Title: Cues to Emotion: Face, Body, Brain
1Cues to Emotion Face, Body, Brain
2Outline
- Emotion in voice and brain
- The voice of emotion an FMRI study of neural
responses to angry and happy vocal expressions
(2006) Tom Johnstone et al - Facial Expressions and emotion
- http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Ekman
- Facial Action Coding System (FACS) Ekman
Friesen - Microexpressions - Ekman
- Poker tells The Body Language of Poker (1984)
Mike Caro - 3D graphics facial expressions FaceGen software
- www.facegen.com
3The voice of emotion an FMRI study of neural
responses to angry and happy vocal expressions
(2006) Tom Johnstone et al
- Range of issues
- Emotions in general vs specific emotions
- General regions of brain (left/right) vs
localized - Perception vs production
- Prosody vs semantic content in speech
- Facial expressions vs speech
- Attention vs inattention
- Type of experiment, controls, and measurement
(FRMI, MEG, PET, EEG, other) - What function does vocal affect have and how to
test
4Importance of response to vocal affect
- From the earliest stages of development, infants
respond to affect-laden vocal expressions from
their mothers (Fernald, 1989 Fernald and
Morikawa, 1993) - Why might this be?
- Relevance to the 4 approaches (darwinian,
jamesian)? - Still important/relevant after?
- When?
- Emoticons?
- Emotion in voice recognized as well as faces
across cultures (Scherer and Wallbott, 1994) - True?
5Early Prior work
- Production/comprehension experiments
- Production vs perception. Makes a difference?
- Production in Right hemisphere (Hughlings-Jackson
- 1915) - How did they know?
- Neurological evidence for comprehension (Tucker
et al., 1977) - Reduced affective speech comprehension in
right-hemisphere-damaged listeners (bowers 1987,
Heilman et al., 1984 Peper and Irle, 1997 Ross,
1981) - Whats missing?
- Where processed?
- Controlled experiments?
- How else to test/identify region?
6More recent Prior work
- Specific regions for facial emotion processing
(e.g. amygdala for fear, insula for disgust) - Little prior work on localized regions for
emotional speech for specific emotions. - Propositional content vs emotional prosody
- Right prefrontal activation (PET - George et al.
1996) - EEG scalp electroencephalography Pihan et al.
1997 - Accented syllable duration and fundamental
frequency - Are those correlated with emotional speech?
- Magnetoencephalography (MEG) (Imaizumi et al.
1998) - Also found some left-hemisphere processing of
propositional and prosodic content
7Recent Prior work
- non-differentiated per emotion
- Selective activation
- Congruence effect with facial and vocal
- Experiments
- Mitchell et al. (2003) found areas of posterior
middle temporal gyrus (MTG) and superior temporal
sulcus (STS) that activated more when attending
to affective prosody as compared with semantic
content of spoken words - Grandjean et al. (2005) and Sander et al. (2005)
have reported FMRI data that revealed a region in
STS that showed greater activation in response to
angry speech as compared with neutral speech - Wildgruber et al. (2005) identified a right
hemisphere network consisting of posterior STS,
and dorsolateral and orbitobasal prefrontal
cortex that showed selective activation during an
emotion recognition task. Differential
activations for the five emotions were not
observed. - Ethofer et al. (2006) identified regions in the
right posterior MTG and STS and bilateral
inferior/middle frontal gyrus that activated more
when individuals identified affective prosody
than when identifying the emotional content of
the spoken words. No distinction was made between
responses to the different expressed emotions
studied - Pourtois et al. (2005) demonstrated an area in
left MTG that showed heightened activation when
congruent vocal expressions and facial
expressions of happiness or fear were
simultaneously presented, as compared with when
only one expressive modality was presented
8The Brain
Whole Brain Atlas Top 100 Brain Structures
http//www.med.harvard.edu/AANLIB/cases/caseM/cas
e.html
9Loci of Sulci and Gyri
- Central sulcus
- Precentral gyrus
- Postcentral gyrus
- Precentral sulcus
- Postcentral sulcus
- Middle frontal gyrus
- Superior frontal gyrus
- Superior parietal lobule
- Occipital gyri
- Longitudinal fissure
10Highly specialized brain function?
