Philosophical Chairs

1

• Philosophical Chairs

2
Preparing for the Discussion

• Read the article about nature vs. nurture.
• Record notes from the article on the
  Philosophical Chairs T-Chart. Then list several
  examples from your own life or from the lives of
  others that support each position.
• Finally, decide whether you are for NATURE or
  for NURTURE..

3
The Set-up
4
Directions

• You must decide whether you are for NATURE or
  NURTURE
• Sit on the side of the room labeled NATURE or
  NURTURE
• A neutral mediator stands in between the groups
• Calls on sides to speak
• Can limit time
• Makes sure everyone who wants to speak has the
  opportunity
• Can call on anyone at anytime to speak. Be
  prepared!

5
Rules

• You must choose a side. You cannot be neutral.
• Listen while others speak.
• Wait for the mediator to call on you to speak.
  Use the notes from the Philosophical Chairs
  T-Chart to support your position.
• In one sentence, summarize the previous speakers
  argument before you respond.

6
Rules (Continued)

• If you have already spoken, wait for three other
  people on your side to speak before you speak
  again.
• Address ideas, not the person stating the ideas.
• Keep an open mind. You may move to the other side
  if you feel someone has made a good argument or
  your opinion swayed.
• Fill out an evaluation form at the end.