Autonomy

1
Values
Autonomy Beneficence Economic efficiency Environme
nt Nonmaleficence Personal ethics Privacy Religiou
s traditions Sanctity of life Scientific inquiry
Social contract Technological Progress
2
Employee rights and public safety For 1 Director
(17,chart, 25) (christina,aj,lisag) 4 Airline
boss (16,20 (kenny,phil,mike) 5 Medical
administrator (18,20 (cynthia,chelsea) 8 Frequent
flyer (37) (david,jay) 10 Genetic engineering
advocate (29) (3ana,andie,mack)
Against 2 Pilot (15,19 (vyom,kymber) 3 Pilot
wife (19, (ashley, jessica) 7 Civil rights lawyer
(19, 23 (britt,lisac,sandeep)
In the middle 6 Insurance agent (22, 24
(travis,tj,ryan) 9 Lab tech (25?,27
(bayley,eileen) 11 Teenager (28,30
(dane,sarah) 14,12 Doctor (31,38) (pawan,amanda)
3

1. Read your part/perspective on the issue. Write
   who you are!
2. Answer the focus questions with your partner in
   your notebook. List the values you are using to
   make your decision.
3. Read at least 2 of the other articles and answer
   its focus questions.
4. Prepare a one minute statement that reflects who
   you are and your position on employee rights and
   genetic screening. My name is _________ and I am
   __________. I believe ____________________.
   DONT JUST GIVE YOUR OPINION!
5. Prepare a question for at least 2 other members
   of the roundtable (think of what their position
   is and how you can refute it!)
6. Be prepared for a rebuttal question from me or
   someone else in the room.

4

• Round table ground rules
• Introduce yourself with your 1 minute statement
  and your position on employee rights and genetic
  screening (for or against screening).
• One person speaks at a time. You need to LISTEN
  to others opinions.
• Comments are made AFTER someones statement.
• Anyone can ask a question to a participant in the
  circle, just raise your hand.
• You have 1 minute time limits for all comments
  and questions.
• Speak only from the perspective of the person you
  represent.
• Be prepared for someone to ask you a question
  about your position.

5
Order of speaking 1. Director 2. Pilot 3.
Airline boss 4. Civil rights lawyer 5.
Insurance agent 6. Medical administrator 7.
Lab tech 8. Frequent flyer 9. Pilots wife 10.
Doctor 11. Genetic engineering advocate 12.
Teenager Think of who you might want to address
in the round table and the question you will ask
them. .