????????,??????
  ??????????????E(I)-Voting???????????????????
• ????????????????E(I)-Voting???????????????????????
  ??????????

3
?????????????

• ????????????????? (Paper Ballot)??????????????????
  ???????????
• ???2000???????????????????CALTECH?MIT?????????????
  ????????(Voting Technology Project)??????????????
  1?
• ??11????????????????????5?5???????Optical-Scan???,
  ??????5????????E-Voting?DRE?????,????10???????????
  ???I-Voting?????913?
• ???(2004)????????11????????????????Diebold
  AccuVote-TS E-Voting?????????????????????????????
  238?
• ?????I-Voting??SERVE??????11??????????10?????????,
  ????????????? 6???,?????????????????????1314?

4
?????????E-Voting????1
5
1999???E-Voting???????????1
6
???????????

• E-Voting ?I-Voting??????15?
• I-Voting????????????????E-Voting???,????????E-Voti
  ng???????????,??????????????????????13?
• ?????????????????E-Voting???????????????????????(D
  RE)??????5?
• E(I)-Voting?????????????????????,?????????????????
  ??4?
• ????????????????????,E(I)-Voting??????????????????
  ?????????????????????,???????????????,????????????
  ???????,?????????6?

7
?????? VS. ???????

• ???(???)?? (E(I)-Voting)??????????????????????????
  ???????
• ???????????????????????????
• ??????????????????
• ??????????????
• ???????????
• ??????????????????????
• ?????????????????
• ????????????????????
• E(I)-Voting??????????????
• ??????
• ?????????

8
??????????

• ???????(???(2004)???????)??DRE (Direct Recording
  Electronic)???E-Voting?????????Punch-Card Voting
  System??????????????????????(Voter Verifiable
  Paper Trial, VVPT)????????10,?????DRE??????????V
  VPT?
• ????VVPT????????,????Paper Ballot???????????7?
• E-Voting????????????????????????,???????????111
  2?
• ??????????E-Voting??,?????????????????????????????
  ??????????Security Through Obscurity??????????????
  ???????????????

9
??????????????

• ????????????????????????????????,???????????E(I)-V
  oting?????????????????
• ????????DRE E-Voting ?SERVE I-Voting??????????????
  ???????????
• ?????????????????????????
• ?????????????????????????????????????????
• ????????????????????
• ??????????????????????????????????
• ????????????????????

10
??????????????(?)

• ??????E(I)-Voting?????????????????????????????????
  ???????????????????????????????????????
• ??????????????????E(I)-Voting?????????????????????
  ?????
• E(I)-Voting??????????????????????????????????????E
  (I)-Voting????????????????????????????
• ????????????E(I)-Voting???????????????????????????
  ??????????????

11
????

1. Voting What Is What Could Be, July 2001.
   http//www.votecaltech.edu/Reports/reports.html
2. Kohno, T., et al., Analysis of an Electronic
   Voting System, Proceedings of the 2004 IEEE
   Symposium on Security and Privacy,
   http//avirubin.com/vote.pdf
3. RABA Innovative Solution Cell. Trusted Agent
   Report Diebold AccuVote-TS Voting System, Jan.
   2004. http//www.raba.com/press/TA_Report_AccuVote
   .pdf
4. E-Voting Can You Trust It?, Jan./Feb. 2004, IEEE
   Security Privacy, Vol. 2, No. 1.
   http//csdl.computer.org/comp/mags/sp/2004/01/j1to
   c.htm
5. Electronic Voting Machine Information Sheet
   Glossary. http//www.eff.org/Activism/E-voting/

12
???? (?)

1. Electronic Miscounts and Malfunctions In Recent
   Elections Summary. 2004, http//www.verifiedvoting
   .org
2. Selker, T. and J. Goler, Security Vulnerabilities
   and Problems with VVPT. VTP Working Paper, Apr.
   2004. http//www.votecaltech.edu
3. Techies Praised for E-Vote Work.
   http//www.wired.com/news
4. Computer Voting Is Open to Easy Fraud, Experts
   Say. July 24, 2003, The New York Times.
5. Dill, D. L., et al., Frequently Asked Questions
   about DRE Voting Systems. http//www.verifiedvotin
   g.org/drefaq.asp.
6. The Electronic Voting Machine Project.
   http//evm2003.sourceforge.net
7. Open Voting Consortium. http//www.openvotingconso
   rtium.org

13
???? (?)

• Jefferson. D., et al., A Security Analysis of
  the Secure Electronic Registration and Voting
  Experiment, Jan. 2004. http//servesecurityreport.
  org/
• Report Says Internet Voting Systems Is Too
  Insecure to Use. The New York Times.
  http//www.nytimes.com
• Alvarez, R. Michael and Thad E. Hall, Point,
  Click, and Vote The Future of Internet Voting,
  Brookings Institution Press, 2004.
  http//www.brookings.edu/press/books/pointclickand
  vote.htm