11Hypotheses
- The question remains, therefore, of whether
specific neural regions are more engaged in the
processing of some emotions than others. - Based on the hypothesis that affiliative social
vocal signals are prevalent throughout our lives
and serve a fundamental purpose in social binding
we hypothesize that emotional expressions of
happiness would preferentially engage parts of
the temporal cortex and inferior frontal regions
previously shown to be involved in the processing
of affective prosody. - A further question concerning the perception of
vocal expressions of emotion is how directed
attention towards or away from the expressed
emotion affects the associated neural response. - How to test this?
- Activation for face versus voice most studies
on face - What types of emotional speech detected? All?
12Experimental approach
- FMRI to detect localized regions for processing
happiness vs anger in speech - Why those two emotions?
- Reasons
- Control for similar acoustic signal.
- Common/basic. Easier to characterize.
- social utility hypothesis regarding happiness
- Which theory of emotion (jamesian etc)
- What was experimental setup?
- Some factors
- 40 subjects
- Facial stimuli consisted of 16 grayscale images
of posed expressions of anger and 16 expressions
of happiness, half of them females. - Vocal stimuli consisted of short phrases (dates
and numbers) lasting on average 1 s, spoken with
either angry or happy prosody. - Half the participants make their decision on the
basis of the facial expression, while the other
half on the basis of the vocal expression - FMRI scan during happy/angry speech
- With corresponding or opposite facial expression
13Experiment Issues/problems?
- Brain regions necessarily responding to emotion?
- Quality of audio? Affects results?
- FMRI measures blood flow. Relevant to neural?
- Right handed subjects. Relevant?
- Faces not correlated to the speaker.
- Why normalized audio amplitude?
- Why no semantic emotional content?
- Why short phrases?
14FRMI
Functional MRI or functional Magnetic Resonance
Imaging (fMRI) is a type of specialized MRI scan.
It measures the haemodynamic response related to
neural activity in the brain or spinal cord of
humans or other animals. It is one of the most
recently developed forms of neuroimaging. Since
the early 1990s, fMRI has come to dominate the
brain mapping field due to its low invasiveness,
lack of radiation exposure, and relatively wide
availability.
15Experiment - results
- Happy voices elicited significantly more
activation than angry voices in right anterior
and posterior middle temporal gyrus (MTG), left
posterior MTG and right inferior frontal gyrus. - Attention-dependent results In contrast with
brain regions showing a main effect of vocal
emotion regardless of attentional focus, a
network of brain regions including the left
insula, left amygdala and hippocampus, and
rostral ACC responded more to happy voices than
to angry voices when attending to the voice, but
showed either no difference or greater activation
to angry voices than to happy voices when
attending to the face. - Do these results support the social binding
hypothesis?
16Results - RT and accuracy
- Why longer RT for voice case?
- Why measure RT and accuracy at all?
17Results
How do these graphs support the stated results?
18Facial Expressions and Emotion - Paul Ekman
http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Ekman
- Found facial expressions of emotion are not
culturally determined, but universal across human
cultures and thus biological in origin. - How did he determine this?
- Fully true? Examples?
- How does this square with the four approaches
Darwinian? Jamesian? Social constructivist?
Appraisal? - Expressions he found to be universal included
those indicating anger, disgust, fear, joy,
sadness, and surprise. Findings on contempt are
less clear, though there is at least some
preliminary evidence that this emotion and its
expression are universally recognized. - examples of non-universal emotions? of
culture-dependent expression of same emotion? Of
individual-dependent expression of same emotion? - Facial Action Coding System (FACS) taxonomize all
human facial expression. (Ekman and Friesen) - 48 action descriptors, which are a contraction or
relaxation of one or more muscles. - http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_Action_Coding_
System - http//www.cs.cmu.edu/afs/cs/project/face/www/facs
.htm - Microexpressions detect lying
- How does this phenomenon square with the four
approaches?
19FACS action descriptors
1 Inner Brow Raiser -- Frontalis (pars
medialis) 2 Outer Brow Raiser -- Frontalis (pars
lateralis) 4 Brow Lowerer -- Depressor glabellae,
Depressor supercilii, Corrugator supercilii 5
Upper Lid Raiser -- Levator palpebrae
superioris 6 Cheek Raiser -- Orbicularis oculi
(pars orbitalis) 7 Lid Tightener -- Orbicularis
oculi (pars palpebralis) 9 Nose Wrinkler --
Levator labii superioris alaeque nasi 10 Upper
Lip Raiser -- Levator labii superioris, caput
infraorbitalis 11 Nasolabial Deepener --
Zygomaticus minor 12 Lip Corner Puller --
Zygomaticus major 13 Cheek Puffer -- Levator
anguli oris (also known as Caninus) 14 Dimpler --
Buccinator 15 Lip Corner Depressor -- Depressor
anguli oris (also known as Triangularis) 16 Lower
Lip Depressor -- Depressor labii inferioris 17
Chin Raiser -- Mentalis 18 Lip Puckerer --
Incisivii labii superioris and Incisivii labii
inferioris 19 Tongue Out 20 Lip stretcher --
Risorius w/ platysma 21 Neck Tightener --
Platysma 22 Lip Funneler -- Orbicularis oris 23
Lip Tightener -- Orbicularis oris 24 Lip Pressor
-- Orbicularis oris
24 Lip Pressor -- Orbicularis oris 25 Lips part
-- Depressor labii inferioris or relaxation of
Mentalis, or Orbicularis oris 26 Jaw Drop --
Masseter, relaxed Temporalis and internal
pterygoid 27 Mouth Stretch -- Pterygoids,
Digastric 28 Lip Suck -- Orbicularis oris 29 Jaw
Thrust 30 Jaw Sideways 31 Jaw Clencher --
Masseter 32 Lip Bite 33 Cheek Blow 34 Cheek
Puff 35 Cheek Suck 36 Tongue Bulge 37 Lip Wipe 38
Nostril Dilator 39 Nostril Compressor 41 Lid
Droop 42 Slit 43 Eyes Closed -- Relaxation of
Levator palpebrae superioris Orbicularis oculi
(pars palpebralis) 44 Squint 45 Blink --
Relaxation of Levator palpebrae superioris
Orbicularis oculi (pars palpebralis) 46 Wink --
Relaxation of Levator palpebrae superioris
Orbicularis oculi (pars palpebralis)
20Facial Action Coding System - FACS
- FACS can be used to distinguish two types of
smiles - insincere and voluntary Pan American smile
- contraction of zygomatic major alone
- sincere and involuntary Duchenne smile
- contraction of zygomatic major and inferior part
of orbicularis oculi.
21Pictures of Facial Affect (resource) Ekman and
Friesen
- 110 pictures of posed facial emotions
- 10 second display to subjects (male and female
50 mix) - 70 accurately identified
- Mark each example as one of
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
2289
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
2356
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
2479
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
25102
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
2654
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
2776
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
2852
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
2934
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
3094
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
31108
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
32Tally your results!
- Should match most of the time
3389
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
3456
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
3579
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
36102
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
3754
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
3876
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
3952
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
4034
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
4194
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
42108
- Happy
- Sad
- Fear
- Anger
- Surprise
- Disgust
43Ekman - Microexpressions
- Play video
- Impact on Darwinian, jamesian, etc?
- What is deception w/r emotion?
44Poker Tells The Body Language of Poker (1984)
Mike Caro
- Poker players exhibit tells that reveal
valuable information about their hands or
intentions to bet - Some tells are unconscious and directly related
to the internal emotion (excitement at a good
hand, disappointment at a bad one) - Some tells are the result of acting the
opposite to try to deceive the opponents. - Tells involve facial expressions, gestures, hand
positions, body posture, and other behaviors
45Poker Tells instant reaction
The Body Language of Poker (1984) Mike Caro
46Poker Tells acting the opposite
47Poker Tells guarding the hand
48Expressions in virtual 3D faces FaceGen
Neutral Pose
www.facegen.com
49Expressions in virtual 3D faces FaceGen Anger
50Expressions in virtual 3D faces FaceGen
Disgustsmile(open)
51Expressions in virtual 3D faces FaceGen blend
other expression, phonemes, etc.
52Next Week
- Hand in either
- A list of possible topics for your course
project, with a paragraph on each, or (if you
have already discussed the project with me and
decided on one) - A one page project specification with
- Project goal
- What you will do to achieve
- What resources you will need
- What prior work you can draw on